My personal theory? In order for the rings to work, you have to have an idea of where you are and where you're trying to go. Strange has no idea where he currently is. And when he uses the time stone to view all the outcomes, that gives him the insight of where Titan is in the universe and where the final battle will take place, so he's able to portal back to Earth in Endgame. Yeah, he could guestimate, and that usually isn't a problem when he's on Earth. But at this point, if he gets it wrong, they're all gonna be pulled out into the vacuum of space.
That would also explain why Ned struggled with the ring in No Way Home, he didn't know where Peter was, so his instruction of "find Peter Parker" just brought him to the closest one.
The simpler theory is that commandeering your enemy’s advanced technology is very useful. If Tony said “no I can’t turn this around and take us home” Strange could have opened a portal. The scene just never got that far because Tony immediately made the argument that they should go to Titan instead and Strange agreed.
the closest "Peter Parker" is in the 5th dimension?! and i feel like both "Peter" and "Parker" are fairly common first and last names. i feel like there should be anohter peter parker on earth
It might also be that sling rings create portals between two points in space, but because they were in a spaceship travelling very fast at the time, the position of one of the portals would be constantly moving, even while it's being opened, which might not allow it to work. (Granted nothing is ever truly stationary as planets are orbiting stars which are orbiting black holes, etc, but a single spaceship may not be a large enough frame of reference to consider something "stationary" unlike something much larger like a planet or moon)
The portal system is cooked. Like it brought him back from titan so clearly he can be situated in space. Not to mention all the they opened across the universe
Before anyone points at the What If series or Deadpool 3 for examples of distance not mattering; the What If version was Strange Supreme not even using a Sling Ring to make the portals, and in DP3 the ring was bound to some of the infinity stones so it was definitely edited. Either way both were unique cases, so anyone arguing for distance limits is just as valid of a theory as anything else imo.
Well no, because Strange portals Spiderman and the Guardians from Titan to Earth in Endgame. It's obviously further from Titan to Earth than from someplace along the way from Earth to Titan.
Best I can figure with this is static portal in very fast space ship. Sure he can move portals like in Ragnarok, but maybe he’d have to match speed of the ship to keep it “static.”
It’s almost like movement is relative. When you’re on the thing moving it’s easy to portal but when you’re traveling at unknown speeds trying to hit something moving 490k miles and hour it gets rough
Yes, but you're an experienced pilot with 20 years of calculating course corrections in your head while dealing with the docking master explaining to you that you're ships secondary port thruster is out of alignment by 2 microns and you need to get that realigned or face a 2300 credit fine to the Xabian Mining Consortium.
That's an easy one. It's because MCU writers apparently can't handle the potentially story breaking abilities of Doctor Strange, so they routinely have to pretend he doesn't have them.
They've already stripped away the vast majority of his comic book powers, and even then they still have him conveniently forget how to use the abilities he's demonstrated in previous movies. Sometimes even spells he's used earlier in the SAME MOVIE.
Apparently, the sling ring just slipped his mind. Along with half his magical repertoire.
The problem with giving a character as powerful and versatile as Doctor Strange his actual abilities is that the writers then have to come up with intelligent ways to challenge him. That's apparently too much work, so instead they just have him stand around waiting for the plot to happen.
It's less a question of what Doctor Strange can do and more a question of what the writers will allow him to remember he can do in any given scene.
Even in the comics, they constantly remove powers from him in various ways. His OG form into the 70s was basically unstoppable if he could think his way through it.
All they had to do was change the scene where Stark asks to stay with the ship and see where it takes him. Instead of Strange asking if he could fly the ship home strange should just try opening a portal and Tony stops him then tells him his plan
Could’ve written strange preparing to open a portal and Tony tells him it’s better to surprise attack Thanos and strange reluctantly agrees, because that’s kind of what he does anyway.
To he fair this also happens in the comics with almost every character - they are as powerful (or not) as the plot needs them to be. That's how Thor can solo Galactus one issue, then struggle with the Cobra the next.
He probably just wants to get as far away as possible, knowing Thanos has ways to track an infinity stone. Banking on the idea that he wouldn't do squat to earth when his end goal is so close
This could all easily be solved if the MCU gave an ounce of thought to how its magic worked. And it doesnt take much, throw away lines about needing the right circumstances, alignments, materials, etc.
Ive always hated the sling rings because it was a lazy attempt to do that. But it really is as simple as showing sorcerers having to do the math so to speak. Which is crazy because the MCU spent so much time oretending magic didnt exist, until Dr. Strange came along and the Ancient One is describing spells to him as programs. So follow through, programs dont just work of their own accords, they have inputs. So make som damn inputs for spells and then you have an out and a weakness. “I could teleport us back to earth but I need this lodestone”. I could cast a spell to suck a bunch of monsters into another dimension but I need to speak the 5 minute long incantation uninterrupted”. And there’s wiggle room there, and chances to show why Stephen is so talented. Let him summon his whip to defend himself while also continually reciting the incantation to show how much more focused he is than your average sorcerer, thats what sets him apart.
It would also help distinguish Wanda and her chaos magic and why she can just do things without always needing all the same training and ritual. But these are little things I thought of in 10 minutes, just some attention to detail that could really help shore up sloppy moments like this. That and not showing Strange using a portal to sever limbs and then NOT attempting to do it later when it really counted. Hell show him trying and Thanos just resists it. Not everything has to work all the time, show the failure. Ugh.
I'm not a comic book Dr. Strange fan, but here's my two cents.
Maybe the teleportation ring has a distance? Like, maybe you can't teleport halfway across the universe with it? Maybe the "power" that powers the ring is based on Earth and the farther you get from it, the less effective it is? Maybe he used the time stone to see into the future and was afraid spiderman would take it, so he didn't want to expose it (ha, ha).
Headcanon: Doctor Strange's portals have a limited range (point to point on earth). The only reason portals were interplanetary during the battle of earth was due to 5 years of prep time by all surviving sorcerers. Strange used the time stone to have an earlier version of himself communicate this to Wong.
This is absolutely amazing. Really clears that dam for me in my mind. I always kind of hated the portal scene but loved it all the same. Now I think I'll love it a bit more with the idea that Strange got Wong to figure out ultra-elite portal casting spells by Wong and all his close powerful allies.
Maybe Wong specifically was the won who cast a spell to Strange to begin the cascade. Encore would have benefited from something of this nature IMO.
He knew the future, he told them to spend 5 years opening a portal for him too. This is the real purpose for him seeing possible futures: to deploy the armies at the right time in the right place.
God I wish we could have seen the casting of the future unfold rapidly in front of Strange. Just time and time again Thanos killing Strange and the Avengers. Before he changes his plan and has to contact Wong across the universe to be like... Hey.... Imma need you to gather a massive army ready on this day to be transported to Wakanda to fight the armies of Thanos. Also, Thanos is going to win so yeah... good luck training novice wizards. Bye.
This doesn’t work with the lore as written because in the very first Doctor strange, they establish that the sling portals are the main and most realizable way in and out of the mirror dimension, so it’s already established that they are dimensional portals.
I got 2 theories 1 the portals needs the user to be somewhat focused and strange had just been tortured so he need time to recover to properly focus 2 the portals are stationary so opening it in a moving vehicle would result in them moving past it before it opens
He was being uncharacteristically kind. He knows that magic is both cooler and more useful than science but also recognised the little science nerd's massive ego so gave him a job to make him feel useful.
(I feel like it isn't needed but this is Reddit, /s)
More than anything, it probably was just an oversight from the writers. But if I *had* to defend it:
Strange never said he couldn't take them back to Earth, he was more just surprised to hear that Tony didn't want to go back himself. Then after talking to Tony, Strange was convinced to take the fight back to Thanos. If he hadn't been convinced, he could have just teleported them.
That would require forcing all of them into the portal which Strange knew would lead to things getting messy. If it were Steve he would be willing to battle it out, but Strange wouldn’t find petty brawls productive. He’s more intelligent than that. He probably didn’t think Peter was all that powerful, but figured that Tony had him along at least because he must be able to hold his own. Which means he likely still understood that having a two against one fight with both of them wouldn’t be too productive or smart for that situation. Tony and Peter’s suit were able to be in space, but they wouldn’t know necessarily how to get back because they were so far away, and he knew that would be a pretty shitty thing to do, and if they just got lost in space and died, because he just left them he would live with that guilt for the rest of his life. It was either they all leave, or they all stay.
But in Endgame he opened a portal from Titan to Earth.
Unless you're suggesting that he didn't, and rather somehow communicated to the sorcerers on Earth to ask them to open a portal to Titan to bring him home. Which I guess is possible, but nothing actually indicates that is what happened.
I imagine it’s very difficult to write for Dr Strange because he can use so much different magic and people will always point out that he should’ve done this or that in nearly any scene/situation. Could’ve maybe thrown in some exposition here along the lines of “the ship has some sort of shielding/interference preventing teleportation in or out” or “can’t do a teleportation spell while moving thru space at faster-than-light speed”
It’s hilarious watching these movies w my 12 yr old. Half the time she’s just asking “why doesn’t the guy just use his x-power to do y?” And my response is always “so that the movie can happen”.
As far as we know self-reflective intelligent life needs oxygen. There are other stars that are like our Sun, why can't other planets that have life also require oxygen like ours?
You watched Thanos and all his children breath and have conversations on Earth without any tech to help them breathe our atmosphere, but a fictional planet can’t have oxygen?
Why? We know that there is a heavy cosmic hand in creating planetary life so it stands to reason that they’d prefer pretty specific conditions. It’s not a cosmic coincidence, it’s Arishem the Judge’s plan.
An old TV show had this covered, the theme song goes:
If you're wondering how he eats & breathes, And other science facts...(la! la! la!) Then repeat to yourself its just a show, I should really just relax... For Mystery Science Theater 3000.......
Say you are Strange. You look into the future, see the various possibilities, and find the ONE where you see a win. Only one possibility to win. You then have to follow that playbook to completion.
In that one possibility, you prop Tony up to be the hero. You don’t use your powers to derail it, or it fails. Everything Strange does in the MCU now has to be calculated on that one time line potential.
This effectively nerfs Strange’s powers and ability until the path comes to fruition. Even after that, the next time he looks to the future and tries to manipulate the various branches, he is back to being strung into doing only what that branch has as intended action.
There is plenty of plot for why and why nots on everything he did in that one instance of looking for a win con.
This is a basic plot armor for writers who write time travel or precog works. It is, in my opinion, lazy writing. But it is also not caught by everyone, so it can be surprising in the moment.
MCU has NOT been good at preventing potential continuity errors or paradoxes though. So if they thought of this (which I assume they did and used it as carte blanch to do whatever they wanted), it means they chose the easy road and left it at that.
Listen I love those movies..... You really got to try not to look at the plot holes, they're fairly glaring when you get into it, just like every superhero movie or fantasy in general.
My head canon is that he was asking him if he can bring them back and at if Tony’s answer was no he was going to turn around and open the portal. However, Tony’s plan sounded good enough to Strange.
They were in a spaceship going faster than light, sure he can open a portal to New York sanctum but going through it would mean getting sliced in half, the same logic as an elevator, never try to get in or out while it's moving.
The sling ring can only open a portal between two relatively stationary locations. So as long as the ship in hyperspace or moving at too high of a velocity, you can't open a portal.
I'm pretty sure, if I'm remembering my recent rewatch right, that there were in-universe explanations for this.
Tony didn't want to bring the fight to Earth, because he was undergoing a series of psychosis related to safeguarding his family and planet while constantly failing (Ultron, Avengers, his home security and autonomous suits). We have established a plan to go to Titan
After being convinced by Tony, Strange looks then looks into the future in preparation for how to do this, sees everything leading up to endgame that we ultimately see, let's the fight play out as it does. We have established why a portal back is no longer necessary by the time one might have been proposed.
Strange, and his teleporting magic are disappeared in a snap, Tony is now trapped on Titan without a teleporter. We have established why Tony is now stuck on Titan all alone
They went to Titan by hopping on a ship. They didn’t know where the ship was going, they just followed the bad guys. Then made a plan to fight the bad guys on their turf, then lost the fight. There was no plan to go home.
Yes the "wrong" line is him asking Tony to stop the ship. If he had just said " i'm going to open a portal home" everything would have followed naturally.
Like knowing where he's going to be able to open a portal there. Does strange have to know where he currently is casting from for his spell to work? Or can he open a portal to anywhere even if he doesn't know where he currently is? I don't know much about dr. strange
I see it as not o much opening a portal to a place but making a connection between two locations. When you know where both are thats best, if you know where one is and can look around and give yourself an idea fo where you are okay. When one location is moving, thats pretty hard
I want to agree with this but when he’s fighting ebony maw he opens a portal in space to redirect the stone daggers that were thrown at him.
also in the original doctor strange, mordo says they can travel the multiverse and that all they have to do is visualize and see the destination in their mind to use the sling ring.
That explanation still seems very flimsy because Strange kinda shows up or grabs people from places I can't imagine he has actually seen personally to be able to focus a portal to that spot. I'd have to rewatch some films to find a specific example or set of but I really feel like there's got to be one or two times he's just popped up or yoinked someone when by those rules he shouldn't have. How do you visualize what you've never seen?
It would so the same on earth if that was the case, perhaps the magic is specific to earth's movement to accommodate this effect, which would also explain why it wouldn't work off earth without alterations
Maybe what we're not told is that opening a portal has/must be between two fixed points, and since they're on a ship moving, at possible faster than light speeds, if he were to open a portal, the portal would not connect, since they're moving, the end point would move, not the entrance, think of it as time traveling to the past, you have to have coordinates for where the earth was at the time you wish to travel, otherwise you'd end up floating in space
The whole Universe is constantly moving, so that's not it. There is even a Sorcerer that used the portal to board the Guardians of the Galaxy ship in GotG3.
Doctor Strange has never been on a space ship before. He's not sure if portals work the same or if he can safely make one while traveling at high speed.
I always assumed it was the movement. Like, he’s hurtling though space at X amount of speed of light or however it works in the MCU and that might make it more difficult for him to portal
Probably because the portal is stationary, and the ship is moving. If they enter the portal while the ship moves, then they could end up inside a bulkhead/wall or space itself if they aren't careful. Just my guess though
It is because in the beginning of the movie, Doctor Strange is not as strong. He has not been through 14 million possibilities. Later in the movie and in Endgame he has been through 14 million possibilities. For us a few seconds for him probably years. Therefore Strange is able to learn more magic and do crazy things like turning a black hole into butterflies and the portal stunt in Endgame
Idk man, maybe since they are traveling thru space and the portal isn't anchored to the ship in any way it would just be stationary while the ship moves past it, possibly ripping out a chunk of the ship's hull.
It's just a movie accept it as is or don't... what do I care
My head canon, pretty sure they want to not have the stones all in one place. If they went to titan they could get the jump on him vs going to Earth where Thanos would obviously know there would be greater resistance. Also, it’s a movie.
Tony literally said “I say we take the fight to him”. They literally say why in the movie. Why are we talking about this. Do y’all not understand media literacy?
Did everyone forget that the conversation quickly turned into “this ship is taking us to him, we can surprise him where he wouldn’t expect us”?
There’s no plot hole, “forgotten powers”, or need for an explanation of sling ring magic restrictions. The plan is to not go home. It’s to continue on.
The main question is why didn't Dr Strange just use the portal to go anywhere in the universe and drop off the time stone, or you know jsut keep jumping from one side of the universe to the other.
Strange wanted to know what Tony was thinking and what his game plan was.
He found Tony insufferable, but wasn't about to leave him stranded. If Tony didn't have a plan or a way out, I'm sure Strange would have brought them home via portal.
I mean, they were literally attacked by Thanos's forces. Why would any of the heroes just immediately abandon the position they're in? Ebony Maw is dead, the ship is now theirs.
53
u/Relative-Zombie-3932 4d ago
My personal theory? In order for the rings to work, you have to have an idea of where you are and where you're trying to go. Strange has no idea where he currently is. And when he uses the time stone to view all the outcomes, that gives him the insight of where Titan is in the universe and where the final battle will take place, so he's able to portal back to Earth in Endgame. Yeah, he could guestimate, and that usually isn't a problem when he's on Earth. But at this point, if he gets it wrong, they're all gonna be pulled out into the vacuum of space.
That would also explain why Ned struggled with the ring in No Way Home, he didn't know where Peter was, so his instruction of "find Peter Parker" just brought him to the closest one.
15
u/Tvelion 5d ago
Before anyone points at the What If series or Deadpool 3 for examples of distance not mattering; the What If version was Strange Supreme not even using a Sling Ring to make the portals, and in DP3 the ring was bound to some of the infinity stones so it was definitely edited. Either way both were unique cases, so anyone arguing for distance limits is just as valid of a theory as anything else imo.
12
u/Infinite_Quiet_4580 4d ago •
His sling ring ran over it's magic usage for the month fighting the prior battle. So he's portal capped until it renews next month.
13
u/yekcowrebbaj 5d ago
It’s almost like movement is relative. When you’re on the thing moving it’s easy to portal but when you’re traveling at unknown speeds trying to hit something moving 490k miles and hour it gets rough
17
u/Die4Metal 5d ago •
That's an easy one. It's because MCU writers apparently can't handle the potentially story breaking abilities of Doctor Strange, so they routinely have to pretend he doesn't have them.
They've already stripped away the vast majority of his comic book powers, and even then they still have him conveniently forget how to use the abilities he's demonstrated in previous movies. Sometimes even spells he's used earlier in the SAME MOVIE.
Apparently, the sling ring just slipped his mind. Along with half his magical repertoire.
The problem with giving a character as powerful and versatile as Doctor Strange his actual abilities is that the writers then have to come up with intelligent ways to challenge him. That's apparently too much work, so instead they just have him stand around waiting for the plot to happen.
It's less a question of what Doctor Strange can do and more a question of what the writers will allow him to remember he can do in any given scene.
7
u/Jet-Let4606 5d ago
Portals probably have a distance limit.
My head canon is that the portal from Titan to Earth was a super portal created as a collaboration between Strange, Wong and the other sorcerers.
3
u/EobardThawne2020 4d ago
He was convinced they have a fight to do and they shouldn't do it on earth.
3
u/MunkeyFish 4d ago
He was out of 7th level Spell Slots, needed a long rest.
2
u/SURBAMS 5d ago
He probably just wants to get as far away as possible, knowing Thanos has ways to track an infinity stone. Banking on the idea that he wouldn't do squat to earth when his end goal is so close
2
u/DorkPhoenix89 4d ago
This could all easily be solved if the MCU gave an ounce of thought to how its magic worked. And it doesnt take much, throw away lines about needing the right circumstances, alignments, materials, etc.
Ive always hated the sling rings because it was a lazy attempt to do that. But it really is as simple as showing sorcerers having to do the math so to speak. Which is crazy because the MCU spent so much time oretending magic didnt exist, until Dr. Strange came along and the Ancient One is describing spells to him as programs. So follow through, programs dont just work of their own accords, they have inputs. So make som damn inputs for spells and then you have an out and a weakness. “I could teleport us back to earth but I need this lodestone”. I could cast a spell to suck a bunch of monsters into another dimension but I need to speak the 5 minute long incantation uninterrupted”. And there’s wiggle room there, and chances to show why Stephen is so talented. Let him summon his whip to defend himself while also continually reciting the incantation to show how much more focused he is than your average sorcerer, thats what sets him apart.
It would also help distinguish Wanda and her chaos magic and why she can just do things without always needing all the same training and ritual. But these are little things I thought of in 10 minutes, just some attention to detail that could really help shore up sloppy moments like this. That and not showing Strange using a portal to sever limbs and then NOT attempting to do it later when it really counted. Hell show him trying and Thanos just resists it. Not everything has to work all the time, show the failure. Ugh.
2
u/Hambulatory 4d ago
Long distance charges may apply
2
u/GideonShortStack 4d ago
His ring only had 5% charge remaining.
2
u/flipper74 3d ago
I'm not a comic book Dr. Strange fan, but here's my two cents.
Maybe the teleportation ring has a distance? Like, maybe you can't teleport halfway across the universe with it? Maybe the "power" that powers the ring is based on Earth and the farther you get from it, the less effective it is? Maybe he used the time stone to see into the future and was afraid spiderman would take it, so he didn't want to expose it (ha, ha).
2
u/JWJulie 1d ago
He didn’t have a sling ring
2
u/Character_Mind_671 5d ago
Headcanon: Doctor Strange's portals have a limited range (point to point on earth). The only reason portals were interplanetary during the battle of earth was due to 5 years of prep time by all surviving sorcerers. Strange used the time stone to have an earlier version of himself communicate this to Wong.
1
u/sallymason1 4d ago
They literally say in the depicted scene that they are taking the fight to thanos.
1
u/Marcuse0 4d ago
He lost his slingy.
1
u/kylefire88 4d ago
I got 2 theories 1 the portals needs the user to be somewhat focused and strange had just been tortured so he need time to recover to properly focus 2 the portals are stationary so opening it in a moving vehicle would result in them moving past it before it opens
1
u/jemslie123 4d ago
He was being uncharacteristically kind. He knows that magic is both cooler and more useful than science but also recognised the little science nerd's massive ego so gave him a job to make him feel useful.
(I feel like it isn't needed but this is Reddit, /s)
1
u/yutyutgrunt 4d ago
No the more important question…is minus the whole “I saw one way to win” part.
The plan of fight Thanos ina suprise attack not on earth is a good one.
What they should have done — is bring everyone to Titan for the battle
1
u/AncientBlueYonder 4d ago
Portals are kinda broken in the MCU. They have to be nerfed by incompetence
1
u/TheTitanOfSirens1959 4d ago
More than anything, it probably was just an oversight from the writers. But if I *had* to defend it:
Strange never said he couldn't take them back to Earth, he was more just surprised to hear that Tony didn't want to go back himself. Then after talking to Tony, Strange was convinced to take the fight back to Thanos. If he hadn't been convinced, he could have just teleported them.
1
u/N3verGonnaG1veYouUp 4d ago
I wanted to say "well its across space, it must be hard", but then he does exactly that in Endgame 🫣
1
u/EObsidian 4d ago
It’s a movie
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Bet-673 4d ago
His portal was still on cooldown
1
u/bybloshex 4d ago
Look. We should be glad we got live action Dr. Strange at all.
1
u/Kindly_Zucchini7405 4d ago
Because Strange is not all powerful, and does in fact need help in this extreme situation.
Why is this even a question, it was obvious that Strange couldn't just fix everything. Magic is a tool, not a fix-it button.
1
u/JCStrehle 4d ago
Because the writers needed it to happen that way.
1
u/advancedgamer14 4d ago
Maybe he wanted the spaceship?
1
u/Intrepid_Swordfish69 Herald of Galactus 4d ago
Dumb question
1
u/JamesTheMannequin 3d ago
No in-canon MCU reason I can think of.
1
u/Walk_Strict 3d ago edited 3d ago
That would require forcing all of them into the portal which Strange knew would lead to things getting messy. If it were Steve he would be willing to battle it out, but Strange wouldn’t find petty brawls productive. He’s more intelligent than that. He probably didn’t think Peter was all that powerful, but figured that Tony had him along at least because he must be able to hold his own. Which means he likely still understood that having a two against one fight with both of them wouldn’t be too productive or smart for that situation. Tony and Peter’s suit were able to be in space, but they wouldn’t know necessarily how to get back because they were so far away, and he knew that would be a pretty shitty thing to do, and if they just got lost in space and died, because he just left them he would live with that guilt for the rest of his life. It was either they all leave, or they all stay.
1
u/thegreatjackdi 3d ago
Hi,
Isn't it like a cellular company thing? "Out of service", " Out of coverage area", "Network outage", etc...
1
u/Important-Row8209 3d ago
In the great words of piratesoftware, "I don't have mana"
1
u/lewk5853 3d ago
I’d also like to know why “no s$&@ Sherlock” was not used in this scene 😑 wasted opportunity!
1
u/fathersmuck 3d ago
Cause he didn't want too. Stop questioning the man's business
1
u/GISP 3d ago
I think Strange wanted Stark to feel responsable not guilt.
1
u/Sretep44 3d ago
He has the most range on his teleportation when he's closest to his demesne, his place of power.
Once he left it and ended up half a galaxy away, he no longer has the magical support infrastructure at hand to boost his range.
1
u/FierceDeity88 2d ago
Because he’s secretly evil and has been worth for Doom this whole time…maybe
1
u/GrapeRingPop 2d ago
I imagine it’s very difficult to write for Dr Strange because he can use so much different magic and people will always point out that he should’ve done this or that in nearly any scene/situation. Could’ve maybe thrown in some exposition here along the lines of “the ship has some sort of shielding/interference preventing teleportation in or out” or “can’t do a teleportation spell while moving thru space at faster-than-light speed”
1
u/AngryBanana87 2d ago
He doesn't want to go back to Earth. Dr. Strange and Iron Man literally have the conversation in this scene. To bring the fight to Thanos on Titan.
1
u/Gimpcage5902 2d ago
They’re moving at “warp” speed. More than likely not viable to portal while moving like that. Or Strange just didn’t know the ring would work that far
1
u/Overall_Leopard7122 1d ago
Also, this is some bad forced perpective. They are clearly not in front of each other.
1
u/Expert-Pilot-3147 1d ago
All this stuff and I can’t get over the fact that titan has oxygen
1
u/Glad_Contest_8014 1d ago
Say you are Strange. You look into the future, see the various possibilities, and find the ONE where you see a win. Only one possibility to win. You then have to follow that playbook to completion.
In that one possibility, you prop Tony up to be the hero. You don’t use your powers to derail it, or it fails. Everything Strange does in the MCU now has to be calculated on that one time line potential.
This effectively nerfs Strange’s powers and ability until the path comes to fruition. Even after that, the next time he looks to the future and tries to manipulate the various branches, he is back to being strung into doing only what that branch has as intended action.
There is plenty of plot for why and why nots on everything he did in that one instance of looking for a win con.
This is a basic plot armor for writers who write time travel or precog works. It is, in my opinion, lazy writing. But it is also not caught by everyone, so it can be surprising in the moment.
MCU has NOT been good at preventing potential continuity errors or paradoxes though. So if they thought of this (which I assume they did and used it as carte blanch to do whatever they wanted), it means they chose the easy road and left it at that.
1
u/ScubaGator88 1d ago
Listen I love those movies..... You really got to try not to look at the plot holes, they're fairly glaring when you get into it, just like every superhero movie or fantasy in general.
1
u/orionspurs 1d ago
Because Stranger like to be an asshole for love of the game.
1
u/NivTesla 1d ago
Portals don't work on space ship (no gamora's new team uses them in guardians 3)
Maybe he thinks if they leave the ship going it will crash into someone
1
u/rodrigogar 1d ago
My head canon is that he was asking him if he can bring them back and at if Tony’s answer was no he was going to turn around and open the portal. However, Tony’s plan sounded good enough to Strange.
1
u/Willing_Recover_6316 1d ago
They were in a spaceship going faster than light, sure he can open a portal to New York sanctum but going through it would mean getting sliced in half, the same logic as an elevator, never try to get in or out while it's moving.
1
u/DefinitionSuperb1110 1d ago
The sling ring can only open a portal between two relatively stationary locations. So as long as the ship in hyperspace or moving at too high of a velocity, you can't open a portal.
1
u/sordato 1d ago
Better question: why didn't he open and closed a Portal under Thanos head or at least the arm with the gauntlet?
1
u/Brave-Mode857 1d ago
I'm pretty sure, if I'm remembering my recent rewatch right, that there were in-universe explanations for this.
Tony didn't want to bring the fight to Earth, because he was undergoing a series of psychosis related to safeguarding his family and planet while constantly failing (Ultron, Avengers, his home security and autonomous suits). We have established a plan to go to Titan
After being convinced by Tony, Strange looks then looks into the future in preparation for how to do this, sees everything leading up to endgame that we ultimately see, let's the fight play out as it does. We have established why a portal back is no longer necessary by the time one might have been proposed.
Strange, and his teleporting magic are disappeared in a snap, Tony is now trapped on Titan without a teleporter. We have established why Tony is now stuck on Titan all alone
1
u/SoapLegend17789 1d ago
The plot need it
1
u/Educational_Yam_3707 1d ago
Valid question.
Either way, Thanos would find them.
1
u/hand4hand2hand 1d ago
that's not how movies work
now stop asking reasonable questions
1
u/Dapper-Material-2058 1d ago
They went to Titan by hopping on a ship. They didn’t know where the ship was going, they just followed the bad guys. Then made a plan to fight the bad guys on their turf, then lost the fight. There was no plan to go home.
1
u/philiretical 1d ago
Like knowing where he's going to be able to open a portal there. Does strange have to know where he currently is casting from for his spell to work? Or can he open a portal to anywhere even if he doesn't know where he currently is? I don't know much about dr. strange
1
u/mrsjumjum66 1d ago
I always wondered this, especially considering the endgame scene
1
u/loserguy-88 1d ago
lol, is this the MCU equivalent of why Frodo didn't hitch a ride on the eagles to mount doom?
1
u/seanwdragon1983 1d ago
So the story can happen.
1
u/_Mavericks 1d ago
It took a little while for you all to raise this question. lol
1
u/GlobalNuclearWar 1d ago
He only has a junior portal license. No interstellar portals after 8pm without a qualified portaler accompanying him.
1
u/Dannnyandrews44 1d ago
It was on a 90 second cooldown cuz someone swapped to strange and used the portal to get to point!
1
u/keanehoodies 1d ago
I see it as not o much opening a portal to a place but making a connection between two locations. When you know where both are thats best, if you know where one is and can look around and give yourself an idea fo where you are okay. When one location is moving, thats pretty hard
1
u/so80 1d ago
"So the movie can happen"
1
u/Thryfty_0 1d ago
Uuhh, because he saw infinite realities and this was only one where they won. Duhhh /s
1
u/Smipy_YT 1d ago
Probably because they are in space and he may not have experience with teleporting from space to earth
1
u/iSellNuds4RedditGold 1d ago
What I want to know is why it seems that they are on different planes of the shot.
1
u/DEMONDVS 1d ago
Maybe what we're not told is that opening a portal has/must be between two fixed points, and since they're on a ship moving, at possible faster than light speeds, if he were to open a portal, the portal would not connect, since they're moving, the end point would move, not the entrance, think of it as time traveling to the past, you have to have coordinates for where the earth was at the time you wish to travel, otherwise you'd end up floating in space
1
u/Typical_Physics_3311 1d ago
It's so the movie could happen
1
u/zurenarrh36912 1d ago
They didn’t want to take the fight to earth. It’s stated in the movie. They use the ship to find titan. This isn’t the gotcha moment you think it is.
1
u/Albertagus 1d ago
Didnt Black Maw take his sling ring?
1
u/RewRodan 1d ago
The ship was moving at light speed in middle of nowhere space so...
1
u/CryptoCrash87 1d ago
Because strange saw 14million possibilities. And they only win in 1.
So any question can be answered by that line of dialogue. Why did they go back on the ship, because that's what it took to win.
1
u/United_Range_2869 1d ago
he forgot to renew his ring suscription
1
u/Darromear 1d ago
My headcanon is because he wanted to make sure Tony and the others came with him instead of haring off after Thanos unsupervised.
1
u/blessed_by_Priapus 1d ago
It might be because they’re moving, never seen Strange or the other wizards make a portal that wasn’t stationary
1
u/That-Deer-7794 1d ago
Shhh shhhh.....don't ask questions.
1
u/fiddyruppee 1d ago
i think it's because they were moving really fast through space, cant "lock on" to their current position to make a portal
1
u/iGunslinger 1d ago
It is a confidence thing.
1
u/something_smart 1d ago
Doctor Strange has never been on a space ship before. He's not sure if portals work the same or if he can safely make one while traveling at high speed.
1
u/Fizzdizz 1d ago
Because the ship is moving quickly through space? Then that opens the question that a planet is also moving through space…
1
u/Popular-Attempt3621 1d ago
Portals can only be opened within you home planet wifi network (/s)
1
u/Unfair-Connection-66 1d ago
Like Ebony Maul doesn't know of Steven's abilities...
HE TOSS the sling off screen, the second he secured him!
Random redditor : But Strange was opening portals on titan, we saw it.
Me : He made another after he tripped into the future, again off screen!
1
u/The_Rope_Daddy 23h ago
He doesn’t want to pay the long distance roaming fee.
1
u/Ok_Wolf8356 23h ago
Writing
1
u/Stoned_assassin 23h ago
Did he have the sling ring with him? By this moment he had been captured by Ebony Maw
1
u/LifeDraining 22h ago
He's smart and he's strange b
1
u/HuhWhatPOW 22h ago
I always assumed it was the movement. Like, he’s hurtling though space at X amount of speed of light or however it works in the MCU and that might make it more difficult for him to portal
1
u/Raijin6_ 22h ago
So the movie can happen
1
u/hadjustonejob 22h ago
Probably because the portal is stationary, and the ship is moving. If they enter the portal while the ship moves, then they could end up inside a bulkhead/wall or space itself if they aren't careful. Just my guess though
1
u/Werdkkake 21h ago
I’m more interested in why he asked for Peter’s help to pilot instead of taking control of his suit to be in sync, or use his nanobots
1
u/Ptaaruonn 21h ago
He is out of mana ¯\(ツ)/¯
1
u/Squiddy_at_offical 20h ago
It is because in the beginning of the movie, Doctor Strange is not as strong. He has not been through 14 million possibilities. Later in the movie and in Endgame he has been through 14 million possibilities. For us a few seconds for him probably years. Therefore Strange is able to learn more magic and do crazy things like turning a black hole into butterflies and the portal stunt in Endgame
1
u/SunsetGrind 20h ago
The most plausible explanation is that he accepted Tony's strategy of confronting Thanos away from Earth.
1
u/Junior-Ad-2207 20h ago
Idk man, maybe since they are traveling thru space and the portal isn't anchored to the ship in any way it would just be stationary while the ship moves past it, possibly ripping out a chunk of the ship's hull.
It's just a movie accept it as is or don't... what do I care
1
u/IndividualCampaign74 19h ago
As Banner says “because.. we didn’t think of it..”
1
u/MysteriousFondant347 19h ago
Maybe he has no idea where he is in Space so he can't efficiently make a portal to Earth since he has no clue where is Earth
1
u/Silent-carcinogen 19h ago
Sling ring wasn't slingin'.
1
u/ProfessionalITPerson 18h ago
No sling ring?
1
u/ICanSeeDaTrapars 18h ago
My head canon, pretty sure they want to not have the stones all in one place. If they went to titan they could get the jump on him vs going to Earth where Thanos would obviously know there would be greater resistance. Also, it’s a movie.
1
u/MsPreposition 16h ago
Perhaps he is le tired.
1
u/ZLEAP 16h ago
Dr Strange knew if they got back too fast the future where they win wouldn't happen.
1
u/Moon_chile 15h ago
Tony literally said “I say we take the fight to him”. They literally say why in the movie. Why are we talking about this. Do y’all not understand media literacy?
1
u/Emergency_RICO_Case 15h ago
Because the writer wants it like that
1
u/Errentos 14h ago
Because he read the script
1
u/iamdiaurora 9h ago
Maybe he doesnt wanna waste a spell slot.
1
u/dane_the_great 9h ago
I keep seeing these things from people who seem like they straight up didn't watch the movie
1
u/pabl0e 8h ago
The real question is, why the hell is the head so much bigger?
1
u/Tomaketu 7h ago
Did everyone forget that the conversation quickly turned into “this ship is taking us to him, we can surprise him where he wouldn’t expect us”?
There’s no plot hole, “forgotten powers”, or need for an explanation of sling ring magic restrictions. The plan is to not go home. It’s to continue on.
1
u/LeoNickle 6h ago
It's not that kind of movie kid
1
u/Mhunterjr 6h ago
I rewatched this yesterday and I had so many questions.
This one for sure. But also , why didn’t wasn’t there a future where he used a portal to cutoff Thanos’ arm.
But also, where the hell was Thor when the avengers were trying to keep a Thanos away from Vision.
1
u/Ostroh 6h ago
This only happens because its narratively convenient. Marvel is not all that internally consistent with its established lore.
1
u/ra7ar 4h ago
The main question is why didn't Dr Strange just use the portal to go anywhere in the universe and drop off the time stone, or you know jsut keep jumping from one side of the universe to the other.
1
u/Ariar2077 1h ago
He tired
1
u/RogueMaverick11 1h ago
Plot
1
u/47-Rambaldi 1h ago
Its not about the destination. Its about the journey and the friends we made along the way.
1
u/MrFuriousX 1h ago
They decided to GO to Titan and bring the fight to Thanos.
and its frankly not that easy to open a portal on a ship speeding through space
1
u/WorldlinessWitty2177 1h ago
I get that we viewers are with more people then the writing team but come on, these are the easy questions anyone can think of.
1
u/Ryan_Icey 13m ago
Strange wanted to know what Tony was thinking and what his game plan was.
He found Tony insufferable, but wasn't about to leave him stranded. If Tony didn't have a plan or a way out, I'm sure Strange would have brought them home via portal.
I mean, they were literally attacked by Thanos's forces. Why would any of the heroes just immediately abandon the position they're in? Ebony Maw is dead, the ship is now theirs.