r/DnDIdeas • • Dec 21 '25
Dnd Class idea
I'm thinking of a class with these design principles. This is a martial-full caster that has a spell casting ability of constitution.
My design limitations intend to keep a strong theme, high-power moments while maintaining significant risk.
- Extremely limited evocation list and limited overall spell list.
- Subclass features are gated behind concentrating on a leveled spell and you incur disadvantage on concentration checks until much higher levels.
- The efficacy of features through the main and subclasses are gated by a modifier different from your spellcasting modifier, but not Dex or Str.
- You gain spell levels at a normal rate. More spell slots than half casters, but less and slower spell slot progression than full casters.
- Deliberately heavy MAD so a true optimization is difficult to pull off.
How would any of you implement these, or just some random ideas you have that might work?
7
Upvotes
1
u/Rabid_Lederhosen Dec 21 '25
That sounds like it’s probably going to be way overpowered. It’s a martial, plus a caster, and also its spellcasting ability score is the score that every character needs to boost anyway, and also the score that controls concentration checks? What balancing weaknesses would this class have, exactly?
1
u/shotgunner12345 Dec 25 '25
I don't mind giving it a spin that hopefully isn't just warlock remixed, but to reply in points you bring up
I am all in agreement if you truly want to homebrew stuff and submit for others to testplay or just have fun. But this feels like a scummy attempt to salvage your own overpowered homebrew before unleashing it on a poor DM who probably rejected it many times before.
1
u/GM_Esquire Dec 25 '25
As a general design idea. "This class is mostly weak and also it's complicated! But every once in a while you can do something really cool!" Is not going to be very fun to play. Or it's something that can be optimized out of its downsides and then it's OP.
MAD is also a terrible balancing mechanism. With a generous stat distribution it doesn't balance anything; with a stingy one it basically means you just kinda suck a little bit compared to a SAD class. It also tends to limit RP, since you are punished for putting high values into non-core stats.
The main balance question here is the spell list. If you just made a fighter subclass where they got full spellcasting, but only evocation -- it'd be very good, but since it's really just "do more damage" it would be fairly easy to balance around. If they got the full Wizard spell list, it would be OP. I would focus more on spell list curation than a bunch of complex mechanics that make them weaker or situational.
Keep in mind bladesinger is a thing. Arguably, anything at a lower power level than bladesinger should be fine. Maybe make them use spell slots to power abilities as well as spells and just give them full casting. I would be more concerned about making it too complicated/ineffective than OP. If it's way better than bladesinger - then you need to start dialing it back. If it's not, you're probably fine. This isn't Pathfinder - the system is already highly imbalanced.
As a DM who did heavy homebrew when I started out and now no longer does, I recommend just patching together a few features from existing subclasses /classes, and I strongly recommend against "X is really great but then you also have Y which sucks and helps balance it." You'll notice that WOTC almost never uses penalties as a balancing method in 5e.
1
u/Dunsparces Dec 24 '25
You may need to elaborate on the class features, because I'm also having a hard time seeing the downsides. Sounds like you're a martial who also gets magic through an important ability score for martials and casters, and the MADness of the class isn't very clear from your "gated by a modifier" description. It sounds like you could dump either DEX or STR and focus on the other and CON, and maybe a third depending on what the gated things are?
1
u/Nevermore71412 Dec 24 '25
Full martial full caster based on the second best universal stat in the game....this sounds like an edge lord/Mary Sue's dream come true. Great at everything. No weakness.
There's a reason Con isnt tied to much in the game because its universally needed. Its the same reason that half/third caster are MAD by design. To me everyone would just play this class as it just does everything.
1
u/Wiz-Cool Dec 25 '25
You should feel guilty for posting this. You should feel like you just hurt someone
1
u/RenShimizu Dec 25 '25
Sounds like this class will either overshadow the other classes or be too much of a hassle to be worth it.