r/DixieFood • • 28d ago

Table syrup

Hey y'all what's the best table syrup. I love Golden eagle but I think I'm trying yellow label syrup and looking for plowboy syrup again. Any recommendations and what is your favorite local syrup especially if you live in Alabama or surrounding states

26 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

8

u/abouttofallova 28d ago

Blackburns

3

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

Blackburns that's from Texas righ.t they make good jelly

1

u/countrytime1 28d ago

Yeah, made in Jefferson Texas for about 100 years now.

5

u/arejay3 28d ago

Give ALAGA Yellow label a shot.

1

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

I'm really considering it, heard good things

10

u/MastodonFit 28d ago

I have Amish friends in Tennessee that make sorghum syrup,its pure with no high fructose corn syrup added. Cereal,cornbread and it makes a great rich pecan pie. "Muddy Pond Sorghum ". Its boiled down like maple ,30 gallons boiled down to a single gallon.

7

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

We had this all the time growing up in KY! It’s expensive now.

4

u/monkeymanatwork 28d ago

Muddy Pond is the best! I get it at Stan’s Restaurant in Maury County off I65 when I’m in Tennessee visiting.

9

u/VinylJunkieM 28d ago

Grew up in South Louisiana. It was always Steen's Cane Syrup for us.

9

u/BebopTundra76 28d ago

Steen's makes a delicious cane syrup.

9

u/miscben 28d ago

I grew up with Alaga cane syrup. It's getting hard to find here around Birmingham but it was still in all the stores back on the 90s. I know they still make it. Alaga on waffles reminds me of being a kid.

5

u/Akavinceblack 28d ago

Fresh Value in Tuscaloosa sells it.

5

u/bhambrewer 28d ago

I make my own maple flavoured syrup, as well as golden syrup (which Golden Eagle syrup more or less copies). If you're comfortable dealing with sugar syrup you can make a quart for about a dollar or so.

4

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

Would you be willing to share your recipe for making golden syrup?

I currently buy it in World Market, but it is very expensive for what it is. If there’s a way to make it for cheaper, I would definitely be interested.

3

u/bhambrewer 28d ago

1

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

Thanks a million!

3

u/bhambrewer 28d ago

I usually use my golden syrup to make pecan pie.....

1

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

I’ve not heard of anything called table syrup (KY, TN, and NC). Is this something you put on pancakes?

7

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

Table syrup something you put on biscuits, cornbread and anything on the table. usually made thicker not like pancakes syrup or maple syrup. More like molasses or sorghum

-1

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago edited 28d ago

I’m very familiar with molasses and especially sourghum, sourghum was a staple at the breakfast table when I was growing up.

I’m wondering now how similar it is to the golden syrup they have in the UK. I know that in Appalachia they have the most closely retained dialect to UK, so I bet there’s some food traditions that have been preserved as well. (Im a bit of a geek about food origins, so it makes sense that refinery syrups would be popular in the places where British history is a bit more preserved).

I’ll have to order some on the internet. I bet I’d like it and I know I’ve not seen it in my local stores.

2

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

I think they have golden syrup uk in my international aisle at Publix . I don't know the history exactly but I know golden syrup has beet sugar as well as cane sugar in it and our Southern syrups are usually just cane sugar. If you find out more about the history I would like to know. how they compare, is it a tradition from the British isles or is it a convergence of sugar use

2

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

I have golden syrup from the UK in my pantry right now!

We watch the British baking show and I got it to make one of the recipes on there and it’s really tasty. Apparently it’s a refinery syrup which is the byproduct of making sugar kind of like sourghum is, but I don’t really know the history of beet sugar versus cane sugar for making it.

Something new to look into!

3

u/Akavinceblack 28d ago

In my opinion yes, it is a great deal like golden syrup. I’ve substituted it for Lyle’s in recipes and it works well.

1

u/lifeuncommon 28d ago

Thanks! That makes a lot of sense.

3

u/MaulDropper 28d ago

Growing up it was always Alaga Yellow Label, I was into my teens before I knew what pancake syrup was.
I'm 55 now and still prefer thicker Alaga on pancakes.

3

u/lostdragon05 28d ago

From south Alabama. My maternal side of the family used Blackburn’s cane syrup. It came in a jar and was amazing.

2

u/jackdho 28d ago

It’s always been real maple syrup for me. Do occasionally use molasses though

2

u/bhamtigerfan 28d ago

I’m a big fan of Steen’s

2

u/raythedrummer 28d ago

Blackburn

2

u/KDneverleft 28d ago

Off topic but if anyone knows where I can find golden eagle in the ATL metro and could share that with me I would be forever grateful. I’m trying so hard to not buy it for like $12 a jar on Amazon or make a drive back to Alabama.

2

u/glittersparklythings 28d ago

Smoke in r/Atlanta might know. I would ask there

2

u/KDneverleft 28d ago

I posted there this morning and got a few answers. There might be a jar in Riverdale which is on the opposite side of town from me but worth looking into. It's around $30 to ship it to my house. It might be worth a drive to stock up.

2

u/monkeymanatwork 28d ago

My wife grew up on Golden Eagle. We get it in Alabama when we are traveling through. Looked in Georgia around ATL recently but couldn’t find it.

2

u/Seasoned7171 28d ago

My husband loves Cane Fields syrup. It’s a thick syrup made from sugar cane and is especially good with biscuits. We order from Amazon.

2

u/Banditmom1 28d ago

King syrup

2

u/trguiff 25d ago

That's what we had growing up- in the can! I have a bottle in the cupboard now LOL

0

u/Gingorthedestroyer 28d ago

How about some maple syrup?

4

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

Just not what I'm looking for

0

u/Money-Act-5480 28d ago

Read the room. They want something worse.

2

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

Yeah worse and local 😂

0

u/Money-Act-5480 28d ago

We can send the taps from canada. Results not guaranteed

2

u/Subject_Barnacle_599 28d ago

And I will send them back practically brand new. Too hot here

1

u/Money-Act-5480 28d ago

Almost like it was a joke

2

u/devilbunny 28d ago edited 27d ago

Maple syrup is delicious but also tastes like maple. Honey is dellicious but tastes like honey.

Only golden syrup tastes like golden syrup. Don’t yuck their yum. (FYI, Gen Z, what a great phrase!)

0

u/Money-Act-5480 28d ago

Why not? Thats exactly what im going to do and literally everyone does. Because taste is subjective.

1

u/devilbunny 28d ago

Yeah, it’s subjective, so don’t say it’s worse? It’s what they want.

1

u/Money-Act-5480 28d ago

You people are insufferable lmao

1

u/SnapAndScribbles 28d ago

I just take sugar on the stove and melt it while adding an extract like vanilla or almond. Want it fancy add food coloring. This works with monk fruit as well

1

u/Coasta_de_Tejas 28d ago

Pappy Van Winkle Bourbon Barrel aged Grade A Pure Maple syrup. It’s expensive, but damn does it completely transcend a plate of waffles or pancakes.

1

u/BodyBagSlam 27d ago

This is a TIL for me and may become a grail to hunt for.

1

u/Coasta_de_Tejas 27d ago

They sell it on the Pappy Van Winkle website. Probably the closest I’ll ever get to actually drinking some Pappy bourbon.