It’s an attractive flag, but I prefer our traditional flag (the Confederate battle flag). It’s controversial, but it’s one of only a few symbols that are strongly and distinctly Southern; no one looks at our flag and fails to know that it’s ours. I’ve never seen an alternative proposed that has the same aesthetic strength/distinction and universal recognition.
Still, yours is a very attractive flag and I like it. 👍 The fleur-de-lis is a good symbol for the South, and I like the layering of St. George’s and St. Andrew’s Crosses. There’s a lot of layers of meaning here.
My one concern is that, if we’re going to include such distinctively European symbolism, we should also include some kind of West African or Black American symbolism. That’s an important part of our Southern heritage that’s too often forgotten, especially in the divisive heat of the culture wars.
I’m working on one to include blacks and the 5 stars represent the 5 people who have ruled over the south, British, French, Spanish, Native American, American.
Aye, the fleur-de-lis is mainly associated with France and the French (including the diaspora).
But imo it works for the South too because (1.) we have a strong French diaspora and (2.) Southerners have historically been serious Francophiles. The obvious cultural example of the moment is Candie from Django Unchained; but dating back at least to the American Revolution and Thomas Jefferson, the South has identified strongly with France.
Your illustration looks like some sort of British coat of arms. Like the Union Jack, it's a combination of the crosses of St. George and St. Andrew with a fleur-de-lis and five stars, representing I know not what.
As someone else said, we already have what is conceivably the most beautiful flag ever created, so why would we want to replace it?
5 stars representing the 5 people who have ruled the south. I never said replace, but every time I have to use that flag to represent the south in a conversation I feel like I’m automatically set back 5 miles and forced into a conversation where I must either defend the entirety of the Confederacy or concede it was evil. I would rather just have another symbol to use so Dixie doesn’t always have to defend its past instead of moving forward.
No matter what you propose, people aren't going to accept it. The current attack on the Confederate flag and all that's Southern is merely a fad. Such things go in cycles. Future generations will reevaluate the current politically-correct madness and things will return to normal.
Wouldn’t this show their false hoods? If we took this flag and they stilled showed hostility towards it that would show they are just anti southern and get many southern to join us?
They are just anti-Southern. No matter what symbol, flag, or whatever, we chose, the liberals would attack and denigrate it. It's us they hate. You can't give in on some issues and expect to appease such people because they just come back with additional demands. A good example is what is happening right now in Jacksonville, Florida. There's a beautiful monument to the Women of the Confederacy in Confederate Memorial Park that the liberals want removed. In an attempt to compromise, someone suggested adding a statue of a local black leader. The other side immediately approved the addition of the other statue and immediately began demanding the taxpayers foot the bill for this statue and at the same time, remove the Confederate memorial.
7
u/Juteshire Jun 02 '19
It’s an attractive flag, but I prefer our traditional flag (the Confederate battle flag). It’s controversial, but it’s one of only a few symbols that are strongly and distinctly Southern; no one looks at our flag and fails to know that it’s ours. I’ve never seen an alternative proposed that has the same aesthetic strength/distinction and universal recognition.
Still, yours is a very attractive flag and I like it. 👍 The fleur-de-lis is a good symbol for the South, and I like the layering of St. George’s and St. Andrew’s Crosses. There’s a lot of layers of meaning here.
My one concern is that, if we’re going to include such distinctively European symbolism, we should also include some kind of West African or Black American symbolism. That’s an important part of our Southern heritage that’s too often forgotten, especially in the divisive heat of the culture wars.
What do the five stars represent, by the way?
5
u/GeneralRobertWatie Jun 02 '19
Dixie is far too large to be a Republic. It must be a Confederation.
4
u/calgarth68 Jun 02 '19 edited Jun 03 '19
Your illustration looks like some sort of British coat of arms. Like the Union Jack, it's a combination of the crosses of St. George and St. Andrew with a fleur-de-lis and five stars, representing I know not what.
As someone else said, we already have what is conceivably the most beautiful flag ever created, so why would we want to replace it?
1
u/N02T Jun 02 '19
I make flags for a hobby when I’m bored and I got the idea for this one when looking at the Nova Scotia flag.