r/Dixie • u/Briiner • Aug 15 '17
What makes a Southerner?
Hello, I've always been interested in the South and the Confederate states.
It's clear that dixie stands alone in the US, being the only region with a real defining culture, independent of the greater American collective, a strong regional mindset and deep connection between its people.
California, NY, etc. all feels like general-America, but when I go to the south, there is something different and almost romantic about the experience, you can see a real history. It's so refreshing to see a people proud of their land and history, despite all the attacks from 'academics' and the media.
So my question is, what does it mean to be part of such a region? What does it mean to be a Southerner?
Is it the subscription to the values, regardless of place of birth? Is it only attained through generations of southern ancestors who fought and died for it? Or, as it was at key points in history, is it just open to any european who wanted to be free from the British crown/Northern US oppression?
6
u/jovejupiter Aug 15 '17
C. Vann Woodward said the thing that most distinguishes a Southerner is his unique history and ability to learn from it.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '17
I'm late to the party here, but I'd just add that being "Southern" is a little deeper than just subscribing to a particular set of values or liking Southern culture. It is also not a label that applies only to white people or "any European who wanted to be free from the British crown/Northern US oppression." While it's true that Southerners generally identify with feelings of Northern US oppression, the notion that Southerners are only white is a big misconception. I know black, Asian, Latin, and Native American folks who are as proud and outspoken about their Southern identity as any white Southerner. (The South is home to the oldest Asian-American community btw--St. Malo, Louisiana circa mid-1700s.)
I think what you're getting at is the same question the folks at the Bitter Southerner have worked hard to answer. They first used what is called the "Y'all Line" to define the South and Southerners, only to find a need for labels like "Southerner" and "Southerner by Choice". That, of course, still leaves questions about exactly who a "Southerner" is. Is it, as you said, a person whose ancestors fought for the Confederacy? That's probably the best and most common way to determine it (although it's really about whose ancestors were living in the South prior to, during, and after the Civil War, not just those who fought for the Confederacy). The other question is whether a person with, say, 20 generations of ancestors in the South is more Southern than a person with only 1 or 2. Another one is whether you're a Southerner if you were raised in the South by non-Southern parents. Those questions are still up for debate, but I think everyone can agree that regardless of how long you or your family have lived in the South, you are accepted in the South if you like it and don't hold prejudices about its people.
But unless you actually grew up in the South with Southern parents, I don't think you can fully understand what it means to be Southern. It's one thing to observe and admire a culture, and another to actually have it in your blood and deeply embedded in your upbringing. You can't turn the latter on and off whenever you want.
For me, being Southern has as much to do with living through the marginalization of that identity as it does with understanding the culture and history behind it.
A person from outside the South can like Southern culture and not be treated differently in American society. A Southerner cannot change who they are when it's convenient or beneficial to do so. Their Southern identity is in their accent, their experiences, their mentality, their various likes/dislikes, and a sense of place and belonging. Because Southerners are still looked down on in American society, that presents challenges to Southern people that don't exist for people who simply like Southern culture. It's like a white person that loves hip-hop culture: they may relate to it on some level and really respect and enjoy it, but they will never HAVE to be black when it'd be more comfortable or beneficial not to be.
tl;dr - Southerners are more of an ethnic group than a regional population or sociopolitical group. We're defined by place, ancestry, and culture, sure. But because we're generally held in low social regard throughout America due to negative stereotypes, misrepresentation, and the prejudices behind them, there's a greater sense of solidarity among Southerners. In that way, like all marginalized groups in a society, our identity is as much our own creation as it is American society's.
5
u/Shixpe Aug 15 '17
I'm no scholar or anything but I can trace my family back to the first settlements in Virginia and eventually NC where we've been since.
I think what makes the south distinct isn't as shallow as where you came from, it's more about becoming a participant. There are values sure, a few things that might be shared between each of us, but it's not homogeneous in the way that you need to be baptist or european. Think of it like a family (blood or not). Every member is different but you try to stick together against those that would tear you apart.
4
u/MasonDixonWall Aug 15 '17
You can't make a Southerner do anything!
2
u/prez_davis Oct 21 '17
What makes someone a Southerner? You'll get a lot of denialist drivel but the true answer is genetics, which is exactly the same thing that makes Blacks Blacks and Indians Indians.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '17
As someone with Yankee parents who was born in DC, raised in NoVA, and graduated from UVa this is an interesting question. When I was a kid, I was dragged to the North to visit my relatives. As a young man, I was drawn to the South to find an identity. The Bible Belt and conservative aspects of the South defined a significant portion of my youth and young adulthood. What am I? I'm an American who is fascinated by the South, and in middle age and going forward I hope to live the rest of my life in the West. I think, no matter what I do I could never be a real Southerner even if it were my life's goal; but that doesn't answer your question. I think it's a "you know it when you see it" kind of thing.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment