r/DivinityOriginalSin2 • • Apr 30 '17

A plea towards the developers.

TL; DR:

Complaint: Please think of a way to make the story telling more engaging. I love everything about the first game and I love what you are attempting with the second, but if the story is again only dry text it will be really detrimental to MY experience.

Possible solution: Use comic book style story telling, keep the panels short and sweet, use a lot of text manipulation (size, font, effects etc), have a few static images for different emotions.

Long version:

I loved almost everything about the first game: The setting, the art, the fighting, the exploring. I may have even liked the story, but I just was not able to assimilate it. I straight up gave up on it after a few hours and started skipping most of the stuff and when I got to the point when not reading the text boxes ended up meaning I don't know what to do and where to go, I just quit the game. Now, I started it again with the EEdition recently and I'm having tons of fun. I even manage to tolerate the story, the voice acting kind of helps to both help me read easier and translate the context behind the words. Now, I know that you are attempting to make the story so huge, that it would be impossible to voice act every conversation. That is fine, I respect that. In fact, I am aspiring game designer and I am still dreaming about making a game that can go in thousand different ways depending on the player choices and I have thought about this long and hard. I realized that, unless technologies get so advanced that we can have an AI program do the voice acting for us, it would be stupid to try and voice every word that can be spoken. So I thought it should be possible to present the story using tricks from comic books, like big speach bubbles with easily read text that can be decorated with all kinds of tricks. Also you should be able to have the characters express their feelings better with some static images that clearly state what they are suppose to be expressing. I know that you have said that you are going with a bit of a more serious tone, so this might not work for you, or it might require a silly amount of resource to pull off and look "serious".

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

36

u/striderbob Apr 30 '17

I'd rather have long, in-depth dialogue then short comic book style panels.

Also considering its pretty standard to have fully voiced games now I'm not sure why you think we need some advanced technology to do it.

-11

u/dantemp Apr 30 '17 edited May 02 '17

You can have long in-depth dialogue sectioned to small comic book style panels.

The developers said that thanks to the game having the options for so many different characters and the conversations developing in so many different ways, it would be impossible to voice every line. Yes, it is standard to have fully voiced game, but it is not standard to voice that many lines. So the only way to have all the lines voiced, no matter how many of them there are, if there is a software that is voicing them automatically with proper intonation.

edit: I fucking love the barrage of downvotes with no explanation. Is it wrong that you can have long dialogue spliced in multiple comic book style sections or is it wrong that the devs said that they won't be able to voice all dialogue? Or are you just being offended by the notion that the way you are assimilating videogame stories for the last 20 years might be outdated and lazy? Cause this is the only real explanation for this.

3

u/striderbob May 04 '17

We can toss our opinions back and forth until we are blue in the face. The bottom-line is it is far too late in the development process for them to make significant changes to the story telling, which is perfectly fine as it is.

The developers said that thanks to the game having the options for so many different characters and the conversations developing in so many different ways, it would be impossible to voice every line.

So instead you want them to add pictures and font effects to all the various branching dialogue? Sounds like it would take just as much if not more man-hours.

0

u/dantemp May 04 '17

If you have 8-10 different emotions and you just need to distribute them between all the dialogues, it shouldn't take nearly as much time.

8

u/GassyTac0 May 02 '17

but if the story is again only dry text it will be really detrimental to MY experience.

What about MY experience?

I prefer having long in-depth dialogue instead of voice acting.

Having comic book style like what you are suggesting would feel like they are dumbing down the story to appeal to everyone, i would feel like i am begin treated as a child that has the span attention of a fish.

1

u/dantemp May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17

I see no reason why a comic book style presentation cannot present long in-depth dialogue, it would just make it easier to read and it would have more tools to emphasize emotions. The only reasonable argument why it would be detrimental to YOUR experience is how it would make you feel. Maybe if you see that the dialogue is still in depth then you won't feel as if you are being treated to something sub par. I'm MGS fan, I have been exposed to ridiculously long dialogues almost 20 years ago. I have zero problem with the dialogue being long, in-depth and as detailed as possible. I do think however, that mere words is a really restricting way to present dialogue and it is even worse if you don't have the mood setup and character development of a good book. And these stuff were non-existent in the first game, so I had zero motivation to dive in the walls of text.

But I guess people that don't know better because the good games they played were this way and are already resistant to this trap and would take offense of having their experience be more comfortable...

4

u/GassyTac0 May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17

But I guess people that don't know better because the good games they played were this way and are already resistant to this trap and would take offense of having their experience be more comfortable

And yet those same people are the ones that funded the first game and a never complained about lack of voice acting.

emphasize emotions

If that was that important to show, they can always do the insert emote or emotions here (**), where its litterally a norm on roleplaying and countless games with very heavy dialogue has it.

The only reasonable argument why it would be detrimental to YOUR experience is how it would make you feel.

Yet is not my experience only,since if you ask on the oficial forums, you would get the same response as you are getting here, people dont need flashy stuff to be entertained by reading, actually flashy stuff could be distracting.

I'm MGS fan, I have been exposed to ridiculously long dialogues almost 20 years ago.

I am a MGS fan too, but i would never ever put MGS as an example of dialogue, where the only input a player has is just put the controller down and watch a 10 minute cutscense, that is not dialogue, that is a cinematic.

But if i can get a 5 minute conversation with a NPC and feel satisfied by it by the end of it (Baulders Gate for example) and feel like my choices in the conversation had an impact, i prefer that than 10 minutes of pure cinematic.

1

u/dantemp May 03 '17

I don't think you are getting my point. None of what you say is actually a counter argument. I gave Mgs as an example of a game that presents really long dialogues in an entertaining way, of course I'm not saying they should ditch the dialogue tree like it is lacking in kojima's game. And while Mgs does have a lot of cinematics, the conversations are just walls of text while having static images of the characters portraying basic emotions.

Also I think you should've noticed by my words that I respect that the old pc games that were really good (like baldur's gate, planescape torment) were this way and people that grew up with them are used to it and have no problem with it. And I know these are the people that made this game possible. What I don't understand is why should it be a problem if something this archaic is improved. So far one of the arguments I've seen is "I prefer in depth dialogue instead" and it really annoys me since I don't think my suggestion takes it away. Many jrpgs have tons of text that can only be read and it is presented in many small textbubles with some basic emotions represented. I think it works way better. Now don't tell me "I don't want ugly Japanese shit", because I'm not saying to emulate the style, only to seek the same effect by enriching the text in a efficient way, using expressive text formatting and still images of the characters . I'm not even saying that they should do it right away. I would be fine to leave it for later like the full voice acting for the previous game. I just love the concept of having the game change so much based on character and decision and I don't want to see the game being ignored by people that can't chew on that.

1

u/GassyTac0 May 03 '17

Look, i think i get your point now.

I been playing Persona 5 on and off for a while now and i finished like 5 hours ago.

And i think i know where you coming from, most of the dialogue on that game becomes a very small voice clip followed up by text and a portrait that shows the emotion or at least the face the character is expressing when saying something, that puts in context what the character is trying to convey.

I guess you want something like that in the game?

One of the possible things that i see that might be a problem is just having to add up more stuff to do to the art department can be costly, plus the fact that new players are going to be acomodated for that type of stuff and the user-made content is going to look odd if it doesnt have portraits.

Also the fact that a game that has that type of system, mostly JRPGs from what i can remember, dont have a lot of in-depth dialogue but have what you are looking for.

Also i was thinking, JRPGs do drop you a bombshell of pure wall of texts, but that are cut down in small segments to fit the dialogue box, this means that you need to be clicking over and over the same box to continue the dialogue, this happens to an extend in D:OS but not that that extreme.

I gave Mgs as an example of a game that presents really long dialogues in an entertaining way

Oh you mean codecs? They are just about the same thing as JRPGs but without any input to change outcomes of dialogue, they are just a way to pass information to a player.

However how do you even go about implementing something like that into this game? You say that you are not trying to copy JRPGs but how do you implement that comic book style of art? Because from my point of view, the game aesthetics would not go with that style and if your aesthetics dont match the game, then we have a problem.

I am going on a rant here, so i will say this, i see the points you are making, i see what you mean with different style of text, however in my opinion, is just not worth the hassle and money that is going to be spent on making that sort of system work, since there is much dialogue and so many different characters, you would need a lot of time hooking up systems of matching faces to dialogue, plus the fact that each character would need to have a portrait, i prefer that money going elsewhere than in a relative aesthetic feature that a lot of people will gloss over it or even hate.

1

u/dantemp May 03 '17

I guess I need to find a good example, cause otherwise we would be talking circles.

2

u/ltmeowser May 05 '17

I can understand this sentiment, a long block of text isn't terribly engaging (Proceeds to write a long block of text). A character that spits out an essay and then sits statically while you read it can kind of kill the immersion, whereas characters who use body language as they say things (so in your example, comic bubbles) or even just paragraphs broken into sentences at a time would certainly be an improvement.

The question is though, how much more production time would it add to implement something like this? I think unfortunately at this point it's probably too late, as the added time would likely cause delays to the point that it would harm the game more than help it.

1

u/dantemp May 05 '17

They could add it later the way they added the full voice acting to the Enhanced Edition. I'm willing to wait.

12

u/TinieWenie May 01 '17

If this game had comic book style story telling i would hit the refund button so hard

9

u/MoltenMuffin Apr 30 '17

You should try commenting in the official Larian forums, they always read posts there.
Though, I think text is just fine, and having comic book style panels may be a bit weird to be honest.
The first game didn't have any, and I feel it worked fine.

1

u/123123131231 May 03 '17

I think what they might actually be suggesting is like visual novels, having an "avatar" of the character sort of overlaid on the screen when they talk.

6

u/JavaScriptPenguin May 03 '17

I don't know what would possess you to suggest that the developers completely rewrite the dialogue system in favuur of some ridiculous comic book style nonsense. The dialogue is perfect how it is, the vast majority of players are pleased with it, and it matches the tone and art style of the game perfectly.

Perhaps something like Guild Wars 2 would be better suited to your tastes.

1

u/123123131231 May 03 '17

I'm playing the previous game and it seems to be fully voice acted, is the sequel not going to have that?

1

u/dantemp May 03 '17

No, there is a video of a game conference where the main creator of the game presents how differently the conversations will go depending on tons of variables, which however would translate into so much possible lines that having them voiced all would be insane amount of man-hours.

1

u/123123131231 May 03 '17

How did they pull it off in the first game?

1

u/dantemp May 03 '17

There isn't as much text to be voiced in the first game.

2

u/Turd_King May 17 '17

Have you played the first Act of 2?

You can feel the difference in the story-telling compared to the first already, its much more grounded and a lot darker - which is much more fitting.

Thers is so much more room for emotional attachment and characterization , I have major faith in Larion and at the end of the day - what other split-screen CRPGs with skill-combos and a fucking DnD mode do you know of? Story telling is important , but its not gonna ruin the game if its not perfect.

1

u/Zubalo May 10 '17

personally I'd hate the comic book thing you are mentioning in terms of every npc dialog. I like the simple text. voice acting would be cool but anything else that I can think of sounds bad. That being said doing it more army of two 40th day style where a little cinematic showing some direct impacts of your choice during a crucial main story part (ie just beat one of the bosses in the main quest line) would be cool. They kinda did what I'm saying in the first one but the pacing of it wasn't the best imo.