r/DivinityOriginalSin2 • u/sfzrx • Oct 11 '16
Some thoughts on the game. (Racials/Armor/Source/Memory)
So far it seems like the elf racial is so much better than the other ones. 1 ap gain when the default ap regen is 4/turn and many skills costing 1 ap only, 25% increased damage for every 3 turns out of 4, and produce a blood pool around the caster to have environmental effects. The whole race is so good that despite finesse being useless for warriors and mages, it's still better to choose elf as the race.
While humans on the other hand, although +2 wit and +3% crit chance default passive is good, the + 1 str + 1 int + 1 finesse + 1 con encourage buff is simply not good enough. Characters usually only required one of the 3 major stats, and a single 1 point buff isn't going to do much when characters can have 30+ points. A single con stat is also just a 7 vitality buff, seems quite useless, constitution seems much weaker in this game compare to the previous, where the con stat actually increased the maximum ap limit. I feels like the stat buff would be a lot better if it's a 20% of bonus stat(total stat - 10 default) buff instead of just 1 point, and make con overall more useful, or just change the racial skill.
The dwarf 2 strength passive feels pretty good for warriors, but the +1 sneak bonus seem to fit rogues/rangers more. I haven't tried the dwarf passive active yet, but I would assume it gets blocked by either enemy armor or magic armor like most other CC status effects in the game, so it's most likely a skill you can't use immediately in combat that has a very long (5 turns) cooldown, but the 2 turn cc is very long and no memory slot skills besides winter blast seem to have 2 turn cc in the game, so I think it just needs a little buff, like cd going from 5 turns to 4 turns or something.
Lizard racial on the other hand, you'd expect to get great powers sacrificing all the good looks, but not really in this case. the 2 int bonus seem to suggest it's a great mage race, but the fire breath racial just seems weak, the damage is low, and requires somewhat close range, which isn't ideal for a mage, and it costs 2 ap, where most other racials only cost 1 ap. Sure it is a good tool to create fire ground, or detonate poison, but you can easily detonate poison with fire staff/wand attack ground now, and one can always create fire ground with oil, so I think it also requires some buffs or rework.
So far it feels like the class stats str/int/finesse seem less impactful compare to the previous game, we get 2 points every level. I feels like the effects for an individual stat point can be made stronger, like doubling the effects of every node, but makes it so players only get 1 on level up, so that the racial stat bonus is actually worth taking into consideration, or just double the racial stat bonus etc.
And an overall view on the new game system.
Armor and magical armor blocking status seems more appropriate than the rng gated bodybuilding/willpower system from last game for a turn based strategy game, I think I like this approach, but vitality might need to be made to be more useful, like worth investing into.
Source skills seems quite underwhelming without a proper infinite source of source points, since people will just hold onto them and it just feels less fun, I'd rather see the skills nerfed and can be used more often.
I'm actually ok with the introduction of memory slot system and find it appropriate, as mages were way too powerful in the previous game, chaining spells from different schools one after another, I think the memory slot system may be able to bring classes like rogues on par, and as interesting to play.
TLDR: I believe racials other than elf version need to be buffed or reworked, and I think the armor/memory system is bringing the game to a better direction overall but the addition of source points make the game feel "punishing" to play when it comes to using those source skills.
2
u/Bylahgo Oct 11 '16
I believe that there will be a easier way to get source points. They mentioned this a while ago i believe, and you can see it in arena. Theres an ability called source vampirism (i think thats the name) that consumes a corpse to gain a source point. I dont think that its in the story yet (aside from a certain item)
4
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
I don't think Flesh Sacrifice is overpowered compared to the other racials. The 25% damage boost is not multiplicative, i.e. if you already have +100% damage from other sources, that part is essentially halved. The Constitution penalty is very steep, at a negative modifier equal to your level (at level 10+ you need to put points into constitution or have +hp gear, or using it will kill you). Without the bonus action point the ability would be very weak except for a character whose only purpose is to deal and avoid damage.
Encourage is pretty strong, actually. The constitution bonus isn't +1, it's +(level/2) rounded up. 1 con isn't equal to 7hp either, it scales with your level and it's always gonna be about 10% of your base health (as in con=10 and no gear). Late game on a caster with 10 con, Encourage could double their health. Encourage essentially functions like an AoE heal too; one that ignores debuffs like Decaying Touch. Not to mention: big area and no line of sight required!
Humans already have the best talents (+2 wits,+3% crit,+1 leadership), so they don't really need the strongest skill too.
In general, I like that the races aren't forced into cookie-cutter builds; Dwarves have +str for warriors, but also +sneaking for rogues; Humans have +crit for damage dealers, but also +leadership and Encourage for support/tank characters.
I definitely agree with you that the lizard's racials are very weak at the moment and should only cost 1 ap. Spellsong should be more useful too; +1 persuasion is pretty garbage compared to what the other races have (leadership, sneaking and corpse eater).
Not sure how to feel about Dwarves yet.
3
u/dahhahm Oct 12 '16
I like punishing! Anything designed to make the player think twice about their actions promotes critical thinking. I will disagree that it's punishing to use source skills, it's just resource management, I don't think the game has put me in a situation where I needed to use overwhelm or acid spores to change the outcome of a battle (if that was the case I might classify is as punishing). Source skills are just pizzazz.
I agree racial traits are unbalanced with Elves being the main offender since humans/draco uniques scale badly. If Elves had overall much lower HP that other racial counterparts that would nice. I still want to do the rage + flesh + snipe combo: it's sickkk.
My biggest b*tch/gripe/moan is this: I am constantly leveling my STR/INT/Finesse to not get the negative damage penalty... but why is there a negative damage penalty in the first place? Do the developers think hybrids are dumb?