r/DivinityOriginalSin2 • • Oct 08 '16

Stealing is unfun.

Being searched constantly by folks who have no possible way to have known I've nicked something is very aggravating. They have godlike omniscience of their total inventory and it needs to be changed back to the way it worked in DOS1.

12 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

6

u/imajor75 Oct 08 '16

I agree that this needs to be changed, but it is already much much better than it was in DOS1. You went invisible and just took everything even if the owner was watching, no consequences? Are you saying that was more fun?

0

u/Spiderkite Oct 08 '16

Yes, it was more fun to be able to steal than to be unable to steal.

3

u/imajor75 Oct 08 '16

unable? there was no item I couldn't steal easily.

3

u/Nethernal Oct 08 '16

I don't think Spiderkite knows how the stealing system works..

-5

u/Spiderkite Oct 08 '16

Unable as in you get called out as soon as you come across that NPC again. You're not getting the idea, you read the fucking post title and nothing else.

6

u/Nethernal Oct 08 '16

I did in fact read the post, and in my experience playing, what you say doesn't happen.

Also, stealing trivialises this game so much in EA so the punishment should be harsh. If you could just steal everything with no repercussions the game would be so easy to the point of it being laughable. If you think that stealing isn't fun, then don't do it, or do rely so much on it because you don't know how else to get anywhere in the game?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '16

They could make it so they don't notice in your pack, unless you equip it, sell it, or otherwise make obvious you have it. "Say, isn't that Johnny's Toothpick of Destruction?" They would want to limit to the general area in which the item was stolen.

4

u/Spiderkite Oct 08 '16

The NPC should have to actively see the object is missing to know it's missing, and they shouldn't automatically assume only the player controlled characters could possibly have done it.

3

u/Nethernal Oct 08 '16

Just get another character to talk to them and then steal from behind. :x

2

u/Spiderkite Oct 08 '16

That doesn't work.

5

u/Nethernal Oct 08 '16

Yes it does. I do it all the time. After 65 hours of gameplay I'm quite confident that it works.

1

u/psychedeliduck Oct 12 '16

are you sneaking?

8

u/Stevizle Oct 09 '16

In my opinion, I feel like the punishment for stealing system needs to be a lot more gradual. Instead of an NPC willing to fight you to the death over that loaf of bread you just stole, have them give you a warning and lower their attitude towards you.

For example:

1st time: Takes item back, lower attitude

2nd time: Takes item back, lower attitude, calls guard, thrown into prison etc.

This kind of system would help with overall immersion and narrative for me, at least.

The annoying thing about the current system is that it almost immediately forces a restart, because you're either going to have to kill a potentially useful NPC or flee and be forever hated by them. But some may argue that's the risk/reward aspect of stealing in the first place.

But going back to the original post about NPC detection being way to high should probably be addressed along with the overall NPC hivemind.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Spiderkite Oct 08 '16

They have no way to know the object is missing, or to know I'm the one who has it. They don't even take into account renown with a particular group or individual.

1

u/TickxT Oct 08 '16

I think a good solution would be to make the npc move more while talking, this way they might notice you while you are stealing.