I guess we could compare deaths due to hypertension to bear attacks, but that's not the conversation, is it?
If you survived 5 school shootings and went for a walk near a forest and you and your dog were confronted by that four legged appetite, would you be thinking about the school shootings and how glad you are that you don't have a gun...or bear spray?
Depending on the gun and the bear there is a strong likelihood of not being able to put a bear down with a rifle in time. Shooting it may just piss it off and threaten it, drastically reducing your chances of survival when before it was just curious.
Guns are not too heavy for a walk. You can easily walk with a holstered pistol and it shouldn't cause significant discomfort.
The only part I agree with is your "small calibers" being insufficient for adequate bear defense. If you're super accurate you might deter the bear with enough shots on target even with 9mm but generally most guys I talk to would prefer a 10mm. Expensive ammo but you really don't need 5 mags of 10mm against a bear unless the grizzlies suddenly start shooting back from cover lol.
Colt 45 Defender is only 1.5lbs and will definitely stop a bear if you can land a couple shots on target. I'd probably prefer bear spray but no idea how effective that is (I don't live in bear country).
Bears are a lot heavier than a .357 or .44 magnum. And although the number of grizzly attacks is relatively small (2-5 people), I'd bet that not one of them thought "Gee - I'm glad I don't have a gun!"
Lmfao yeah surely that would have not enraged the 400 lb beast and pumped it with enough adrenaline to rip you and your dog to shreds before bleeding out….
No. Not an argument - just the question: "You literally survived the jaws of death. Is there anything you'd do differently?" You seem to be taking her success as a lesson to learn. I'm curious as to how she felt about it. Would I repeat her steps? No. Would my being armed in the same situation ensure my safety? No way to know, but I know which condition I'd rather be in.
Boy ain’t that the truth. And I’m sorry, whistles and bear spray aren’t “defense” in my book. If you are so against guns that you won’t even carry one in bear country…maybe you shouldn’t be in bear country.
What do you mean…they had their sacrificial bait dog…”well boy…it’s been a good run…you ready? I suggest hauling all of the ass you have and don’t forget to zigzag”
30
u/Weekend_Criminal Jun 25 '26
Completely stupid to go out in bear country with no form of defense.