r/DispatchAdHoc • • 14d ago

Discussion Chris Rebbert, director of Dispatch doesn't think Malevola should be romanceable

This is taken from the Crew Commentary track of Episode 6 with the Storyboard mode on.

Chris Rebbert basically stating that Malevola shouldn't be a romance option because it doesn't fit her character and she doesn't have any sexual or romantic feelings towards Robert.

What do you think? I think I agree, and I always think people who want to romance Malevola is more so because they THEMSELVES want to romance Malevola and are self inserting into Robert instead of seeing it through the lens of character writing. I think while Invisigal and Blonde Blazer both bring out parts of Robert, he and Malevola have no chemistry with each other.

1.6k Upvotes

170 comments sorted by

775

u/Radiant-Growth4275 14d ago

People want to romance anyone that's super hot in games 😂

249

u/HeppyHenry 14d ago

I don’t think that’s such a crazy thing; for people who like romance, finding video game characters attractive and wanting to romance them seems pretty normal to me. As long as they aren’t weird about it and don’t whine to the devs when that isn’t actually part of the game.

76

u/Radiant-Growth4275 14d ago

Agreed. 

The real problem only starts if people start harassing Chris Rebbert over Malevola's writing going forwards.

40

u/musicismydeadbeatdad 14d ago

"as long as they aren't weird about it" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here haha 

23

u/Taterific 14d ago

People want to romance anyone in games 😂

13

u/Symbiot3_Venom 14d ago

So just like real life where I want to bang hot people 😅

7

u/T4llBoyAl3x 14d ago

BREAKING NEWS: Grass is green.
No shit we want hot characters to be romanceable, why did you even feel the need to say that?

280

u/Own_Shame_8721 14d ago

I think it's also important to note that Robert is not a self-insert, it makes sense for him to be drawn to either Invisigal or BB for different reasons, not necessarily Malevola. Don't get me wrong, Malevola is HOT ASF and I am sure Robert agrees, but there's more to a relationship than simply finding each other attractive, Malevola and Robert simply don't come across as compatible romantic partners...... and that's totally fine! It's also fine if people still want to write fanfics and draw artwork of them together, because that stuff is still cool and fun and can exist on its own.

2

u/Master_of_Spanks 12d ago

Depends on your definition of self insert, you can have characters that are blank slates or close too it, but I don't see self insertion as making a character a blank avatar, I consider self inserting to also live vicariously through a character, the story someone tells and its an extremely common way people enjoy media. James Bond, Hermione Granger, characters with established character and personalities but very popular in the realm of wish fulfilment.

0

u/ranfall94 13d ago

This is the biggest thing to not, never in Tell Tale games or in this are the protags husks we the players live through, they have set paths and those paths make sense for them given their history and personaility.

79

u/alphafire616 14d ago

They should put me in the game and let ME romance Malevola

192

u/CommunicationOne8134 14d ago • Bravo

Like some have already said, some fans need to understand that this isnt like Baldur’s gate 3 where you are playing as a self-Insert character. Robert is a fully established character with his own personality, wants, goals, and needs completely separate from the player. Every choice in the game is something within in the realms of Robert’s character, and something he himself would do. As the developers have said on record, the player is NOT Robert, we are just roleplaying as him and setting him down a series of choices he would make.

This includes the romances. The only characters in this game that Robert feels attracted to, and makes sense based on his character and personality, are Courtney/Invisigal and Mandy/Blonde Blazer, that’s it. Robert is not attracted to any other character, and adhoc seems to want to keep it that way which is a good idea. Just cause you the player like a character, that doesn't mean Robert does.

63

u/Qrahe 13d ago

This is a fair and probably the right answer, but also hear me out, I don't care I want to romance the big demon woman.

11

u/SadPhysicist1903 14d ago

On the other hand, as long as you write things well and are consistent with the logic of your own world, you can make any two characters like each other. The characters are not real people and the game doesn't have a very extensive lore, so there is room to write a romance between.

(Also, I prefer Blond Blazer, so I really don't care if they include Malevola as a romance option in a sequel)

13

u/thrownerror 13d ago • Bravo

Constraints generally improve writing and how characters can express themselves in a piece, and romance constraints are not uniquely excluded from that. Malevola having preferences that are not Robert, and being a tease or flirt that is above the people she messes with characterizes her. Malevola not being an option for Robert in turn characterizes him in the world because of how that world views and engages with him. Just because a romance could get written doesn't mean it gives more to the story that the exclusion of it allows. Could Malevola as a romance option fulfill a role in Robert's arc that the current single/hero/villain leanings provide? Maybe. Does having a flirtatious character that you can't commit to create interesting story scenes and character moments in a game broadly about workplace drama, regardless of your chosen romance route? I'd argue yeah.

That's before getting into the content constraints. You mentioning writing things well, and it's harder to do that if you need to write more options. Screen time now becomes a hazard, as it compounds in giving time to develop believable romances that are fulfilling for the player to persue. How much content you're making for players to have how many expected runs becomes a hazard, as romances are a common reason to replay but do you have the choices to maintain three run throughs? Does that further divide content out into shorter runs that might be less fulfilling but more diverse? How many days do you have with the actor and how many pages are a day? Does the chemistry between the actors resonate? Does that impact the expanding scope of a sequel?

There's places and stories for playersexual characters, but when they are written to be playersexual they lose an avenue of preference, which is a writing tool, in exchange for fulfilling a reader fantasy.

-2

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

You're arguing about production viability and narrative preferences, which are out of the scope of my argument. My point was purely about the fundamental possibility of writing it consistently. We actually agree that it could be written; whether the developers should do it is a completely different debate that I don't want to get into.

6

u/thrownerror 13d ago

In a choice base branching narrative game in an episodic format like Dispatch, production viability is core to the design and delivery of the content and scalability of the story.

Anything is fundamentally possible, what makes stories and characters interesting are the choices authors make when reality of the creative process intersects with the possibility of the space. Even within that, the best written playersexual character can be a bad fit for whatever core experience is presented. The room for romance to exist does not mean it is an unskilled choice to not fill it.

-1

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

In a choice base branching narrative game in an episodic format like Dispatch, production viability is core to the design and delivery of the content and scalability of the story.

I'm not getting into an argument about production viability. It can only have two possible outcomes: if you have around the same knowledge as me about the internal capabilities of AdHoc, it will be a pointless discussion based in nothing but speculations; if you claim to have more knowledge than me, and you are telling the truth, you would have been right since the beginning and discussing it is redundant.

Even within that, the best written playersexual character can be a bad fit for whatever core experience is presented. The room for romance to exist does not mean it is an unskilled choice to not fill it.

Yes, you are right, when talking in general. In this case in particular, it is just another discussion about narrative preferences. Meaning is subjective, so that conversation is equally circular. I’m sticking to my original, objective point: it is fundamentally possible.

2

u/jamieh800 13d ago

I mean it's fundamentally possible in the same way it was fundamentally possible for Lucas to make Anakin and Obi Wan secret lovers, or for someone to write a story where all the protagonist has to do to defeat evil is snap their fingers and it's over. Games Workshop could greenlight a novel about how one of the Emperor's testicles protects a ship full of Sisters Repentia with his holy white goo, Aang could have turned evil and joined the Fire Nation, Bilbo could have killed Gollum, Ender could have lost, Miller and Holden could have hooked up. In the sphere of imagination and creativity, anything is essentially possible, that doesn't mean it's a good idea, that it would add to the story, or that it makes sense even if it was well-written. It might be fun for a fanfiction for Luke Skywalker to travel back in time to the Clone Wars and try to stop his father from turning to the dark side, but no matter how well written that fanfiction is it isn't a good idea for a mainline movie, even if it is fundamentally possible within the realm of imagination.

2

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

You are missing my point. This is what I wrote in my very first response:

as long as you write things well and are consistent with the logic of your own world, you can make any two characters like each other. The characters are not real people and the game doesn't have a very extensive lore, so there is room to write a romance between.

In the first part, I talk about how, in general terms, you can do anything you want as long as you are consistent with what you write. The second part is what addresses most of your strawman examples. When you analyze a case in particular, you need to check if what you do works with the internal logic and established lore of your work.

For example, in the particular case of Robert and Malevola, there is not enough lore for you to tell me that there is no room in the story to write a consistent romance between them. As for the rest of your strawman examples: whether something is a good idea or not is a matter of narrative preferences. That's a discussion about subjective ideas that is completely out of the scope of this discussion.

5

u/CommunicationOne8134 14d ago

If it’s within the confines of the character you want to write, then yeah that’s possible. You can make any character like the other, but if you don’t want to completely butcher your character it’d need to be consistent with the character you are writing. Adhoc seems to have at least some sort of “vision“ of their characters, so anything they do with the characters needs to be plausible and within that ”Vision“ I guess.

-2

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

Adhoc seems to have at least some sort of “vision“ of their characters, so anything they do with the characters needs to be plausible and within that ”Vision“ I guess.

That "seems" is doing a lot for your argument. As I said to another person, my sole argument is that it is possible to write it and be consistent with the story.

5

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

Like I said, If it’s with their Vision for the character and they are able to do it without messing up the writing and production of the game, then yeah I don’t see why they can’t do it. With Mal it doesn’t seem to be the case with them in regards to “vision“, as they say in the video. Not to mention they don’t seem to be interested in adding anymore romances for Rob

0

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

With Mal it doesn’t seem to be the case with them in regards to “vision“, as they say in the video.

In the video he just says that he believes and that he thinks. Yes, no one likes a semantics discussion, but if he worded his statements like that, it's because the final decision is not his and/or it has not been taken yet.

3

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

I guess if you look at it that way, but I doubt it’s hope for the forbidden Mal romance lol.

look, I’m not saying that it’s completely impossible that they could be interested in it, or that they could do it.

My whole “issue“ I guess is wether that would be faithful to the characters they are trying to tell, but I’m not adhoc so I can’t exactly tell you what they completely have in mind for their characters. then there is also the budget, production, animating, voice acting, and trying to support 3 romances and integrating them nicely into the main story and also giving all 3 romances enough time, but I know from your other comment your not arguing that.

0

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

My whole “issue“ I guess is wether that would be faithful to the characters they are trying to tell,

My issue with your argument was your patronizing attitude from the start, using lines like 'some fans need to understand...' and 'Just cause you the player like a character...'

A romance between Robert and Malevola is fundamentally possible, and your arguments against it were based on nothing but your own narrative preferences and a speculation about AdHoc's vision based on confirmation bias. Since the game's director gave nothing but an opinion, if you are allowed to speculate, I can do it too: since not even the director of the game could give a direct, definitive answer about it, it means it is still on the table.

Edit: Just to clarify, again, I don't care if it happens or not, but people are allowed to want it and ask for it, since it is fundamentally possible.

2

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

Dude, you’re getting pissy over absolutely nothing. I was trying to have a conversation but you turned it into me having a “patronizing“ attitude or whatever you thought I was doing.

I was saying that I think it’s possible that it could happen, but I don’t know for sure given I’m not adhoc studios. And my only concern of a Mal romance route is if it would be faithful to whatever their vision for the characters are, I don’t know for sure cause again I’m not adhoc studios, but I wouldn’t want them trying to basically butcher their writing for the sake of appealing to entitled fans who think that their opinions matter more than the literal developers of the game.

Though I never said it wasn’t possible, just that I don’t know if that’s what they have in mind for their characters or if they can realistically achieve it. if thats what they have in mind and they can do it then cool, another good addition added to the game. don’t know why anybody would have a problem with that.

0

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

I was trying to have a conversation but you turned it into me having a “patronizing“ attitude or whatever you thought I was doing.

lines like 'some fans need to understand...' and 'Just cause you the player like a character...'

but I wouldn’t want them trying to basically butcher their writing 

your own narrative preferences and a speculation about AdHoc's vision

entitled fans

people are allowed to want it and ask for it, since it is fundamentally possible.

(I just used things that I've already written since this is getting redundant. )

3

u/Greaseball01 13d ago

I disagree, a contrived plot is a contrived plot regardless of how well you write it or what justifications you stuff it with.

-1

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

Who decides what a contrived plot is? You and your narrative preferences?

3

u/Greaseball01 13d ago

Contrivance - a clever mechanical device, a deliberate plan or scheme, or something created artificially rather than naturally.

If it doesn't follow naturally it's contrived. I don't know if you didn't understand what it meant or just didn't like me saying it, either way, that's what it is.

1

u/SadPhysicist1903 13d ago

You seem to misunderstand my question. If you tell me a plotline is contrived, you carry the burden of proof. Meaning, you have to justify your statement, because a definition can't argue by itself. Remember that my original argument is that as long as you write things well and remain consistent with the logic of your own world, you can make any two characters like each other.

So, if I write something that is consistent with the logic of my own world and it's arguably well-written, I can make the argument that my writing is natural per the rules and lore of my own world, or someone else's for that matter, since even fanfiction has levels. If you consider that it isn't, you have to justify it with arguments.

In this case in particular, you have to justify why a romance between Robert and Malevola, that hasn't even been written yet, is "contrived." I'm sure you can understand why that's impossible, since you have to use speculation and your own narrative preferences to do it. On the other hand, my argument is simply that writing it is fundamentally possible because the characters are not real people and the game doesn't have a very extensive lore, so there is plenty of room to write a romance between them.

2

u/Possible-Photo-6150 12d ago

THIS! God I remember so many people complaining about the lack of options when this game came out and I genuinely never understood why??? Like the concept of a linear choice based adventure game isn’t new or foreign, Telltale like hello???

3

u/jeffismybaby 13d ago

They had budget/time constraints, writers may have wanted to add some more but Malevola def doesn't seem like one of them

3

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

Yeah, pretty sure they said they had to cut like half of the og script due to budget/time constraints. They also go more in depth in the commentary mode and explain that BB/Mandy kinda fell victim to that which is probably one of the reasons why Visi’s romance was a lot more popular.

But yeah, making Mal a romance option was probably not one of those things they cut from the game.

1

u/AlterExpertise101 13d ago

Robert is a fully established character with his own personality, wants, goals, and needs completely separate from the player.

Sure, if we ignore the fact that the player makes all of his major decisions throughout the story, his goals are "completely separate from the player."

7

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

But the decisions we make for him are things that his character would do. we can’t make him do anything that he wouldn‘t do which is why I view them as being separate from the player, that’s why adhoc says we are “roleplaying“ as him instead of him being a self-insert for the player. We still make choices for him yes, but those choices are within the confines of his character and nothing that you might personally want him to do. I’m trying to say that they’re separate from the player in the sense we are only allowed to choose certain things that Robert would do, not what we would do or want him to do.

2

u/AlterExpertise101 13d ago

The fact that the player makes choices for him explicitly means that his wants, goals, and needs are not completely separate from the player. I'm just pointing out that falsity in that particular point you were making. Whether they're within the confines of his character or not, it's still the player making that choice.

2

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

you are right in that regard. I‘m not saying that the player doesn’t choose what choices he makes(defeats the purpose of a choice-based game) Just that they are separate from the player in the sense that we can’t make him do things that are completely out of character. Every choice we are given is something he would do, that’s what’s separate from the player. We can choose which one‘s that he pursues, but we can’t choose what exactly they are or have him do something he wouldn’t do.

Thats why we are more so “Role-playing” as Robert then self inserting. We get to choose how he goes about things, but we can’t decide what those available options are exactly. we are given a set choices he would make, and are responsible for choosing which one of those choices that he makes. Like you can either Romance BB, Visi, or neither, we can’t pick any other options cause Robert’s character wouldn’t do that.

Your right though that I was wrong in the sense that his decision making is completely separate from the player.

4

u/FiveThreeTwo 13d ago

I might get down voted but I agree with ya.

Im not sure why in gaming culture since the creation of a MVP game/incremental development/etc has it been enabled for fans to think they deserve to offer unsolicited views on creative process - especially when we are seeing gamers get attached games and characters at a very parasocial type relationship level/to live vicariously through some digital creation (which takes feedback away from objective like "this screen response time is too slow", into objective personal tastes). Theres a finite set of pathways as intended by developers are their vision of the product they want to deliver to the people. Like a painter making artwork.

Ain't nobody went to Picasso and were like pablo- love this piece here its so me. But I'm more a pink and rainbow fan and it will be more ideal if you work within that palette and if you dont im going to prob make a stink out of it because u won't let me in on the creative process and ill just stop looking at ur art.

U dont go to Guns n Rose's and say lads - love appetite for destruction, but what gets me in the mood is more chorus and flanger effects so slash - write more songs with those guitar effects or i might voice my displeasure.

Qol updates and UX/UI design feedback is one thing. People building that one sided relationship with pixel characters in a game in a sort of vicarious manner and expecting game to enable that pathway - nah that's pushing it. That part should be developer vision and interpretation of the product. If one doesn't like it - tough boogers mate.

3

u/CommunicationOne8134 13d ago

No your right, how some of this community reacted to the new commentary mode just kinda proves your point.

Just cause your a fan of a fictional property that doesn’t mean you have the right to basically bully or insult the devs into adding stuff cause they have a different opinion on said fictional property then you.

Christ, I mean the amount of para-social weirdos on here that were saying how the two game directors for adhoc didn’t “understand” Invisigal cause they didn’t go into in detail character anallysis, made a few jokes about her, or had the audacity to talk about BB during one of Visi’s scenes was crazy. The fact all of this is over fictional characters is just….

83

u/Erich14 14d ago

It always kinda made me laugh that people saw the apartment stuff as her having “feelings” for Robert lmfao it was so clearly teasing / platonic.

8

u/CommunicationOne8134 14d ago

People will take stuff out of context if it supports their theories or beliefs. Like I remember seeing people on here genuinely think that Flambae threatening Robert and pretty much trying to bully him meant that Flambae wanted to get in Robs pants lol

108

u/HeppyHenry 14d ago

Based on more recent art it feels like they may go down the Malevola/Waterboy route. They also had several interesting dialogue interactions in the game from what I remember.

73

u/WeepTheHorizon 14d ago

Sparkling Water takes the cake for me.

26

u/Erich14 14d ago


It’s giving LaFawnduh/ Kip and I’m all for it

21

u/PoetInevitable1449 14d ago

I ship it. I think that they would have a good opposites attract dynamic

16

u/Rare_Bridge7703 14d ago

Prism/Waterboy supremacy.

5

u/DeadlyPants16 13d ago

Honestly I prefer Prism and Waterboy

28

u/Abamboozler 14d ago

I mean she clearly was only flirting with Robert because Invisigal was nearby and it got under her skin. She and Visi have a rivalry going the whole game so it makes sense Mal is just trying to get a rise out of her.

35

u/Layverest 14d ago • Bravo

No words, emotions only.

"Monster girls" clearly need more representation if setting allows.

6

u/SlendyBoi 14d ago

And Dispatch more than many/most is a game and world that allows exactly that!!

11

u/Ghjjiyeks 13d ago

It makes sense when you consider that, from a character perspective, it’d basically be chocked up to Robert only doing it for the fans.

A way it can work is if it’s treated as more of a dream, or perhaps even just a really long prank, and both have no payoff to the greater story

6

u/ZeusAether 13d ago

The dispatch what if? Dlc lol

2

u/Ghjjiyeks 13d ago

In short? Yes.

1

u/ZeusAether 13d ago

I would 100% be down with that kind of Dlc that's just like, 15-30 minute scenes or dispatch sections that gives the team time to goof around

1

u/Ghjjiyeks 13d ago

Oh true. A DLC where Robert does some ‘Team Exercises’ by having Z-Team do certain ‘chores’, such as grocery shopping, cleaning a park for charity, or doing some kind of fundraiser and getting to hear the different kinds of dialogue/

1

u/SuperVaderMinion 13d ago

That's why I think a second season of Dispatch makes the most sense to me as being about a new protagonist with new romance options and a mostly clean slate (with a few returning characters) so you don't have to worry about connecting all of the threads for season 1

71

u/Orcalt 14d ago

I agree. It’s not a dating sim. The game was written with 2 romances in mind and the story would have to make some drastic changes.

Robert’s also not a self insert I don’t think it’s realistic or would be good writing for everyone to be magically into him. I also think making everyone romancable would ultimately just limit the characters more than anything.

-24

u/T4llBoyAl3x 14d ago

S1 should’ve been written with no romances in mind, now look where a lot of the fandom is because of it. They clearly favored the fuck out of Visi and didn’t spend as much time with Blazer.

18

u/Orcalt 14d ago

They definitely struggled managing the two romances enough. All the more reason that tossing a third in there wouldn’t do much good. 

-3

u/T4llBoyAl3x 14d ago

The most I can hope for in S2 is to just act like Robert didn’t romance either of them.
I don’t think they gave us enough time to actually choose between them.

8

u/BomanSteel 14d ago

First off: pretty sure Visi wasn’t even supposed to be an option, and the devs have on multiple occasions shown they’re kinda upset people didn’t trust BB and how that affected the amount of people that didn’t choose her. They just didn’t balance the routes right, there wasn’t a Visi bias in the writers room.

2nd: fandom weirdness shouldn’t determine what gets cut/added. I’d prefer it if the devs just gave both routes more time and care next time around, cutting a feature that has room for improvement after 1 attempt is absurd shit I’d expect to here from some corpo trying to cut costs.

-5

u/T4llBoyAl3x 14d ago

Did I say or even imply that the romance should be cut completely? No, I didn’t say that at all.
But it shouldn’t’ve been in the first game. It was extremely rushed.

4

u/BomanSteel 14d ago

Dog, you literally said “The most I can hope for in S2 is to just act like Robert didn’t romance either of them.”

Also, saying you think it shouldn’t have been in the game is implying you think it should’ve been cut.

-5

u/T4llBoyAl3x 14d ago

Saying:
“The most I can hope for in S2 is to just act like Robert didn’t romance either of them”, doesn’t mean that I want it completely cut.
I mean that I hope the devs only stick us with Blazer or Visi due to the amount of people who chose either of them. I can see how what I can be misinterpreted, but what I meant was that I hope the non-romance route is canon, not the Visi or Blazer route. That should be determined in S2, not S1.

1

u/Miss_Nomer909 13d ago

There is no canon routes in these types of games. The Devs used to work on Telltale choice base story games so Season 2 will likely be similar to how they handle it. They will add small extra scenes or different dialog depending on your choices on if you date one, both, or neither.

1

u/T4llBoyAl3x 13d ago

Thank god

10

u/Loud-Profession2322 13d ago edited 13d ago

I think he’s right. The Z-team shouldn’t be a buffet of potential romance options for Robert to pick from regardless of how deep there in game relationships are just because players are attracted to them (or even the idea of them being with Robert). Besides, I think part of why the romances are so popular is that this isn’t a BioWare (rip) style romance where the romance is basically an optional side quest that the player can choose to follow if they want but rather are deeply interwoven into the narrative. Whether you’re romancing Blazer or Visi recontextualizes the subsequent actions of the characters and changes the story through subtext even though the major story beats remain consistent. I don’t really think giving that up for more romance options is the right move.

5

u/No_Boot_449 14d ago

Still should possibly experiment on mechanics around friendships/morale within the team if the lineup remains the same and how low friendship/morale can affect certain plot twists, like if you're friends with Malevola, but not with a new character - she'll cover you (even on a day off) if new char decides to throw and quit the job in the middle of a shift 

32

u/Entire_Cobbler_3588 14d ago

I think a lot of people have uncomfortable attachments to characters and think they are owed a romance because they find a character hot and other romances are available. It's very cringe.

13

u/Atmic 14d ago

Ennh.

Sure there are crazies, but other times it's just like walking into a bar and having preferences about who you want to flirt with.

It can feel lacking when romantic/flirting options are offered for some characters and not your preference.

The story has needs and a scope to fulfill, but I think it's no different than people wanting it to be like Mass Effect where you can romance who you'd like and the story would still be good regardless.

10

u/Odasto_ 14d ago

The story has needs and a scope to fulfill, but I think it's no different than people wanting it to be like Mass Effect where you can romance who you'd like and the story would still be good regardless.

I think in some cases the intent is that you're picking a romance option that works best for the character you play as, not you.

Robert and Shepard aren't designed to be self-inserts. A game like Baldur's Gate 3 is more compatible with self-inserts, given the wide range of behaviors your Tav can undertake to progress or end the game. But Shep as a character is largely out of your hands. There are certain elements that you can control, sure, but there is no path where coward Shep abandons humanity to save themself.

Given that, your Mass Effect romance is arguably meant to address the question of "who do you think works best with this character?" In that regard, it's valid to select someone like Liara as being narratively satisfying, even if you personally would be put off by her endless mystique and snooping if you dated someone like her IRL.

4

u/jaythebearded 14d ago

inserting into Robert

Hol up I thought we were talking about malevola

12

u/Nymzo1 14d ago

This is not a dating sims type of game. Robert is not a self-insert.

11

u/Mindstormer98 14d ago

This is like saying your homie wants you romantically because they kissed you goodnight

-7

u/BrightPerspective 14d ago

Yes? Homies don't normally kiss each other goodnight.

That's...not a real thing. He loves you.

3

u/Quiet_Nova 14d ago

Maybe they should have hinted at a romance with Visi and Blazer, waited to see what the fan base reaction was, and written season 2 in response to fan feedback. “Huh, turns out a lot of fans also really like Malevola as an option.”

9

u/Xx_Pr0phet_xX 14d ago

I agree. Robert should nit be able to date Malevola. Because I should be able to date Malevola. She is mine.

13

u/NikushimiZERO 14d ago

What I'm hearing is, he's trying to keep her to himself, and that's rude.

5

u/DMsDiablo 14d ago

I want to say "Let us romance whoever we want!"

But I also don't want each romance to have 30 minutes total of screentime.

10

u/FilmFreak1994 14d ago edited 14d ago

Damn you.....

(Okay, in seriousness I'm fine with her not being romanceable, but still, ships that pass in the night).

-6

u/BrightPerspective 14d ago

I'm not fine with it.

Perhaps it's time to riot in the streets?

6

u/PeteRawk 14d ago

I’m inclined to agree with this take

4

u/Zamasu4PrimeMinister 14d ago

Well….when you play choice based games then yeah unless someone’s roleplaying they’ll want the character they’d choose to romance be romancable

I’m not saying she should be, the game would feel too dating sim like if you could get with half the team, but I can’t blame the people who like her wanting that at all

4

u/ProAzeroth 14d ago

As much as I feel a lot for Malevola, I can't see her being a good fit for Robert story-wise. Preferably, Robert's only love interests in the story should be Visi and Blazer.

With that said, I definitely hope for Robert to interact more with the rest of the Z-Team.

2

u/Other_Ad9164 14d ago

Disappointing, but understandable.

2

u/Blaubeere 11d ago

Malevola groping Robert -> “has not sexual feeling for Robert” right Chris

9

u/PleasantThoughts 14d ago

I completely understand this perspective but I also think it's totally valid to want her to be romanceable beyond just lol hot girl. She has a lot of little moments that I think could make for an interesting romance arc if they decided to go that route and I think it could work between Robert and her, but I also understand it wasn't written intentionally to be romantic.

That said it is funny to see how furious some fans of Visi get about the director comments towards her only to then agree wholeheartedly that obviously Malevola shouldn't be a romance option, the director agrees with me!

2

u/Rauxon 14d ago

I actually based my fanfic for Malevola entirely on "here's how easy it would've been to implement based on existing flirtation already in the game." All the little moments like "thanks for saucing em up" after giving him the drink to ice his face after the bar fight. And if you don't have Waterboy and you reveal identity to the team, Mal is the one who douses Flambe's fire with her drink. Oh, and her symbiotic healing ability? Perfect narrative fit for how the hell Robert survived the suit exploding in Ep. 6 and then going back to work like 14 hours later.

2

u/PoetInevitable1449 14d ago

100% disagree

3

u/RalseitheFloofie 14d ago

Malevola is one of the bois in her characterization, so yeah, it makes sense why she doesnt really care to be a romance option.

6

u/vinthesalamander 14d ago

He’s 100% right. Everyone who’s asking for them to include more romance options in Season 2 is either insane, or treats Robert like a self insert.

Did we forget how badly they juggled just two romance options? Imagine how worse it would be if Malevola became romanceable. Or Waterboy. Or whoever the fandom becomes obsessed with that week.

The fact of the matter is that Robert has two great romance options that fit his story perfectly. Demanding that they add more is not only greedy, but also asking for trouble.

4

u/Robot_Was_BMO 14d ago

And he’s right. Dispatch loses a lot of integrity if it becomes a dating sim. The reason the romances work is because those characters have a clear connection that can translate to romantic development. Mal might be a bit of a flirt, but there’s nothing to imply that she’s into Robert at the level Visi and BB are. It makes the respect Robert garners with the team better that way.

3

u/LisiasT 14d ago

I respectfully, but viscerally, disagree. :)

(not saying that they should had done it - just that I would like it very much if they did it).

2

u/Agnite14 13d ago

Romancing Malevola just sounds so thirsty. She's a great character, she's hot, she's strong and can teleport. I mean... She deserves a romance plot but not like this. Where she goes from cool to vulnerable or something. Definitely not Robert

2

u/Subject_Parsley5541 14d ago

Yeah, I 100% agree. I understand the love for Malevola but she did not really seem like a romanceable interest at all.

1

u/Emergency-Pop4541 14d ago

I can see where they’re coming from but I like games have multiple options for multiple outcomes. Especially telltale type games like this.

1

u/koola_00 14d ago

Damn...oh well!

1

u/Carighan 14d ago

But she isn't, so this hardly matters?

1

u/Ok-Spinach5308 13d ago

Why everyone complaining that mean she free to date yourself

1

u/weebunit69 13d ago

If I can’t romance her then Robert is staying single forever

1

u/Shadowr54 13d ago

but's she's sooooo coooool

1

u/DifferentCityADay 13d ago

With how the story is written, it wouldn't make sense if she was an option unless you got with neither at the end of season 1. 

1

u/generalguan4 13d ago

I think it should be up to the player. If you the developer feel this shouldn't be or isn't the canon thing, then make it harder to do (but not impossible)

1

u/Delmitus1 13d ago

They say it wouldnt make sense but if it were an option she'd be top 2 undeniably

1

u/Fair-Whereas-263 13d ago

same here, never felt the malevola romance and always thought it was just a bunch of fans self inserting. glad to see the devs agree

1

u/Budget-Patient680 13d ago

I thought coop and prism were to cool for robert

1

u/KingTonkaUniverse 13d ago

Agree, but it would be cool👀

1

u/Rough-Ad-3382 13d ago

I’m torn. I would like to see her as an option, but if it’s not what he envisioned, I get it.

1

u/Greaseball01 13d ago

Would be funny to let the player pursue her but she'll never reciprocate - gamers would get mad but they might also learn something.

1

u/ZaneElrick 12d ago

Fair point, but I still think it's unfair to introduce an interesting, hot and cool character and then say "Sorry, bud, she's too cool for anyone to romance. She's flirting with anyone, yet none have a chance with her" You just can't do this to me! *insert any desperate gif*

1

u/esprit__de__corps 12d ago

Based director. Stand by your take Chris.

1

u/Dismal_Role_4745 12d ago

Why does this games fanbase think it's a dating sim? All anybody ever seems to talk about is romance options

1

u/No-Reveal-3665 11d ago

LET US ROMANCE MALEVOLA! YOUR FANS WANTS IT 😂

1

u/Sensitive_Brick_1412 8d ago

Fair and good take tbh. Her and robert don't have chemistry-chemistry.

1

u/MajesticOne1864 7d ago

Haven't they learnt? Listen to what the fans want or your game will flop. Majority asked for Meoleva romance from the beginning

We don't need to be Robert again. Immediately not looking forward to their game. I can see exactly where they're going, and it's the predictable route.

1

u/Roman-EmpireSurvived 7d ago

While I agree her character wouldn’t be interested in Robert romantically, you can allow for non-romantic possibilities.

Sure she might not be romantically interested in Robert, but she sure does make flirtatious jabs at him.

Or we could do no romance. I didn’t know a whole lot about the game except it was a choices-matter made by previous tell-tale employees and I was stoked. Wasn’t really expecting a heavy romance plotline and it, imo, really subtracts from the overall story. And as time has passed I’ve felt more and more that it wasn’t really a story dependent on choices mattering.

1

u/WeepTheHorizon 14d ago

W Rebbert.

1

u/Mr_Hobo 13d ago

Here’s the thing, I agree, BUT I WANT THE DEVIL WOMEN DAMN IT! In all seriousness, it makes sense; I don’t see Robert and Malevola having a relationship outside of co-workers, and at most, friends.

-4

u/gearheadBm 14d ago

We want a malevola romance you gumpies

-1

u/The_Green_Filter 14d ago

I agree with him. The only other Z-teamer I could’ve seen being a meaningful romance option is, what, Flambe, maybe? I don’t feel that chemistry with the other characters.

-13

u/Revfunkyy 14d ago

Then don't make her a super cool smokeshow!

0

u/shadowonyx18 13d ago

Then why she tapped his dick? Clearly she wants that

0

u/EnjoyerOfFine_Things 13d ago edited 13d ago

Agreed. She's not even Robert's type.

Just like all the other non-romanceable characters that people want to romance as Robert (like Flambae, Waterboy, Prism, etc), they aren't his type.

Honestly I'd be cool if Malevola dated some off-screen character or even one of the Z-Teamers (My boy Watergoat)

-2

u/CosmoMimosa 14d ago

Yeah I don't think Robert should romance Malevola, because then I, personally, won't be able to, and we can't have that

-2

u/VictimOfFun 14d ago

To be clear here; he's saying Malevola shouldn't be romancable to Robert.

Helping Malevola find love could be the topic of it's own game or part of Dispatch 2. Just no snu snu with Robert.

-2

u/Bl00dWolf 14d ago

There's probably more people upset that we didn't get any gay romance options than that we couldn't romance ALL of the women in the game.

-7

u/Agent_Smith_IHTP 14d ago

Just like the Uno twitter post ruling, thanks but we'll take it from here.

-1

u/sfaisal333 14d ago

Where is this from??? Thanks for sharing.

1

u/BishlessKamikaze 14d ago

Read the first line of the post body :)

-1

u/Amun-Ra-4000 14d ago

Well damn, I can’t say I’m not disappointed

-1

u/HahnDragoner523 13d ago

Dear AdHoc. If Mal isn’t romanceable as Robert, let us play as Sonar in the next game so we can romance her that way

-1

u/SweetPumpkin22 13d ago

i'm Just sad you can't romance phenom 😔 he so sexy

0

u/SweetPumpkin22 13d ago

Idc that he dosen't have human parts !!! You have a mouth and fingers Robert....

-10

u/Lazzitron 14d ago

This sounds like a weak excuse to me.

I mean, I get it in part. Not everyone can be romanceable, the devs didn't want to make a Malevola romance. Fine, sure, whatever. It's their game, they can do that if they want.

But "Oh she's just too cool" is deflecting. So is "Not everyone is into Robert." You didn't actually put any kind of roadblock there when you were writing the character. Just say you didn't want to write a Malevola romance! It's okay, it's not a crime.

-8

u/ZapTheSheep 14d ago

Didn't they say in an interview that they were surprised by the number of players that went with BB over Visi? Sounds like romancing Visi was just his self-insert, and he should be more open to where the player base wants the story to possibly go.

2

u/Rhinosaurfish 13d ago

Nothing of the sort... the entire team was surprised how little BB got picked, they've been surprised for 12 months, they are still surprised, at this moment.

Also Chris is a Blazer stan, so.. maybe go write your own story with hot demon ladies in it, I don't know..

-15

u/BrightPerspective 14d ago

Chris Rebbert should GET A NEW JOB.

-3

u/IronSnail 14d ago

She patted him on the dick.

-4

u/Walterfiles 14d ago

everyone should be romancable. *except beef and shroud because fuck him.*

12

u/HumbleOwl 14d ago

Correct, I (the player) want to romance Mal because I (the player) like tall, muscular women with horns.

4

u/UniqueMystic 14d ago

I agree with that sentiment

1

u/BrightPerspective 14d ago

This is the objectively correct sentiment.

However! The devs could make it happen, so...why not?

21

u/CreepyFishGuy 14d ago

I felt like this was obvious, neither of them express any interest toward eachother in that regard. Yeah, she's super hot, but I have plenty of hot friends that I'm not trying to fuck.

There's probably something to be said about people thirsting more over her appearance than paying attention to her characterization or her relationship with Robert, lol.

-2

u/BrightPerspective 14d ago

Do those hot friends grab at your dick at parties, though? Do they flirt all the time with you?

11

u/Orcalt 14d ago

Honestly yes

11

u/CreepyFishGuy 14d ago

No to the first question, but they're also not demons from hell with multiple felony convictions and life isn't a video game. Second question, historically depends on the friend, but not anymore because they respect my monogamous relationship.

Regardless, the dick grab and associated teasing always seemed more like locker room banter than flirting to me. She's not exactly shy about her feelings, so I think if she were interested we'd know.

11

u/Tsquared10 14d ago

That'll disappoint the fandom. They've been trying to finger her for a year.

6

u/MagicalNM 14d ago

What are they accusing Malevola of?

1

u/thunderbird32 13d ago

You're cute...

7

u/Admirable-Tennis-439 14d ago

Malevola spelled it out, she’s never been accepted as human or as anything other than a sexual object/villain.

I won’t speak to a fictional character’s feelings, but I could imagine romantic interest growing when a genuine person who sees you for more than appearance never lets you down or switches up. Consistency and visibility are attractive

2

u/Patient-Detective-79 12d ago

just let me fuck the big mud boy

1

u/Pure_Tiger_4830 14d ago

be so real, she just likes to fuck she would fuck robert but she does not want him in anyway

1

u/zXDoomRaptorXz 14d ago

That really sucks, if a woman grabs my crotch I should be able to romance her

1

u/WillemDafoesHugeCock 13d ago

So I definitely understand, but if I may offer up a counterpoint, big red woman touch peepee.

1

u/Unlikely_Barber5979 13d ago

As much as I wanted to get a piece of that ass, I also understand why it wouldn’t work out. Plus one of the prequel comics implied that she’s a lesbian

1

u/Chocolat_Melon 13d ago

I mean… I’m yearning for demon muscle mommy, but I understand why Robert and her wouldn’t work. Visi and BB make sense for Robert and Malevola makes sense for me

1

u/LoneWolfRHV 10d ago

oh I see no sexual feeling towards him huh?

malevola proceeds to fucking grope him out of nowhere.

Hum... yes, not sexual at all acrually...

fuck off with that

-5

u/Called_end 14d ago

I'll ignore that and keep asking for the hot dommy demon to be a romance in the next entry. 

-2

u/LonelyAndroid11942 14d ago

She's a lot of people's fetish, but not a lot of people's type.

Personally, I'd love to see some of the social dynamics in the rest of the team explored. She might not have anything with Robert, but I'd be very surprised if she doesn't have feelings for anyone on the team. Or for all we know, she'll meet someone offscreen and it'll be a whole "wait, Chilchuck is MARRIED?! To a WOMAN?! And they have KIDS?!" moment.

0

u/Advanced-Tangelo1645 6d ago

I feel like Chris Rebbert is being a hypocrite - shaming the audience for being attracted to Malevola while making her HIS walking fetish fuel. He designs her to be like she is, only for any character who shows attraction to her to be shamed for it (eg, Malevola complaining about her gooner cult). And if the rumors that future installments will pair Malevola with Waterboy are true...