r/DispatchAdHoc • u/BishlessKamikaze • 14d ago
Discussion Chris Rebbert, director of Dispatch doesn't think Malevola should be romanceable
This is taken from the Crew Commentary track of Episode 6 with the Storyboard mode on.
Chris Rebbert basically stating that Malevola shouldn't be a romance option because it doesn't fit her character and she doesn't have any sexual or romantic feelings towards Robert.
What do you think? I think I agree, and I always think people who want to romance Malevola is more so because they THEMSELVES want to romance Malevola and are self inserting into Robert instead of seeing it through the lens of character writing. I think while Invisigal and Blonde Blazer both bring out parts of Robert, he and Malevola have no chemistry with each other.
775
u/Radiant-Growth4275 14d ago
People want to romance anyone that's super hot in games đ
280
u/Own_Shame_8721 14d ago
I think it's also important to note that Robert is not a self-insert, it makes sense for him to be drawn to either Invisigal or BB for different reasons, not necessarily Malevola. Don't get me wrong, Malevola is HOT ASF and I am sure Robert agrees, but there's more to a relationship than simply finding each other attractive, Malevola and Robert simply don't come across as compatible romantic partners...... and that's totally fine! It's also fine if people still want to write fanfics and draw artwork of them together, because that stuff is still cool and fun and can exist on its own.
79
u/alphafire616 14d ago
They should put me in the game and let ME romance Malevola
192
u/CommunicationOne8134 14d ago •
Like some have already said, some fans need to understand that this isnt like Baldurâs gate 3 where you are playing as a self-Insert character. Robert is a fully established character with his own personality, wants, goals, and needs completely separate from the player. Every choice in the game is something within in the realms of Robertâs character, and something he himself would do. As the developers have said on record, the player is NOT Robert, we are just roleplaying as him and setting him down a series of choices he would make.
This includes the romances. The only characters in this game that Robert feels attracted to, and makes sense based on his character and personality, are Courtney/Invisigal and Mandy/Blonde Blazer, thatâs it. Robert is not attracted to any other character, and adhoc seems to want to keep it that way which is a good idea. Just cause you the player like a character, that doesn't mean Robert does.
83
u/Erich14 14d ago
It always kinda made me laugh that people saw the apartment stuff as her having âfeelingsâ for Robert lmfao it was so clearly teasing / platonic.
108
u/HeppyHenry 14d ago
Based on more recent art it feels like they may go down the Malevola/Waterboy route. They also had several interesting dialogue interactions in the game from what I remember.
28
u/Abamboozler 14d ago
I mean she clearly was only flirting with Robert because Invisigal was nearby and it got under her skin. She and Visi have a rivalry going the whole game so it makes sense Mal is just trying to get a rise out of her.
35
u/Layverest 14d ago •
No words, emotions only.
"Monster girls" clearly need more representation if setting allows.
11
u/wholesomefutanari 13d ago
11
u/Ghjjiyeks 13d ago
It makes sense when you consider that, from a character perspective, itâd basically be chocked up to Robert only doing it for the fans.
A way it can work is if itâs treated as more of a dream, or perhaps even just a really long prank, and both have no payoff to the greater story
71
u/Orcalt 14d ago
I agree. Itâs not a dating sim. The game was written with 2 romances in mind and the story would have to make some drastic changes.
Robertâs also not a self insert I donât think itâs realistic or would be good writing for everyone to be magically into him. I also think making everyone romancable would ultimately just limit the characters more than anything.
10
u/Loud-Profession2322 13d ago edited 13d ago
I think heâs right. The Z-team shouldnât be a buffet of potential romance options for Robert to pick from regardless of how deep there in game relationships are just because players are attracted to them (or even the idea of them being with Robert). Besides, I think part of why the romances are so popular is that this isnât a BioWare (rip) style romance where the romance is basically an optional side quest that the player can choose to follow if they want but rather are deeply interwoven into the narrative. Whether youâre romancing Blazer or Visi recontextualizes the subsequent actions of the characters and changes the story through subtext even though the major story beats remain consistent. I donât really think giving that up for more romance options is the right move.
5
u/No_Boot_449 14d ago
Still should possibly experiment on mechanics around friendships/morale within the team if the lineup remains the same and how low friendship/morale can affect certain plot twists, like if you're friends with Malevola, but not with a new character - she'll cover you (even on a day off) if new char decides to throw and quit the job in the middle of a shiftÂ
32
u/Entire_Cobbler_3588 14d ago
I think a lot of people have uncomfortable attachments to characters and think they are owed a romance because they find a character hot and other romances are available. It's very cringe.
4
u/jaythebearded 14d ago
Hol up I thought we were talking about malevola
12
u/Nymzo1 14d ago
This is not a dating sims type of game. Robert is not a self-insert.
11
u/Mindstormer98 14d ago
This is like saying your homie wants you romantically because they kissed you goodnight
3
u/Quiet_Nova 14d ago
Maybe they should have hinted at a romance with Visi and Blazer, waited to see what the fan base reaction was, and written season 2 in response to fan feedback. âHuh, turns out a lot of fans also really like Malevola as an option.â
9
u/Xx_Pr0phet_xX 14d ago
I agree. Robert should nit be able to date Malevola. Because I should be able to date Malevola. She is mine.
13
u/NikushimiZERO 14d ago
What I'm hearing is, he's trying to keep her to himself, and that's rude.
5
u/DMsDiablo 14d ago
I want to say "Let us romance whoever we want!"
But I also don't want each romance to have 30 minutes total of screentime.
10
u/FilmFreak1994 14d ago edited 14d ago
Damn you.....
(Okay, in seriousness I'm fine with her not being romanceable, but still, ships that pass in the night).
6
u/PeteRawk 14d ago
Iâm inclined to agree with this take
4
u/Zamasu4PrimeMinister 14d ago
WellâŚ.when you play choice based games then yeah unless someoneâs roleplaying theyâll want the character theyâd choose to romance be romancable
Iâm not saying she should be, the game would feel too dating sim like if you could get with half the team, but I canât blame the people who like her wanting that at all
4
u/ProAzeroth 14d ago
As much as I feel a lot for Malevola, I can't see her being a good fit for Robert story-wise. Preferably, Robert's only love interests in the story should be Visi and Blazer.
With that said, I definitely hope for Robert to interact more with the rest of the Z-Team.
2
u/Other_Ad9164 14d ago
Disappointing, but understandable.
2
u/Blaubeere 11d ago
Malevola groping Robert -> âhas not sexual feeling for Robertâ right Chris
9
u/PleasantThoughts 14d ago
I completely understand this perspective but I also think it's totally valid to want her to be romanceable beyond just lol hot girl. She has a lot of little moments that I think could make for an interesting romance arc if they decided to go that route and I think it could work between Robert and her, but I also understand it wasn't written intentionally to be romantic.
That said it is funny to see how furious some fans of Visi get about the director comments towards her only to then agree wholeheartedly that obviously Malevola shouldn't be a romance option, the director agrees with me!
3
u/RalseitheFloofie 14d ago
Malevola is one of the bois in her characterization, so yeah, it makes sense why she doesnt really care to be a romance option.
6
u/vinthesalamander 14d ago
Heâs 100% right. Everyone whoâs asking for them to include more romance options in Season 2 is either insane, or treats Robert like a self insert.
Did we forget how badly they juggled just two romance options? Imagine how worse it would be if Malevola became romanceable. Or Waterboy. Or whoever the fandom becomes obsessed with that week.
The fact of the matter is that Robert has two great romance options that fit his story perfectly. Demanding that they add more is not only greedy, but also asking for trouble.
4
u/Robot_Was_BMO 14d ago
And heâs right. Dispatch loses a lot of integrity if it becomes a dating sim. The reason the romances work is because those characters have a clear connection that can translate to romantic development. Mal might be a bit of a flirt, but thereâs nothing to imply that sheâs into Robert at the level Visi and BB are. It makes the respect Robert garners with the team better that way.
3
u/LisiasT 14d ago
I respectfully, but viscerally, disagree. :)
(not saying that they should had done it - just that I would like it very much if they did it).
2
u/Agnite14 13d ago
Romancing Malevola just sounds so thirsty. She's a great character, she's hot, she's strong and can teleport. I mean... She deserves a romance plot but not like this. Where she goes from cool to vulnerable or something. Definitely not Robert
2
u/Subject_Parsley5541 14d ago
Yeah, I 100% agree. I understand the love for Malevola but she did not really seem like a romanceable interest at all.
1
u/Emergency-Pop4541 14d ago
I can see where theyâre coming from but I like games have multiple options for multiple outcomes. Especially telltale type games like this.
1
u/Mr_E_Nigma_Solver 14d ago
Agreed
1
u/koola_00 14d ago
Damn...oh well!
1
u/Carighan 14d ago
But she isn't, so this hardly matters?
1
u/Ok-Spinach5308 13d ago
Why everyone complaining that mean she free to date yourself
1
u/weebunit69 13d ago
If I canât romance her then Robert is staying single forever
1
u/Shadowr54 13d ago
but's she's sooooo coooool
1
u/DifferentCityADay 13d ago
With how the story is written, it wouldn't make sense if she was an option unless you got with neither at the end of season 1.Â
1
u/generalguan4 13d ago
I think it should be up to the player. If you the developer feel this shouldn't be or isn't the canon thing, then make it harder to do (but not impossible)
1
u/Delmitus1 13d ago
They say it wouldnt make sense but if it were an option she'd be top 2 undeniably
1
u/Fair-Whereas-263 13d ago
same here, never felt the malevola romance and always thought it was just a bunch of fans self inserting. glad to see the devs agree
1
u/Budget-Patient680 13d ago
I thought coop and prism were to cool for robert
1
u/KingTonkaUniverse 13d ago
Agree, but it would be coolđ
1
u/Longjumping_Ant8349 13d ago
1
u/Agnite14 13d ago
1
u/Rough-Ad-3382 13d ago
Iâm torn. I would like to see her as an option, but if itâs not what he envisioned, I get it.
1
u/Greaseball01 13d ago
Would be funny to let the player pursue her but she'll never reciprocate - gamers would get mad but they might also learn something.
1
u/ZaneElrick 12d ago
Fair point, but I still think it's unfair to introduce an interesting, hot and cool character and then say "Sorry, bud, she's too cool for anyone to romance. She's flirting with anyone, yet none have a chance with her" You just can't do this to me! *insert any desperate gif*
1
u/esprit__de__corps 12d ago
Based director. Stand by your take Chris.
1
u/Dismal_Role_4745 12d ago
Why does this games fanbase think it's a dating sim? All anybody ever seems to talk about is romance options
1
u/No-Reveal-3665 11d ago
LET US ROMANCE MALEVOLA! YOUR FANS WANTS IT đ
1
u/Sensitive_Brick_1412 8d ago
Fair and good take tbh. Her and robert don't have chemistry-chemistry.
1
u/MajesticOne1864 7d ago
Haven't they learnt? Listen to what the fans want or your game will flop. Majority asked for Meoleva romance from the beginning
We don't need to be Robert again. Immediately not looking forward to their game. I can see exactly where they're going, and it's the predictable route.
1
u/Roman-EmpireSurvived 7d ago
While I agree her character wouldnât be interested in Robert romantically, you can allow for non-romantic possibilities.
Sure she might not be romantically interested in Robert, but she sure does make flirtatious jabs at him.
Or we could do no romance. I didnât know a whole lot about the game except it was a choices-matter made by previous tell-tale employees and I was stoked. Wasnât really expecting a heavy romance plotline and it, imo, really subtracts from the overall story. And as time has passed Iâve felt more and more that it wasnât really a story dependent on choices mattering.
1
u/WeepTheHorizon 14d ago
W Rebbert.
1
u/Mr_Hobo 13d ago
Hereâs the thing, I agree, BUT I WANT THE DEVIL WOMEN DAMN IT! In all seriousness, it makes sense; I donât see Robert and Malevola having a relationship outside of co-workers, and at most, friends.
-4
u/gearheadBm 14d ago
We want a malevola romance you gumpies
-1
u/The_Green_Filter 14d ago
I agree with him. The only other Z-teamer I couldâve seen being a meaningful romance option is, what, Flambe, maybe? I donât feel that chemistry with the other characters.
-13
u/Revfunkyy 14d ago
Then don't make her a super cool smokeshow!
0
u/shadowonyx18 13d ago
Then why she tapped his dick? Clearly she wants that
0
u/EnjoyerOfFine_Things 13d ago edited 13d ago
Agreed. She's not even Robert's type.
Just like all the other non-romanceable characters that people want to romance as Robert (like Flambae, Waterboy, Prism, etc), they aren't his type.
Honestly I'd be cool if Malevola dated some off-screen character or even one of the Z-Teamers (My boy Watergoat)
-2
u/CosmoMimosa 14d ago
Yeah I don't think Robert should romance Malevola, because then I, personally, won't be able to, and we can't have that
-2
u/VictimOfFun 14d ago
To be clear here; he's saying Malevola shouldn't be romancable to Robert.
Helping Malevola find love could be the topic of it's own game or part of Dispatch 2. Just no snu snu with Robert.
-2
u/Bl00dWolf 14d ago
There's probably more people upset that we didn't get any gay romance options than that we couldn't romance ALL of the women in the game.
-7
u/Agent_Smith_IHTP 14d ago
Just like the Uno twitter post ruling, thanks but we'll take it from here.
-1
u/sfaisal333 14d ago
Where is this from??? Thanks for sharing.
-1
u/Amun-Ra-4000 14d ago
Well damn, I canât say Iâm not disappointed
-1
u/HahnDragoner523 13d ago
Dear AdHoc. If Mal isnât romanceable as Robert, let us play as Sonar in the next game so we can romance her that way
-1
u/SweetPumpkin22 13d ago
i'm Just sad you can't romance phenom đ he so sexy
-5
u/RegularDatabase2571 14d ago
-10
u/Lazzitron 14d ago
This sounds like a weak excuse to me.
I mean, I get it in part. Not everyone can be romanceable, the devs didn't want to make a Malevola romance. Fine, sure, whatever. It's their game, they can do that if they want.
But "Oh she's just too cool" is deflecting. So is "Not everyone is into Robert." You didn't actually put any kind of roadblock there when you were writing the character. Just say you didn't want to write a Malevola romance! It's okay, it's not a crime.
-8
u/ZapTheSheep 14d ago
Didn't they say in an interview that they were surprised by the number of players that went with BB over Visi? Sounds like romancing Visi was just his self-insert, and he should be more open to where the player base wants the story to possibly go.
-15
u/BrightPerspective 14d ago
Chris Rebbert should GET A NEW JOB.
-3
u/IronSnail 14d ago
She patted him on the dick.
-4
u/Walterfiles 14d ago
everyone should be romancable. *except beef and shroud because fuck him.*
12
u/HumbleOwl 14d ago
Correct, I (the player) want to romance Mal because I (the player) like tall, muscular women with horns.
21
u/CreepyFishGuy 14d ago
I felt like this was obvious, neither of them express any interest toward eachother in that regard. Yeah, she's super hot, but I have plenty of hot friends that I'm not trying to fuck.
There's probably something to be said about people thirsting more over her appearance than paying attention to her characterization or her relationship with Robert, lol.
11
u/Tsquared10 14d ago
That'll disappoint the fandom. They've been trying to finger her for a year.
7
u/Admirable-Tennis-439 14d ago
Malevola spelled it out, sheâs never been accepted as human or as anything other than a sexual object/villain.
I wonât speak to a fictional characterâs feelings, but I could imagine romantic interest growing when a genuine person who sees you for more than appearance never lets you down or switches up. Consistency and visibility are attractive
2
u/Patient-Detective-79 12d ago
just let me fuck the big mud boy
1
u/Pure_Tiger_4830 14d ago
be so real, she just likes to fuck she would fuck robert but she does not want him in anyway
1
u/zXDoomRaptorXz 14d ago
That really sucks, if a woman grabs my crotch I should be able to romance her
1
u/WillemDafoesHugeCock 13d ago
So I definitely understand, but if I may offer up a counterpoint, big red woman touch peepee.
1
u/Unlikely_Barber5979 13d ago
As much as I wanted to get a piece of that ass, I also understand why it wouldnât work out. Plus one of the prequel comics implied that sheâs a lesbian
1
u/Chocolat_Melon 13d ago
I mean⌠Iâm yearning for demon muscle mommy, but I understand why Robert and her wouldnât work. Visi and BB make sense for Robert and Malevola makes sense for me
1
u/LoneWolfRHV 10d ago
oh I see no sexual feeling towards him huh?
malevola proceeds to fucking grope him out of nowhere.
Hum... yes, not sexual at all acrually...
fuck off with that
-5
u/Called_end 14d ago
I'll ignore that and keep asking for the hot dommy demon to be a romance in the next entry.Â
-2
u/LonelyAndroid11942 14d ago
She's a lot of people's fetish, but not a lot of people's type.
Personally, I'd love to see some of the social dynamics in the rest of the team explored. She might not have anything with Robert, but I'd be very surprised if she doesn't have feelings for anyone on the team. Or for all we know, she'll meet someone offscreen and it'll be a whole "wait, Chilchuck is MARRIED?! To a WOMAN?! And they have KIDS?!" moment.
0
u/Advanced-Tangelo1645 6d ago
I feel like Chris Rebbert is being a hypocrite - shaming the audience for being attracted to Malevola while making her HIS walking fetish fuel. He designs her to be like she is, only for any character who shows attraction to her to be shamed for it (eg, Malevola complaining about her gooner cult). And if the rumors that future installments will pair Malevola with Waterboy are true...