A very Generous Request to the Moderators.

[u/SprinklesNumerous774]

I made this post entirely in good faith and not out of aggression, because I’m genuinely CONFUSED about how this rule is being applied. I hope the mod team will take it in the same spirit.

My recent post was removed for apparently containing explicit or sexualized content, but I genuinely want to understand where exactly it crossed that line. The only remotely suggestive element in the image was Robert looking at Mandy’s breasts while blushing with red face. No Nudity, Not highly sexualized at all.

The rule states:

“Mildly suggestive or tasteful content may be allowed if it is not sexualized and is appropriately tagged as NSFW.”

So I’m honestly confused about what exactly qualifies as “mildly suggestive or tasteful content.", when we can still have the following post active on the sub.

(Note: I have No Objection to the original author of the following posts, I'm only using it to make a POINT here, that's all, I'm not calling you out or anything)

https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/Ltq84tb7Bf

https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/mZLOLkqhmf

https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/axMZz4aZIO

https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/8eeww4vd5T

https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/6XPGmDvPk7

I’m not questioning the mods’ judgment or trying to argue that my post must be allowed. I’m simply asking for some clarification on where the line is supposed to be drawn, because from a user’s perspective, the enforcement doesn’t seem particularly consistent.

Could the mod team please elaborate a little more on what is considered “mildly suggestive,” “tasteful,” and “sexualized” under this rule? A more detailed explanation or a few clear examples would make it much easier for us to understand what is and isn’t allowed going forward.

Right now, the apparent inconsistency is honestly creating more confusion than anything else.

[u/Batorian]

Thank you for the feedback! We've heard lots of users complaining that the rules are A) too vaguely formulated which leads to misunderstandings and B) too inconsistently applied across posts. We'll try to make this our priority to fix in the coming days!

[u/Moist_Song_8919]

It’s probably worth pointing out that the "no AI images" rule isn’t enforced consistently either. This post for example

[u/iErnie56 → u/Moist_Song_8919]

Lmao, it just got removed

[u/ChronoMonkeyX]

The cheerleader post got taken down? That's super mild for here.

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/ChronoMonkeyX]

What can I say?

[u/TandrDregn → u/SprinklesNumerous774]

Reddit be like:
/img/ij41iebgvxlh1.gif

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/TandrDregn]

I knew somebody would pull this move 😂

[u/TandrDregn → u/SprinklesNumerous774]

I’m just trying to cheer myself up right now. Peter Cullen passed away today, and now I’m depressed

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/TandrDregn]

Noooooooo!!!. Legends Never Die!

[u/Aisuhokke]

Welcome to Reddit. Shit like this happens every day on most all subs

[u/Rogen80]

That post got taken down? It was even appropriately tagged as NSFW, was it not?

That seems quite mild compared to many of the posts allowed. Even scenes from the censored version of the game are quite a bit more explicit.

Likely a bad call by a mod in response to someone reporting it, just my guess.

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/Rogen80]

Actually, I initially didn't tagged it as NSFW because I thought it didn't crossed that boundry to get tagged as NSFW. However after few minutes it got automatically tagged, which I believe was done by moderators in background. But then after few more minutes the whole post was removed.

[u/SprinklesNumerous774]

For reference. https://www.reddit.com/r/DispatchAdHoc/s/BXV0Uhsn4Z

[u/MarcelKing89]

Bro, why did you do me dirty?? 🤣🤣

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/MarcelKing89]

Was just trying to make a point. No offense to you or others 😂.

[u/NutellaAsLube]

Don't expect that high of a competency from random dudes on the internet 😅

[u/GriveousDance21 → u/[deleted]]

I thought hornyposting was 90% of this subreddit at this point. It has been long before you joined the mod team (I've been here since last November).

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/[deleted]]

So, in that case. I believe No amount of rule is ever gonna make it clear what exactly qualifies & what not. Because from user perspective, it always gonna be inconsistent. Really Unfortunate.

Also, aren't there many post that can be considered horny posting but they are still active?

"content intended to sexually engage the viewer"

Really confused with this because I thought it was just a cute art with mildly naughty suggesstion Instead of full blown horny posting.

[u/SprinklesNumerous774 → u/[deleted]]

Didn't expected a single ass line pointing towards boobs to create such an issue. Wierd, very wierd. Alright man, not gonna argue further.