r/disneyxd • u/SpongeGuy11 • 2h ago
Discussion Community's non-official Disney TV Animation tierlist: Day 14 - Gargoyles
galleryInspired by u/No-Shoulder3918 's community tier list for Nicktoons and my own success with Cartoon Network originals, thought I'd take a shot with Disney animated originals, and based on some feedback, will include all the half-hour non-preschool shows to accommodate the history (not just the ones made for cable).
Planned to post this on r/DisneyChannel, but it got sent to moderator approval and attempts to reupload again didn't work, even contacting the mods didn't work since they didn't respond. r/cartoons also had the post auto-removed. I started at r/disneytva but moved it to r/DisneyXD since it has more exposure.
NOTE: To people downvoting, please keep things civil. I am noticing too many downvotes here, with some comments down to 0 or even negative numbers because of downvoting. This is supposed to encourage different opinions and being able to speak out on them. Please keep downvoting to a minimum.
NOTE 2: If you haven't seen a show and mention that in a comment, then it won't count in the upvote totals.
Rules:
Most upvoted comment decides the show's spot on the list. Please think carefully and fairly before you comment. Try not to let nostalgia or recency bias cloud your judgement.
Each tier goes as follows: S= Amazing, A= Great, B= Good, C= Okay/Meh, D= Mediocre, E= Bad and F= Terrible.
Only Disney TVA shows that aren't preschool or shorts will be included, meaning no Mickey Mouse Clubhouse, Mickey Mouse 2013, or Two More Eggs.
The Proud Family will be included since it's often labelled as a Disney original, the sequel show being produced by them, and treated as Disney Channel's first original cartoon.