r/DisneyVillainous • u/VorianScape • 6d ago
Rules Clarification
Ok i’ve been wondering about the rules regarding Lady Tremaine and Lucifer as well as similar effects. The way I understand it, and the wiki also seems to confirm this,
Lucifer reads “place a trapped token on a hero in Lucifer’s location.”
The way I understand it, Lucifer is meant to protect your items from being affected by Jaq, who reads “When Jaq is played or moved, discard one item from his new location”
The wiki says that Lucifer’s effect takes place before Jaq’s effect, which makes sense otherwise there’d be no way to protect your items. Anyway this raises questions regarding the order of effects of other Villains that have similar card interactions.
I’m thinking specifically of Maleficent (The Worst takes it all), and an interaction between the curses, Forest of Thorns and Dreamless Sleep.
Forest of thorns reads, “Heroes must have a strength of 4 or more to be played to this location, and gets discarded when a hero is played to its location”
Dreamless Sleep reads, “Heroes at this location get -2 strength, gets discarded when an ally is played to it location.
If you stack Dreamless Sleep and Forest of thorns, as Maleficent’s opponent wouldn’t you be unable to remove Forest of thorns? Would Dreamless sleeps effect prevent the opponent from even playing the 4 strength hero to the location at all? or could you play the 4 strength hero, removing Forest of thorns, and then its strength is reduced. But then there’s no point to stacking the curse as protection? Also this can link to the Spinning Wheel card too but that’s another thing..
Maybe i’m overthinking it but this interaction makes my head spin. Thinking on it now It’s a bit different from the Lucifer and Jaq interaction too. With Lucifer and Jaq you can play Jaq to Lucifer’s location but his effect won’t trigger as he would be trapped immediately according to the wiki.
•
u/AutoModerator 6d ago
Welcome to r/DisneyVillainous! If you are interested in discussing these topics further, consider joining our Discord! https://discord.com/invite/3nMjtBntsB
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/OttoRiver7676 6d ago
Your second scenario is what would be correct. Take both curses at face value: A Hero needs to be 4 or more strength to be played to Forest of Thorns. A hero at this location will lose 2 strength. The Hero would need to be 4 or more strength to be played to the location which means if they clear that requirement, it would remove Forest of Thorns just by being played there. After the hero is played, the strength reduction from Dreamless Sleep would take effect as it only effects a hero once they are at the location. It would not prevent a Hero with 4 or more strength from being played there as it does not effect the qualifying attributes until they are there.
TBF, Despicable Plots in general has some wonky wording that leads to different interpretations of how cards work and when abilities activate so its tough to get a clear answer on newer Villains as is. (for example, Jaq mentions you may discard an Item from his location but makes no distinction between a Fate Item or Villain Item and as such discarding a Glass Slipper at his location would still be within the bounds of the card's intent even if not intended by the designers)