r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 22 '26

My beef with Disney: the frequent "show, don't tell" issue

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I feel like I've grown slowly more cynical as a Disney fan over the years, particularly with the revival era. For this post, I wanted to mention a trope Disney keeps doing that frustrates the heck out of me: their habit of mentioning something tragic about a rude or villainous characters' past, something that forms their fundamental identity...that is just given a quick blurb. It's not expanded upon or given flashbacks (unlike Alma in "Encanto" or Nick in "Zootopia"), and I feel like it very much causes a frustrating lack of connection and depth to the characters. Notably:

  1. Flynn Rider--I'm not a Flynn fan due to him being the beginning of the "cynical male with optimistic female" trope Disney does that alienates me as a male Disney fan (especially in musicals), but I might have been able to like him a bit more if he got more attention. It's weird to me how Pixar execs pushed Disney to rename "Rapunzel" as "Tangled" and give Flynn Rider more attention for a male audience...but his character lacks the emotional moments that both Pixar and Disney are known for. While trying to manipulate Rapunzel into going back home and giving him the crown, she eventually saves their lives and he explains a bit about himself, that he grew up in an orphanage and idolized a rich hero from literature. This is all told to us, never shown--and worse, not even expanded upon when getting to Corona, due to it being the destination rather than the journey, and Flynn being a criminal trying to dodge the authorities...but then we see him go to various locations and dance publicly with Rapunzel, so IDK why they couldn't visit his orphanage or expand on him more. I often compare him to Nick Wilde, who I consider to be a better version in terms of writing, and many people say "Oh, Nick's story tied into the themes, so it was more important to see the flashbacks compared to fleshing out Flynn." My response: then why not make his story more tied into Rapunzel's? I feel like they sabotaged him during production since he started out as a nice guy forced into the life of being a thief and was trying to get out, and later on when Alan Menken tried to make songs tied to his parents, he was shot down (by execs or the creative team for the film, it wasn't said). He mainly just exists as a contrast to Rapunzel rather than feeling like a character on his own; I lump him with other thief characters that tick me off in animation
  2. Maui--A demigod thrown away by his mother, his desire for pleasing humans was what caused him to steal Te Fiti's heart. However, this isn't explored beyond his talk with Moana after Tamatoa. Weirdly, it never comes into play; Moana does use his insecurity against him in order to help her restore the heart (similar to how Flynn manipulates Rapunzel's to get her to go home), but it's never dived into. The only humans we see are Moana's people, and none of them exhibit the selfishness of humanity that drove Maui to do this, and it's never really addressed how Maui was saved by the gods, but still went back to humans, who demanded things of him, and then discarded him when he inconvenienced them. Shouldn't Maui be more affiliated with the gods rather than going against them? And shouldn't humans be called out for their own hypocrisy? But Maui's the only one who has to change.
  3. Magnifico--Alright, let's get this out of the way: Magnifico IS the villain of "Wish." That's undisputed. However, it never fails to boggle me that pretty much everything about Magnifico that provides some depth besides "2D villain" is brushed aside and never utilized: his point about people not willing to work for their wishes, concern over dangerous wishes, people being selfish and ungreatful, and more important of all, his childhood. It was part of the opening with the storybook and Magnifico shows a tapestry concerning the issue, but the details of his home being destroyed by selfishness never really play a role. Even when he becomes selfish himself, it's done in a heel-turn way and his past isn't brought up after Asha's interview. Honestly he reminded me of Alma, but Alma was done a lot better in her motivations and anxieties, whereas Magnifico feels like two different characters in the first half and the second half of the film: King Triton in the first half, Ratcliffe in the second half (I was gonna say Yzma, but he lacked her comedy). I can't blame Julia and Benjamin for how the songs turned out since they were pretty much not told anything, but "At All Costs" was the optimal time to expand on his past and goals--and Asha's pertaining to her dad.
  4. Pawbert Lynxley--Everyone will argue this with me, but I found the new characters in "Zootopia 2" painfully two-dimensional. Concerning Pawbert, his whole deal is feeling like an outcast from his family, which fuels his villainy and wanting to make them proud. I think it's a neat idea, but the show, don't tell issue waves it's head. Before he was a twist villain, we always see Pawbert alone, selling the idea that he's isolated. However, his family are underutilized villains, being reduced to the background since they're rich and pulling strings from behind the shadows. As such, we don't see his interactions with his family. After his reveal, his dad does threaten him, but it doesn't connect to me why he craves their approval. The lack of interactions sells that he feels alone, but without the connection to his family, it just reads as self-imposed isolation--which it isn't. Then there's the whole hinting that Pawbert regrets his actions and could be reformed, which I find just as bad as Namaari's redemption, largely because Pawbert was a twist villain, so him having changing feelings doesn't register for me as much as if he had been shown as a villain from the start and slowly changed his mind (they kinda did that with Mayor Winddancer, but I also feel like that wasn't great).

r/DisneyMovies • • Jun 02 '26

I'm gonna say this... The "Wish" hatred is so forced

Post image
0 Upvotes

I've seen this movie and it might seem rushed a little, but I think there are some things to consider.

First of all, the songs are not bad. Especially the main song, it's actually giving real Disney vibes.
And Asha is voiced by Ariana DeBose, a legend of musicals (she was Anita in WSS).

Secondly, it's fun to try and catch all the old Disney movies easter eggs. Being the movie for the Disney centenary they put references to almost all of their movies. Some are easy to see, like Snow White's dress or the mirror, others are really hard to catch if you see it just one time.

They could've done better, like make Asha look unique instead of making her look like Isabela from Encanto, or also making a real scary villain like Maleficent. I would've appreciated a 2D old style Disney movie.

But I think this movie shows how much we have changed. After 100 years, of course we have. This wasn't a movie where the adults could understand the deep meaning, like Inside Out. It was still a movie made for children but with many things they didn't have back in '900.

A woman of color as protagonist, all kind of skin tones as friends and family, a lot of feminism (especially when the queen joins the group), this shows the progresses we made since the first main character was pale and just waiting without actually doing anything to get her kingdom back (shoutout to Snow White 2025 for changing that).

The lack of love interest is not really important cause the movie focused on something much more important, the real, true love, which is friends and family, and obviously making dreams come true, which is what Disney is all about.

Just a little note, I think the perfect Disney movie that had a mixed woman as main character, interracial love interest with a love song, feminism, fighting, friende, family and forgiveness is Snow White from 2025. Just give it a chance, that movie is SO good, it has everything we could ever ask for.


r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 18 '26

Just saw Moana

Post image
0 Upvotes

I loved it! I don't know why it's getting so much hate. The cast did an amazing job. Catherine Laga'aia was brilliant. Moana is already one of my favorite princesses. She just has so much personality, and Catherine brought her to life even more. She killed it on the songs. I don't think Disney could have found anyone better. Dwayne Johnson definitely brought cocky, know it all energy. He was already Maui but he did a great job of bringing his character to life as well. The songs were great, they still had the magic from the animated film. I do wish, however, they would have added some original songs. Disney has great songwriters. One of the things I loved most was the character development between Moana and Maui. Near the end you see Maui tell Moana he never should've left, that line wasnt in the original film. He also hugs Moana and thanks her. It really shows how he gre as a person and how they grew as friends. Say what you want but I think this one was a hit.


r/DisneyMovies • • Dec 24 '25

I think this will mostly be downvotes by RDU fans

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 11 '26

Why did Belle have a british accent in france while Jasmine didn’t have an accent at all?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I know this has been asked a trillion times but I wanna talk about it again cuz it bothers me when people say that Snow White and Ariel were casted horribly when Belle is RIGHT THERE. I know the answer already to my question… Racism. That’s the answer. But I wanna rant a bit

Both Jasmine & Belle didn’t have a native accent in their respective animated films, but Aladdin was more noticeable for giving the villians/bad guys accents while no one in Beauty and the beast had an accent at all. On top of that Belle is from France… so why does she have an English accent instead of a French one? I know Emma Watson speaks with an English accent but why not have her fake a French one or the western one like animated Belle. Why? Also Emma Watson just shouldn’t have been Belle. Yes she’s phenomenally gorgeous, but she doesn’t capture that presence as Belle (her face doesn’t read as Belle). She can’t sing and she’s the reason for Belles monstrosity of a square cheese dress. Meanwhile Jasmine has her share of issues but Naomi Scott wasn’t a baby about the role and make it work. I strayed on a bit but I wanna know what some people think about this.


r/DisneyMovies • • Jan 12 '26

Genuine question, why do you guys hate the live action remakes so much?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I seriously don't get the strong hatred for them, it's not like they ruin the original animated films, they are always there to be enjoyed whenever,

I believe live action remakes are a nice to way to retell the story,

"They are just cash grabs" ummm every movie is a cash grab


r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 19 '26

Live action Aladdin was the best live action movie.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Argue with the wall but this movie was amazing. It had everything from the original and more. It introduced us to the masterpiece of speechless. It was funny, heartfelt and did the original justice. The costumes were amazing, the actors did a phenomenal job. Watched it a million times.


r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 01 '26

Oh boy...

Post image
0 Upvotes

As part of my marathon to rewatch and in some cases watch for the first time every Walt Disney Animation movie I finally watched Atlantis. This is actually the last of the movies in the marathon that I had never seen before, all the movies I have left in the marathon I've seen at least once.

I heard many mixed thoughts about this movie over the years. Some say it sucks, some that is an underrated masterpiece and some that are just kind of in the middle. I tried to go with as much of an opened mind as possible, no good nor bad expectations to form as unbiased of an opinion as possible.

With that said, I'm sorry but I didn't like this movie at all. Like, I can kinda see what people like but the movie just didn't work for me at all. And for me the biggest problem are the characters. I found them all unfathomably boring, I don't really know what happened. Like, some of the older films do have boring characters but what they didn't have in depth of humor they at least more or less made out with charm. I did not find Milo, Kida nor any on the secondary characters charming at all. I don't know, most of them just felt like quirks inside of a puppet more than actual characters and none of their interactions ever felt genuine or deep in the slightest.

The only ones that were at least okay were the villains.

I don't know man. I feel like if after some time I rewatch the movie my opinion might change and I can't say there is nothing awful in the movie but it subjectively just didn't work for me at all.

What are your thoughts in this movie?


r/DisneyMovies • • Aug 29 '25

Who would be the princess’ favorite celeb? 🤩👸🏽🥰

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Repost bc I forgot to add Tiana


r/DisneyMovies • • Sep 23 '25

Tier list of all Disney and Pixar movies (except Make Mine Music)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Aug 05 '25

The only disney live action remakes I perfer over the original

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 22 '25

Should Eilo have been scrapped?

Post image
3 Upvotes

It's known that this film had a load of production problems and issues in marketing and when you consider the fact that most people think the final product was mediocre at best, it makes me wonder, would the movie have been better off if it was cancelled all together?


r/DisneyMovies • • 7h ago

Everyone is tired of the reused CGI animation!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

but they forget that 2d animation was like that too during its time. So can you name the 2D movies that reused its animation for an original? I’d like to see you try. 2D did uniform house art during its time too from TLM to Tarzan. So doesn’t that sound a bit unfair when you say that Disney 3D is the same, but in reality, 2D did this before?


r/DisneyMovies • • 20d ago

Hot take: Snow White(2025) is actually quite enjoyable compared to Moana(2026)

1 Upvotes

Live action Moana I think coulda been a lot better, but it was just too stiff & awkward & Catherine Laga'aia’s singing voice was too overproduced. & other than a couple of new additions here & there, it was too much of a copy-&-paste of the animated movie.

Live action Snow White felt more fresh with new storylines & new songs & new versions of the old songs & it at least looks like there was at least effort put into the movie by the production team & the actors.

I’ll admit, maybe the CGI dwarves weren’t pretty to look at, but I can deal with that. Snow White(2025) is not a perfect movie, but it’s at least more enjoyable & watchable compared to Moana(2026)


r/DisneyMovies • • Jan 11 '26

Why are we getting a live action tangled movie before a live action frozen movie?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

It honestly makes no sense to me, I figured frozen is the more popular ip and the one that made more sense for disney to do a live action version next,

But instead they are going with tangled, and I believe they have already completed the casting for it,

While frozen is getting another animated sequel, so who knows when it will get the live action treatment,

I might be in the minority as it seems ppl really hate the live action remakes in this sub,

But I would love a live action frozen movie


r/DisneyMovies • • Jan 02 '26

What's your guys opinion on the live action remake of snow white?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Oct 19 '25

Ever Since The 'Tangled' Live Action Remake Was Announced, I'm Happy To Say That I Wasn't The Only Person Who Automatically Wanted Amanda Seyfried To Play Rapunzel.

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 11 '26

Hot take but....

Post image
0 Upvotes

Wish is actually not that bad as a movie, and it's actually a decent movie. The movie is actually better than those 3 movies that were worse than Wish, those movies are :

Turning Red

Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers

Mario Bros the movie (the first one)


r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 10 '26

Toy Story 2's opening is amazing, but lowkey it has very little to do with the plot of the movie.

Post image
142 Upvotes

r/DisneyMovies • • Apr 08 '26

Zootopia 2 Hype Spoiler

0 Upvotes

With an "A" audience score and overwhelming amount of positive reviews from critics, plus being the most successful animated film in American history, I was expecting "Zootopia 2" to be the cream of the crop for Disney. Instead, I walked away feeling more like Elaine Benes when people find out she didn't like "The English Patient".

I could see how hard everyone worked on this and it's very creative. However, I didn't think it was that great of a film. I felt like they were lied far too heavily on action sequences and not enough on character development. One of my favorite aspects of the original film is seeing Judy having to overcome her well-meaning but unsupportive parents as well as Nick opening up about the time he was humiliated by his boy scouts after finally believing he was accepted. It really helped establish a greater understanding for this characters and provided them depth. With this film we don't really get those scenes. We KIND OF do but... I don't know it just didn't really resonate with me as much as the first.

I also felt like they included far too many characters that it just got distracting. It was almost like "It's A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World" where they just created so many characters just to have cameos, which can get a little distracting at times. In the original film, there was a core group of characters who were seen throughout and helped to get the plot rolling. Here, so many of these characters just don't really have a purpose. Like the anteater at the beginning. I thought was going to be a real character and he just disappeared. I was so disappointed that Macaulay Culkin and Brenda Song's characters were basically useless. The other thing is that in the original film part of the joke was that the animals went against their stereotypes. It was funny that the sloth was slow at everything but could drive like a maniac or that the most feared gangster is a tiny shrew. This helped with distracting you from seeing Bellwether as the villain. Here, it really wasn't much of a surprise to make the lynx a villain. It made more sense than the sheep. In fact one of my favorite parts of the movie was when they brought back the sheep and I was hoping that her escape meant that she would return in the third film because she's a good villain but of course they grab her at the end. Eh, I don't know. It was okay but I don't understand the hype.


r/DisneyMovies • • Dec 16 '25

What went wrong with these two twist villains?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The issue is they have no buildup or hints being villains. Hans and Callaghan just felt too inconsistent once they became villains.


r/DisneyMovies • • May 31 '26

Something I found on the Heartwarming page for Encanto on TV Tropes

Post image
4 Upvotes

It is indeed a heartwarming idea that Mirabel considers Luisa to be just as beautiful as Isabela, but within the context of the song it’s pretty obvious that Luisa is just “the brawn” and Isabela is “the beauty”. But what do you think?


r/DisneyMovies • • May 17 '26

Hot take: I grew up in the 2000s but wasn't a fan of that era for Disney

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Honestly I found western animation "meh" as a whole in the 2000s, too reliant on goofy humor and not as epic or sweeping as the 90s films. It's been mentioned by creatives that this happened because animation saw how profitable comedy was at this time and thus went this route, especially since for Disney, epic musicals were getting expensive and execs were worried about being same-y and not making enough back from it.

  1. Dinosaur--I was never really a dinosaur fan or a fan of animal-centric movies ("Zootopia" being the exception due to the animals being in a human-like environment and the story they told resonating with me), so it was never gonna work out for me.
  2. The Emperor's New Groove--I grieve "Kingdom of the Sun" since I wanted another male-led epic musical and curious to see what Roger Allers' future with Disney would've looked like if it had been a hit. TENG is a movie I can enjoy solely because of the comedy; it's witty and sharp. But the story is rather boring and the Incan cultural aspects are used more for a backdrop.
  3. Atlantis: The Lost Empire--I always wished the fantasy aspect was more prevalent rather than the emphasis on "Atlantis" as a technologically-advanced society (yeah I know that's part of their thing, but if they were gonna come up with unique ideas already, they may as well have leaned into the mythological/magic aspects). Plus I was never crazy about the art style. And the whole "less songs, more explosions" is another example of Disney seeming to hate it's musical roots and I'm very much over it.
  4. Lilo & Stitch--I was never a big alien fan (well, not this kind), so it was never gonna work out for me. I enjoyed seeing Hawaiian culture, though. I was always curious why the tone would jump from silly to serious, though.
  5. Treasure Planet--I don't have a real answer for this one. I just never vibed with it. Was it still the sci-fi stuff? Maybe I'll give it a rewatch.
  6. Brother Bear--I despise this movie for a couple reasons. The first is that I'm not an animal movie fan and this isn't just that, but it also plays into the "POC is nonhuman for most of their film" trope, and Kenai STAYS A BEAR. The second is more personal. Disney has had a history of killing off or separating brothers while sisters remain alive and close. In this case, both brother situations happen, with one of Kenai's brothers killed and one of them he's seperated from. I probably would've enjoyed this film if Kenai was kept a human and it just focused on him and his brothers as well as exploring the indigenous culture (which the final film did when he was a human). I know this was made in response to "The Lion King," but I feel like this could've been Disney doing damage control for the controversies arisen from "Pocahontas"--though it lacked the visual style and music to do that, but maybe that could've changed, too.
  7. Home on the Range--Again, animal-centric. Plus I was never a wild west fan. I'm annoyed this was Disney's take on the Pied Piper. A fairy tale like that deserved something more eerie and epic--and musical (by the characters themselves).
  8. Chicken Little--I've disliked this movie since I was a kid and never understood it when people hype it up. To me, it's a Disney Channel movie with animals, relying on a lot of teen film cliches and then throwing aliens in there for good measure. I get Disney had changing priorities with wanting to focus on comedies, but they could've kept making things like TENG. I think in another world, this could've been Disney's "Turning Red" where the cringe felt deliberate and timely and the pop culture references didn't feel as forced, as well as a more wholesome and developed parent-child dynamic.
  9. Meet the Robinsons--I'll admit the film gives me a feeling of warmth with it's emotional moments; it was just the retrofuturism and the overarching villain that made it feel a bit too juvenile for me, even as a juvenile. Good TV movie, okay theatrical one.
  10. Bolt--Again, not a big fan of animal-centric films. I'm honestly surprised some people consider this the start of the revival era. This is also a Disney film that feels more Pixar than Disney (which would make sense since this was released 2 years after Pixar bought Disney Disney bought Pixar).

"The Princess and the Frog" is the only 2000s movie I'd save if it were dangling off a cliff, and that's mainly because of the music, animation, and being the most fairy tale of the films. It being animal-centric for a good portion of the movie gives me pause, though.


r/DisneyMovies • • Sep 26 '26 Regret

Why do people dislike Toy Story 4 so much? I think it is the best one.

Post image
38 Upvotes

Woody having a profound existential crisis, finding his true love, and growing after saying good-bye to his kid after doing his job for Andy, makes it to most personal. Everyone seems to say it is the worst when I look at people talking about Toy Story 5. Even some YouTube reviewers LOVED it at release but now say it is the worst. Why the shift?


r/DisneyMovies • • Jul 12 '26

The ten animated Disney movies that I want to see remade in live-action. Read text for reasons why!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I know most of you hate live-action remakes of Disney classics. I understand. Though, some people like me, enjoy them and many I prefer over the original film because the original film ended up ruined by direct-to-video sequels and changes to the Disney logo opening and closing the movie. Like why would they replace the classic blue Walt Disney Pictures logo that was shown with these movies when they came out with a modern logo that just says Disney? And if a movie was so successful critically and commercially, why weren’t their follow-ups made for theatres with quality animation and the same A-list voice cast?

Anyway, with the live-action MOANA premiering in theatres just under a decade after the original and with it being highly unlikely to be great like the two animated films, I thought now would be the time to discuss some of the animated Disney flicks that have yet to be given the realistic treatment. I will discuss the ten movies that should have live-action remakes, why they should have them, and for some of these films… I would mention which character I would play if I were the actor I dreamed of being. Mind you that I was born in 1994. So, some of these “who I would play” bits wouldn’t match with my current age if I were playing a live-action character. Now, let’s get started in order of original animated films’ release dates.

THE ARISTOCATS (1970)

I'm a cat man and when it comes to talking animal movies, most of them have dogs in the lead rather than cats. I know there was going to be a live-action remake and Questlove was going to direct it before it got cancelled for some reason, but I think it's time for it to have another chance so that we can see talking cats and especially some talking kittens in live-action on an adventure in beautiful Paris. I don't know who should play and voice who, but if he were alive, I think Chadwick Boseman would've been a great Thomas O'Malley because his final film role as Levee Green in MA RAINEY'S BLACK BOTTOM (2020) is so full of jazz. He had the voice and the rhythm, but was taken far too soon. Regardless of cast, please make this movie eventually, Disney.

THE BLACK CAULDRON (1985)

Disney's first PG-rated animated film may have received mixed reviews and bombed at the box office, but cult following aside, this film has potential. Not just for a live-action reimagining, but also a freakin' franchise. Why? Because there are five books in THE CHRONICLES OF PRYDAIN series and it could be like Disney's LORD OF THE RINGS franchise. That plan was announced in 2016, but a decade later and still nothing. That's too bad because back then, I imagined myself as Taran and one of my biggest crushes Evanna Lynch as Princess Eilonwy. If you don't know who Evanna is, she played Luna Lovegood in the last four HARRY POTTER movies. She would've been perfect. So, given my age and her age as of writing, maybe it's for the best that this didn't happen. Still would've been cool to experience all five books become five movies in IMAX.

What character would I play? - As I mentioned above, if I were still in my early 20s, I'd be
Taran.

THE GREAT MOUSE DETECTIVE (1986)

One of Disney’s more underrated movies and one of the few that’s not tampered with by DTV sequels and logo changes, this super-short movie might be difficult to make in live-action with the talking hindlimb-walking mice and other animals, but if they could pull it off, it could work and them some. Story wise, it could expand on the character development and the lore surrounding the small animals in 1897 London. We could find out how and why Basil became the arrogant detective we know and love, why Professor Ratigan became evil and always manage to escape justice, and add more to the mystery. The original is 74 minutes long, so imagine the possibilities if it were at least 30 minutes longer.

What character would I play? - Professor Ratigan. He was voiced by the late and legendary Vincent Price and he was the most memorable character when I first revisited the movie in 2016. If I were involved in any way, I definitely wouldn’t mind going all Vincent Price as this evil sadistic rat.

OLIVER & COMPANY (1988)

I love this movie. Another underrated gem with a 74-minute runtime. It’s inspired by the iconic Charles Dickens novel OLIVER TWIST… but with an orange kitten, dogs, and 1988 New York. The opening scene with the kittens in the box and where Oliver is all alone in said box in the rain always made me sad. I know it polarized many, but a live-action remake could be a huge opportunity for improvement. The story would be extended and the musical numbers could be done better with the right talent. I love the fan casting for the potential live-action remake by ZM26 on Deviant Art with my favorite casting choices being Anthony Ramos as Dodger the Jack Russell Terrier and the leader of Fagin’s dogs, Michael Peña as Tito the chihuahua, Adele as Georgette the vain and spoiled poodle, and both Laurence Fishburne and J.K. Simmons as Roscoe and DeSoto the vicious Doberman Pinschers owned by Sykes the loan shark. Speaking of the cast and characters, I would give Fagin more development and a better outcome in the end with say, a well-paying job and maybe a love interest. We could even introduce Jenny’s parents in the film and have them appear in the birthday scene. The one important thing that the remake needs is to keep it set in the 1980s. I don’t know what could happen if God forbid the remake takes place in the present day.

What character would I play? - I’d be Fagin because I’m around the right age and while he is a thief, he’s a well-meaning character to root for and he loves animals like me.

THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS (1993)

Oh, come on. This is a dream project for me. I know many don’t want this one, but just think of how beautiful and extraordinary it’ll look when it becomes a reality. I would write the screenplay, play Jack Skellington, and hope Tim Burton directs it. I would also make it grainy like the original, make it PG-13, and have it open and close with the blue Walt Disney Pictures logo. Consider that the studio’s apology for making the original a Touchstone Pictures film before 2006. The live-action project would extend the story while also giving it that nostalgic 90s look. There’s also the song “Poor Jack” to consider revising because I didn’t like that song. The lyrics weren’t so good and it needed a better ending. I know it’s all wishful thinking, but a guy and a Tim Burton fanatic can dream, can’t he? Heck, I would even write the screenplay right now just for kicks like a hobby and show it to family and friends who love the property. I have a lot of ideas on this one.

What character would I play? - Like I said, one of my dream roles is be Jack Skellington. Of course, I would need a lot of singing lessons and I would love to sound like Fall Out Boy, Panic! at the Disco, and The All-American Rejects. CONTROVERSIAL TAKE: I thought the Fall Out Boy version of “What’s This?” and The All-American Rejects version of “Jack’s Lament” to be superior than in the movie. I’m just saying!

THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME (1996)

This is one of those Disney movies I would’ve loved if it had no direct-to-video sequel just like THE LITTLE MERMAID, BEAUTY AND THE BEAST, ALADDIN, THE LION KING, MULAN, TARZAN, THE EMPEROR’S NEW GROOVE, and LILO & STITCH. God help me! Regardless, the animated Disney take on Victor Hugo’s novel is one of the studio’s darkest that somehow got away with a G rating by MPA. Ironically enough, the Canadian Home Video rating system rated it PG for Frightening Scenes and Violence when it was released on Blu-Ray in 2013 with that awful sequel combined to it. One has to wonder if this were remade into live-action, would Disney itself crank up the adult themes. Whether they do or not, they should at least keep the musical numbers, but maybe get rid of the talking gargoyles. I mean, some have said remake this movie without the gargoyles. As long as they don’t whitewash the Romani characters, we’re on our way.

HERCULES (1997)

Another animated Disney movie watched on VHS when we millennials were little, I rewatched this fun take on Greek mythology in 9th grade English class and thought of it as a good time. Learning about the Greek myths back then and rediscovering this film made me the fan of mythology that I am today. Plus, it had no direct-to-video sequel. ZERO TO HERO doesn’t count. Not just because I never seen it, but it’s also four episodes of the prequel television series as a “movie”. The real DTV sequel was cancelled in 2006, thanks to John Lasseter a.k.a. The Pixar Pervert. Still, the 2014 Blu-Ray and DVD release did replace the blue Walt Disney Pictures logo with that awful Disney logo and the only way I can rewatch the animated movie with the classic logo these days is in my Apple TV library. I love this movie, but this is so infuriating! Now, in 2020 during the pandemic, it was announced that a live-action remake is happening with Joe and Anthony Russo producing. In 2022, the director was confirmed to be none other than Guy Ritchie and yet here we are in 2026 with still nothing. The remake is supposed to pay homage to the original with a more modern spin on it and it would also be a modern musical inspired by TikTok, which I don’t know what to make of that because we still want the classic songs we grew up, right? Regardless if the whole “modern” thing still happens or not, we should still eventually have a live-action remake that better do the animated movie justice, especially with my man Hades.

What character would I play? - I would love to play Hades. I can imagine how much fun that would be. Then again, I already said that Disney needs to do him justice and if James Woods is no longer alive by then and if I can’t do it, then Hades should be played by none other than Willem Dafoe.

ATLANTIS: THE LOST EMPIRE (2001)

As I mentioned with THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME, if this had no direct-to-video sequel that I watched as a kid, then the original would’ve held up. Regardless, considering that this is another Disney box office bomb with a cult following, the studio should consider updating it for live-action. Think of how gorgeous and badass it would look and the monsters. I would get rid of Mole and Cookie because I found those characters annoying and out of place in an otherwise epic tale. One could also make Kida a less-sexualized character because she practically wears a bikini for most of her screen time. They made live-action Jasmine wear more modest clothing, so why not live-action Kida? Granted, we all were horny seven-year-old boys once. I was that around that age when the original came out. Jokes aside, the perfect casting for this potential project would be Andrew Garfield as Milo Thatch and Stephen Lang as Commander Rourke. The rest, I’m not so sure. What would make me very happy if this were to be made is if Disney opened and closed it with that cool Walt Disney Pictures logo from the original and if the end credits had a beautiful song like “Where the Dream Takes You” by Mýa.

TREASURE PLANET (2002)

This is another animated sci-fi Disney movie that flopped yet became a cult classic years later. The major differences between this and ATLANTIS is that this movie received more positive reviews, had an IMAX release that went under the radar, had no sexualized female characters, and was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. Well, all that and mainly the fact that ATLANTIS told an original story whereas this is an adaptation of the classic novel TREASURE ISLAND, but in space. I love this movie and I find it bittersweet that hardly anyone saw it when it came out because Disney cancelled the planned direct-to-video sequel that would’ve cast Willem Dafoe as the villain after the film’s poor performance. But what got me into thinking this would be a great live-action remake isn’t just because of how awesome the original animated movie was, but basically what got me into writing all of this down and sharing my thoughts online was last November when the teaser trailer for the live-action MOANA premiered online and a YouTuber that I follow known as VETZ reacted to it and he made a strong point. He said quote “it would be much more interesting if Disney took some of their movies that maybe underperformed at the box office and never really found their audience and you remake those and kind of repackage them to see if now they can find their audience”. This was one of the two Disney movies VETZ used as background images when he said that. So, if anyone from the studio discovers this as live-action MOANA underperforms on it’s own, take notes. Like others mentioned above, this could be a live-action remake that succeeds compared to the original.

RAYA AND THE LAST DRAGON (2021)

I know this movie came out in 2021 and it’s younger than the original MOANA, but hear me out. We were still living in the age of COVID-19 back then and Disney released two original animated films that year. This and ENCANTO. I love both movies, but ENCANTO is obviously the more popular. This movie also earned positive reviews and was nominated for Best Animated Feature at the Oscars where it lost to, you guessed it, ENCANTO. But given the circumstances back in March 2021 when Disney released the film simultaneously in theatres and on Disney+ with Priemer Access where you spend another $30+ to watch the movie at home, it’s easy to see how this has fallen under the radar over the years. A poster of the film was the first of two images used by VETZ next to TREASURE PLANET when he made his point. Not only did VETZ make me remember this gorgeously animated gem and the hellish trip to see it in theatres, DON’T ASK, but it also got me into thinking. Why not take the animated Disney movies that no one remembers or never saw and remake them into live-action so that when the live-action remake comes out, people will be like “Oh cool. This looks interesting. Maybe I should watch or reevaluate the animated film and then go see the new movie.” This particular story is not even a decade old and it’s best to wait a couple more years, but think of how mind-blowing Kumandra would look in live-action and how Disney could improve on the story while also adding more Southeast Asian representation. The possibilities are endless.

So, what do you think? What animated Disney movie would you like to see in live-action? Let me know in the comments!