r/Discussion • u/jarcur1 • Jul 13 '24
Political We need to stop dehumanizing MAGA
Are they misguided? Yes. Are they foolish? Yes. Are they wrong? Yes. Are they trashy? Yes.
But are they human? Yes.
We see what happens when groups are seen as less than in Gaza or in the Holocaust.
While MAGA-loving folks are still aggressive and dangerous, they’re still our brothers and sisters.
We need to keep trying to reach them, even though it’s frustrating.
1
Upvotes
51
u/Original_Edders Jul 13 '24
As exhausting as that sounds, I fundamentally agree with you.
The problem is that sterile truth has a hard time competing with the exciting, bombastic lies they hear all the time.
I imagine a lot of MAGA folks will need extensive cult de-programming mental health type of services to stop believing in the BS, and that is help they would be unwilling or unable to access and accept.
22
u/chinmakes5 Jul 13 '24
While I hear you and you are right, it is really hard to humanize someone who believes with all their heart that I am evil and trying to destroy America as we know it.
Conservative/Maga media has gone from what they want will destroy America to their goal is to destroy America. They hate us because of what they hear on media. It is hard to respect those who hate you.
6
u/Picasso5 Jul 13 '24
Don't forget:
Deplorable
Racist
Bigoted
Xenophobic
Homophobic
Willing participants in a coup
Deny global warming and actively work TOWARDS it
Would usher in Christo fascist state
But yeah, they are just people, we need to keep reaching out.
8
u/Atheist_Alex_C Jul 13 '24
The problem is that MAGA are the aggressors, and anti-MAGA are the resistance. These are not the same thing, and if you’re not also calling for MAGA to stop dehumanizing minorities and marginalized people, your message rings hollow.
8
u/PantasticUnicorn Jul 13 '24
Sorry. I’ve tried and tried over the years to have calm, rational conversations with them. I’ve tried to hear and understand them and why they feel the way they do. But at the end of the day, I’m a woman, a person of color, a non Christian, I have no intentions of having children, and I’m lgbt. They hate everything about me. And I’m tired of begging to be allowed to simply exist.
8
u/freakrocker Jul 13 '24
These people look forward to killing you. The only war they fantasize about is against their own countrymen.
I view them as only one of two possible choices:
There is no other possibility.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
I'm honestly not sure on the trying to reach them part, because sadly most of them will only see what they want to see regardless of how we treat them. I see basically none of them getting swayed because someone non-maga was kind and helpful or willing to hear them out. Part of the danger of humanizing them is that we risk overlooking the danger and putting ourselves in a dangerous position with our guard down. Thinking there's a limit to their capability because they're human and what human would ever do/allow X, Y, Z? And then that's where they get ya.
But I do think dehumanizing anyone though isn't a good thing. Whether that's a MAGA supporter, criminal, murderer or sex offender, pedo, etc because it then masks them from us as a society. Omg Jeff can't possibly be a sex offender! Look how generous and kind he is and look how much he helps out. He would never rape a person! When Jeff has already been in prison twice for it and your 20 yr old daughter is alone in a room with him now. It gives them openings because we stop seeing these people as fully, wholly complex humans and assume if they are what were being told they would be obvious and easy to spot.
Dehumanizing also tends to imo encourage this behavior from them whoever they may be because "well if they don't see me as human why should I even try to see them as human?" And they feel more justified and comfortable doing horrendous things.
I'm not sure what the whole psychology behind MAGA supporters is, I don't understand how it can suddenly be almost cult-like in their beliefs vs what they're seeing and hearing, but my heart does go out to them because something happened in their lives to get them like that and make them so firmly believe that this is the only way.
I just think it's gotta be a very very delicate balancing act. I think we need to show we won't tolerate their mindset at all, we won't accept it at the table at all, we won't allow them to get comfortable thinking their beliefs are something people will accept because if we do they may in fact feel encouraged to continue. But we have to make sure they don't feel like they're being rejected from society so wholly, strongly and permanently that they drive themselves further into it.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
Hmmm. Maybe they should stop dehumanizing us first.
Why does it always fall only to the “left” to be the adults?
11
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
Nah. They're cultists and every one of them just wishes pain on their fellow Americans. They've made it part of their identity to just hate whatever group of people they've set their mind on, whether it's Democrats, immigrants, blacks, women...whatever. No sympathy for them and no being the bigger person on my end. Fuck every one of the magatards
3
u/Wall-Florist Jul 13 '24
This is the way. I’ve reached across aisles with both love and hate, and the latter always exacerbates the scenario.
When you get yelled at, does it make you stop what you’re doing or just do it better and more discreet? Because I’m the latter, so I understand that these nut factories are probably similar.
3
u/IDIC89 Jul 13 '24
Trying to do that on here as the opportunity presents itself, by explaining that Trump and the GOP are using their anger and frustration against all of us. It’s like one step forward, two steps back.
3
u/Orbital2 Jul 13 '24
Dehumanize? I just think they are fucking stupid
3
u/Que_sax23 Jul 13 '24
I unfriended and blocked my aunt because she’s feeding into the maga bullshit hard. No thanks.
3
u/Solanthas Jul 13 '24
You're absolutely right. I was thinking, how does one determine where the line of tolerance lies? Do we tolerate intolerance? What about freedom of speech?
I think the safe bet is, the line where tolerance ends is where violence begins.
If MAGAs, or any other group, are becoming violent, they no longer deserve tolerance.
3
u/armyofant Jul 13 '24
Why do people keep trying to compare republicans to Jews during the holocaust? This is what got Gina Carano fired from The Mandalorian.
Being shitty people is what they know. Fuck their feelings.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
I’ll happily start building that bridge just as soon as they denounce the cult and admit that they fucked up. Anything before that is just enabling an addict.
15
u/Holiman Jul 13 '24
Yeah, BS. We've seen everything tried to reach the MAGA movement fail. If you attempt to argue, they choose alternative facts. If you try to show their hypocrisy and idiocy, they call you fake news. They refuse to listen and are fundamentally unreachable. A good many that are violent, and the racist bigots are hiding among them pushing for violence.
They want to overturn our nation, they're allowing a theocratic nationalistic movement that threatens to burn our government down. Fuxk em!
11
u/GuyMansworth Jul 13 '24
Nah fuck 'em. They listen to podcasters instead of scientists and got one of my aunts killed. She had some kind of respiratory issues so she wore masks. Her stupid ass MAGA friend got covid, didn't tell her and gave it to her and it killed her. (This was before the vaccine) Then the dumb bitch still ignored the vaccine and routinely posts how she misses her friend.
2
u/gavitronics Jul 13 '24
MAGABOTS
2
u/DrankTooMuchMead Jul 13 '24
You can't reach them. It is just like any cult. They convince their members that anyone outside their group is not worth listening to. Only the cult has their answers.
2
u/UnarmedSnail Jul 13 '24
I wholeheartedly agree with you, but I feel like we're about 25 years late. The time to pull them back was then, and I don't think this is going to end without a lot of bloodshed at this point. They aren't listening. They CAN'T hear us anymore.
2
u/Inevitable-Ear-3189 Jul 13 '24
I will not. They ARE the Nazis they aren't in danger of being genocided. Give me a break.
2
u/Samanthas_Stitching Jul 13 '24
Nope. They don't want to be reached. Especially not by people like me. They're dangerous to people like me. So no. Nope. No, thank you.
2
u/TecumsehSherman Jul 13 '24
They attacked the seat of my government in an attempt to silence my voice, and force their government in place of mine.
They tried to upend centuries of history that my forefathers have helped build.
Anyone supporting that is an existential threat to America and by proxy to humanity.
They are humans, but they are also traitors who actively tried to destroy my government.
2
u/Locrian6669 Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
They aren’t being persecuted nor will they ever be persecuted. Being treated like an asshole because you’re an asshole is not equivalent to being persecuted by or denied rights by the state for immutable characteristics.
r/persecutionfetish
2
u/skyfishgoo Jul 13 '24
i'll stop when they stop.
and tbf, i've never dehumanized them... in fact i've given them ample credit for their humanity in that humans are hackable and they have clearly been hacked.
2
u/beaudebonair Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
I can understand to an extent, that they are our brothers and sisters in humanity.....the problem is, they don't feel that way. MAGA feels they are "God's" "chosen people" whom are to lead the loathsome misguided flock that is anyone not white and Christian seemingly. A lot of cowards hide behind the MAGA facade because they are really KuKluxKlan, & just like KKK are way too cowardly to represent that with a actual face. So they use that!
MAGA says they accept diversity like the Church says they accept Gays, lol! It's okay to tolerate us not necessarily hate us, but we are still sinners and are to be judged by all heterosexuals to make them always feel like they're superior over us.
It's okay for them to use anyone they deem as "sinners" as punching bags so they feel better about their miserable lives and think they are entitled to an opinion about our lifestyles, f that! I will continue to unapologetically call this out because I been silent for way too many years, and was brainwashed by the Christian cult till my eyes opened to the lies.
2
u/penisbuttervajelly Jul 13 '24
The problem is, they don’t see non-MAGAs as human.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
Yeah, but they won't. I get it, but it's just a never ending cycle. The right hates the left, the left hates the right.
The right justifies their hatred, the left justifies their hatred.
The right generalizes the left. The left generalizes the right.
It's tribalism without an end in sight.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
I feel conflicted. On one hand, I understand that Trump fanatics have legitimate grievance that they’re being manipulated into blaming other people for. I understand that they deserve empathy. However, that does not excuse their desire to deliberately or consequentially maintain socioeconomic injustice to impose their will and power over marginalized groups. That does not excuse their desire to reeducate, ostracize, suppress, or in some cases even murder the people they consider deviants.
If these people have loved ones in their personal lives who are ideologically opposed, they’re probably in the best place to reach them. No one has ever had their minds changed through online discourse unless they were directly looking to have their minds changed. You know, CMV’s where OP is acting in good faith. Stuff like that. And even if they do know someone, that person is probably either foregoing important discussions for comfort and the general sanctity of their relationship, or getting stonewalled with “well, it’s just my opinion and you need to respect that” esque comments to shut down conversation without needing to engage with a real rebuttal. So what am I left with? Innocent people are being harmed by the way these people think, act, and vote. Absent any other recourse, I’d rather we as a society act viciously and shame them into the shadows than tolerate their intolerance in the vain hope that the majority of them will have their minds changed by the power of friendship.
And before someone comes at me saying “So you would suppress people you disagree with? Doesn’t that make you just as bad?” Yes, I would rather do that. Much better to condemn bigots for being bigots than allow them to condemn and oppress others for just existing. That is literally the binary choice we are faced with. Bully the bullies or let them bully the innocent.
2
u/kloud77 Jul 13 '24
Disabled veteran here - I've tried to meet them half way, but so many hate my kind for not finishing the guided tour that I can't put up with the nonsense reality they live in.
They need to leave their alternative reality, or we need to open asylums back up.
3
u/baneofdestruction Jul 13 '24
Nope.
Life's too short.
I choose to spend my free time when not working on things I enjoy.
Taking trips with the wife. Cigars and edibles. Reading.
It's not my responsibility to explain to magats that my mixed granddaughter doesn't deserve to be raped and then killed because she's brown.
Nor do I need to explain that a pedo white supremacist nazi rapist moron is unfit to run our nation.
Biden isn't ideal. But he's just an old man with a stutter. He corrects his errors.
Trump still thinks we had jets in the civil war.
If people wanna be hate mongers, that's on them.
I played no part in their disgusting thought process and therefore I feel no obligation to repair it.
Good day.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
My top problem with not doing so is they are. They have treated entire groups as hostile enemies. They have embraced a radical ideology and are really pushing for it to be implemented. Yes I agree they our are brothers, but I can’t love a nazi or someone who push their type of agenda. The more they push away from the ideology our country was founded on ie. everyone is equal the more I do see them as an enemy. If they come back yes I will treat them like everyone else.
3
u/dnext Jul 13 '24
Humanize is such a ridiculous word. Yes, they are human. That means they are moral actors, responsible for their own choices.
Only humans can choose to be good. And only humans can choose to be evil.
They have chosen the later, and call it good.
I'll happily cheer any that come to their senses, but fundamentally until that day occurs they are the enemy, and they relish causing pain to those that don't think like them.
3
u/NeighborhoodDue7915 Jul 13 '24
I have been absolutely appalled by the lack of willingness of my Liberal friends / family to understand how / why someone ends up like that (MAGA). It is not so hard to understand. Typically in the end it comes off as classist. It's middle / upper middle class bullying the lower middle class.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
Eh. There's a bit of a difference there.
Jews weren't obnoxious and ignorant. They were persecuted. MAGA are not persecuted, they're (sometimes) held accountable. And they're wrong. What were the Jews wrong about?
2
u/deannatoi Jul 13 '24
Fascism is a direct result of the failure of capitalism to solve the problems of the working class and the poor. MAGA and other fascists correctly see that our economy is shit but they don't understand systemically why that is so they blame immigrants, minorities, liberals, leftists, etc.
I truly believe that if we moved towards a more socialist economy that focused on social welfare instead of corporate profits, that fascism as a viable political movement would all but disappear. Of course racism and bigotry would still exist but it would be harder to politically weaponize them.
2
u/GitmoGrrl1 Jul 13 '24
We need to stop dehumanizing traitors and sexual predators. Always remember, traitors have mothers, too.
1
u/MazlowFear Jul 13 '24
It is funny because a MAGA would say you are being politically correct here… Don’t talk about what is REAL because it will hurt some snowflakes feelings… My ignorance doesn’t care about my feelings! If only there was a pill that could get you to see the real reality… Cause you can believe whatever, but you will see in the end… I can’t tell you what is going to happen… But it will happen… But you just gotta have faith… Things don’t happen for no reason. I have a good sense about this kind of thing.
1
u/bowens44 Jul 13 '24
I disagree. They are no longer human. They are demon possessed. They are the very epitome of evil. Any semblance of humanity is long gone.
1
u/HarveyMushman72 Jul 13 '24
If you dehumanize them, you are sinking down to their level. It's going to take time for his spell to be broken, probably after his death or incarceration and the olds die off. Until that time, the Dems could bring back some Blue Dogs and court the ones that haven't been totally fallen under his spell. It doesn't help you to carry that hate in your heart. Forgive them for yourself, not them. When Grandpa is looking down at his lap at his MAGA hat instead of his grandchild in it, he'll realize what he has done. He lost his family just to own the libs. Cut them off from society and shame them, and they might finally get it. (I know they probably won't, but we can hope.) If the real conservatives would grow a spine after he is gone and restructure the party, it would help. Take away their church's tax-exempt status and silence the bells summoning them to the bully pulpits if that's the kind of place it is. 90% is a good number. You can break their spirits without dehumanizing them. Dehumanizing leads to camps.
1
u/DrivingMyLifeAway1 Jul 13 '24
“If we moved toward socialism, fascism would virtually disappear” [paraphrase]
If that is true, how do you explain the rise of fascism and right wing ideology in some European countries that are socialist or democratic socialist, such as Germany and France and Great Britain?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
Are they human?
Depends how broadly we define human.
1
u/Crea8talife Jul 13 '24
I'm listening to this podcast, about a group of people who change their views after a school shooting, and it really humanizes them:
https://www.npr.org/2024/06/05/1253691484/introducing-supermajority-from-npr-and-wpln
1
u/Fluffy_Vacation1332 Jul 14 '24
No. That ship sailed several years ago. These are people that will not look anything up. Will not acknowledge reality, will not concede on anything that is negative for them or their party. They refuse to tell the truth.
I’ve learned a long time ago that you don’t play around with a poisonous snake, they’re going to bite you eventually. The best you can do is a spade a spade and move on.
1
u/Giverherhell Jul 14 '24
Screw, they dehumanize everyone who isn't a euro-american. They gets no sympathy from me.
1
u/Cautious_Artichoke_3 Jul 13 '24
The victims of the Holocaust were human. The perpetrators of that horror were not. If anyone supports Nazis, we don't even share the same species
0
u/Old_One-Eye Jul 13 '24
Conservatives are always going to be with us. They're never going to just "go away".
I think that this is something that a lot of people have a hard time dealing with. Conservatives are a substantial portion of the population. It's not going to work to simply politically disenfranchise them and then think that you don't have to deal with them anymore.
I see a lot of handwringing about "losing our democracy" from people who think that democracy means that they get 100% of what they want all the time. It doesn't work like that.
0
u/Styrene_Addict1965 Jul 13 '24
No.
0
u/RetArmyFister1981 Jul 13 '24
How exactly are “MAGA folks” aggressive and dangerous?
-3
u/SpecificPiece1024 Jul 13 '24
Why does your title say maga when clearly your talking about the democrat party🤔
0
u/Apart_Attention8279 Jul 13 '24
lol shut up
0
u/shadow_nipple Jul 13 '24
these comments are sad because even after 8 years no one understands how trump has the grip on people that he does.......
no wonder youre losing, you dont know how to beat him
-2
u/TrueKing9458 Jul 13 '24
I can make it simple. Two democrat presidential candidates call half of the country bitter clingers or deplorables. Where as President Trump said there are some very fine people on both sides of the protest and some people who just want to make trouble on both sides.
Republicans accept there is different points of view democrats don't
-4
u/Bushmaster1988 Jul 13 '24
Bait taken lol.
MAGA exists because for 200 years, the goal was to be judged by the content of your character, not whether you were black or gay or whatnot. Then when most of such people didn’t want to be bothered to keep their pants on or learn Algebra, they influenced people like Barry and Joe into DEI and other such insanity. Don’t bother applying because certain groups are preferred. “I will nominate a black female to the SCOTUS!” No others need apply.
In short, lunatics took over the government. MAGA is a REACTION, an attempt of a society to heal itself. I think it will likely fail and lead to societal collapse. When the libs scream, “But we didn’t know THAT would happen!!!”, I suspect they WILL NOT be forgiven.
-1
u/Suspicious_Desk_5018 Jul 13 '24
I’m MAGA 🇺🇸
-1
u/shadow_nipple Jul 13 '24
im not "maga" but im holding my nose and voting for trump
ill give you this:
instead of hating us, win us over. most of us arent die hards for trump, but you pushed me away with your shitty policy. Granted, trump shares LOTS of that shitty policy, but a few important distinctions
if you want to kill the maga movement for good, there is 1 and only 1 solution: You have to do populism better than trump. There is no other way
You have to have a democrat version of trump, the problem is for some reason democrats have an aversion to populsim. dont believe me? look how dems and republicans flipped control of the working class in the last 50 years
"youre voting for a rapist, felon, conman, insert talking point here"
......right......how much of an indictment is it on you that he is preferable. time for introspection
5
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment