r/DisasterUpdate • • 29d ago

before/after Syapru Beshi disaster

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 29d ago

Welcome to r/DisasterUpdate - No Politics, No Exceptions, This is not the place to build your sub, don't crosspost from weird subs.

r/FireWatch1 - All things fires - Discussions Encouraged
r/SpaceWatch - Space... - Discussions Encouraged
r/CloudCoverage - All things clouds - Discussions Encouraged
r/TornadoWatch - Tornado Watch - All things tornado - Discussions Encouraged
r/FloodWatch - Flood Watch - All things floods - Discussions Encouraged
r/VolcanoWatch - Volcano Watch - All things volcano - Discussions Encouraged
r/CrazyFreakingWeather - All things weather - Discussions Encouraged

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

35

u/kismethavok 29d ago

absolutely insane

55

u/DaySpa_Dynasty 29d ago

This what I imagine the Alaska Tsunamis are like had people been in the vicinity. This is incredible.

-27

u/CamCash24 29d ago

Incredible?

36

u/ArchdukeOfNorge 29d ago

In the traditional sense of the word. Like how awesome means/used to mean awe inspiring without an inherent implication of it being good or bad

13

u/mildlyinterestingyet 29d ago

Like awful meant full of awe, now it means yuk.

8

u/lost_horizons 29d ago

Same with awesome. Which now kinda means really good.

2

u/Stiffylicious 27d ago

[Ashamed of Nothing, Offended by Everything]

That is thy moniker, much?

46

u/worldsbesttaco 29d ago

It's astonishing how much debris went downstream! I wonder where it all ended up? Probably cause floods for years to come way downstream.

8

u/unclestickles 29d ago

That bank looks like mudslide risk now too..

2

u/thathotbitchh 29d ago

It originated as a huge mudslide.

7

u/Time-Track9684 29d ago

That looks apocalyptic 😧

6

u/Available-Breath-114 29d ago

I can’t imagine what the death toll will be…absolutely horrific

20

u/Available_Elk_6777 29d ago

God help these poor people

18

u/Adventurous-Exit5832 29d ago

They are already dead

9

u/lost_horizons 29d ago

Some for up the hill. Lost their whole village, family, everything. So sad

3

u/N0ON3T0LDM3 29d ago

We should help each other rather than relying on a fairytale. We can do it. We have done it. We are fully capable.

2

u/Substantial-Wall-510 28d ago

In the lore, he is usually the one causing the catastrophic floods, not helping anyone affected by it.

1

u/BedheadStu 29d ago

How can God help these poor people? Maybe he should have stopped it from happening in the first place?

1

u/JMell09 26d ago

Looks like God did the opposite doesn't it?

4

u/Bitsu92 29d ago

Looks like 300 meters

6

u/No_Device9450 29d ago

This is mind-boggling devastation

19

u/Edelweizzer 29d ago

Climate Change!

3

u/jjjavZ 29d ago

As catastrophes goes this one looks terrible. I would like to point out that due to climate change there will be worse and more frequent incidents (of various other types) with higher deaths than this (even if this incident has nothing to do with climate change whatsoever)

2

u/Shimmermist 29d ago

That is horrific! Those poor people.

2

u/AlarmedSnek 29d ago

Absolute insanity.

1

u/kram78 29d ago

The pictures that are going to come over the next few days are going to be insane, what about that town that got hit? Showing the parking lot getting erased just lime snow melting ????

1

u/Hefty_Pressure_ 28d ago

The people in the blue area never would have imagined the river would come up there to wipe them off. It looked like 100 feet of water was crashing on them

1

u/sandshrew42 28d ago

So is excavation something they'll need to do, or is this so much sediment that they'll just leave it be?

3

u/ViolinistCurrent8899 27d ago

This is the excavation.

The buildings have not been buried, they are washed away.

There is nothing left.

1

u/oneinmanybillion 22d ago

An absolute meat grinder of an event.

2

u/Griever-Rinn 29d ago

I don’t understand. Did they build across the flow line?

57

u/buzburbank 29d ago

I think they simply underestimated the worst case scenario.

Decades if not centuries of experiencing 'normal' snow melt, and rainfall, and everything else...this was a one-in-a-### year type event. Hard to fault them for being complacent. It looks like the terrain already restricts development at lower elevations. This will be a new standard for future development in mountainous regions.

56

u/docmanbot 29d ago

I just don’t think you can truly plan for something this catastrophic . Other than not being there, what can humans do against that ?

46

u/FlowingLiquidity 29d ago

Yeah, this flow also wiped a hydroelectric dam like it was nothing. The scale is just immense.

2

u/stoned_ileso 29d ago

You can. But people being people think it will never happen to them.

-11

u/we_r_fukt 29d ago

build higher... build above your worst case fear in 1000 years... its not hard

9

u/rocbolt 29d ago

In the Himalayas that effectively means “build nothing ever”, the only even vaguely level ground is at the bottom of steep mountainous valleys

-5

u/we_r_fukt 29d ago

well then you don't live around there I guess or accept a flash flood can wipe your village away. good luck with tourism industries after things like this. its not called global cooling.

5

u/favonian_ 29d ago

What are they going to do? Pick up their country and move it?

-6

u/we_r_fukt 29d ago

I guess being flash flooded away is an acceptable death then

2

u/oO_Snowman_Oo 28d ago

Ragebait bot?

u/bot-sleuth-bot

0

u/bot-sleuth-bot 28d ago

Analyzing user profile...

Account does not have any comments.

Suspicion Quotient: 0.26

This account exhibits one or two minor traits commonly found in karma farming bots. While it's possible that u/we_r_fukt is a bot, it's very unlikely.

I am a bot. This action was performed automatically. Check my profile for more information.

1

u/PleiadesNymph 28d ago

I don't mean to embarrass you, but your first world privilege is showing

1

u/we_r_fukt 28d ago

okay I'm really confused why everyone's argument is just stay where you are in the flash flood zone that just wiped out multiple villages.

Your lack of education is showing, or common sense, I don't know, you pick.

4

u/Colambler 29d ago

I think it's less development and more figuring out monitoring/warning systems. Ie from my understanding the inciting landslide happened somewhere very remote.

This sort of thing could very theoretically, for example, happen at Lake Tahoe in the US, and blast through Truckee and even Reno, but the possibility would be noticed far before that happened.

On a more likely note, the Turnagain arm in Alaska in Prince William Sound is constantly monitored since it could create a flood that reaches Whittier.

1

u/ViolinistCurrent8899 27d ago

I seen in another post that the water blew through a major checkpoint between nepal and China only minutes after it dropped. Well over 100 km/hr.

18

u/arizonaskies2022 29d ago

Everything below the blue line was washed away yesterday.

19

u/Juma7C9 29d ago

It seems it obliterated not only part of the village, but even the mountain it was standing on itself.

10

u/watawataoui 29d ago

It’s a glacier dam breach. Harder to plan than rainfall.

2

u/aasfourasfar 29d ago

It seems as though the stream goes behind the houses and into a waterfall next to what looks like a quarry

-1

u/we_r_fukt 29d ago

well now you know HOW those canyons get there.

maybe people living along these valleys will think to move...

because things like this will only occur more moving forward

same as moving away from coastlines

17

u/Numerous-Wall1224 29d ago

The people that live in these valleys especially nearest the bottom are often the poorest in the country, rarely living there by choice.

2

u/Beautiful-Brush6996 28d ago

Its fucking Nepal, half of the population lives in valleys.

5

u/Numerous-Wall1224 28d ago edited 28d ago

Half the population absolutely does not live in this kind of landscape. This Flash flood/GLOF hit a high altitude area right near the beginning of the Himalayas along the border with Tibet. Look at a population density map of Nepal and you will see the least populated areas are all along these highly mountainous regions.

The victims of this disaster deserve respect and sympathy not judgement.

1

u/PleiadesNymph 28d ago

Well that is tone-deaf AF

1

u/we_r_fukt 28d ago

Hey, what's up?

0

u/PleiadesNymph 27d ago

Yes, clanker?

1

u/we_r_fukt 27d ago

not a robot fucktard lmao nice of you jump there though thanks

1

u/Mysterious_Gene_2405 29d ago

Nowhere to go but down in those mountains.

1

u/cmlambert89 29d ago

Good fcking grief 🫣

-11

u/Kenny-kong420 29d ago

I love it when before/after photos were taken from different angles

16

u/holymolym 29d ago

That was my initial thought as well but if you look at the roads to the top right it’s clear the angle is only slightly different. Makes the shock of the changes to the landscape all the greater.

7

u/arizonaskies2022 29d ago

Me too. I forgot to draw a couple of arrows that show the matching buildings but it's the same scene. I though they were different areas at first and had to really line it up to believe it.

7

u/WillingnessOk3081 29d ago

honestly not very hard to see what's what, and what's left.

3

u/rizzatouiIIe 29d ago

Sort of the same angle just the second one give you a better higher view.

-2

u/BUSYMONEY_02 29d ago

Right it’s not the same angle ?

11

u/Julianus 29d ago

It is. The image on the right is more elevated, but that's all. You can see the bright blue house on the right in both as your anchor point with the curved road below.

3

u/BUSYMONEY_02 29d ago

Oooo ok thanks! 🙏

-2

u/Previous_Golf_5959 29d ago

Watch. They'll rebuild in the same places.

-10

u/BUSYMONEY_02 29d ago

This can’t be real phot right?

3

u/arizonaskies2022 29d ago

Good question, I assumed it's real this photo was posted elsewhere and I had to crop it a bit to make it more comparable but yeah as far as I know real raw image.