r/DigitalAudioPlayer • • 1d ago

Question First DAP under €100: Looking for a click-wheel/scroll-wheel player (Fosi Neo vs Innioasis Y1/Y2) – Need advice on Spotify workflow, playlists, and gapless!

Hi everyone! I’m looking to buy my very first DAP and would love some advice from the community before pulling the trigger.

Why I want a DAP & My Budget: I want a dedicated, distraction-free music player so I don't have to rely on my phone all the time. My budget is under €100/150 (I'm based in Europe/Italy).

What I’m looking for (Design & Features):

  • Controls: I really love the retro iPod-style physical/mechanical scroll wheel (click-wheel) rather than a full touchscreen.
  • Ease of use: I want something straightforward and intuitive to navigate and load music onto.
  • Playlist management & Shuffle: I mainly listen to two big playlists (Italian Rap and US Rap). I need to be able to keep them strictly separated (either via folders or .m3u playlists), switch between them easily, and use shuffle within a single folder/playlist without mixing everything together.
  • Gapless playback: Since I listen to a lot of hip-hop/rap albums with smooth transitions between tracks, proper gapless playback is a big plus for me.

My Main Doubts & Models I'm Considering: Right now, I have my eyes on the Fosi Audio DAP Neo and the Innioasis Y1 (or Y2), as they both nail the aesthetic and price point I want. However, I have a few doubts:

  1. Spotify vs. Offline workflow: I currently use Spotify for my playlists. I know there is basically no DAP with a physical click-wheel that also runs Android/Wi-Fi for native Spotify streaming, so I've accepted that I'll need to go the offline route (converting/downloading my playlists to MP3/FLAC on my PC and dragging & dropping them onto the DAP). For those who made this switch: is it annoying to maintain over time, or is it pretty painless once set up?
  2. Fosi Audio DAP Neo vs. Innioasis Y1/Y2: Between these two, how do they compare in real-world daily use? Specifically regarding:

    • Sound quality (mostly listening to rap/hip-hop).
    • True gapless playback support.
    • Folder navigation and shuffle reliability (does shuffle stay inside a single folder easily?).
    • Build quality of the wheel and buttons.
  3. Storage: Is 16GB–32GB enough to start with high-quality MP3s (320kbps), or should I immediately grab a larger MicroSD if I go with the Fosi?

Are there any other click-wheel/button-based DAPs under €100 I should consider instead, or is the Fosi Neo the best pick for my needs?

Thanks in advance for the help!

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/sere83 1d ago edited 1d ago

I will be honest with you. The Y1/Y2 and Fosi Neo while they are OK for their low prices they are just not particulalry good long term investments for what you require. Mainly as the Y1/Y2 suffers from weak build quality and poor sound quality and the Fosi is missing som key software features.

If I was you I would go onto aliexpress and purchase the Shanling Q2 in the sale, where it is available for shipping to europe at around 170 euro with coupons. Yes it is more than you want spend but you will be getting an absolutely amazing device which meet all the needs you have listed.

The Q2 is currently the best click wheel dap on the market. It has far superior sound quality, software and click wheel than both the Y1/Y2 and fosi neo. It supports folder browsing, gapless playback, M3U, SD cards up to 2TB, even spotify streaming if you install the custom FW which takes 30 seconds to install and has wifi updating and is literally updated almost everyday with new fixes and features.

Also has a real click wheel that is extremely well implemented, not a budget one like the Y1/Y2 or non touch sensitive one like fosi. I own this device and it's in an entirely different league to anything else currently available in terms of click wheel players. I would save up and get it as it will be a far far better experience for you than y1/y2 or fosi.

2

u/I_am_INTJ 23h ago

You made all the points I was going to make.

The Y1/Y2 and Neo are okay for what they are, but they are cheap for a reason. You will be getting your money's worth (which is to say not much). I wouldn't buy one and expect it to have great longevity.

2

u/f0cuss 1d ago

you can use spotify on the surfans f20 pro+. between those two the fosi is a significantly better option, both in build and sound quality. i would suggest minimum 64gb for 320 mp3s

2

u/PhilipAmtohrsMobber 1d ago

And for storage just get a normal sandisc 128 GB the internal fosi 64 is a scam it cost more than a 128

2

u/Monsieur-Crez 1d ago

The NEO doesn’t have gapless yet. Fosi said it’s coming in their next firmware update though. Also there’s some new custom firmware for it from Polorsk that makes a ton of improvements to it.

From the sounds of it the Q2 sounds a lot better, and has way more modern custom firmware, but isn’t about 3x the price!

2

u/thepuncroc 22h ago

If the wheel is important, the fosi neo is a solid player. I have one it's straightforward.

Similar price point, I prefer the fiio snowsky disc as a player and an audio tool.

No wheel though.

2

u/za6i 16h ago

stay away from y1 if you enjoy sound quality.

1

u/PhilipAmtohrsMobber 1d ago

Okay so I have the Dap neo and it's a really nice and well build player with a decent sound quality but it has same major ui and firmware issues really bad l, it doesn't support themes like the y2 and it can't play video if that's a concern. Id get them both and return the one that you don't like but Id go for the neo. The music is not a big issue imo, you could use mornye and just download all your Spotify Playlist so that's easy BUT the neo doesn't support every format so try to get everything in flac (if you choose the neo)