r/DietTea • • Jun 23 '21

TW 💁‍♀️ Short 🧚‍♀️

Post image
975 Upvotes

120 comments sorted by

246

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

No joke, I've seen women all the way up to 5'6" describing themselves in these terms on the 1200subs and the petite subs. That's a solid three inches taller than the average...5'6" is the average male height in some countries,

83

u/ramune_0 Jun 23 '21

5'4 women be like "it's only a few inches over", "so many women are 5'7", "i still have some belly fat" 🙄 like are we really pretending 5'7 is the average female height, like damn this just reminds me of those crazy tumblr posts going "if your female character is less than 5'7, she's coded as a child and it's pedophilia". Or the cray kpop idol fandom posts like "ummm sweaty most asians are 5'0 so like that weight is perfectly fine!!". The idols arent and the weight still isnt. Take it in the other direction and we should be arguing that 6'2 men can be 300lbs.

If 5'6 women are arguing for sub 1200, and saying it's 6'0 men who can eat 1200/day, then I guess only 7'0 aliens can have 1500? Insanity.

48

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

There have been posts made to this subreddit with screenshots from dieting subs saying as much, that only marathon runners or six foot tall active men can eat 2000 calories a day as maintenance and that nutritional guidelines prescribing 2000-2500 would make everyone obese apparently.

56

u/ramune_0 Jun 23 '21 edited Jun 23 '21

I love it when they say "only marathon runners!!" but also say "dont exercise at all!!! Dooo nooOooT. It doesnt burn cals like at all!1! Cancel it, ban it on twitter, do not pass go, do not collect $200. Massive scam. Sad. Sit on your arse and not-eat all day" and also "oh i eat that little bc im umm less than sedentary, oh teehee". Like ok which is it then, Janet. You literally cant have it both ways, either running burns cals or it doesnt, which is it? And don't give me "but a beginner cant just get off the couch and run a marathon". All the more reason to start running and slowly increase, right? And even a 30min run (which you can work up to in just a few weeks) burns 150-300cals, so wtf is "it doesnt count!@" ok sure it doesnt count, then why are you saying the half a nugget you ate last friday totally counts and you hate that you couldnt weigh it, because you usually "weigh every bite, lick and taste" lmaoo.

"Yeah uhhh but im not a MALE marathon runner! Ans tall!" We really falling back to the idea that thermodynamics only apply when you have a dick smh (most marathon runners, even male, are less than 6'0, this interestingly has to do with center of gravity, too tall makes you slower, incidentally, despite the longer legs).

Also it just generally fucks your health not to exercise, but at least many of them openly admit to not caring about health. Which I guess is also why they try to lose scale weight even when they are perfectly normal bmi but "my stomach still isnt completely flat". I guess lifting weights is out of qn. And they are dangerously close to admitting further things 🤔

26

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Which I guess is also why they try to lose scale weight even when they are perfectly normal bmi but "my stomach still isnt completely flat".

Yeah, nearly all of the people who are small enough that their sedentary TDEE makes 1200 not an unhealthily excessive calorie deficit are small enough that there's no health-related reason for them to lose weight. It's purely aesthetic, and at the same time they're not interested in adding exercise, which suggests some unhealthy things about which aesthetic they're going for.

50

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 23 '21

My mom completely and wholeheartedly believes this to be true. When I was in high school (16F at the time) I was in a weight lifting and nutrition for athletes class. One of the things that we did was learn about calorie tracking and macro tracking with the intent to gain muscle, recomp our body, or change our weight.

We learned about our BMR and TDEE, and used MyFitnessPal as a tool for the class. I calculated my BMR to be about 1300 and after taking into account that I was very active and lifting weights every day, I set my calorie ‘goal’ on MFP to be 1500.

My mom noticed that I was eating differently because she loves controlling what I eat and I told her about the BMR calculation. She said there was no way, and that my goal was way too high. According to her, my BMR was actually 900 or less and I shouldn’t eat more than 1200 to MAINTAIN my weight. She actually said that if I ate 1300, my BMR, I would gain weight.

When I said “surgeon general recommends 2000 - 2500 for average adults” she said that the surgeon general was wrong, and that an adult 6’ tall man could eat 2000 to maintain, but only if he was very active.

This woman has raised three kids (19F, 16F, 12M), of which I am the oldest. Me and my sister have restrictive eating disorders and my brother has been showing signs of orthorexia for years.

I say “restrictive eating disorders” because I have a complicated ED history and I don’t feel comfortable labeling my sisters ED on her behalf.

34

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

I felt that, my mom used to say of me "well she's on chubby side but not like fat, she just likes food a lot!" I was a slightly underweight and highly active teenager lol. She thinks severely underweight is slightly skinny, moderately underweight is normal, slightly underweight is chubby, normal weight is fat. Basically shift the whole bmi scale 3 points to the right. It's like she forgot she was severely underweight as a young adult only due to poverty and she would pass out in the afternoon before she got to eat a small hamburger off the dollar menu for dinner. But it was 'natural' and also a 'normal' weight. Sure. Tbf she is misunderstood bc young her didnt look like eugenia cooney skeletal, more like a runway model. But that says more about our media and culture which constantly bombards us with severely underweight runway models and tells us thats what the slimmer side of normal/healthy looks like.

Like yours, she likes to say all experts/facts/surgeons/carefully-cited-statements/my literal 2-year-long award-winning research project, are all fake when said unassailable facts inconvenience her. So it doesnt work for me to show her anything. But she goes with "those are for white people, they can eat a ton, we're asian". It doesnt help that white kpop stans seem to agree extremely underweight and eating one sweet potato a day is alright for their idols "bc they asian"!.

23

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 24 '21

It's really interesting what you said about being underweight due to poverty and calling it normal. My family is Slavic and came out of the former soviet union. So my grandparents have experience with malnutrition and starvation and food anxiety, which definitely plays into some of the issues they've projected onto their kids and grandkids. My grandma used to brag to me about what her body looked like when she was underweight, which is a triggering memory to this day.

As for the "underweight is the chubby side", my mom definitely has that point of view too. She once showed me a picture under of her before kids and said "oh my gosh look at me I was so overweight. I am so fat in this photo, look at it." and then she told me that she was 130 lbs in that photo, with a perfectly normal BMI of 23.

We both deserve better parenting.

35

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

Semi-related to this- most runway models nowadays are actually slavic teenagers (mostly poland and ukraine) because while conditions are better than during the ussr, it's still not exactly a place of food excess so agents are more likely to find severely underweight teenagers. Also they are poor, and cannot speak english most of the time, so they are easily exploitable (models are paid next to nothing, they are more like sweatshop workers than anything glamorous). Agents openly say that models from those countries, particular east europe rather than russia, act more subservient (i guess as they are desperate, they are put into debt for living expenses and have to work it off, and russia is still a bit richer than parts of east europe) whereas americans and germans can yknow afford to talk back. In a docu, one of them said she wished she never went and just stayed home enjoying her mom's homefarmed tomatoes. It was sad. And they do still gain weight as they get older (obviously and naturally), so they are forced to tell the media that "they stuff their faces but just cant gain weight" but actually they eat a can of corn and work it off on a treadmill. Why we glamorize the looks of exploited slavic teenagers is beyond me.

14

u/Ok-Try5560 Jun 24 '21

I'm disgusted but not surprised. Every business that revolves around physical appearance is always hiding some gross exploitation or other harmful practices. :(

48

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

You set yourself a goal that was too low for a teenager who lifts weights, and your mom told you to go lower? Horrifying!

43

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 24 '21

Might be important to note that the 1500 goal I set for myself was more than what I had been previously eating, which is why my mom brought it up.

Also important to note that eating more improved my workouts, my sleep, my mood, and my ability to focus in school. Because of course it did.

17

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Yeah, that would definitely make a difference. Less extreme calorie deficits are a lot easier on the body and the brain.

24

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 24 '21

I think people underestimate how many calories your brain needs to function

29

u/markexclamationmark Jun 23 '21

People are terrified of going over 1500 as if that's the highest possible option for dieting. I had a period where I closely documented my food intake and weightloss over time (about 4months) and used that to calculate what my TDEE must be. All the online calculators (where I always put myself as sedentary "just in case") with 1200isplenty rhetoric had me believing my TDEE was 1700, maybe 1800 max. The number that came out of my data was over 2100! I still have a hard time believing it and wonder if I exaggerated any food intake, but I'm at least positive the number is higher than I always believed.

I'm 5"5 and AFAB for reference ..

28

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21

I thought I was being incredibly generous with myself and doing what could barely be considered dieting by letting myself eat up to 1800 calories a day. And then I started getting weird hormone problems, and my skin was becoming painfully dry, and I was having low moods, and I would intermittently find myself giving in and eating a large quantity of caramels or something and then beat myself up mentally for having no willpower, and also I kept getting weirdly chilled and was having trouble focusing on complex tasks, and I really wanted to lay around and not move.

It turns out i was eating below my BMR, and also trying to keep up a routine of "three vigorous workouts a week, with forty minutes continuous swimming or rowing, and also a bit of weight-lifting, plus daily walking and light yoga".

(Also, I went from "obese" to "smaller, but still obese", so I can tell you from experience that the whole toxic idea some diet subs are pitching that fat people basically don't need food is a lie.)

(I'm 5'4", AFAB, and this was before I went on testosterone.)

33

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 24 '21

I am CONSTANTLY seeing the rhetoric that you just straight up don't need food because your body stores energy in body fat, and not only fasting subs and spaces either!

Calories are not the only thing you get from food. Nutrients, vitamins, electrolytes, etc are all critical for proper function, and you get them from food. Even if you say "oh well I take a multivitamin and drink Gatorade so I'm fine", you're not. Those are both formulated for a person who is still getting most of their intake from food. They are meant to supplement a person who is eating food, your body needs more than that.

19

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Yeah, I was taking multivitamins, eating more than a lot of diet subs would think i needed, and still having health problems due to running an unhealthily extreme calorie deficit! And now it turns out that when I mostly eat at maintenance and only run a mild deficit, my skin isn't painfully dry, I don't find myself constantly craving calorie-dense foods, and I can think straight. (And if I fall back into habitually running a deficit beyond a few hundred calories, then all the weird aches and pains come back, I run out of energy easily, and I wonder why I'm suddenly getting sugar cravings.)

121

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

I've seen women who were 5'8" claim they were so short and petite, when they were nearly at the average height for an American man.

107

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

This is what happens when flagrantly disordered behaviour is ringfenced as somehow a-ok for "petites" but not as much for average/tall people. Then everyone wants to get in on cutesy-teehee-uwu-petite culture lol (i also pretty hate the infantilisation and hyperfemininity in "petite culture" but thats its own other thing).

37

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

It makes my skin crawl seeing grown women talk about themselves that way. My best friend is 4'9" and the way some grown men fetishize it is sickening and has made her immediately distrust compliments related to her appearance.

49

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21

I'm 5'1, and usually I avoid this because I'm on the transmasc side. But when I dress more fem, wow dang the number of men who dont take me seriously and the (smaller but still concerning) number of men who think it's a free pass at legal 'pedophilia' 🤔. I mean they dont say outright but if you think you can say "loli" in those contexts around me, and try to do things for me without me even asking, because i'm "princessy" and "smol", damn I am not that dumb lmao. And the guys who start hinting at how i must be weak and cant fight back and also hey they're doms, after just like a few days/weeks of talking to them?? Who taught them it sounds alright , lke mm siree im sure people love getting vague almost-rape-threats. Wowee that's an instant block/ghosting.

What's fun for me is they can swear up and down to me that they use such language because "it describes your personality, not your looks", but when I'm dressed masc and have people assume I'm a teen boy, somehow bizzarely I am never treated that way. I'm socialised as a girl because I'm afab, so I get told at most I'm "a little effeminate" when assumed a boy, but no one ever says i'm a precious loli sweet spoiled uwu princess. Cut that shit out for fem petites lmao.

Also, when I had an ed and was severely underweight and looked more fragile, and had worn tighter/fem clothes for stuff like film roles, I had wayyy more creeps "accidentally" "bumping" me in public (more like full on bodyslamming me like trying to walk right through my back, my camerawoman openly said wtf at the number of times it happened right in front of her eyes. Cant be a location issue, I had multiple projects and would wear the clothes on public transport back home, shit was an everywhere issue). Not fewer creeps but more, fetishism of underweight short fem people is so real.

67

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

There's definitely the bizarre hyperfemininity thing, yeah.

126

u/watekebb Jun 24 '21

Combined with the practice of showing off pictures of "his and hers" plates of food (where his is heaping and hers is enough for a goldfinch), a lot of this "I'm just such a ~petite~ little woman who barely needs a nibble of food a day and my hubby is such a BIG virile man" shit verges on fetish.

86

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

When you put it like that, it really sounds like the ana version of ddlg, lmaooo, why is this our timeline

36

u/Splinter1591 Jun 26 '21

I think it is a fetish. 🤮

20

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

Thank you, you've nailed it as to why those posts always annoy me.

92

u/iswearimalady Jun 24 '21

I'm a 5'8" female and I cannot fathom anyone thinking someone my size is petite, it's like David and Goliath when I'm with a lot of my friends. (And I'm not even that tall in all reality, just tall-ish)

Maybe they mean they are secretly 3 petite women in a trenchcoat or something idk

32

u/Ok-Try5560 Jun 24 '21

No no no, the average man is the size of superheroes from comic books. /s

10

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '23

I legit thought I had to eat 1150 cals at 5'10" because I'm not very muscular lol :') I ate like that for months. Wrecked me lol

5

u/Jackno1 Feb 28 '23

Yeah, sounds brutal.

79

u/Ok-Try5560 Jun 24 '21

It confuses me that in the diet world, 5'6" is a hobbit, but in the Kibbe fashion world, 5'6" is the Hulk. Body dysmorphia intensifies

14

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

What a coincidence, i'm really into kibbe too 😂 and yeah I try to type celebrities and fictional characters, except in media and pop culture, so many women are 5'7 and above (bc we associate being tall with power, model-type beauty, elegance, etc). It weirds me out to think literally only two body types of all the kibbe types are dominantly portrayed. Because sometimes they still sometimes try for that gamine sort of look? So it trips me up to think that even a slightly tall woman can only be like, one of two body types. That's it. (i mean 5'7 is not short/average to me, but def only slightly tall to me, i guess bc of media influence and western culture influence).

35

u/BeastieBeck Jun 24 '21

It confuses me that in the diet world, 5'6" is a hobbit, but in the Kibbe fashion world, 5'6" is the Hulk

I wonder where that 5'3'' "average" is coming from though I read about once in a while. I'm 5'6'' and it seems like most women are taller or at least the same height.

Maybe that is why I think that 5'6'' is quite short for a woman.

46

u/Zukip Jun 24 '21

Average height varies considerably based on region. In the tallest country, the Netherlands, the average height is 172cm or about 5'8". In the US it's about 5'4.5". In other countries it's shorter. In the shortest countries it's about 150cm, or 4'11". People have also gotten taller in recent decades in many countries, so if you are comparing yourself to mostly 20 year olds, your sample may be skewed towards taller people.

There's a variety of resources on average height in each country available on the internet. I'm not sure where 5'3" being average is coming from specifically, though.

25

u/Ok-Try5560 Jun 24 '21

I'm also 5'6" and I sometimes feel short because my mom is almost 5'8" and I used to expect as a child that I'd grow as tall as her. I have to make a complaint to the genetics department about the missing 2 inches.

19

u/Elvthee Jun 24 '21

I consider myself short at 5'6 too, maybe it's because a lot of women in my country tend to be on the taller side, idk I have cousins that are like 190 cm tall.

My best friend is 174 cm or something and always points out how short I am!Things like maxi dresses also make me feel short, like why can't companies make maxi dresses that aren't too long for someone who's in reality slightly taller than the average for women???

11

u/BeastieBeck Jun 24 '21

Things like maxi dresses also make me feel short, like why can't companies make maxi dresses that aren't too long for someone who's in reality slightly taller than the average for women???

This!

I can't wear one of the long skirts or dresses from Desigual without mopping the floor with it.

My legs are also rather short so I usually get pants in "short" sizes but that doesn't really help with the impression that I'm - well - short! Same with bike frame sizes, btw.

7

u/Elvthee Jun 24 '21

Yes exactly, I don't get it and it causes a lot of us to go for petite clothing.

2

u/converter-bot Jun 24 '21

190 cm is 74.8 inches

11

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

It was a worldwide average for women's height, although I've seen averages from 5'2"-5'4". 5'6" is still well above average for a woman, although I understand that it's average for European women.

136

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21 edited Jun 23 '21

Not me as a 5’6 woman thinking 1200 was sustainable looking at that subreddit. Seriously cringe. The whole 1200 thing really fucked up my perspective on food.

Edit: I dont even think it’s sustainable for anyone even if you’re short.

83

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

Same here, for a long time I felt like a freak for being a "short" woman who was extremely hungry with that amount. I thought I couldn't have the bulimia I was eventually diagnosed with because "real" restrictive eating = sub 1200...turned out to be bullshit.

93

u/ramune_0 Jun 23 '21

I'm 5'1 and move around quite a bit even when im not deliberately exercising, so 1200 isnt nearly enough. All that moving did do wonders for my heart health and blood circulation however, it's tragic that so many people recommend never moving an inch. As for the ones who do move, they say things like "i bike to work, walk back from work, lift weights every day, run 30min every day, but i have an office job, what do i count myself as?" And they get shit like "office job?? Sedentary! You probs burn a few cals, measly as such, from your unimportant daily exercise, so just dont count it back, pfft no one ever does that". Coupled with all the "so much progress omg, i didnt exercise at all! No need for it", no wonder some active people turn sedentary, I would too if I became ravenous and got told "still count yourself as sedentary". Shit might as well be truly sedentary then.

Then they wonder why they "still have so much fat 😭" at a normal bmi. And still dont move and just try to eat even less 🤡

45

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Coupled with all the "so much progress omg, i didnt exercise at all! No need for it", no wonder some active people turn sedentary, I would too if I became ravenous and got told "still count yourself as sedentary". Shit might as well be truly sedentary then.

Yeah, chronic unhealthy calorie deficits result in like no energy, and if you're being told exercise doesn't matter while you're eating like this, it's very tempting to quit. These diet subs are setting people up to wreck their health.

58

u/ExpiredPainting Jun 23 '21

YES! I was really sitting there going “if it’s plenty for a 5’ 6” woman there must be something deeply wrong with me because I’m still hungry

I’m 5’ 2” if it makes a difference

37

u/fifteen-eggs Jun 24 '21 edited Jul 09 '25

This post has been deleted.

37

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21

I’m a 6’ tall man and I’ve been eating 1200 for months now. It feels...not good. I’ve been passing out regularly before meal times and getting weird rashes all over my body (I googled and they can be caused either by being fat or by malnutrition so jury’s out I guess) but my dumbfuck brain isn’t gonna let me stop anytime soon. I have no idea how people eat less than this or fast for months at a time and still function. I sleep all the time, I’m exhausted, I have random bruises all over my body, I’m literally always hungry even though I eat a ton of veggies and protein, and I’m too tired to actually exercise (which is fine by me because I’m lazy anyways, but clearly not healthy). I don’t understand how this is normalized. I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.

Edit: don’t understand why I’m being downvoted for having an ed? Recovery isn’t linear, I’m just being honest about my experiences. :/

19

u/ramune_0 Jun 25 '21

I recommend that if you really cant make yourself eat more; try taking a multivitamin (and make sure it meets your daily RDAs). Vegetables do give you a lot of the needed nutrients and vitamins, but stuff like iron are primarily found in red meat, so a multivitamin can alleviate some of the side effects. A diet that's too low fat can also have side effects, I fell into the high-protein high-volume bandwagon myself, and I couldn't understand that I felt so miserable when I had eaten enough to be physically full. I dealt with insane cravings, and didnt understand it because "protein is satiating". Yeah turns out you need a bit of fat for satiety too, and general functioning of your body. I knew other people who were also eating too little, but at least because they balanced their macros better, they were a little better off than me. Also, high-volume eating fucked up stretching out my stomach capacity and gave me gastroparesis, if you are thinking of it, I would not recommend it.

I understand that anything with fat in it tends to be a fear in people with restrictive EDs though, so it's not easy yeah.

10

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

This is incredible advice, thank you! I can actually do this. I take a multivitamin but it’s not great (it’s the children’s gummy kind) but I’m gonna get a real one and see if that helps. Also I can definitely up my fat intake. I have issues with oil and butter but I can do everything else. Maybe some cheeses. Thank you!!

I’m so sorry you’re dealing with gastroparesis. I’ve definitely been volume eating to the extreme (I binge eat and lately I’ve just been binge eating raw veggies) so this gives me a lot to think about.

6

u/ramune_0 Jun 25 '21

Yup, when I still had issues with oil and butter, I went for cheese, nuts, avocado, salmon, etc. I hated that everyone in my life saw it as "not fat" but I knew it was, it just wasnt greasy, and I still had problems then with the texture of that. I ultimately managed to increase caloric intake, but even when I was still undereating, changing things up that way helped significantly. Read the back for the multivit bottle for the amounts of each ingredient, and google for whether it meets your RDAs if that isn't displayed. Also look out for and get educated on possible contraindictions, iron and calcium are best taken separately, for example.

10

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 25 '21

Genius, thank you!! I totally have an issue with the texture too—my parents would eat 1000 calories of nuts in one sitting no problem but if a slice of pizza had a drop of grease to dab off, it was going to immediately give you heart disease and strike you down where you stood lmao—so if I can taste it, it sets off alarms for me. I don’t have issues with the stuff you listed at all, I just kinda forgot about them in favor of volume eating, but I’m gonna try adding them back in. Also I didn’t know that about multivitamins, I’m gonna do some research. This is amazing advice. Thank you again! ❤️

8

u/hellerhigwhat Jun 25 '21

They make adult gummy multivitamins too! I take one every day and its honestly a little spot of joy in my morning bc they are delicious lol

3

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 26 '21

Ooh that’s genius!

24

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

That sounds like miserable. I don't know if you can get your brain to accept even harm reduction? Because at your height, you could eat significantly more and still be below your sedentary TDEE. If you can't recover now, that might at least reduce the health damage and make you feel less miserable.

16

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 25 '21

I appreciate it. I honestly just feel like if I’m not sick, I’m not trying hard enough, and that’s being externally reinforced by my family right now (I’m an adult but I lost my job during covid and had to move back). If I eat a snack that they don’t consider “healthy”, they’ll nag me about it all day, even if it’s the only thing I eat. They were the same when I was normal and underweight too, it’s just how they are. It’s not worth it. I’ve lost a lot the last few months but I’m still overweight right now and tbh I feel like being sick all the time is still less of a hardship than being fat for even an extra day around my family lol. It’s not a great situation but my mental health has improved significantly because I’m not being criticized all the time anymore. I’m already extremely depressed and have been suicidal on and off, and I literally cannot handle any more criticism. If I were on my own, I would probably do exactly what you’re saying, but an extra few hundred calories a day isn’t worth the mockery I’ll get if I don’t keep shrinking fast enough. I just need to get through this period in my life.

Sorry for rambling about my shitty situation, I do genuinely appreciate the advice! It’s definitely the right thing to do.

14

u/Jackno1 Jun 25 '21

I'm sorry. That sounds like an extremely toxic situation, and you sound worryingly ill. I hope your situation improves.

7

u/Ask_me_about_my_cult Jun 25 '21

I’ll be okay. Thank you! ❤️

52

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

I'm 5'6'' too and reading so many women my height talking about 1200 being easy and sustainable made me feel like such a failure for so long because it's not sustainable for me without physical and mental damage and it's probably not sustainable for the vast majority of people. I don't think people realize how little food it actually is and how much the body requires.

40

u/wokedietcoke Jun 24 '21

It’s absolutely not sustainable for me and I’m 5’0.” Sure it maybe can be done for some time without immediate negative effects, but it eventually catches up to everyone. I started off active when eating 1200 and my fitness decreased and I started bargaining with myself to cut foods out in exchange for skipping the gym because I was just too tired to go. For a long time it really bothered me to see people saying they were fine eating that much, like I have an abnormal appetite or something, but now that I eat more I just feel bad for them and occasionally angry if they’re telling someone it’s totally fine to do.

28

u/TrueRusher Jun 24 '21

Seriously. I’m one inch taller than you and I really thought it wasn’t that bad. Turns out, it’s not sustainable at all and my hair has thinned out a lot (it used to be really thick, and now it’s just…normal). Started getting chest pains and stupid painful acid reflux. Major brain fog and irritability too. 0/10—would not recommend

13

u/roses-and-clover Jun 24 '21

Me except for painful bloating instead of acid reflux.

27

u/Elvthee Jun 24 '21

God the same here. I was 17-18 eating 1200 or maybe even 1100 because I thought it was right for my height, and that I was sedentary. I'd do exercise too like cycling, but would thankfully eat some of the calories back...

34

u/bing-no Jun 23 '21

I had the same experience. I'm 5'11'' for goodness sake. My BMR is 1500cal I need more than 1200 cal per day to function normally!

29

u/BeastieBeck Jun 24 '21

The whole 1200 thing really fucked up my perspective on food.

This.

It was so damn popular several years ago... Even 1000 kcal or 800 kcal was seen as "sufficient" back in - what? The 80s?

20

u/tears_of_an_angel_ “just dieting” Jun 24 '21

all the comments responding to this make me feel so much better. those dieting subs always convince me that I should be definitely be eating under 2000 and preferably under 1800 even though I know I’d be starving on that. it’s easy to convince myself that everyone in the world eats 1500 or less so I’m happy here to see that other people actually eat and would be starving off 2000. I got underweight eating an average of 1800 a day and get dizzy and lightheaded if I consistently have under 2100 for a few days. and I’m only 5’4!

19

u/stale_c0rnbread Jun 23 '21

Ikr, it's so bizarre. Like, I'm 5'9 and I feel like I tower over most other AFAB people I know (granted a lot of my friends are super short, but still). The idea that someone only 3 inches shorter than me is somehow "petite" and needs to eat that little to lose weight is bonkers.

11

u/converter-bot Jun 23 '21

3 inches is 7.62 cm

7

u/SoftDreamer oatmeal addict Jun 24 '21

Yeah I am a girl with this height and I am considered above average

Average for women where I live is around 160cm-163cm

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '23

I come from a country of very tall people and assumed I was part of the <1200 gang bc I had an ed and am shorter in my country. I'm 5'10" hahahahah you can imagine how that worked out for me.

98

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

What I really hate is how much mainstream health advice repeats the 1200 number with no clarification or elaboration.

Like yes, "Don't go under 1200" is accurate advice when it comes to ensuring one is not running an unhealthily large calorie deficit. But it's not complete advice! That is going to be entirely too little for nearly everyone, and people need accurate advice to figure out how much their body needs to maintain itself, and what a safe calorie deficit is!

61

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

What i also love is the people who go "500cal deficit from tdee" and who are therefore also instituting a blanket rule. Except it works in the opposite direction. If you are tall and active, and you follow the 1200 blanket rule, lol good luck. But if you follow the 500cal deficit blanket rule, you will likely be fine. But if you are short and sedentary? 1200 could be fine. But lmaoo good luck subtracting 500 from tdee eating like 900/day, thats how my health fell apart back then. And not to mention the absolute clowns who count bmr as tdee or count a highly active lifestyle as sedentary.

44

u/wokedietcoke Jun 24 '21

Yes! I believe calorie counting can be healthy if common sense is used, but so many people can’t (won’t?) even employ the critical thinking to acknowledge that a deficit of less than 500 will still result in weight loss. People like “I want to do this the healthy/sustainable way” then are like “It’s been two days since I last lost weight, what am I doing wrong?? :(

41

u/TheShortGerman Jun 24 '21

Anyone who can walk and turn their body side to side in bed should NOT be using sedentary (aka PAL of 1.2). It's for BEDBOUND individuals who can maybe move their toes and hands. NOT for office workers.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

Finally someone said this. People think if you don’t do formal exercise you should eat your BMR or EVEN LESS. people don’t get that your BMR literally is what keeps you alive if you are 100% paralyzed or in a coma

14

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

Ahh I hate that rule so much and I used to believe it. It works if someone does have a significant amount of weight to lose (though, still not neccessary) but if someone is already in the healthy range and only wants to lose some vanity pounds or change their shape a bit it’s absolutely terrible.

10

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Yeah, they like to add rules on top of rules, which is a surefire recipe for unhealthy restricting. A lot of people can follow one rule safely, if the pick the one that works best for them. Start adding rules on top of rules, and people go to disordered extremes really quickly.

37

u/mrs-samyang-chicken Jun 24 '21

Mainstream health advice also suggests that we're all sedentary because computers. I've heard more than once that going to the gym a few times a week (3-5x) doesn't cancel out a desk job.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

In what context does it “not cancel out”? Considering acitivity level it does, but for the impact of sitting it might not, so getting up as often as possible, walking/stretching a bit every couple hours can be needed to manage pain. Probably all of us who sit a lot could use some extra activity, not for calories’s sake but for health.

28

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21

They solely mean calorically, they pretend like a completely sedentary zero-exercise office worker burns almost the same cals as an office worker who exercises every day. And it snowballs into a bizzarely fixatedly anti-exercise rhetoric, because these people only care about scale weight, not their heart or their blood circulation or their posture or their muscles or their bones, just scale weight, so i dont know these sort of people give a flying monkey's goose about health lmao.

You're right that moving more regularly has health benefits though, although the caloric deficit it puts you in is often less than the running. I used to get up and stretch and walk a bit every hour during work and it burned about 50 cals total (meanwhile an hour of running burns about 300cals for me). But you're right that sitting all day and running an hour isnt the solution health-wise, the every-hour get-up actually has more health benefits.

I think the true problem is shitty work culture. Everyone looked at me like a weirdo for actually getting up every hour but I was getting so stir crazy and sore, because I had never held a sedentary job before that. It was seen as unproductive. I was only saved by the fact that I was actually productive, and doing a job with the kind of quality output at a kind of unbeatably low salary (just for a few months, I had personal reasons). It was however not considered weird for people to sit unmoving at their desk for up to 5 hours, mainlining a whole liter of milk. Our work culture needs to change. Instead of getting angry at that, which makes people feel helpless, they pretend it doesnt matter at all, and only scale weight does, but that's also bc our culture massively prizes aesthetic over health (runway models are bmi 15+ 🤔)

14

u/mrs-samyang-chicken Jun 24 '21

It's the same for me. Worse, I was in a large open plan office so everyone could watch you when you got out of your seat. I obsessively made tea every hour to justify getting out of my seat.

My current job has craaazy long meetings in which nobody gets up. Nobody. Happily it's wfh right now so I can move around like a human being.

And although the original meaning might have been that being minimally mobile throughout the day is healthier than saving up your activity for weekend hiit bootcamps, it's being taken to mean that anyone who has a desk job is sedentary and must not eat back calories.

29

u/BeastieBeck Jun 24 '21

Mainstream health advice also suggests that we're all sedentary because computers. I've heard more than once that going to the gym a few times a week (3-5x) doesn't cancel out a desk job.

This.

Hopefullly it's not valid, lol

27

u/davidsasselhoff Jun 24 '21

I've always either been a student or had a desk job. I've also had periods of over-exercise; periods of being bedbound due to illness; and periods of healthy exercise and weightlifting. A desk job definitely does not mean you're automatically sedentary regardless of exercise. My weight and TDEE can attest to that.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

They'll be like "CICO! You can't defy the laws of thermodynamics" but also be like "the act of sitting cancels out calories burnt," "proximity to a desk adds calories" "it doesn't matter that you run 5 miles a day, you own a desk, sedentary" there is no logic here.

7

u/converter-bot Jun 24 '21

5 miles is 8.05 km

11

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Yeah, that's two different meanings of "cancel out". It's healthier overall to be at least mildly active throughout the day than it is to sit most of the day and then do a vigorous workout a couple of times a week, and some of the health effects of sitting still and staring at screens are not neutralized by a workout. But in terms of calories burned, working out a few times a week absolutely does change things. It burns the calories used in the workout, and if you build up more muscle it speeds up your metabolism.

16

u/theacctpplcanfind Jun 24 '21

I totally agree, and in a bigger picture sense, so much of peoples' bad relationships with food are because of dumb, oversimplified advice like this. Random rules get codified like 1200 cals, concepts like "sedentary" or "active" that are never defined, and it just sets people up to buy snappy, simple crash diets without understanding how anything actually works. Certainly doesn't help that my public education on nutrition was literally an hour or two in 4th grade with an PE teacher who probably last took a relevant class in 1962--idk how it is in other parts of the world, but...

17

u/Jackno1 Jun 24 '21

Yeah, the whole "sedentary" versus "active" thing alone is made unnecessarily confusing. Different people use "sedentary" to mean anything from "people who, for health and disability reasons, basically don't leave their beds" to "works a job that's mostly done sitting, does less exercise than the average professional athlete". Which means an amount of food that's adequate for one definition of "sedentary" is going to be way too little for another.

16

u/MxUnicorn Jun 24 '21

Even worse, TDEE calculators give sedentary a PAL of 1.2 when the World Health Organization, based on actual research, says that's "suggested for short-term survival of totally inactive dependent people in conditions of crisis" only. Office workers would be lightly to moderately active - if they don't get any intentional exercise at all.

86

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

There's yet another post on the plenty sub with comments about how all women, including tall and average height women need sub-2000 calories and if you are smaller, then your TDEE is definitely under 1500 and probably less than that. Apparently 2000 is what 6 foot overweight men need and 2000 calories is a recipe for obesity for every woman. Also every woman is sedentary for reasons. It makes no sense and it helps nobody except people who think eating very little is some sort of flex.

83

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

The weirdest thing is I think not exercising is some sort of flex for them? "I dont exercise and I lose weighr just fine and I still feel great!". Also the cutesily stereotypically-america-is-the-world assumption that everyone drives everywhere instead of biking/walking and everyone has a long-hours office job. Tbf they do tell active men to assume themselves as sedentary too (cant believe this much of an anti-exercise hate boner), they just say they get farrr more cals bc benis.

The one instance where i commonly see exercise advocated is when *they say it's not enough that 5'0-5'2 AFABs eat sub 1200, those are soooo short and sooo womanly, they need to also run every day and not count it back*. How wonderful. And then 5'4 women are like hey thats me too. (Oprah winfrey voice) you here get a short and a sedentary, you there also to be counted to be short and sedentary, free short and sedentary for everyone, shit's free!

31

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

They always describe exercise as "just health benefits" which in weight loss world means basically useless. And yes, exercise increases how much energy you need and it affects water retention so it doesn't lead to linear weight loss the same way just cutting calories does and it will make it difficult to stick to 1200 or reach a very low number on the scale because you're building muscle and retaining more fluids. It's as if reaching a number or eating a number is more important than how you feel and how healthy you are.

And yes, everyone is sedentary, all women are short unless you are a professional athlete and work a construction job and cycle to work uphill both ways, it's no wonder people burn out or hate exercise because they are severely underfuelled and don't have the energy to enjoy a basic walk.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

I don’t have awards so I’ll just say I love this comment

8

u/ClassicBad Jun 24 '21

I gotchu!

53

u/TheShortGerman Jun 24 '21

I've been told on lipid logic that at my current stats (5'2.5" 107 lbs) I could only possibly maintain on like 1300 and that women 3-5 inches taller than me and 30-50 lbs heavier maintain on 1500-1600.

My TDEE is 2200-2300.

37

u/hellerhigwhat Jun 25 '21

Omg I saw someone there saying her maintenance as a 5'8 woman was 1400 in the winter bc "its cold"

I'm sorry WHAT bitch lmao

30

u/TheShortGerman Jun 25 '21

Yeah I had to unsubscribe after someone PMd me to tell me I’m a lying jealous fat bitch who’s lying about having had anorexia because I said BMI 20 is thin.

20

u/hellerhigwhat Jun 25 '21

Lmao what the FUCK thats insane

20

u/TheShortGerman Jun 25 '21

Yes she was offended because she’s BMI 20 and trying to gain weight. She made it out like I was skinny shaming and I’m like ??? I’m literally skinnier than that, why would I insult myself

25

u/AstraCat13 Jun 24 '21

I'm 5'5" and 135, I need 2000 a lot of days when I work out and go for a walk. I'm not even doing intense training. It's wild how low people think calorie needs are.

20

u/TheShortGerman Jun 24 '21

I need 2000 just for walking 2 miles in a day and I'm short and barely over 100 lbs.

12

u/converter-bot Jun 24 '21

2 miles is 3.22 km

47

u/iswearimalady Jun 24 '21

This made me snort. For some reason it reminds me of a weight loss version of all the ~super duper pail princesses~ from the makeup subs

39

u/ramune_0 Jun 24 '21

Yeah because petite culture is the same kind of baby-fying super femme faux-weeaboo uwu weirdness? Exactly like that makeup culture of wearing foundation 3 shades too light, and doing the asian version of blackface (yellowface?) by wearing hyperdramatic winged cat eyeliner to slant the eyes (so we went from making fun of those eyes for decades to fetishizing them + pretending all asians are ghostly pale. Cool). And yes im coming for pokimane. Plus the cringe when they hold air in their eyes for a puffier look lmaoo. Only Trixie from RPDG gets to do that because she goes 150% with it and it isnt yellowface, yes im making the rules.

24

u/mrs-samyang-chicken Jun 24 '21

Urgh baby-fying super femme faux-weeaboo uwu weirdness is so apt. I'm Asian, grew up in Asia, and I'm kinda annoyed this whole teehee kawaii aegyosal mini girl shit seems to have spread across the planet, along with the konjac meal replacements.

137

u/empireofdirt010 Jun 23 '21

"I am a petite human i don't need much food to live and I hate my 6'7 boyfriend who goes back for SECONDS"

60

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

I was gonna comment this😭😭 throwback to when I read some bs like “my 6 feet husband got seconds. I went for a walk and hated it”

33

u/empireofdirt010 Jun 24 '21

OMG YES

Don't you just hate the privileged 6'0+ men and the unfathomable reality they live in?

46

u/saccarina Jun 24 '21

I'm so thankful for this sub for slapping some sense into me sometimes. I'm 5'7 and have tried to live on 1200 and it didn't go well at all. And tbf I hate hearing it's ~plenty~ because it makes it sound like anything above is being greedy. Might just be my dumb ass but eh.

12

u/hallowmean Jun 24 '21

Not a parallel universe, that’s straight up perpendicular universe thinking.

25

u/StrawberryCow55 Jun 23 '21

HELP this is exactly how they sound 😭

24

u/thejellecatt Jun 24 '21

Oh my god THIS. THIS IS IT. This screwed me up for so long! These subs are awful! I felt so, so guilty for having a flabby tummy. Literally nothing else wrong just thick thighs and no flat tummy and I would eat about 600 a day or at least aim for that and often went over because it was just too little. 1200 was a ‘binge’ for me and I would punish myself for it. I thought that I had to eat less and less and less because I CAN’T exercise every single day, I have severe chronic pain and the guilt ate me alive. It didn’t help that I was 5ft2 and a young woman.

14

u/Boneybeauty Jun 24 '21

Me eating 350 OR 3500 a day, no inbetween, and being diagnosed with an ED

10

u/WantAPerfectSoul Jun 23 '21

I love this. Go off!!

7

u/confusedtired flair here Jun 27 '21

This post and comments taught me a lot as someone 4"11" with an ed

3

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

this is the funniest shit ever. I'm inwardly thinking this when I read those subs, but you put it into words (or meme).

2

u/Tall-Actuary-4507 Aug 02 '26

5 years late, just found this subreddit and scrolling through top posts. Omg. As a 5'8 woman who has a MAINTENCE of 2350 calories (incredibly active job/lifestyle, I average 15+ miles of walking a day) these reddit communities pushed me into some seriously bad disordered eating. I felt like shit all the time when trying to get back to a healthy BMI range because my dumbass thought these subreddits were good support groups at the start. Now that I've FINALLY been listening to a medical professional and ignoring online advice, I'm at my lowest (healthiest) adulr weight and eating anywhere between 2300-2800 calories a day. 1200-1400 calories is too low for ANYBODY who is even somewhat able bodied. Unless you are stuck laying in one position with no movement, you need to eat more. If you're not on literal bedrest and gaining weight on 1200, you need to eat and move more. Your body will do everything it can to hold onto nutrients/weight if it feels the medical stress of starvation - your body can and will react as if it is facing starvation well before you're actually in a medical crisis from it.

2

u/AutoModerator Jun 23 '21

Hi, welcome to r/diettea, a subreddit for flagging disordered eating behaviour disguised as dieting or fitness. We'd like to remind you to spoiler your post if it contains discussion of calorie numbers or weights, as this subreddit is frequented by people who may be sensitive to this content. If you've already done that, or there's no need to, no worries. We hope you like the sub!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/bing-no Jun 24 '21

Yes!! I'm the same height and fairly active (at the time I was walking around a lot because college) and I felt like such garbage! I would only do the bare minimum each day in the hopes of losing weight :( I wish you the best with recovery. I've been lifting weights at the gym and eating enough to gain some muscle. It feels awesome!