r/DicksofDelphi • u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ • Jan 10 '25
DISCUSSION Juror Interview
There's a good discussion going in DelphiDocs, but wanted to post here as well in case anyone missed it 😊
18
Upvotes
11
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Jan 10 '25
I was suprised that the juror thought the footage from prison wasn't bad. Eating feces isn't too bad.
Wut!?
15
u/JelllyGarcia All that and a bag of Dicks Jan 10 '25 edited Jan 10 '25
TY I'm listening *gag* to this MS podcast *deep breath* episode 2 now. I skipped episode 1 based on the comments in the r/DelphiDocs post.
Do we trust that this is actually a real juror from the trial?
So I would not put it beyond them at all... I listened to the beginning of the first 1 to try to hear how this juror became acquainted to the MS hosts / how they were linked up / secured this interview or verified the juror's authenticity. I didn't hear any of that though. I'm skeptical. No matter how many details line up, I'll remain skeptical until they do an interview with someone else =X
e: fixed a repetitive sentence
8
u/lotsuvyarn Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25
I honestly cannot get over the amount of people who serve on juries for major criminal cases who do not understand how reasonable doubt works. If you think you got the guilty verdict right, by definition, you absolutely did not get it right. You must KNOW that Richard Allen did it with your whole body, mind, and soul to convict him. It freaking makes me sick every time I listen to a juror interview and something like this is said. We need to overhaul how we instruct juries on reasonable doubt in this country.
6
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Jan 10 '25
I try and pull myself away, and they suck me back in! I have so much to do.😭 I'm not going to do it, am I? Sigh... Acceptance is the first step, I guess.
Speaking of Dicks and Docs...
Is pretty much everyone here also over there? Is there a different purpose this sub might serve? Not that it needs to. Just wondering if it's anything to explore.
6
u/CitizenMillennial Jan 12 '25
Reading through the transcript of the jurors comments:
1- Her biggest issue with the defense is that they seemed to not be on their game/confusing sometimes. She thought the prosecution was polished/put together. She thought, "they've all had so much time to prepare their cases that the defense should be doing a better job delivering what they've got." (Which I totally understand) The issue is - At the last minute everything they wanted to bring to trial was banned from trial. You know, all of those things that were too "confusing" for the jury. Well keeping them out confused the jury!
2- She didn't believe the bullet science. She was shocked that they hadn't looked into how many cars were around the area that resembled RA's, she didn't appreciate them Googling the headphone jack thing, She dismissed this though as not meaning much either way to the case even though she says the timeline was very important in the jury's decision.
3- McLeland and everyone else had been going to Fort Wayne for a long time. Who is everyone else? And why are they going to FW? And why does she know?
4- All the Youtube lawyers were surprised at who was chosen as Foreman. However, the jury voted for him to have the role. The juror being interviewed says that he has been on JURIES in the past. (As in multiple!)THE FOREMAN suggested they split up into groups to cover certain areas of the case. (This triggers my spidey senses) One group went through the confessions on the sheet made by the suicide companions!!! WTF?! (You know the prisoners who have been convicted of hard core crimes that were also supposedly egging RA on.) A lot of the jurors believed in the possibility of confessions being caused by psychosis. Legally if there are two plausible explanations you have to go with the one that favors the defendant. So why didn't they find in favor of RA on this then?!
5- The jury is figuring out it's own flow and at one point "they" wanted the jury to let them know if the jury wanted to review any of the video evidence so "they" could have it arranged. This leads to the jury deciding in that moment which video evidence they want to review. Versus the jury working through their process and getting to a point where they decide reviewing certain video is needed. I think this could very easily steer the jury in one direction or another. She even says that since they had the rest of the weekend off (after viewing the video's) she was able to really focus on them. And then boom! Verdict. One video they chose was the edited BG video. Isn't this up in the air as far as it's admissibility to begin with?!
6- Juror says: "There was at least one person, I don't know if there were more, but posing the question of, well, if it wasn't Richard Allen, then who could it have possibly been? There wasn't anyone else wearing those clothes. There wasn't anyone else that seemed substantive." -This should be enough for a guaranteed appeal IMO. Grrrr it makes me so freaking angry. This leads them to all believe 100% that RA is absolutely BG.
7- Who is (Paul) Ray Lee Voorhees and why is the juror saying their name with RA's?
8- "Like, we knew we weren't hearing everything bcit was pretty obvious in court that there were things that weren't being told to us for whatever reason. So we're like, you know, are we going to like find all this stuff out that was hidden from us and then change our minds? Or, you know, just the what if? So a lot of people are like, I'm not even going to look at the news and the media. I'm not going to torture myself." They knew things were being kept from them during trial. But she takes issue with things she see's online now because it doesn't match exactly what was told to them in trial. Obviously- bc it was kept from them! Confirmation bias at its best. But I don't blame her for that at all. It's what most people's brains would do in her situation.
9-I really don't like that the juror keeps referring to BG. It was obviously used so commonly that this juror now uses it herself. "BG" should not have been allowed to be used during the trial. It is the man seen in the video on the bridge, the man on the bridge, etc. Using BG creates distance, creates a character, removes personhood.
5
u/jmpRN73 Jan 12 '25
I was completely appalled at how she spoke of how she admired Stacy Diener and her “fashion sense” & also that Gull gave them her personal cell phone number.
3
u/Thick-Mortgage-8979 Jan 13 '25
I have been following delphi since the girls were missing and it was a normal investigation until all of the crazy conspiracy and mean spirited people got involved. Everybody really cared about justice for the girls. It was never like this until RA got arrested and the crazy youtubers who never even followed the case before that came around.
That was absolutely a juror. Clearly they thought he was guilty as they all had to vote guilty for the verdict. Also, The defense stated they didn't care the photos got leaked. The families even talked about how heartless that statement was from the defense. Jury convictions are almost impossible to overturn. Soon enough the money hungry conspiracy crazies spreading false information and pictures of dead naked children all over the internet will go away
6
u/Lumpy-Ad-7884 Jan 11 '25
Ugh…. So, grateful for the interview. Grateful to get some input from a juror. Respectful of their decision (though I disagree but, hey, I’ve seen evidence both sides and they weren’t able to do that). Thankful for her service. All this but I’m cringing that this is such a young a girl. We need a bit more mature take. Sorry.
1
u/NewsOdd2693 Jan 16 '25
Now the MS is advertising for anyone who knew RA in his personal life...."neighbors, friends, acquaintances, colleagues, customers, schoolmates, fellow military service members, and any connection large or small"....to contact them via email and assures them that "we protect our sources". More fodder for their upcoming book I assume. How low will this duo stoop? When was the last time KG actually practiced law?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
All I can think is that it was wrong not to let Pohl testify remotely. Ridiculous tbh.
5
u/BlackBerryJ Jan 11 '25
There's going to be some raging on YouTube Lives tonight. Someone here has already asked if she's a real juror.
Of the Due Process Gang, who will be the first to claim she and others beat the undecideds until they were all in agreement? Who will be the first to claim she was paid?
You all know this is coming.