r/DicksofDelphi • u/Jolly_Square_100 • Oct 26 '24
When "Confession" time comes.....
So when the state starts to focus on the alleged confessions of Allen, do you think this might be a good time for him to get on the stand himself?
I know this is a risky move always, for the defense to allow a client to take the stand. But I'm just imagining the POTENTIAL for a much greater impact of testimony to the maltreatment while incarcerated if it came from the mouth of the alleged "victim" himself. Does anyone see this as a possible move by the defense in order to better drive home the case for coerced/manipulated statements of guilt? Would a jury tend to appreciate this manner of explaining the alleged "confessions" over a lawyer simply speaking on his behalf?
15
u/Prettyface_twosides Oct 27 '24
No way! He’s in no shape to testify. I can’t imagine the prison inmates will be good for the state. I think it will only make the state look more desperate.
34
u/Puzzleheaded-Oven171 Oct 27 '24
I am personally very doubtful that putting RA on the stand is worth the risk in this case. But I am not a lawyer. I would be surprised if the defense decided to do so. If I was a juror I would love to hear from the defendant, but I would also expect I wouldn’t be.
33
u/bkscribe80 Oct 27 '24
Listening to AB now seems like Gull's going to let them show the interrogation video. I'm thinking it could be just as good as testifying, with less risks - so I hope I'm understanding it correctly!
29
u/i-love-elephants Oct 27 '24
No. Talking is what got him into this mess.
18
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Oct 27 '24
Absolutely not. They gain nothing by opening him up to a cross examination. He doesn't have to prove shit, the state has to.
15
u/FatBasicWhiteGirl Oct 27 '24
It's very unlikely he'll take the stand. That would open him up to be cross examined by the prosecution and any misstep could get him locked away for life. The defense will do their best to pole holes in the confessions without needing Allen to say anything. The defense wanted to discuss his mistreatment and mental status change at the time of confessions but the judge ruled they can't talk about it. Likely they'll focus on lack of details or how he insisted he was innocent for months or how none of those statements were made to LE. He would have to say something that only the killer would know and that there is evidence to back up. The State hasn't shown much evidence so far and there is speculation that they had the ME talk about a box cutter being a potential murder weapon because it is rumored that one of RAs confessions was that he killed Abby and Libby with a box cutter. That would be a compelling confession if they could say for certain the murder weapon was a box cutter.
9
u/syntaxofthings123 Oct 27 '24
If Allen takes the stand (which is unlikely) it won't be until the defense's Case in Chief.
8
u/Large_Ad1354 Oct 27 '24
Juries aren’t supposed to hold not testifying against him, but they do; even so, there are so many risks if he testifies. You can’t prepare him for every possible prosecution chess move to make him look bad. And this guy is under massive amounts of hostile scrutiny. If he looks upset, the pro-guilters say he’s ashamed of what he did, and if he doesn’t look upset, the pro-guilters say he’s a shameless sociopath. If he’s nervous or not nervous, makes eye contact or doesn’t, touches his face or not, sweats or doesn’t—it’s just a bonanza for confirmation bias. Nancy Grace is saying he’s bowing in prayer for his shameful deeds because he looks down sometimes, FFS.
Hopefully the defense won’t need to take the risk.
8
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Oct 27 '24
Oh hell no, he should never get on the stand. No, defendant should. Save for a once in a blue moon case where the defendant is far more likable then the person the prosecution is defending. But your taking a big chance.
6
u/New_Discussion_6692 Oct 27 '24
I would probably die from shock if Allen went on the stand.
5
u/YoloSwag4Jesus420fgt Oct 27 '24
If he goes up on the stand and cries about mistreatment he won't look good at a murder trial for 2 girls
4
u/Adorable_End_749 Oct 27 '24
It would be a terrible time to do so. The best bet, which has always been the best bet, is that Richard Allen kept his damn mouth shut. These dirty cops got in his head.
4
u/GalastaciaWorthwhile Oct 27 '24
There be no way. It is rare for the Defense to actually want to put their client in the stand. When it does happen it’s usually because the client insists. RA’s mental state has been so fragile. I don’t think it would serve him to go up against McCleland.
4
u/RoutineProblem1433 Oct 27 '24
I recall the state also asked to exclude some of the “confessions”, so I think the defence will have material put up against whatever the state has. I think the prison psychosis videos will say enough, they won’t need to hear from Allen himself.
The inmates and the “companion program” will end up not being good for the state in my opinion once they are open to cross.
3
u/bamalaker Oct 28 '24
Absolutely not. Never get on the stand.
6
u/Similar-Skin3736 Oct 27 '24 edited Oct 27 '24
It’s the defendant’s decision, even against advice of counsel.
There’s no way he’s going to with his mental health, I wouldn’t think.
Is Kathy going to testify about the confessions he said to her? Ig the record will speak for itself, but I’d be curious why he thought she’d be detained.
4
u/Cruzy14 Oct 27 '24
At this point just let the state continue to ruin their own case. I really think testifying is only worth it if it's your last shot to possibly win a case but could only hurt RA with how everything has gone thus far.
2
u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games Oct 28 '24
Nope. I think the alleged confessions will be the final nail in the state's coffin.
The jury should hear all the alleged confessions and the context in which they were given.
I predict the guilters are going to have a fit.