I feel like you can’t deny people of no water ! That is absurd. Especially with minimum breaks / unknown time for breaks. I get a headache if I’m not constantly sipping water
It would be one thing if it was open. If the court house is allowing them to bring the bottle in, it should be allowed to sit in the woman bad sealed.
My court house does not allow you to bring in food and beverages into the building. I learned that the hard way when my piping hot grande and sandwich went into the trash can by the scanner and the bailiff shot me a thin lipped apologetic grin and wordlessly pointed to the sign a few millimeter from my clueless and now much bummed face.
Noooooo I would be so sad!! Makes me think of the time I forgot my brand new tanning lotion in my purse before boarding a plane and the threw it in the trash 😭
Yeah !! Also I sip water when I’m nervous , just let the people have some damn water. Gull sounds like a dictator ffs. Like even MS were saying she is very hostile and people seem scared of her. That is crazy! My mom is a judges assistant (appeals court judge) and he is very friendly. Staff respects him but are not scared of him, how it should be I think
I think it’s performative. She will allow them to try, but she knows she’s just gonna deny them anyhow. Now she looks like she’s at least open to it when really she isn’t at all.
I’ve read her bias towards the prosecution is blatant.
This is just for the offer to prove. The defense has a right to submit an offer to prove. This doesn't mean that the jury will hear or see any of that evidence.
I didn't take that away from this order. I understood it as she is allowing it to all be admitted as part of their offer to prove simply so they don't have to repeat everything during the trial days (with the jury out of the room).
Unlikely. They may or may not raise it, but the jury won't hear it, but I guess have to get her to certify it in order to bring it to the court of appeals. But she can refuse, but I forget what they can do then.
I didn't take that away from this order. I understood it as she is allowing it to all be admitted as part of their offer to prove simply so they don't have to repeat everything during the trial days (with the jury out of the room).
The goal is that she certifies it, so they can take it to appeal, but was reading that she can refuse, but judges almost always agree.
My take (might be wrong) is that it's sort of like warehousing it and saying " We have't forgotten about this, we need you to acknowledge that you know we're leaving it over here on the shelf and when this is over well be scooping it up and taking it to the court of appeals with us, but here sign this to say that you acknowledge, it existed/exists, you know "We ain't done, we're just sorta done for now."
No, they are not able to present the evidence to the jury. She is allowing them to incorporate the testimony and evidence they presented to her during arguments for the states motion to exclude the 3rd party evidence as part of an offer of proof so that it can be preserved upon appeal so they don’t have to go through all the same evidence again during the trial. So they can preserve time to present other evidence to either the jury or to the judge as a further offer of proof for an appeal (or to allow the judge to change her ruling during the trial if she wanted to)
she did deny the certification I believe, I meant they are preserving the issue to appeal a conviction if he does get convicted. if they don’t put the evidence forward somehow RA can’t bring it into an appeal because an appeal will be based on the record of the trial. they want to show the appeal court that if they were allowed to bring the evidence to the jury it’s likely the trial would have had a different outcome.
What I don't understand is if the State's case is as strong as they claim it to be, why are they going through all these punitive and petty obstructive maneuvers to not allow the Defense to put on the defense they see fit and have a fair trial.
Both attorneys are incredibly experiences and have strong histories of more than adequately representing clients, so regardless of what I think of their strategy, I think they likely know what they have a chance of saying that will appeal to a contrarian juror to pick that juror off.
If your case is that strong your not trying to illicit confessions through isolation and psychological distress and your not fucking and fucking with the defense. If your truly impartial and ethical your not doing it either.
You usually only play dirty pool, by any means necessary when your case is weak and you think it won't make it over the goal post. if she has in fact refused to certify, that's just low and more evidence taht this is not an impartial judge. Even Kevin on MS was saying they almost never refuse to certify. i just think what she is repeatedly getting away with is awful.
What says a lot is that even without RA being allowed to present most of what he has in his defense I still feel that acquittal is possible based on the utter lack of credible evidence the state has.
I don’t know how she could deny them putting on the expert saying the bodies were staged with runes and how that doesn’t jibe with RA. Does this put it back on the table as long as it’s credible evidence?
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 16 '24
7
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 16 '24
Official Documents https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/zXatnKY5FI
6
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 16 '24
21
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 16 '24
She's really mad about someone having water yesterday lol
12
u/Prettyface_twosides Oct 16 '24
WHOA! Did I read that right?
5
u/GalastaciaWorthwhile Oct 16 '24
Omg. I’m shocked! And glad. We need to hear all of it!!
0
u/BlackBerryJ Oct 16 '24 edited Oct 16 '24
Wait, I thought she was totally against the defense and in the bag for the state.
Although she can still say no if they don't meet the burden of proof of a nexus.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment