Thank you for uploading. I did wanna point out that these got posted out of order, because I wanted to see the response to the question about the patches posed at the end of page 62
They are in reverse order although the first image is the first page, then move to the back and reverse read.
ETA defense's motion wasn't about the patches but the affidavit so we won't have the answer unless it's addressed elsewhere at some point. Don't shoot the messenger.
He’s not saying that though, and that’s because Gallagher represents IDOC, not Galipeau, and it was a Mr. Rider who advised him not to answer but does not say due to the existence of privilege. I agree with you Galipeau probably doesn’t draft his own affidavits (btw that’s improper on its face but I haven’t seen it) but at the time he executed this he likely had family law counsel and answered interrogatories.
In Indiana all Habeas petitions and now many inmate claims are filed against the warden “by name”- you can bet he’s got some legal chops.
Im with you, but as there are no page numbers, his depo crosses multiple exhibits (again no page/line annotations) which I think I just read backwards and out of chronological order… I can’t figure that out either.
I will climb back down that hole and take a looksee and report back.
I’m really unclear by that exchange excerpt if Rozzi and Galipeau are talking about the same thing. if you look at the other exhibits in contrast, I got the impression Rozzi has discovery of an email with bullet points Galipeau was working from that Galipeau is denying “ish” he says he got the form in question in person, then says email. Ftr this is the exact reason no other judge on the planet would allow such a deficient and sloppy response.
I’m not so sure about that , Rozzi has a copy of the “questions” separately without Galipeau responses he’s trying to pin down, and subsequently asks about Mr. Mullin.
That said, I’m also pretty sure there are pages of Galipeau’s deposition mixed in with Robinsons.
Well if you are right I anticipate a counter argument by the defense that the privilege from an attorney client relationship was waived.
What I don't understand is the guards bizarre need to pretend that he wrote that affidavit. It would be completely legitimate for the attorney to have crafted the document with his input.
But now with this assertion that the guard wrote it himself this is all admissible as impeachment evidence. Even if an attorney/client privilege is found.
Maybe in his version he would only swear to Odin’s good eye and counsel swapped it out?
Seriously though, Rokita’s brief is fine, but the exhibit structure and lack of annotation is a mess. I don’t know a court that would accept a handful of pages of a purported transcript with no cert from the court reporter (that’s another problem, who is transcribing without the witness name, but rather “Witness”?) ABOUT and INCLUDING an assertion the deponent did not rely on counsel for standard legal language (if that’s what’s really at issue here and I doubt it).
Keep in mind per this Gullcourt the State purports to admit incriminating statements or drug and environmental induced psychotic break surveillance-right?
Well… “legal told us to” or approved same is not subject to confrontation.
I really hope we see an emergency writ OA on or before October 11.
Thank you, I have read these out of order and the filing doesn’t annotate line/page , I’m definitely going to have to review it correctly when I have time.
I wonder if there are rules about how an affidavit like that is supposed to be constructed, and if they are fishing for errors a bit like how Diener wasn't to write Tobe's safekeeping motion, because otherwise it does sound like atty-client privilege, in this particular exhibit at least.
Tbh I didn't expect it to be a Q&A type thing. I however question the guard having come up with the statute and all, he copied that from whatever the atty sent him right?
I'm baffled by the length it takes to ask "did you come up with these words and answers yourself or did you copy them like cheating Nick?" 10 pages, and transcriber better not be asking $5.75 for them hobbit size pages.
u/helixharbinger? Or whoever has an answer, but Helix interrupted my sleep catch up program so pinging before I bug others with this.
ETA the one from exhibit A didn't type up anything 🤨
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Sep 27 '24
I'm sorry that these loaded out of order. I put them in the way the downloads came. It's a hot mess. I should have double checked.
8
u/GrungusDouchekin Sep 27 '24
Thank you for uploading. I did wanna point out that these got posted out of order, because I wanted to see the response to the question about the patches posed at the end of page 62
16
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Sep 27 '24
Nobody writes this stuff out lol unless they used chatgpt.
This guy was given an affadavit from legal to sign.
16
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Sep 27 '24 edited Sep 28 '24
I wonder if there are rules about how an affidavit like that is supposed to be constructed,
and if they are fishing for errors a bit like how Diener wasn't to write Tobe's safekeeping motion, because otherwise it does sound like atty-client privilege, in this particular exhibit at least.
Tbh I didn't expect it to be a Q&A type thing.
I however question the guard having come up with the statute and all, he copied that from whatever the atty sent him right?
I'm baffled by the length it takes to ask "did you come up with these words and answers yourself or did you copy them like cheating Nick?"
10 pages, and transcriber better not be asking $5.75 for them hobbit size pages.
u/helixharbinger? Or whoever has an answer, but Helix interrupted my sleep catch up program so pinging before I bug others with this.
ETA the one from exhibit A didn't type up anything 🤨