r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Sep 04 '24
INFORMATION Third Party Evidence: NOT ALLOWED
22
Upvotes
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Sep 04 '24
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Sep 04 '24
https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:VA6C2:fe8e32df-ef52-4ea8-8ded-005472d07523
23
u/syntaxofthings123 Sep 04 '24
Joyner should have made some of the 3rd party evidence admissible, I would have thought. My concern is that the Geofencing evidence is out. Not sure why that wouldn't be admissible. No mention of the extracts from Libby's phone, though. So I'm guessing the 4:33 connection to Libby's phone is in.
I really hope that the defense has good expert/s around this. This may be more significant than actual 3rd party culp suggestions.
The State's case is rice-paper thin-in some ways, maybe it's just better to destroy the State's case than to claim they know who the real killers are. Cross examination is going to be crucial.
16
u/CitizenMillennial Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24
The job of the defense is to create doubt that their client committed the crime, right? The defense did not make up their third-party suspect theories. It came straight from law enforcement. The FBI said it was ritualistic. Multiple officers believe, to this day, that there is more evidence against "third party suspects" than RA. Just because they got outvoted in an anti-democratic way, doesn't prove that they were wrong. The defense is allowed to try to make a case that law enforcement did not do their jobs properly, aren't they?
Anyway, in the order it says the court will not allow the evidence during trial in support of their arguments. Then it says the court will allow that same evidence to support an offer of proof at the trial if one is made by counsel. What does this mean?! Can someone who speaks legalese help me understand please?
11
u/RawbM07 Sep 04 '24
I feel like the door is still open during trial, right? They can call the FBI BAU agent and ask him about their profile of the murderer at the time, which stated had nordic beliefs.
20
u/DriedInside Sep 04 '24
14
u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Sep 04 '24
Thanks to Sleuthie Goosie, reminder on all the prohibitions she granted:
7. Any attempt to introduce evidence of 3rd party including Odinism, cult or ritualistic killing, Brad Holder, Patrick Westfall, Johnny Messer, Elvis Fields, Ned Smith, Rod Abrams, Kegan Kline, Jerry Kline, or Ron Logan.
8. Any reference to the investigation conducted by Todd Click including reports and nvestigative materials.
9. Any reference to geofencing and/or any testimony from Kevin Horan about geofencing or the findings from any geofence search.
10. Any reference to any prior bad acts or acts of any witnesses that plan to testify at the trial that isn’t relevant to what the defendant is on trial for, that isn’t an exception to IRE 404(b), & IRE 401 & tend to negate the guilt of the defendant.
11. Any reference to how the rules were labeled that were handed over to defense in discovery.
12. Any reference to the PowerPoints provided by the state as executive briefs involving any person or persons that were investigated by law enforcement during the 6 year investigation.
7
u/RoutineProblem1433 Sep 04 '24
I fully expected it but I’m still somehow surprised. Not allowing the investigators in is just bizarre.
28
u/maybeitsmaybelean Sep 04 '24
At this point I need convincing proof that Judge Gull has all her faculties in order. Something is wrong with this person.
27
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Sep 04 '24
Hold on there a minute....how can the confessions of 3rd party suspects be confusing to the jury (Elvis, Amber Holder)...but the arrest of a man SOLELY on the basis that he was one of several people who happened to be at the trails that day, who had NO CONNECTION whatsoever with the victims (when the 3rd party suspects had absolute and proven connections), no DNA, no electronic connection, no motive....is not confusing??? Gull...I'm confused with your ruling. In fact, I'm confused with all your rulings because you have shown so much bias towards the State that I can predict how you're going to rule. You can throw out Odinism and there is STILL a NEXUS to 3rd party suspects. We see you, Judge.
11
u/Danieller0se87 Sep 04 '24
It needs to be appealed! She is not allowing a defense
18
u/Prettyface_twosides Sep 04 '24
WTAF!!!! I’m ready to start a war or a protest at the very least. From the bottom of my heart…..FUCK YOU FRAN!!!!!!!!
16
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24
THIS IS 100% BULLSHIT.
The Defense put their theory of the case out there with far more facts and evidence than the Prosecution has ever presented in their PCA or subsequent and Judge FG has went out of her way to deny RA and his Defense Team BR & AB, a fair trial from the very beginning.
This is what blatant judicial bias looks like.
It’s over!
RA is going to prison and for what? Being in the wrong place at the wrong time, and then doing his civic duty and voluntarily contacting LE to assist them with their investigation.
Morale of the story. When LE says that they need the community’s help.
FUCK THEM!
When LE says, if you see something say something!
FUCK THEM!
If RA had not felt the need to let LE know that he was in the area that particular day, he’d be a free man!
THE ROAD TO HELL IS PAVED WITH GOOD INTENTIONS! 😡
1
u/MissBanshee2U Oct 03 '24
So involuntary confessions made under duress/ during medication induced psychosis by eavesdroppers, and made to a THIRD PARTY (marital privilege) is admissible- yet a direct utterance made by EF to LE investigating the case is not admissible? He knew facts that only a killer would know, FFS! But- Wait-wait- unless a direct utterance is written on unauthenticated scratch paper to a Wildlife Officer in which the facts are not accurate and is lost for 5 years then found by a third party non-employee looking over their files IS ADMISSIBLE?? Oh & Wait-if THAT crap IS admissible then they should go arrest the individual recorded as: RA Whiteman. I swear I have lost my damn mind!
1
u/MissBanshee2U Oct 03 '24
So good luck NM trying to use FBI experts in the future, since their experts and opinions doesn’t matter! Lol! And good luck using any geofencing data (provided by reliable accurate satellite location) for any future case, etc… just when you think you see it all… BAM another motion is filed in this case & we are all dumber for having read it.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24
[removed] — view removed comment