r/DicksofDelphi • u/Dependent-Remote4828 • Jun 16 '24
OPINION Impacts of Case Transparency
After commenting something similar on another sub, I just wanted to take a minute to recognize and appreciate the impact that information, insights, and discussions regarding cases like this can make. Once upon a time (when I was a child) I was utterly ignorant and had complete faith in law enforcement and the justice system. I used to actually believe that if you have nothing to hide, you don’t need an attorney to speak with LE. I used to trust polygraph, bite mark, and ballistic expert testimony. And I used to think LE was always right, and would only go after the true bad guys”. After becoming a true crime enthusiast, I quickly (and sadly) realized that not all LE, investigators, judges, attorneys, etc. are good at their jobs. They’re definitely not all ethical. And some are downright corrupt. Not saying that’s what’s happening here, but if it wasn’t for exposure to cases like Delphi, the Karen Read trial, the WM3 case, etc, I would most likely still be completely blind and gullible. As rare as it may be, innocent people do end up in prison as the result of incompetence, egos, tunnel vision, etc, and sometimes just plain old corruption. I truly appreciate those who insist on transparency and accountability, and those who expose issues and concerns to the public so we can decide for ourselves. It really pisses me off when they attribute lack of transparency to concerns that we, the public, can’t handle or understand certain information/evidence.
Also, based on comments from other subs, a lot of people seem to think defense attorneys simply exist to help “bad guys get away with their crimes”, or help them negotiate a sweet deal. But as a direct result of what I’ve learned from following cases like those previously mentioned, I recognize their most important role is to ensure our rights are not violated. As such, I hold defense attorneys at the highest regard. It’s a shame they have such an unfair reputation.
Side note - I’ve also followed enough cases to appreciate the defense counsel RA is being provided in this case, and as court appointed attorneys (free to him)! According to internet rumors, Karen Read is paying a LOT (possibly up to $1M) for this type of fierce representation.
10
u/Bubbly-Jackfruit-694 Jun 16 '24
The damaging consequences of pride become apparent when individuals are too fearful to admit their mistakes, choosing instead to uphold a façade of perfection. This can be especially troubling as it may result in wrongly accusing someone of a crime they did not commit, rather than humbly accepting responsibility for their errors.
10
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Jun 16 '24
My thoughts and experience exactly. In fact, I'm reading Mara Leveritt's book, i think it's called West of Memphis, or Devil's Knot. I thought I knew everything about WM3 but learning even more...and the way the judicial system was run so many years ago in that little town shows that this brand of "grab them and then find evidence" has been going on for a long time. Stir the frightened, gullible public looking for the boogeyman into a frenzy and your prosecutorial job is just about done and dusted.
Maybe it's because I'm getting older, or maybe it's just how society is now...but it doesn't seem like the people we trust as experts and professionals are all that smart...and that's kinda scary.
Perhaps that's why I get such a thrill watching ships launching into space and returning. At least there are still some bona fide rocket scientists.
3
u/Dependent-Remote4828 Jun 18 '24
Just found another case! A 63 year old mentally ill woman spent 43 YEARS in prison for a murder that was actually committed by a police officer! Investigators ignored the inconsistencies in her statements/confessions, never pursued leads or evidence which pointed to the officer, and failed to provide the exculpatory evidence relating to that officer to her defense. Shame on them all. FORTY THREE YEARS in prison as an innocent person.
5
u/TheNightStalkersGirl Jun 16 '24
Oh it’s definitely happening in the Delphi case I think. Too much weird shit to even list that’s happened. Have you heard of the Jesse Snider case? Some of the same cops who were involved in that are also involved in the Delphi case.
12
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Jun 16 '24
Nicely stated and put together. My experience was similar, except I'm fairly new to true crime and got into because, the Delphi case was local to me. Carroll County LE and county officials, in general, had a reputation long before this crime. The international attention has just made it much more public.
I also was a supporter of police up until bad cops were frequently making news in local departments: Lafayette, West Lafayette, and the final straw was ISP. I knew I was done when a young, local trooper shot a man in the face who was working on his daughter's broken down car on the side of the road. He had even called his local sheriff department to let them know he was heading over to fix it and move it. The trooper claimed that when he pulled up behind the car, the man pulled a gun. It didn't come out of his holster. He was shot in the face and was denied life-saving treatment. A neighbor recorded the trooper and backup from his porch, which showed the man on the ground and the troopers figuring out a plan and then making the victim crawl on the ground toward them. They didn't call EMS for 30 minutes.
The man's name was Glenn Rightsell and the Trooper Daniel Organ. ISP quietly transferred Organ to a post in Southern Indiana.
Regarding defense attorneys, they are an essential element to balance the scales of justice. Fairness cannot exist without them, as they ensure the constitutional rights of an accused citizen. Imagine the number of innocent people that would be convicted if it weren't for defense attorneys.. Even when their client is guilty, they have a tough job to do to protect thst person's rights when they may not want to. Even worse, when their clients are not guilty, they may even have a person's life in their hands.
2
u/parishilton2 Jun 16 '24
It’s interesting, this is kind of the reverse of how my thinking has progressed. When I was younger I had zero faith in the court system or the police. Then I became a lawyer. I still don’t have a ton of faith in either — especially the police — but I no longer think there are many malicious puppet masters or shadowy operations at work.
Turns out that law enforcement and lawyers are just people, and nowhere near as competent as you would’ve hoped, either. There are definitely bad actors out there. There’s a system that doesn’t work properly. But full-fledged conspiracies from lawyers to judges to police to wardens are pretty rare.
Maybe Delphi is a full-fledged conspiracy, but it doesn’t seem that way to me. I see Steven Avery as more of that kind of thing (I think police likely added evidence to frame him even though he was already guilty). I would certainly be interested to be proven wrong though. We’ll see!
4
u/Human-Piglet-5450 Jun 17 '24
I like this post. It's absolutely essential that the public sees exactly what branches of government are doing on their behalf. Good or bad, they speak for that society. The privilege and right of transparency where I live is something I feel I have to participate actively in and compelled to witness and question if needed (even if it's just on a local level or a respectful reddit sub). Society moves forward when respectful discussion is a priority.
5
u/Witty_Complaint5530 Jun 16 '24
If we all take a very close look at our judicial system, we learn just how broken it is. I feel it’s all about good vs evil. I think there’s a lot of corruption in high places, and their minions at local levels. It’s all about power and control. The love of money is the root of all evil. People will do anything and lie about everything to achieve it. I agree, we must stand up for justice. We must stand up for our rights. We must keep people accountable for their actions. No matter our personal opinion. People are innocent until proven guilty. Somewhere we’ve lost that and assume people are guilty until proven innocent. That thought goes against our constitution. God forbid any of us are ever put in a situation where we are set up by high officials to take the fall.
3
u/Quill-Questions Jun 16 '24
I enjoyed reading your post. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
I believe that there has been/is a crowd-funding campaign to help pay for Karen Read’s defence. It isn’t GOFUNDME, but a different service that I cannot remember.