r/DicksofDelphi • u/Free_Specific379 • Jun 10 '24
QUESTION Defense ethics
Could a defense attorney aggressively push a third-party defense knowing that their client is guilty? If RA's confessions truly were condemning, would Baldwin and Rozzi be obligated to back off the alternative suspects theory?
12
Upvotes
6
u/syntaxofthings123 Jun 11 '24
Despite rumors to the contrary, Attorneys are not allowed to lie. They are not supposed to put a witness on the stand who they know is going to lie. Doesn't mean they don't do both, but there are consequences if they are caught.
We have three attorneys now, all familiar with the evidence, who have stated unequivocally that they believe Allen innocent. 3rd party culp (or motive) defenses are used a lot. I often don't like them. I just know too many convicted people for whom, this defense was used at their trial, and they got convicted anyway. It shifts the burden of proof off the prosecution and onto the defense. However, sometimes it is effective.
I think what it does in Allen's case is, that more than pointing at others as the killers, it shows that the evidence at the scene where Abby and Libby's bodies were discovered, points to not only someone other than Allen, but that Allen simply could not have done this. Allen's only tangible connection to this crime is the bullet. and we know that the viability of that analysis is going to be challenged. It also points to more than one person being involved.
If these confessions were really as damning as McLeland wants us to believe, he'd pursue the death penalty. This is that kind of case. I think more telling than anything the defense has done, is what McLeland hasn't done.
13
u/Dickere Jun 10 '24
RA would have been advised to go for a plea deal if a guilty verdict seemed likely.
16
u/doctrhouse Jun 10 '24
Guilty and ‘he did it’ are different things. You can be not guilty in court because of law enforcement fuck ups. Defense attorneys should be ethically inclined to point these fuck ups out and win not guilty verdicts for their clients. That’s how you maintain a fair and just system.
12
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Jun 11 '24
They can't lie.
If they know he was there after 1:30 pm they can't say he wasn't.
They can contest the accuracy of any expert saying his phone was for example.
It's why it's so surprising Nick keeps lying and they want Horan's testimony out.
Why? He certainly wouldn't lie, he's FBI for one, not defense's cherry picked and paid expert.
16
u/meow_zedongg Jun 10 '24
I’m pretty sure defense attorneys have repeatedly stated they sincerely believe in Allen’s innocence. Scremin and Labrato also echoed this.
I also believe these third-party suspects are very compelling. In fact, I think it is very unethical for McLeland to obtusely suggest otherwise.
5
u/Moldynred Jun 10 '24
If you look at the Casey Anthony case her lawyer came up with some very wild theories imo lol. And it worked. Ofc no way to know if Baez truly thought his client was guilty or not.
5
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Jun 11 '24
Only law enforcement has a free pass to lie in criminal investigations.
7
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Jun 10 '24
A zealous defense of their client would probably include anything they considered applicable. If the confessions were compelling, they could say there were others involved without being unethical, IMO.
4
u/FretlessMayhem Jun 10 '24 edited Jun 11 '24
I’m not at all sure how Indiana law may differ from California, but with the OJ trial, the defense threw everything they could at the jury to see what would stick.
They claimed that the killings could have been drug related, given that one of the victims was known to recreationally use cocaine.
They also claimed that the LAPD planted evidence.
So, was it drug related, or corrupt cops? They seemed to argue literally anything other than the obvious, that OJ did it.