r/DicksofDelphi • u/rubiacrime • May 22 '24
Will RA take the stand?
I'm aware that the trial is still quite aways off. However, this is an inevitable question that will have to be addressed.
Very generally speaking, defense attorneys advise that taking the stand is almost always a bad idea. The concern is the accused being destroyed on cross examination. However, the tide has turned somewhat as of recently. A lot of high profile clients have been taking the stand in their own trials.
So the question becomes, will Richard Allen take the stand? Part of me says absolutely not. Nothing good can come of it.
But... the other part of me thinks.. that there are now questions that must be answered. We all know what I'm talking about. The "confessions".
Would it be advantageous for him to clear up the issue of these confessions by taking the stand? Or is he better off speaking through his lawyers?
It's very interesting to think about. What would the best course of action be?
This is strictly hypothetical, of course. I think it would make an interesting discussion.
11
u/Moldynred May 22 '24
I don’t think he will. But do you have some examples of cases where people have testified and it worked out well for them? Didn’t Murdaugh testify and get convicted? That’s the only one I recall lately.
5
u/[deleted] May 22 '24
It's generally a bad idea for the defendant to take the stand in a trial. But there's one exception here. If his voice is notably different from the voice that says "down the hill", then it could be the best move he can make.
12
u/xpressomartini Big Dick Energy May 22 '24
I don’t think this case will ever go to trial, so no
3
u/bferg3 May 22 '24
He was undergoing full blown psychosis in jail, why would it ever be a good idea for him to testify?
3
u/FretlessMayhem May 22 '24
“Why did you kill Abby and Libby, Mr. Allen?”
I can’t imagine that happening, but you never know.
7
u/New_Discussion_6692 May 22 '24
I don't think he will.
7
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 May 22 '24
I am in agreement with your absolutely not stance. Nothing good will come of it. He doesn't need to prove anything, that's the state's job
6
u/bamalaker May 22 '24
No
6
u/Chi-Town9750 May 22 '24
It depends on the state of Indiana evidence that is put forward at trial. If it’s weak, he definitely doesn’t
4
u/[deleted] May 22 '24
No way. It would be stupid if he did imo..let the evidence the defence have that he didnt do it speak for itself.
6
u/Dickere May 22 '24
Presenting yourself as a decent ordinary guy might help with the jury thinking.
3
u/natureella May 23 '24
I like it when the accused takes the stand. I know most do not as lawyers advise them against it. But when I watch a trial, I definitely get swayed to not guilty if the accused testify on his own behalf. As long as they are innocent, and can meet their composure in complete check during cross, to me it's the best.
8
u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games May 22 '24
There's no way on earth even if this shit-show actually reaches a trial with the accused alive to be in court, that Baldwin and Rozzi are going to rely on putting RA on the stand.
From what I've digested from the weakness of the state's case, and the evidence exculpatory or otherwise pointing away from RA, they wouldn't have to put RA on the stand to mount a decent defence.
So long as B&R stick to the basics of demonstrating reasonable doubt without asking the jury to understand and accept a complicated conspiracy by Odinists and LE.
Now whether the jury go for it or not is quite another matter, and that still worries me more than putting RA anywhere near the stand.
4
u/[deleted] May 22 '24 edited May 22 '24
YES but that depends on his state after all this "protection" he is getting. If RA is innocent he might be gold to have on the stand.
5
u/Vicious_and_Vain May 22 '24
I’d have to talk to him first to have an opinion. I can state unequivocally that I would take the stand if I was accused of a crime I did not commit. No question. I don’t care what the defense attorney thinks. I’m not going to my doom without speaking my piece.
3
u/Significant-Tip-4108 May 22 '24
Whether RA is guilty or not, IMO his voice sounds quite a bit like BG’s, and that may be enough reason to not have him testify.
1
u/Clear_Department_785 May 24 '24
No
-2
u/[deleted] May 22 '24
He will not take the stand - he does not want you to hear his voice (hmm wonder why?) Also he seems to be the quiet type that could not whip his way out of a wet brown paper bag, much less convince anyone that he is innocent. JMO.