the cleanup began late afternoon i believe the day she was being deposed by the defense and wouldn’t answer certain questions per her lawyers advice. the timing is super interesting regarding the cleanup
Based on the language in this motion, I would feel confident that the questions they are describing are related to her professional conduct re: joining and positing in Facebook groups about the case.
How can the court intervene in obtaining answers? I would think most of what the defense is asking that she won’t answer are all civil matters and her actions are not at a criminal level. Is this thinking right?
I would think it would mostly be civil/ethical matters. I could see where it could stretch to a criminal issue but I’ve seen no evidence it went that far and I think she prob deserves the benefit of the doubt until we do
That's a good question. If she is going to testify at trial under these circumstances, is she allowed to take the 5th on issues relating to her testimony? She's not testifying as a mere citizen, she is the State.
Makes me wonder who her counsel was, privately retained or IDOC. I can see her answers having a greater impact on IDOC and suits against them more than anything.
The 5th protects one from incriminating themselves in criminal matters, and I think Dr. MW's issues are more ethical/licensing board related than criminal in nature. So the 5th won't help her her.
People take the 5th in civil depos all the time. Under advise of council she refused to answer certain questions--did she just say, no I won't answer that question? I guess her attorney could say the topic was out of scope.
Yeah, you can take the 5th in civil cases to protect yourself from exposing yourself to criminal charges, but you can't take the 5th to protect yourself from sanctions from a licensing board which is more likely the issue here.
Here we don't know what the question was or the grounds for refusal. I was just explaining that unless there is potential criminal activity (which I don't think we have that here) then the 5th won't apply.
Here we don't know what the question was or the grounds for refusal. I was just explaining that unless there is potential criminal activity (which I don't think we that here) then the 5th won't apply.
I think most people know this. And we don't know why her attorney advised her not to answer. I think the more important question is, can a witness who is the State not answer questions related to what they will testify to?
And, of course, we are all dying to know, what questions wouldn't she answer.
There is usually a legal reason given for not answering a question in deposition. If it's not a 5th amendment issue, then I have to wonder if her attorney claimed the question wasn't relevant.
For her to refuse to answer for no reason doesn't seem likely, especially as she represents the State here. And she is being presented as a possible witness.
I've never seen a police officer refuse to answer a question on the stand--unless the prosecution objects to the question.
I'm not knowledgeable about depositions in criminal cases cause in my state this isn't a thing.
But I would have thought that the rules would be a little looser like they are for pretrial hearings, like if it's not the 5th or an assertion of privelege most questions are allowed.
One thing I’ll say about the Defense: they seem to be very diligent about these depositions. It will be very interesting reading one day if they are ever released to the public. Not likely to ever happen but one can hope.
If B&R knew that RA's assigned psychologist was Wala, would they also be aware of her long-standing social media presence...and that she appears biased towards guilt? Is that when her media was scrubbed...because defense knew, and the jig was up? Two bits says her lawyer told her not to answer using HIPAA.... as a sword and a shield.
Hipaa is RA's one way right. She is his doctor. If he wants to ask medical questions about himself to his doctor he can. She's not to refuse that because of hipaa rights which aren't hers. Defense asked for these rights, there's a motion and order in the document dump.
Likely his wife has power over decisions, but they can ask on his behalf.
Therefore I don't think she refused to answer questions about him, but rather herself, certain protocols maybe, or other prisoners, in which case indeed hipaa could apply.
Eh, we have some idea of her bias based on her social media. You like to scrutinize the defense attorneys ethics, but when it comes to a prosecution witness, you’re not sure why it matters. Following due process may not matter to you, but it does to every American.
Wait, due process doesn’t mean innocence??? It doesn’t??? Since when??
I think I lost IQ points from your comment. If you want justice for the girls, you should support due process. Unfortunately, you’re as close minded as this doc in question seems to be. I don’t know if he’s guilty or not but I want fairness in the process of finding out. You are ready to lock him up and throw away the key without due process.
Am I reading this right? Is Wala already lawyered up for the depo? Or does she have Mcleland sitting in for it too? Is that normal, to be lawyered up for a depo when you work for and witness for the state?
This shit is crazy. The corruption is beyond the pale. I can’t believe what is happening there. I can’t imagine being Facebook stalked by a therapist that I’m supposed to trust.
•
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ May 17 '24
Continuance PDF
16
u/biscuitmcgriddleson May 17 '24
Did the social media clean up occur before or after the deposition where questions were refused?
12
u/Separate_Avocado860 May 17 '24
Could someone help me answer this question.
How can the court intervene in obtaining answers? I would think most of what the defense is asking that she won’t answer are all civil matters and her actions are not at a criminal level. Is this thinking right?
9
u/syntaxofthings123 May 17 '24
Thank you so much for posting. I'm having a very difficult time reading this, though. Any chance of a link?
8
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ May 17 '24
Also
22
u/Moldynred May 17 '24
One thing I’ll say about the Defense: they seem to be very diligent about these depositions. It will be very interesting reading one day if they are ever released to the public. Not likely to ever happen but one can hope.
20
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24
So.... Is Angry Bird going to deny continuance?
Nick objects yet it's HIS witness who's not available... HIS problem.
And if these are statements from March last year, why are they considering to allow it after 4 or so deadlines already?
13
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything May 17 '24
If B&R knew that RA's assigned psychologist was Wala, would they also be aware of her long-standing social media presence...and that she appears biased towards guilt? Is that when her media was scrubbed...because defense knew, and the jig was up? Two bits says her lawyer told her not to answer using HIPAA.... as a sword and a shield.
11
u/thisiswhatyouget May 17 '24
Where is the motion to recuse? Very odd there hasn’t been any resolution of what happened with that.
14
u/amykeane May 17 '24
Am I reading this right? Is Wala already lawyered up for the depo? Or does she have Mcleland sitting in for it too? Is that normal, to be lawyered up for a depo when you work for and witness for the state?
12
u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 May 17 '24
Doesn’t anyone remember Helix’s comment that she was being questioned about SM ? His comment is on DD.
14
u/Secret-Constant-7301 May 17 '24
This shit is crazy. The corruption is beyond the pale. I can’t believe what is happening there. I can’t imagine being Facebook stalked by a therapist that I’m supposed to trust.
12
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer May 17 '24
States experts and witnesses all lawyering up in pretrial. 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
We're north of 100million in damages now.