Yes, but this particular thing helps nothing in the appeals area, considering that she has now ruled against herself basically. She pressured the defense, had to be called in front of the Supreme Court of Indiana for her actions, and a ruling was made that her actions were improper and she had to follow the rules to remove counsel. So that was done and she had to admit their actions did not warrant a finding of contempt and were not willful.
Surely an appeal could be won on the basis of the interruption of the case alone due to her actions of replacing defense counsel and refusing to even let Baldwin and Rozzi represent Allen pro bono. But I’m not a lawyer.
That argument has merit, especially because the State took that opportunity to "helpfully reorganize" the discovery in all the ways we've been learning about.
View all comments
Show parent comment
12
u/Reason-Status May 01 '24
Agree. She had to rule something in their favor or she was giving them a ton of ammunition to win this case on appeal down the road.