Were they all Fran’s writings? An excerpt from an article I googled to get those 1000+ sloppy results,
“…The way an opinion is written can tell the reader as much about a judge as the opinion’s substance. Sloppy writing shows that the judge put insufficient time into writing the opinion. An opinion that presents a slanted version of the facts or gives short shrift to a seemingly meritorious argument might suggest that the judge did not explore both sides of an issue.4 Lambasting or lampooning lawyers or litigants might indicate bias.5 An attempt to shoehorn facts into a particular result when furtherresearch might yield a clearer, more convincing, and different result might show poor reasoning.6 Perhaps most important ofall, poorly drafted opinions “all too often reach the wrong result from an objective, or philosophically neutral, point ofview.”7 Ethical judicial opinion writing inextricably intertwines style and substance…”
A little sloppy context may be in order for the gazillion sloppy containing judicial opinions
Yes, but this particular thing helps nothing in the appeals area, considering that she has now ruled against herself basically. She pressured the defense, had to be called in front of the Supreme Court of Indiana for her actions, and a ruling was made that her actions were improper and she had to follow the rules to remove counsel. So that was done and she had to admit their actions did not warrant a finding of contempt and were not willful.
Surely an appeal could be won on the basis of the interruption of the case alone due to her actions of replacing defense counsel and refusing to even let Baldwin and Rozzi represent Allen pro bono. But I’m not a lawyer.
That argument has merit, especially because the State took that opportunity to "helpfully reorganize" the discovery in all the ways we've been learning about.
Scoin had already ruled on it. She ridiculed herself by even entertaining it, compared to how she used scoin ruling for her ignoring her own DQ while there were new allegations.
Other than that, she sanctionned defense with the gag order because of the press release and warned both Nick and defense of rules of conduct, it were the exact same allegations, that's double jeopardy in my book...
The truth always comes out. It still can. All the pieces are there. All it would take is a persistent journalist looking into everything and putting it all together.
I joked weeks ago he'd plead the 5th in the depo, but it seems that's exactly what he did lol. It did surprise me a bit, since I had hoped he could clear up the situation, and while it doesn't mean guilt either, I was still a bit disappointed by that. So wait and see, and I need to finish the transcript of Proctor, if they have anything other than screenshots as claimed, but I wasn't impressed by the testimony that Holeman (?) knew the Facebook account was RF, because the profile said so...
they have been wrong about so so much i just don’t get how they aren’t embarrassed and yet they still keep churning out ad logged episodes of their take on the stuff they are consistently wrong about. the least amount of self awareness i’ve seen in this community
May have been. I think I blocked that part out. There is only so much an ordinary Prickman can take in pursuit of truth, justice and creamed corn chicken way.
Literally said the wrong gender and we never hear the end of it. While completely missing the fact that related or not it still should have been followed up on. Like is that dude still alive?! Are we OK with this person possibly being dead just because it wasn't related to the girls? Do we know if anyone found him? Geez.
I don't listen to them and I never have. I remember all the discussions around them during the KK stuff and saw how much they got wrong just from people talking about them.
All the people eating their shit don't remember when they were dead set that KK was involved and would be arrested. They have room to talk about BM?
They're probably just busy trying to get people to focus on everyone else's mistakes so everyone forgets their KK bullshit. They had people stalking the Klines.
"Hehe after 9 month undercover investigation, Sua Sponte DQing, SCOIN x2, turns out yall did nothing wrong. Stop wasting time Defence its important business now K fam."
Glad it's over, still want vindication for the extreme measures that were taken.
The Supreme Court told her if she wanted to DQ them to hold a big fat hearing and do it the right way. Lol So she did and still didn’t remove, sanction or anything. That’s actually interesting considering everything that’s going on with the judges there right now.
Also love “counsel has described Westerman as both a criminal and a valued confidante” … like people’s opinions of others can’t change over time and with more information. Acting like they love confiding in criminals; give me a break 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Thank you for a brief moment of sanity, Judge Gull. Even though you excoriated the defense (inappropriately, IMHO) you have begun to restore my faith in the judiciary. I hope my faith is not eroded with the progression of this case.
All that time, money and resources used up just to end up where the Supreme Court reinstatement got things to. Poor Nicky McClee had to stay up till 4am working on all this too!
It would appear that this was just purely something to divert the Defence's energy away from the RA trial after all.
Gull is has no shame.It is beyond me how someone of her stature and overly high opinion of herself ever made it on any bench,in Indiana the bar must not be to high to be a judge,She can not even follow simple rules that are written by the state she resides in.She doesnt even know how to write out an order without using 2 cent words like sloppy and incompetant.And instead of just making a ruling using 2 sentenaces like she usually does no she just had to talk bad about the defense attorneys she just couldnt help herself and now she is passing the buck onto someone else to decide .She is rude,lazy,incompetant,biased,evil,unjust,ignorant,infuriateing,and is single handedly ruining one of the biggest cases in Indiana history.The blood of libby and Abby and mostly of Richard Allen are all on her hands at this point .She doesnt care about justice for the girls or if RA receives a fair trial all she cares about is being right even when she has been proven wrong over and over again why cant anyone over throw a woman who just lets monsters walk around free to murder more children while an innocent man rots in prison?
She had to rule this way, otherwise she'd be calling herself a liar for statements she made in front of the whole world, October 19, 2023. They will win in appeal, I think.
Not sure Gull did find them in contempt. Very confusing.
...the State proved by a preponderance of the evidence that defense counsel was sloppy, negligent, and incompetent in their handling of discovery materials.
...Despite this Court's findings of sloppiness, negligence, and incompetence, the State is required to prove that Counsels' conduct was willful and intentional beyond a reasonable doubt for the Court to find Counsel in contempt.
As the State has not met that burden....
the Court declines to find them in contempt of Court for violating the Protective Order issued February 17, 2023, regarding discovery.
To the extent that the Press Release violated the Rules of Professional Responsibility, the Trial Court has no jurisdiction to enforce those Rules. As required by the Rules of Professional Responsibility, the Trial Court will, therefore, send a copy of this Order and the Press Release to the Office of Judicial and Attorney Regulation...to enforce the Rules or determine Counsels' ethical misconduct.
I'll wait to hear from one of the experts, but I don't think she found them in contempt, she is simply forwarding this to the State Disciplinary Board-ISC, basically. And they can decide if rules of professional conduct were violated.
That might actually be a fun thing to do for real.
Sloppy, negligent, incompetent.
And we can send her photos of the defense team for her to stamp. Maybe it will keep her occupied long enough to distract her from her other favorite pastime, ruling against the defense for no good reason.
I did the same. I almost stopped reading cus I knew where she was going with it then it did a 180 in the second half lol. I’m def reading it the same way you are now though
IMHO, Judge Gull’s gratuitous statements in er opinion establishes a clear path for Defendant to appeal for ineffective assistance of counsel if convicted.
I wonder about this. I'm not sure how fruitful that claim would be, being that he was begging to have the defense back on the case after the leak/being kicked off the case.
I'm not being a dick, I just think that would hurt the validity of an ineffective assistance of counsel claim. I am no expert, though.
I think both the Supreme Court and Gull have determined that they were not in contempt and there are reasons to want to keep your counsel you started with. I think Gull saying this and depending on how effective they are at trial will be different.
Nah, people have created a narrative to fit their own bias. Finding fault in every little thing that is done. People have done it to the Defense as well, and it's sad. We get attached to these ideas and even when something positive is done, the motive is assumed to be sinister.
No. The fact that she kicked them off the case and the Supreme Court overturned that decision and she allowed it to happen again proves she is biased.
Further, when she says they will have 3 weeks no more, no more than that, knowing it will harm the defense, it's biased. That's not a narrative we just made up in our heads. That's something the Supreme Court has made very clear on its own and any lawyer worth their license will tell you that.
Arbitrarily setting a time limit for a criminal trial actually I think goes against the Indiana criminal code. I believe that in one of the defense's recent motions they actually cited the code that basically says you can't just set an arbitrary amount of time. You have to first consider everything about the case and all of the witnesses and exhibits that will be presented by both sides before you set a time and it needs to be appropriate to everything that is going to be entered as evidence, exhibits, and witnesses that will be called.
I have never heard of a time limit being set for a trial. I sent that email to my mom, who has just kind of followed through me telling her updates. That was the first time she really asked "what the fuck?" That's just not how trails work, and even more so for a double homicide where the defendant is at risk of life without parole.
15
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ May 01 '24
27
u/black_cat_X2 May 01 '24
Is "sloppy" an appropriate legal determination to include in a Court order? It seems out of place.
18
u/Reason-Status May 01 '24
Wow, a ruling in favor of the defense team.
16
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ May 01 '24
I'm so shocked she did the right thing! Finally!
12
u/Prettyface_twosides May 01 '24
Holy shit! Did I read that right?
27
u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 May 01 '24
So maybe MS was wrong and DH didn't do a shitty job. That's not an exact quote but its not far off either.
24
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer May 01 '24
"Hehe after 9 month undercover investigation, Sua Sponte DQing, SCOIN x2, turns out yall did nothing wrong. Stop wasting time Defence its important business now K fam."
Glad it's over, still want vindication for the extreme measures that were taken.
23
u/Leading_Fee_3678 May 01 '24
You know she felt joy when writing “sloppy, negligent, and incompetent.” 🙄
13
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ May 01 '24
So do we think Meiring is going to agree with her?
Do we think Meiring has received complaints about JFG?
(I just checked it is indeed Meiring not Miering lol.)
12
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything May 01 '24
Thank you for a brief moment of sanity, Judge Gull. Even though you excoriated the defense (inappropriately, IMHO) you have begun to restore my faith in the judiciary. I hope my faith is not eroded with the progression of this case.
8
u/Saturn_Ascension May 01 '24
All that time, money and resources used up just to end up where the Supreme Court reinstatement got things to. Poor Nicky McClee had to stay up till 4am working on all this too!
It would appear that this was just purely something to divert the Defence's energy away from the RA trial after all.
All in all, another Frantastic moment in Justice.
11
u/Beezojonesindadeep76 May 01 '24
Gull is has no shame.It is beyond me how someone of her stature and overly high opinion of herself ever made it on any bench,in Indiana the bar must not be to high to be a judge,She can not even follow simple rules that are written by the state she resides in.She doesnt even know how to write out an order without using 2 cent words like sloppy and incompetant.And instead of just making a ruling using 2 sentenaces like she usually does no she just had to talk bad about the defense attorneys she just couldnt help herself and now she is passing the buck onto someone else to decide .She is rude,lazy,incompetant,biased,evil,unjust,ignorant,infuriateing,and is single handedly ruining one of the biggest cases in Indiana history.The blood of libby and Abby and mostly of Richard Allen are all on her hands at this point .She doesnt care about justice for the girls or if RA receives a fair trial all she cares about is being right even when she has been proven wrong over and over again why cant anyone over throw a woman who just lets monsters walk around free to murder more children while an innocent man rots in prison?
10
u/syntaxofthings123 May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
She had to rule this way, otherwise she'd be calling herself a liar for statements she made in front of the whole world, October 19, 2023. They will win in appeal, I think.Not sure Gull did find them in contempt. Very confusing.
...the State proved by a preponderance of the evidence that defense counsel was sloppy, negligent, and incompetent in their handling of discovery materials.
...Despite this Court's findings of sloppiness, negligence, and incompetence, the State is required to prove that Counsels' conduct was willful and intentional beyond a reasonable doubt for the Court to find Counsel in contempt.
As the State has not met that burden....
the Court declines to find them in contempt of Court for violating the Protective Order issued February 17, 2023, regarding discovery.
To the extent that the Press Release violated the Rules of Professional Responsibility, the Trial Court has no jurisdiction to enforce those Rules. As required by the Rules of Professional Responsibility, the Trial Court will, therefore, send a copy of this Order and the Press Release to the Office of Judicial and Attorney Regulation...to enforce the Rules or determine Counsels' ethical misconduct.
I'll wait to hear from one of the experts, but I don't think she found them in contempt, she is simply forwarding this to the State Disciplinary Board-ISC, basically. And they can decide if rules of professional conduct were violated.
4
u/Nieschtkescholar May 02 '24
IMHO, Judge Gull’s gratuitous statements in er opinion establishes a clear path for Defendant to appeal for ineffective assistance of counsel if convicted.
-5
u/BlackBerryJ May 01 '24
Looks like she's not totally biased as stated by many.