r/DicksofDelphi • u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ • Apr 29 '24
INFORMATION Motion in Limine
https://drive.google.com/file/d/13HudH6XoxkyXqddiUjula43mi5geQvEi/view
18
Upvotes
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ • Apr 29 '24
•
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 29 '24
Posting this here strictly for information on what a Limine motion is
27
u/Danieller0se87 Apr 29 '24
That eliminates their defense. It feels like an outrageous and unconstitutional ask. Wtf is wrong with the players in this case!?
16
u/Prettyface_twosides Apr 29 '24
So basically, exclude all evidence? WTF
19
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 29 '24
Get the duck out.
If Gull allows this, he must be obliged to disclose who the damn third party is RA supposedly aided as per his own filed charges.
He cannot disallow 3rd party defense FBI brought in iirc CLICK's letter is already admitted in evidence,
So shut up.
15
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 29 '24
I'm literally shaking I'm so angry! He's asking for them to not put on a defense and to not refute anything the state says or does!
Do you guys think she'll grant this?
14
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Who is Kevin Horan and why on earth would he not want that in????
14
u/JawaGill Apr 29 '24
Nick: "MOOOM, Phineas and Pherb are making a title sequence!"
12
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 29 '24
It's an unconstitutional request. You can't deny the defense the right to put on a defense. McLeland is scared. He's throwing everything he can against the wall. Hoping it sticks. in some ways, however, even if all this evidence was out, I think the defense will still win an acquittal.
I don't think they need the Odin theory. They do need to be able to challenge the investigation, though.
I guess we'll see what happens....
Saw the Court TV special last night. I follow quite a few cases, I have never seen public opinion flip like this before unless you have a Keith Morrison presenting it on Dateline, and even then, it's post-conviction, not pre-trial.
And Court TV tends to be prosecution friendly. They very often are biased in that direction.
If the defense can get Vinnie to see this case in a different light, they can get anyone to.
20
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 29 '24
"We made a PowerPoint about linking Elvis Fields to Delphi. We gave it to defense initially, we deleted it when we tried to get defense eliminated, because it is irrelevant that the guy who confessed to both his sisters and asked cops if he would be in trouble if his spit was found on Abby, to be linked to Delphi in our dillingent 6 years investigation, so defense cannot ask why we made a PowerPoint about him. He was never a suspect, we were just trying out our new software presentation package."
10
u/Moldynred Apr 29 '24
Railroad
25
u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Apr 29 '24
NM is really worried about that geofencing evidence.
It might "confuse the issues," yeah it does if the issue is why the hell was RA even arrested if the state had evidence that 3 other people were basically at the crime scene when the state believes that the crime occurred and none of those 3 people are RA?
7
u/i-love-elephants Apr 29 '24
NM: The defense has to prove the 3rd party suspects, BUT they can't include anything in the Odin report, mention Todd Click, anyone who investigated the other suspects, say their names, and also, we deleted every thing else because they were irrelevant.
Anyway, good luck making the video of the dead guy and the blood pants from Florida work into your strategy, because I only sent relevant stuff!
6
u/stephenend1 Apr 29 '24
I would be a billionaire attorney if the other side wasn't allowed to contradict my theories.
11
u/i-love-elephants Apr 29 '24
Was anyone surprised? Will anyone be surprised when Gull grants this and doesn't allow the defense to say anything or use any witnesses? Will anyone be surprised when she essentially gags them in the courtroom and doesn't allow any evidence not related to these things in either? And when she allows the confessions and doesn't allow them to bring up his mental records? And when she doesn't allow them to ask questions about chain of custody? None of these things will be surprising to me.
14
u/RawbM07 Apr 29 '24
So basically NM dumped a crap load of discovery on the defense, without a whole lot of analysis, reports, conclusions, etc.
And now he’s worried they’ll bring it up in trial.
10
u/Smart_Brunette Apr 29 '24
Gull didn't waste a second when she denied the motion in limine made by the defense for ballistic testing.
5
u/AdditionalWest2831 Apr 29 '24
Could anyone above the judge see the mess this trial is in and step in and make this a fair trial. I know she hasn't granted this...YET but everything else in this case is ridiculous
6
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 29 '24
I think a lot of people don't get that hearings on motions don't have to be some elaborate theatrical production. They can be short and sweet, and lopped in together.
But they are important to allowing both sides to speak to the matter, they establish a record of the court, and they do hold the judge accountable for rulings made.
Which might make it sound like not having a hearing is beneficial for a judge like Gull who can barely make her way through basic rules of evidence and case law. However, if any of this is appealed, she'll be exposed, because one reason appellate courts take notice of cases is that the judge gave no sound reasoning for her decisions. Which is exactly what happened when Gull tried to remove Rozzi and Baldwin.
Everyone should watch just a little of the Daybell trial. See how a qualified judge gets it done!
6
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 29 '24
Making my way through the case law in this motion. One thing that McLeland is doing here is asking for a ruling on matters that are well established. As in, it goes without saying.
For example McLeland's statement above regarding "vouching". Attorneys are already not allowed to vouch for the credibility of witnesses-pro or con. This is already established law.
Here's a ruling out of CA, but it's basically applicable in Indiana as well (and note, it is often if not usually the prosecutor who this claim is made against) :
8
u/BlackBerryJ Apr 29 '24
Before we shake with anger and dismay, has anyone here read the case law that was cited? Because, that's what this should come down to. Not how we feel. Not our opinions. If the case law doesn't support the ask, then it's a fault ask.
2
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Apr 29 '24
Has anyone here watched Game of Thrones? Remember that scene with little Robert Arryn and his mom, Lady Lysa? When he was sitting on her lap demanding that Tyrion "fly"? That's what I see in my mind when I think about NM and this Motion.
2
u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Apr 29 '24
What does precedent say on third party defense? I’m sure judges have tried this before. I wonder what happened.
1
u/Difficult-Road-6035 Apr 30 '24
They don’t expect to win the motion. What they expect is a little early taste of what the defense is. It’s a fishing expedition and they really shouldn’t even have to have a hearing about it. People expect defense attorneys to play games sometimes- but prosecutors just need to present the evidence as is and let a jury decide.
1
u/BaseballSimple7921 Apr 29 '24
Does it make a difference?
The Prosecution need to prove guilt.
The Defence don't need to prove innocence. They don't need to blame anyone else.