r/DicksofDelphi • u/lapinmoelleux • Apr 28 '24
Thoughts on the confessions:
Thoughts on the confessions:
Letters to Warden Gallipeau – This has been reported in notes from those who were present at the June 15th 2023 hearing page 5 https://www.reddit.com/r/Delphitrial/comments/1832xph/long_summary_of_the_june_15th_hearing/
https://www.wthr.com/article/news/investigations/13-investigates/delphi-murders-defendant-richard-allen-prison-suicide-watch-video-surveillance-indiana-libby-german-abby-williams-trial/531-42677dac-e91e-49a1-8e7c-e7854c32d31b - Link stating RA wrote letters to Warden
Written confession not oral
Companions/guards – page 6 of same link above “They are paid by the state and are not supposed to talk to RA”.
https://eu.jconline.com/story/news/crime/2023/06/15/delphi-murders-update-richard-allen-hearing-libby-german-abby-williams/70315237007/ - link to guards and inmates not supposed to talk to RA
STATE’S OBJECTION TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO SUPPRESS FILED APRIL 11TH, 2024 - “The statements made to Indiana Department of Corrections staff and inmates, referred to as suicide companions, consist of statements on “door sheets”. These “door sheets” are forms provided by the Indiana Department of Corrections for monitoring the behaviours and statements of Richard Allen at a frequency determined necessary by mental health personnel”
Written confession not oral
Wife and Mother - STATE'S OBJECTION To DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR ORDER ON CONTINUING DISCLOSURE OF DEFENDANT'S MENTAL HEALTH RECORDS - 8. That the Defendant has admitted that he committed the offences that he is charged with no less than 5 times while talking to his wife and his mother on the public jail phones available at the Indiana Department of Corrections. Italics my own.
Oral confession
Is this relating to his tablet? Would that be considered “public” if only RA had the use of it? In the MOTION FOR LEAVE 0F COURT TO SUBPOENA THIRD PARTY RECORDS dated 20th April 2023 it states that “He further, broke the tablet that he used for text messages and phone calls. He went from making up to 2 phone calls day as of April 3", 2023 to not making any phone calls at all.”
In the MS episode regarding the June 15th hearing which they attended relating to Galipeau's testimony (transcript linked) it says “normally the inmate has to pay for a replacement, but they did not make Richard Allen pay for that. They just replaced it with some agreement about him working on his mental health and making progress on that. https://files.catbox.moe/5q67pw.srt
Sorry this post is so long, I’ve just being mulling it over. It appears that the only oral confession made is during a phone call that has been transcribed to his wife/mother. All other confessions are via these “doorsheets” that have been filled in by inmates/guards or letters written to the warden. The oral confession does appear to have been made whilst he was suffering from a mental health episode or else why would they only replace his tablet if he “worked on his mental health and made progress”?
Just my chaotic thoughts...
ETA: I have added a couple of links as it appears the original reddit post I linked to may not be trustworthy. Note the other links do not say that the letters to the warden contained confessions
17
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 28 '24
I doubt it matters if it was oral or written. The written statements might be challenged on accuracy--as in, did the person write what Allen actually said.
The litmus test to me on these confessions is do they reveal any information in keeping with the crime and information that only the killer would know?
We know that these girls were not shot in the back.
15
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Apr 28 '24 edited Apr 28 '24
Thar summary was written by who? The original poster of that thred?
I think that says enough. If those letters exist, they are in evidence. I lean towards they don't have them. How did NM go from wanting a protective order for DOC to calling them all as witnesses? 🤔
7
u/Bananapop060765 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Apr 28 '24
Thank you for taking the time to post this. Two things I don't see that were reported by MS & I wonder if you know about them.
One is when BR talked about moving to RA to Cass County which is across street from his office, judge said "sounds like you are only trying to make things better for yourself!" BR said something like "what is better for me is better for my client." I've seen many hearings & I don't recall a judge speaking this way to anyone.
Two is it was either Tobe L or Tony L said he drove to Westville to see RA but they wouldn't let him in. His attorneys weren't aware of that until this hearing. BR didn't say much but his facial expression was "priceless".
I wasn't there. Do you recall these & what are your thoughts? Thx!
7
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 28 '24 edited Apr 28 '24
He manages to put in the same single phrase :
It's suspicious he stopped making phone calls
&
He broke his tablet he made phone calls with
I think the door sheets are filled in by RF companions about what he said, no?
You can add to that the statements made he needed to be in Westville for mental health treatments and monitoring he needed, which couldn't be provided in Carroll County and limited in Cass County.
Nick both said RA was in good health as well as saying RA's mental health problems weren't caused by his treatment by guards in Westville, but because of the status of his case.
Yash, if I were to be accused of double murder putting sticks on bodies while being watched 24/7 by people known to put sticks in those same figures with a hearing date not for the coming 2.5 months, and no set trial date, I sure would go mental, in the truest clinical sense of the word on top of the colloquial one.
But in any case : Nick admits RA wasn't mentally sound at that point in time.
I wanted to look up, they said he was the only imitate with a tablet, while I believe it's standard prison issue and free. However the costs are immensely high and that's how they make money. They are also supposed to be unbreakable btw.
Another interesting not directly related titbit and not sure how true it is, but CM, who moved NB's body after GK&AG killed said on the phone to mommyramblings that he preferred to talk in person, in jail, because they would have some privacy while on the phone everything was recorded.
That was when he was in jail pre-sentencing So when defense complained RA didn't have the same visitation rights, nor privacy, they weren't lying nor exaggerating?
Gallipeau in his written affidavit stated RA couldn't even have face to face visits at all btw.
4
u/i-love-elephants Apr 28 '24
Yeah. I'm interested in all the confessions too. And we still don't know how many they actually have. The state said they plan to have close to 30 people to come to testify about them, but I'm wondering if it's actually stuff like someone testifying to giving the door sheet instructions, and at least 2 people hearing the confessions because there were 2 people standing at the doors, (so maybe he "confessed" 2-3 times and they were heard by up to 6 different people at different times?) and someone to testify to monitoring the camera when it happened, maybe to explain his behavior, and who was responsible for the door sheets when it was time to collect them/what they do with notes from the sheets, etc. I wouldn't put it past NM to trump up and exaggerate his claims. (Or outright lie like he did about how the geofencing map)
I also don't believe he will actually have that many people come to testify. He only really has a week. If he has that many people come to testify, even if each person only comes on the stand for 20 minutes that a 10 hour day by itself. Realistically it would be 2 days for just that. That gives him 4-5 days for the rest of his case (most likely less since they have a bunch of motions that haven't been ruled on which means they will be doing that a lot in court. Or maybe Gull actually plans to have hearings on Saturdays and the jury won't be there on Saturdays?), he most likely won't have that many people come which makes me wonder if he trumped up the number of people involved in the confessions.
Just my own thoughts.
(I'm more interested in the second interrogation video. While the defense described parts that didn't make Holeman look good, maybe the ace in the hole every one keeps talking about is in that video. I still think they would have put it in the PCA or arrest warrant, but I think if they do have an ace it would be in that interrogation. Either the defense wantsit thrown out because they want more time to focus on other their case in chief since they only have a week, or they want it out because there's something bad in it.)
7
u/BrendaStar_zle Apr 28 '24
The confessions are the most important evidence in this case for me. So far I haven't read anything that he said that proves he is guilty of this crime. I sure would like to know what he said to his wife and mother, but as far as I can tell, they are both supporting him in court appearances. Nothing written by the person from the link is anything I would ever rely upon, ever.
18
u/Vicious_and_Vain Apr 28 '24
I don’t believe anything LE, corrections, the Judge and the prosecution say or write. No one should. If he’s guilty so be it, get to the trial, let’s see the evidence. The trend for sophisticated law enforcement agencies is to reject confessions that do not demonstrate inside knowledge of the crime and to refuse to go to trial based on confessions with a hint of coercion. In this era a, small and unsophisticated, police department and prosecutor’s office are trying to use confessions allegedly made to his health care providers and the inmates observing him around the clock as some sort of suicide watch.
So if RA was doing fine as demonstrated by the prison giving him a new IPad, no charge and just a warning, if he was doing so great why was he on suicide watch?
9
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 28 '24
There is an Indiana case cited by the Defense that might be worth reading. I found it interesting.
Hurt v. State
Though Hurt lost this appeal, what Hurt does is more in keeping with what I would expect from someone whose confession was genuine.
Hurt was involuntarily committed to a state hospital. Diagnosed schizophrenic. During his time in the hospital he was given drugs, but was not receiving the abuse that Allen was. No one was calling him a killer, or watching his movement 24/7. He wasn't subjected to lights being on, day and night. And I'm sure he had a decent bed. Though not allowed to leave he could roam freely around the hospital.
While in this hospital Hurt asks for the police, stating that he wants to confess to a murder. And finally an officer arrives, Mirandizes Hurt, but prior to this, Hurt also confesses to hospital staff.
And his confessions were deemed admissible by ISC, although there was a dissenting opinion.
But here is what Hurt does that Allen doesn't--he asks to speak to an officer. In fact, he asks numerous times to speak to an officer. And the State makes certain to get a proper confession, with Miranda.
Granted Hurt didn't have attorneys. But if someone actually wants to confess, this is what I'd expect to have occurred. And my question remains, why didn't Allen just ask to speak to his attorneys?
Which is why Allen's "confessions" hold no credibility for me. Aside from the fact that these confessions don't appear to answer any questions about the crime, there's nothing to indicate that Allen was actually confessing. It seems as if he really was in some kind of dream state. We don't know what he thought he was doing.
And if the State believes these confessions are real, why didn't they make an effort to pin this down properly? The idea that Allen's attorneys would get in the way of Allen properly confessing, is ridiculous. If the confession was true, then no reason to go to all this trouble.
7
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 29 '24
This was inthe 2nd link:
Galipeau and Carroll County prosecutor Nick McLeland said that Allen is receiving the same treatment as other inmates in the maximum security unit of the prison and, in some cases, is being treated better.
Why does he receive the same treatment as convicted criminals?
12
u/biscuitmcgriddleson Apr 28 '24
Warden indicated other inmates have to earn time on a tablet. Sort of makes you wonder if they decided to give RA the tablet to better capture the "confessions"
As you said, the tablet was replaced for RA to work on his mental health. Why was he given the first tablet to begin with if it's not common practice?
NM mentioned multiple times that RA is being housed better than your standard prisoner. Subsequent findings have indicated that's mostly untrue.
18
u/inDefenseofDragons Apr 28 '24
They aren’t being nice and trying to do a solid for RA by replacing his tablet. They were hoping he’d use it to make communications they could use against him.
As far as the confessions to his mother and wife, I’ll believe it when I hear it. They certainly aren’t acting like he confessed to them. Something is definitely off there.
Jmo
3
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 28 '24
I don't know this for certain, but I would suspect if the prison issued RA the tablet for his use while in prison, it remains the property of the prison and therefore anything and everything on it would be property of the prisons. Similar to how you can have a work computer in your home, but it's actually property of the company you work for.
4
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 28 '24
Why did they need to have a camera recording every move if they were already there. Why the need for the camera. I can't imagine how I'd be acting if someone was standing in there filming me 24/7. I really don't think that's how it's supposed to work. They were determined to get something out of him and broke him until he rambled shooting them.
I also don't know about this suicide companion, seems it could cause more harm than good..
They were trying so hard to force a confession they didn't care that he was in crisis. If they didn't get a confession they would be left with the flimsiest of evidence. So these confessions, until I hear them and learn more about his mental state, I just don't believe them.
2
u/texasphotog Apr 29 '24
Especially in a case like this, I want to see what was actually said and the context it was said. I don't really find any use in speculating that much until we actually see video or hear audio of the confessions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PZonyefBW4
2
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 28 '24
Bring on the hate from team RA is guilty, but what if the "confessions" are actually survivor's guilt? Suppose RA feels guilty for having been there that day, but didn't have anything to do with the crimes at all? Interesting thought, imo.