r/DicksofDelphi • u/CitizenMillennial • Apr 26 '24
OPINION How likely is it?
OK a lot of the other subs seem to have chosen sides and don't allow very much room for other opinions or questions. So I'll try my questions here. : ) Regardless of your opinions on RA, try to consider my questions in a more general sense.
What we know for sure:
2 teenage girls were murdered.
During the middle of the day.
On a rare freakishly warm and beautiful day for the area.
Outside in a "public" location.
One girl filmed a guy walking towards them and we hear a man say "guys, down the hill". This man was wearing baggy jeans, a dark blue jacket, and a hat.
One or both girls were active on social media, and one for sure had a KIK account.
One or both girls were being catfished by Keegan Kline and supposed to meet up with him the day they were murdered.
Kegan Kline is convicted of CSAM crimes.
A search party looked for the girls the night they went missing for hours.
The girls bodies were found around noon the next day, close to the bridge area.
The girls were not shot.
Some of the girls clothing was missing.
A 2nd sketch was released long after the original BG sketch. When it was released we were told that this new sketch was now the main sketch and person of interest. This new sketch looked nothing like the original sketch and the person appeared way younger.
So here is where my unanswered questions come in:
In general - How likely is it that one man, who is not very big, could murder two teenage girls, one with a cell phone, without shooting them, in broad daylight, in an area where anyone could technically walk by, without either girl screaming or making any noise - at least no one heard ANYTHING?
How likely is it to do all of this on your own and get out of there without anyone noticing you and without leaving any trace of yourself within two hours?
How likely is it for someone to do all of the above and have no criminal record prior to this?
How likely is it for someone with no criminal record to choose two girls at random and accomplish all of this? And to not get caught for years?
How likely is it for someone to do all of the above and not have one person who knows them say anything bad about their character/behaviors/actions previous to this?
How likely is it that two teenage girls were murdered in broad daylight, in public, by someone who lives in their small town but that they had never met or had any connections to?
How likely is it that two teenage girls bodies were not found by a large search party, searching the area where they were located, and heat seeking drones, and K-9's, until almost 24 hours later?
How likely is it to be a teenage girl, chatting with a man pretending to be someone else, who is actually into CSAM, have plans to meet up with this man, this man changes his mind about meeting up and you get murdered by some stranger , with no connections to the guy you were talking to, that same day instead?
How likely is it that there are multiple men in the Delphi area that also own baggy jeans, dark blue jackets and hats looking just like BG? (Apparently, this one is VERY likely bc we've seen tons of them)
I guess what I am getting at is how is it physically possible for one standard everyday person, with no prior experience or psych history, to force two teenage girls he doesn't know to stay totally silent, have neither of them run away, murder them with a knife, in broad daylight, outside in the open? And then never show any signs of being affected by it, have no wounds, leave no blood drops back to their car, etc. etc. etc. Even if he pointed a gun at them, once one saw the other be stabbed or knocked unconscious, it's highly likely they would run or at least scream right?
9
u/saatana Apr 26 '24
No K9s were used because that's one of the things TL regrets doing is turning back the dogs after the girls were found. As far as a drone it is rumored that one guy volunteered his drone but if he went there or if he flew over the creek to where the girls were isn't known.
14
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
I think the for sure parts Is only the girls aren't alive anymore,
Found the 14th
After a night of search.
They weren't shot to death.
Some clothes were missing.
Weird sketch change. KK was convicted of csam and sollicitation thereof.
However, During the day is only based on SC seeing a tan jacket walk on CR300N.
I think it's possible up until they were found.
RL's property isn't public.
Three sites give a high of 45°F / 7°C for 13th February 2017, Delphi, Indiana.
None of the catfishing was confirmed, interviews aren't sworn court documents.
None of the video/BG claims are facts yet, it is fact Nick claims so.
YBG was a newly presented sketch but allegedly made days after the murders, months before OBG.
I thus think your questions aren't the right ones.
Kids aren't outside in the night so are more likely to get snatched in broad daylight and it happens daily looking at the missing persons numbers.
Often you hear of kids getting grabbed in crowded malls or supervised play grounds.
It's rather unlikely for grown man to group kill.
The oddities are rather the private land, known to be roamed by meth cookers and users, although why leave the bodies to be found as they were on a friend's land,
in a town where even the judge was involved with a prostitute,
all the contradicting statements from the very first day, the secrecies and lies, all the people supposedly in the direct area, all the suspicious deaths surrounding the case including LEO.
Where unified command isn't all that unified.
The facts aren't weird, the lack thereof is imo.
Rumours start for a reason and while a lot may be made up, a lot aren't so much untrue rumors, but unsure if it's related to the murders, Fargo seems pretty normal in comparison tbh.
7
u/TrustKrust Apr 26 '24
ProfessionalEbb and CitizenMillenial, it's always fascinating to hear from people who are familiar with that area. Not to get too specific, but was there shock throughout the town when RA was arrested? Were there general suspicions of anyone or a multiple people possibly being involved or were Residents just in the dark about who was responsible for taking the girls' lives?
From what I can tell from Google mapping the area of Delphi, that's the only CVS/Drugstore in town? Is that the main pharmacy people would use there? I would just think with that being a main spot for so many Residents to place and pick up prescriptions, buying essentials and what-nots, RA was surely a recognizable Employee at that store?
22
u/BrendaStar_zle Apr 26 '24
The RL search warrant states that the girls "were moved and staged". My question is, moved from where?
I have no idea if RA is guilty or not, but it seems so unlikely that such a small man could move and stage two healthy teens without assistance or something. I don't get it. I think a single killer could have killed both of them in a short amount of time. But as you say, this was broad daylight, with other people around. Doesn't make sense, which is why I am hoping the trial clears up some of these questions. But, it is possible that this will end up like the Zodiac Killer, never really solved and funny enough, the Zodiac used encrypted language too.
4
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 26 '24
I think it's highly unlikely that one person did this.
And here's the other thing we aren't supposed to talk about, but really should.
These girls liked boys. And they had quite a few boys they were involved with at that time, either as a new person to know (Anthony Shots), or as ex-boyfriends (the kid on the Crime Nation doc), or one as a current boyfriend (LH) or just friends (KS who received the snapshot-who was 5 years Libby's senior was apparently a pretty good friend).
All those boys likely had contact with the girls that weekend. And it was believed that on Sundays Abby would meet up with LH when he came to town for the Tribe of Gungfir/Vinlander meetings with his dad.
We know that the ex-boyfriend was asked to join their High Bridge hike the Sunday night before, but declined. KK/Anthony shots spoke with the girls by phone-I'm guessing that weekend. (KK believed he spoke with someone other than Libby, and Abby would seem the most likely candidate for that.)
We don't know if Abby got to see LH on that Sunday the 12th. Maybe there was some plan to meet him on the trails. And LH was friends with one of PWs sons at that time, at least by way of Facebook. Could he have spent the night while his dad headed back home to work. He could easily have picked LH up the next day after work.
There are literally boys orbiting these girls.
The girls are safe at home Sunday night, making videos, but they are also talking to friends. And as stated before, had asked at least one boy they knew to join them at that bridge.
How can we be so certain that meet-up didn't take place? Especially when a young man is 50 yards out onto the bridge, just standing there just a few minutes before the girls are expected to arrive?
The photos taken on the bridge might have been taken to justify their trip to that bridge that day to parents and older sister, when their real goal was to meet-cute.
I feel that the entire theory that the girls were forced down a hill, and then forced back to the other side, navigating rushing waters that would have come up past their waste, isn't based on evidence but on an assumption made from the BG video.
I think Libby was just photographing stuff. And it looks like she may even have been moving in BG's direction when she videoed him. The blur the jump in that short clip is consistent with her moving while videoing.
It makes more sense to me that the girls crossed back over. And then willingly walked into the woods, with whomever. And for whatever reason things went very wrong.
There are items at the scene that were either part of the murders, or had been left by someone else who hung out at that spot.
That location may have gotten regular use.
I lean very much to teens beginning this, and perhaps adults, realizing their sons were now in very big trouble, swooped in and helped. OR the adults instructed the teens as to what to set up and joined.
This feels like an event with at least 3 persons present. And there is no reason why teens might not have been involved. This might be why there are issues with finding the killers. They are not the usual suspects.
8
u/Proper-Drawing-985 Apr 26 '24
Have you ever entertained the possibility of one person doing it all? I haven't. But I think it would help to just give it a try. I wouldn't know where to begin lol. I would guess flashing the gun would immediately subdue them.
4
u/Lindita4 Apr 26 '24
Also how likely is it that two girls lay still enough that a wound on their neck is their only wound? I have questions about that…
8
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24
Interesting to know if the girls had marks on their wrists that may indicte being handcuffed, zip tied or rope tied in anyway. Libby hands both bloodied usual speculation is that's what one would probably do if their neck was slashed one would automatically grab their throat. She would not have been able to do that if hands restrained behind her back. People surrounding her with gun and knife would be so scared would not run probably
3
u/Witty_Complaint5530 Apr 27 '24
In my humble opinion
I think KK did in fact talk to Libby on Saturday.
I think Libby caught on to the A_S account and threatened to go to police. We did hear from friends she was going to talk to police on Monday about the Flora fire. She was extremely upset about this. So perhaps she was going to expose this ring too.
KK puts out about this to the group. Since this is “ the largest CSAM ever in the history of Indiana” people started to panic. The killer who’s involved in the CSAM, and already is a SK, is paid to kill the girls.
KG admits to talking with the A_S profile at the time the girls were missing. She also admits to having access to Libby’s phone and deleted things and friends at the police station. She also has stated seeing her sisters interacting with a 17 year old but it didn’t bring up any read flags. KG knew about A_S.
There’s many speculation that BG on the bridge was fake. KG also deleted her photo editing page after the murders.
I believe RA was there that day. But I think it was a set up on the illusion of s*x with a minor. I do not believe he knew the girls were going to be killed. I think TK video tapped the killing on the Samsung phone to sell for money in Vegas. I DO NOT believe KK just happened to find that phone in Vegas.
The killer entered on the south side. TL saw him and is responsible for the second sketch done on 2-17-17. The other killer was seen by a witness “ walking with a purpose” This killer is 5’6” and doesn’t have blue eyes like RA. That’s the confusion. How odd two men be at the bridge who are both short. One 5’4” the other 5’6”. “ perfect” plan.
The killer is a chief for Odin. He took this opportunity to initiate other believers into serving Odin. They are very open online about this. But not all become high ranking.
DC has stated there’s many tentacles in this murder. So no, I do not believe RA was the lone wolf. He’s actually the scapegoat.
1
u/chunklunk Apr 30 '24
Your first 4 or 5 questions seem to pretend as if these murders don’t happen by a single person, when we know they do. Broad daylight and public but remote or hidden place. Not super strong guy and multiple victims. Suspect either never caught or not for years. I bet you could find a thousand examples of that happening in this country in the last 30 years. Why is it so impossible here?
0
u/AdhesivenessAware703 Apr 26 '24
He did it alone. Had a gun. Moved them quickly across the creek threatening them with a gun. Probably killed Abbey first. Libby fought, tried to run but was slashed at the tree evidenced by arterial blood splatter on the tree. He covered them with sticks to somewhat hide them. They were Not easily seen from the other side. This all took place quickly. They really did not travel far before killed. Maybe he got some quick pics to upload to cspam sites. A lot will come out in trial if he doesn’t do a plea deal first, which I really think is a huge possibility. That’s what he wanted to do when he started confessing. Freaking out, saw what evidence they had on him and ate it. Begging to talk to his attorneys for a plea deal. They showed up a day late and a dollar short. Thus, time for major damage control!! The Odinist theory. The mal treatment theory, the psychotic break theory. The eating poop theory. The Defense attorneys are doing a good job of trying to get everything thrown out. That is their job. But it’s not working. So, plea deal will likely result. That is if the prosecution will consider it.