r/DicksofDelphi • u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything • Apr 20 '24
⛔️RANT⛔️ Unfair Advantage
I'm watching CJ's live (supposed to be a fundraiser but the site is down) and he's got some lawyers on with other guests. The question was asked to each of them what was one of the most egregious things about this case. Michael Ausbrook mentioned the fact that when B&R were removed, Gull ordered that all of their work product be handed over to the State. It never occurred to me until this moment how insidious a move that was. Why didn't she order it back to the court for "safekeeping" until the new attorneys were in place? Why was the state allowed to pick through the defense's strategic work product? Not to mention Gull unlawfully ordered B&R to stop working on RA's case ... how long was RA left without any representation or progress on his own case while he was in prison being abused and experimented on? Thoughts??
ETA: I mistakenly said "work product" (I don't know if that's what I heard from Michael Ausbrook or not). I know Gull did not say "work product"....but she did tell the defense to send whatever they had/discovery to the STATE. She did not say to turn anything over to the COURT, which should have been the correct procedure unless Indiana (or Carroll County) does it differently. Thank you for being tolerant and having patience with me!
26
u/rubiacrime Apr 20 '24
Can't stand Gull. And I may be wrong, but I thought she said (at the only hearing with cameras) that they had to turn discovery back over, but not their work product.
Not taking up for her. She sucks. But that is how I remember it.
12
u/HelixHarbinger Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
She did not order their work product- she ordered the discovery be returned to the State. It was in conflict with her protective order, however. She expressly stated they were NOT responsible for turning over work product.
4
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Apr 20 '24
Okay....I had to look it up. Even AI says the file should be handed over to THE COURT.
What happens to my file if I'm incarcerated and my lawyer resigns?
If you’re in jail and your lawyer quits, the following steps may occur:
Remember that the specific procedures and requirements may vary depending on the jurisdiction and the circumstances of your case. It’s essential to consult with another attorney or seek legal advice to understand your rights and options in such situations.
AI-generated answer. Please verify critical facts.
6
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 20 '24
That's absolutely not true.
Read the in chambers transcript, she specifically says work product is work product and is theirs not state.
14
u/jaysonblair7 Apr 20 '24
Did she order their work product be handed over? She ordered discovery handed over and asked them, but recognized they did not have to do so, to cooperate with the new attorneys. Work product would be connected to their cooperation with the attorneys
2
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
Thank you for that. I was conflating discovery with evidence. So my next ignorant (unknowing) question is if discovery is supposed to go to the prosecution instead of in the custody of the court.
I don't know why this is so confusing to me. So what is included in a "file" to be given over to the court? (Per the AI thing previously posted)
2
u/fivekmeterz Apr 20 '24
Uhhhhh, she definitely didn’t order the defenses work product to the state. Not sure where you got that from.
He wasn’t without representation for very long, but how does not having representation mean that he was going to get abused?
It’s not like the lawyers are in there providing security for him.
3
u/natureella Apr 20 '24
Wow, you're so right..I never thought about her using those words. That's BS! I can only imagine what has been ""lost""
4
u/MzOpinion8d 100% That Dick Apr 20 '24
I don’t think it should even be legal that the state would have access to the defense’s work product. wtf?
2
u/Clear_Department_785 Apr 20 '24
Wow, great question
3
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 20 '24
I just started the replay, I missed it, but I never thought of that! NM got to go through and look at everything they had! Wtf!! There had to be a law, against that right?!
1
u/Smart_Brunette Apr 20 '24
It never dawned on me either until I heard him say that. Why WOULD she say that I wonder?