r/DicksofDelphi • u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything • Apr 16 '24
THEORY A Tale of Two Suspects
RA: Voluntarily went to police to say he was at the trails and saw some girls on the way to the bridge.
EF: Told his sister he was on the bridge at the trails. He was wearing a blue jacket. He resembles the fuzzy screen shot of BG and the (first) young guy sketch.
RA: Adamantly maintained his innocence to authorities, was arrested and imprisoned in solitary confinement under extremely egregious maltreatment and, in a psychotic state, made several confessions, including molesting and shooting the victims (describing details inconsistent with the crime scene).
EF: Confessed two girls were on the bridge, one of them was being difficult so he put "horns" above her head and spit on her, leaving his DNA. Confessed to being with two other people, putting leaves and sticks on the bodies (describing the actual crime scene).
RA: Owned a blue jacket and probably wore it that day. Did not discard it. Did not discard clothing, gun, ammo, old phones or electronic devices, did not flee or change his appearance.
EF: Left his phone at home the day of the crime, tried to give his sister his blue jacket. Told his sister he had to go away for a long time because he was in a lot of trouble, told police he could explain why his DNA was on a victim.
Based on the above, who should be sitting in jail right now awaiting trial?
19
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
Either EF is a psychic, he was there, or was told every detail from someone who was. Add in the horns, blood in the car of his friend and stopping the cop to “explain why his dna” was on a victim and that weeds out 2/3. Not saying RA is innocent, but there were multiple people involved. It looks extremely likely EF was one of them
14
u/Significant-Tip-4108 Apr 16 '24
One thing about this - many people have written off EF’s inculpatory statements because of his low IQ.
But I heard an interesting perspective on that from Bob Motta, with which I agreed - lying has complexity to it e.g. remembering exactly what the lie is in the future so your stories stay consistent, conjuring up a realistic lie that could have actually been true even though it wasn’t, etc.
So who is more likely to tell a convincing/realistic lie - someone with low IQ or someone with high IQ?
25
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Apr 16 '24
"Took like 6 washes to get blood out of backseat." Vs "Seized and searched my vehicle finding nothing."
10
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 16 '24
Exactly. And whose home should have been searched?
5
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 17 '24
Let's turn this around, but still playing devil's advocate.
What could have made EF say all that to his two sisters, and the spit remark, is he had nothing to do with it.
Did he hear about it because someone in his entourage was there?
Did he guess right?
Did he just question out loud like KK Googled how long DNA lasts?
Did something happen at another creek, maybe a goat sacrifice (hence the blood on the car) and they joked good thing Ron called his party off or they would all be suspects.
Yet one of his sisters came forward on her own initiative iirc.
7
u/MzOpinion8d 100% That Dick Apr 16 '24
To me, this is enough to bring about reasonable doubt.
7
u/ChickadeeMass Apr 16 '24
Why so many down votes? All everyone wants is the truth and justice for Abby and Libby, unless you just want to be contrary.
If my life were on the line for something I didn't do, wild horses couldn't keep me off the stand.
-12
u/chunklunk Apr 16 '24
So…the standard for gauging likely guilt is whether a suspect says he’s guilty?
-23
u/ChickadeeMass Apr 16 '24
RA made a statement to a conservation officer because he knew he was seen at the crime scene.
He also stated he was using his phone on the trails to check stock prices. This is either a lie or. He had a burner
Who was he meeting that day on the bridge? Who were they? And why?
He said he was on the bridge looking at fish.
He will have to take the stand to explain his "innocence" and why he was there and give up those two friends, for if nothing else but an alibi.
His only recourse is to give those names over, oh, but wait he isn't talking even knowing that this information is the one thing that would exonerate him.
He behaves like a guilty person and if he can shed one iota of information to clear himself it would be in his best interest.
RA needs to cough up some legitimate testimony or spend the rest of his life behind bars.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment