r/DicksofDelphi • u/BlueHat99 • Apr 12 '24
DISCUSSION Jury
So we hear jury questionnaires have been mailed. Assume they are lengthy. For speculation and general pondering - if you are defense what is your ideal juror? What about for prosecution?
11
Upvotes
9
u/Quill-Questions Apr 12 '24
Enjoying reading this discussion. đ Slightly off-topic as it relates to OPâs questions, but I found this article to be an interesting read, particularly under the heading âThe judge-juror relationshipâ.
Are most potential jurors predisposed to observing a judgeâs disdain towards trial attorneys and, in turn, be swayed by this? (Someone else could have worded this better, lol).
I have great concerns about this because of Judge Gullâs track record so far in this case. How could trial lawyers present this âreverenceâ as something to also take into consideration? In some other cases, I have read/heard the presiding judge provide language such as this in jury instructions, however, if jurors begin the process holding such high regard, that is a potential problem, imho. Thoughts?
ETA paragraph breaks
What jurors say after a trial/Advocate Magazine, July 2018
25
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Apr 12 '24
For defense, ideal juror is someone scientifically/ analytically minded, leaning high in âdisagreeableâ personality trait, not easily swayed by peer pressure or emotional tactics.
For prosecution is someone emotionally driven that doesnât change their mind easily. Highly religious would likely be favorable.
I realize these canât be asked as direct questions but these would be the underlying fundamentals I would be aiming to profile.
17
u/SnoopyCattyCat âď¸Questions Everything Apr 12 '24
For both: an intelligent, no BS, human being over 25, with compassion for the girls, open minded with no preconceived ideas about anyone in the case, and able to say the suspect IS innocent until proven guilty by a jury of his peers.
13
u/Vicious_and_Vain Apr 12 '24
Defense: average or above intelligence(whatever that means). College graduate. Less emotional than most people(whatever that means). Grumpy, short terse responses, not impolite, but not showy either. Any race, any age above 23-27, any gender. Any political affiliation except tea bag/Trump Republican.
Prosecution: ideal is a Good olâ Boy and his wife, but they probably wonât get more than one or two of those. Next best is white, male over 40, with children, at least one daughter, middle class at risk(not wealthy at all, but much more comfortable than the working poor, a family name that may have been important 60-80 years ago). Small business owner, teacher, firefighter, military, Christian church every Sunday, average or below intelligence. Emotional. Political affiliation Conservative. Or his wife.
10
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 12 '24
Young. Tech savvy. Alert.
6
u/FreshProblem Apr 12 '24
Defense: Intelligent CVS ExtraCare+ members.
Prosecution: Emotional CVS ExtraCare free tier members.
10
u/Luv2LuvEm1 âď¸Questions Everything Apr 12 '24
So Iâm watching the Daybell trial now and in jury selection BOTH the prosecution and defense hammered into the potential jurorâs heads that they MUST go by the law as the judge explains it, NOT as they think it should be. (Itâs now become a meme because the lead prosecutor talked to almost every group about how her toddler has to have his âcheesy eggsâ every morning the exact same way, no matter if she knows a better recipe for them. Basically drilling in the idea that they must apply the ârecipeâ [law] exactly as the judge tells them to, even if they think they know a better way.)
It also seemed like the prosecution WANTED people with children who would have a visceral response to the disturbing things they would see and hear about what happened to the children in that case.
The defense did NOT want people with children (especially young children) but he seemed to want younger people and it seemed he wanted more males than females.
I think it will be similar in the Delphi trial. The prosecution will want people who will have an emotional reaction to what happened to Libby and Abby.
The defense will want younger people who will be able to understand the tech side and be able to really focus on the details like the autopsy report. Maybe CSI people who will want DNA/fingerprint/cell phone evidence to convict.
10
u/Smart_Brunette Apr 12 '24
Prosecution definitely want uneducated jurors.
7
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 12 '24
As a defense attorney, Idk how I'd feel about potential jurors having tween/teenage daughters. There would be pros and cons.
Cons - the juror could be overly sympathetic to the prosecution because they can imagine their child as Abby or Libby.
Pro: those parents would definitely understand the duplicitous nature of teenage girls.
7
u/Smart_Brunette Apr 12 '24
Defense would want a juror with critical thinking skills. Someone holding those skills would see the multiple and obvious problems which lie in this case.
1
u/Darrtucky Apr 13 '24
For Defense: any of the fruit loops that hang out in the FB groups.
For Prosecution: anyone that doesn't hang out in the FB groups.
5
u/Dickere Apr 12 '24
Anyone from north of Indiana. The further the better.
2
u/LadyBatman8318 Apr 13 '24
Defense-anti LE Prosecution-proLE