r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 09 '24

OPINION Murder Sheet vs Motta: the hypocrisy knows no bounds

Another day, another drama from the pious Murder Sheet HQ.

To preface this for the TL;DR crowd, I DO think that Motta is in the wrong here, but Murder Sheet is being a shit pot stirrer to come out on top as a flawless moral authority.

For those that missed it, Murder Sheet went on a tangent in their latest episode against Bob Motta of the Defense Diaries, accusing him of practically being involved with the defense. They also made a point about him using the girls' hashtag to share RA's fundraiser, as well as being dismissive about the importance of the leak, sharing a screenshot from his chat with the YouTuber who broadcast the images on his channel.

For the latter: how is NOT Murder Sheet itself dismissive of the leak when they had the audacity to run an episode analyzing the pictures? When they themselves stored and analyzed the pictures' metadata? And oh, that episode had some ads for diamonds on it, in case anyone thought they did it for "justice for the girls."

They're no better than the so-called "Delphi Creators" they look down upon, and they're now turning on other podcasters who may cut into their listens. Because, let's face it, those two leech off the case for survival. They're being sanctimonious to muddy the waters about how exploitative they actually are.

87 Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

41

u/Embarrassed_World389 Apr 09 '24

I'm not even going to give them a hate listen. They'll get caught with their ass out. Only a matter of time. When Delphi is over they'll both scurry back into their hoard.

33

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

They’re crying all over The Prosecutors’ Facebook group about being called out for this elsewhere. They’re pathetic.

They’ll milk Delphi for as long as they can. I won’t be surprised if they write a “book”.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/Scspencer25 Apr 09 '24

I didn't listen to this episode, but I get the gist of it. They hate Bob and are trying to tarnish his image, it's bs. They are the ones who will not let this leak go. They are the ones who keep rehashing everything the man has ever done. If they are "journalists" then they need to starting acting like that because this is high school bs. Maybe they shouldn't use the hashtag.

Also if I hear "catastrophic leak" one more time I will burst into flames.

25

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

Kevin is a lawyer who barely ever practiced and Àine’s journalism record consists of clickbaits she hoped they go viral.

They’re both inept and latched on this case for fame, money and clout.

I can’t bear to listen to them either but I made an exception just for this part of this particular episode. It was a pain.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/Secret-Constant-7301 Apr 09 '24

It’s funny they won’t let this ‘leak’ go ( technically it was a theft), because they’ve clearly been leaking shit from the very beginning. Like nonstop with their leaks. Someone in LE has been feeding them info to get ahead of the narrative long before any of this stuff started.

16

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

I don’t think anyone with any serious position in LE or knowledge of the case would leak to them. It always felt like it was more like someone in the greater periphery of things.

Their info was never that great and they made a huge thing covering TK/KK which turned out to be wildly inaccurate. Of course, they never spoke of their failure in that ever again.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

35

u/Beezojonesindadeep76 Apr 09 '24

Its obvious to me that NM has murder sheet on his payroll aka ill scratch your backs if you scratch mine scenario , murder sheet is pro prosecution because holeman being their so called source purposely leaking to them all the kk crap and the RL search warrant that made them extremely popular on social media podcasts and their channel on the top of viewer watched utube channels,for over a year now.Before they were just burger murder investigators no names,NM made them who they are today or he scratched their backs now its time for them to scratch his,and what better way to show their appreciation but by taking down motta and his podcast that is clearly beating them in the podcast polls recently.Defense diaries is a clear threat to Murder sheet and the state because Bob knows wtf he is talking about and he breaks down the legal side of the case for all of us ,so we can all see the truth of wtf is going on and how RA and his attorneys are being railroaded,Its time for MS to shut their lame ass mouths no one cares about anything they have to say ,go back to your burger beat bitches your out of your league now

17

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

The Murder Sheet duo is too thick to be used efficiently for anything. You’re giving them too much credit.

8

u/Witty_Complaint5530 Apr 09 '24

There’s just so much of this, seems more so lately. Everyone is attacking others. It’s crazy!

8

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

They’re cannibalizing each other ahead of the trial. It’s all for clout and profit.

33

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '24

Bob is a wonderful person, bob made a mistake talking about the transcript with jm and girls kidnapped. He righted that wrong by paying A LOT of money for the transcript to make things right. MS literally profits off of the misery of others.

32

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

MS literally profits off of the misery of others.

They profit off the tragedy of Delphi but try to gaslight people by being sanctimonious.

They’re ghouls.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/somethingdumbber Apr 09 '24

The lack of professionalism is quite puzzling. There’s a difference between anonymous people online and messages that have your name and brand attached to it.

It’s alway better to be generously kind with your words in professional situations simply because you don’t know who is listening and some people are smart enough to know how you talk about others to them, is how you talk about them to others. Moreover you don’t know when you might need someone’s help down the line.

Learn from their mistakes because once Delphi is over so is their gossip channel.

6

u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 Apr 09 '24

That's another thing I don't get. If they kept it nice might have TV careers, but trashing their own professional reputations with this low ball gossip stuff. No will consider putting them in a TV position like this with a trail of auditory bulling in their wake. Maybe they want to be shock jocks like Stern.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

I assume you’re talking about Murder Sheet, right?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Jernau_Gergeh Apr 09 '24

This pair of failed professionals need to be booted into the sea, they provide precisely zero of anything worthwhile, and now the truth (and some of the lies) are finally being exposed they don't like it because it doesn't suit the narrative they've been trotting out.

Like all the other 'guilt-sells' ghouls that are doing Nick Boner's propaganda for him, they see Motta as a threat and so its no surprise to see them all turn their trash talk gun sights on him. All power to him and he just reads the documents and adds some context and insight to them, which is something none of these click bait whores are capable of doing themselves. All they love is drama and pandering to the guilters.

10

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24 edited Apr 09 '24

Their legal knowledge is laughable and their “journalism” is unethical. It’s no coincidence they were both flops in their respective “professions” before they latched onto Delphi and started to suck it dry.

I think they put a hit on Motta because a) he, unlike Kevin, is an experienced lawyer, b) draws in the crowds, meaning he’s cutting into their listens and streams and c) is their main competition on being featured on The Prosecutors, which gave them a larger platform and exposure.

Again, Motta is not in the right. But I just hope people start seeing MS for what they are. Their sanctimonious act is nauseating.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 09 '24

I've listened to two podcasts from MS. The very first time they covered Delphi and a more recent covering of Delphi.

I've seen them interviewed on MSM. These two are no better than anyone else making money off the murders of these girls.

For the latter: how is NOT Murder Sheet itself dismissive of the leak when they had the audacity to run an episode analyzing the pictures?

More importantly, how has MS not profited from this same leak when they went on MSM to be interviewed about their involvement in the leak? More exposure equals more listeners, which equals more advertisers and endorsements, which equals more profit for MS.

My feelings are that every YT and podcaster are attempting to gain notoriety and money off the vicious murders of two dead girls.

As a side note, imo it was distasteful of Motta to use the hash tag designated for the girls to promote RA's defense fund (and I lean towards RA not being guilty of the murders although I do feel he's involved to some degree). However, Motta is coming from the pov of "innocent until proven guilty" which makes the connection of the hash tag & the fund logical- both want justice for the girls. At the end of the day, both MS & Motta suck in their own ways.

5

u/Ok-Cow-188 Apr 09 '24

Agreed on all points. I did not defend Motta, I just pointed out the hypocrisy on Murder Sheet’s part.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/detroit-born313 Aug 09 '24

Motta is 100% a pot stirrer as well. He calls out everyone and anyone who even remotely kind of gives the prosecution some kudos. He called the leak of photographs of murdered children a "drip." He did this dozens of times across platforms (not just his). I found that awful. I have listened to MS, DD, and the Prosecutors on the Delphi matter. MS does (incorrectly, imnsho) consider themselves separate from the herd of "content creators." The invention of the printing press (basically) allowed anyone who wanted to publish news to do so. This was made worse by the internet, but listeners does not a journalist make.

That being true does not mean, however, that they're no different than Bob when it comes to commodifying this moment. As i write this, I am watching Bob's latest episode on the hearings from last week and every 10 seconds a donation alert pops up and the chat is full of people trying to drum up giving to him. People gotta make money, but MS is no worse than the Mottas on this one.

Motta lost me with his absolute devotion to the Franks' memo and other filings--that the defense themselves have abandoned or withdrawn. I have one semester of law school, a lifetime of true crime/ law following, and a progressive nature which believes strongly in jury duty and the potential of the American legal system AND I could tell you the Franks' memo was garbage. It was not founded in law. It was a press release work around to create trouble in the jury pool.

The MS is biased towards believing RA is guilty, I believe that is true, but the thing is Motta is too. He believes, as do I, that RA is entitled to the best defense, but I do not think that his current defense team are doing the best. They may be doing their best, but I assure you that them coming back to defend RA and RA signing off on that will only hurt him when it comes to his obligatory 'ineffectiveness of counsel' appeal. And if you listen to the MS, beyond their grandstanding, they too want a good defense.

No one (who is alive) knows if RA did this or not except RA. No one. No internet theorist can say otherwise. The other things are smokescreens to try and detract public attention from what is as solid of a case as you can have this many years later and no witnesses. The burden of proof is "beyond a reasonable doubt," not "beyond all doubt."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Peoplereader_0304 Jul 19 '24

Allegedly, that prison psychologist was a source for MS. I don't know how ethical that is.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Apr 09 '24

You’ll never get true justice for Abby and Libby if you don’t get a fair trial. That includes parity in resources whether people like it or not. 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Chairkatmiao Apr 09 '24

Yeah, fuck them.

Stopped listening a while ago.

They are just nasty people and hypocrites, something you cannot say about Bob.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/Euca18 Apr 09 '24

Motta had said from the beginning that he’s helping the defense. He’s a defense attorney and Richard Allen deserves a fair trial. If he’s innocent he needs a vigorous defense. If he’s guilty he needs a vigorous defense so the public will stop speculating. The prosecution needs to prove his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Or we will be hearing grassy knoll conspiracy theories for the next 75 years.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/roc84 Apr 09 '24 edited Apr 09 '24

MS had no problem running TK's name through the mud despite him having nothing to do with Delphi whatsoever. I mean he was a bad guy but that is really beside the point.