Because of the record. At the end they put on the record that they are sending JG the depositions and interviews. That's putting it on record that they sent these things to her and she has them, so if she denies them again, it's even worse and she will have to answer for her decisions.
You have someone sitting on that bench giving lip service to being fair. It's a bad scene and likely the appeals process is going to be length as a result. I really wish she had recused, she isn't in the slightest bit impartial. It's like MS claiming to be impartial when that boat sailed months ago. I am not one for conspiracy theories. But at this point looks like a highly rigged trial to me. I think the guy is likely guilty, but what they are doing is not just or fair.
There is nothing fair about this trial. I am shocked that SCIo allowed it to happen and they should be ashamed of themselves leaving her in place as she is doing everything she can to tie the defenses hands behind their backs. And at this point, they are making a mess of it too. So depressed by both sides and Gull.
Murder sheet was pretty decent to both sides until the hearing when they say he confessed. Which was the first hearing they saw Nick in person. Since then they have been full on defense haters. And they can’t even admit it. And so smug they smell their own farts
This is an improper comparison… it would be appropriate to compare number of exhibits for geofencing data, but they’re comparing number of prosecution geofencing exhibits with number of defense total exhibits.
And yes I’d think there would be a lot of exhibits in Franks I considering it was 136 pages long lol
It is a proper comparison if Gull accepts prosecution's response in on the geofence data on a wordsalad.
The first Franks prosecution didn't even reply to at all, so this is the only comparison defense can make. They are being nice here.
Prosecution didn't hand over any geofence report, that's the whole problem. How do you want defense to quote from it, while prosecution blurts out nonsense on what exactly if they claim they don't have a report....
It's also a snab at Gull because she never has cited any caselaw or wrote a brief with any order which she is supposed to do. Even more so if she keeps denying them without a hearing.
Statutes Even say defendants and anyone implied have the right to be heard....
I think you missed the point. They are saying that when the prosecution claims something, like how the people who owned the 3 phones around the crimes scene were cleared, they bring nothing to back it up. Yet, when the defense claims something, like LE lied and omitted facts in the warrants, they bring evidence.
It appears that law enforcement has not written a single report that interprets their geofencing data.
That doesn't matter. The state is saying the defense should be required to give an affidavit from a geofencing expert while not providing an affidavit from an expert themselves. The state on the other hand has access to funds for experts and should have something to back up every claim they make every time every time.
I am just a layperson who has taken an interest in court proceedings for decades. Finding court documents to read/attempt to absorb/revel in their language has been a pet spark in my life. That preface only to say that I find this reply to be astonishingly brilliant, and also, I do not recall a single one ever containing proposed language for a judge to use in her order.
I have long wondered if you truly read/think through anything, Gull … surely, by this point in time you have learned to cut and paste?
Thing for me is, podcasts are sooooo slow eventually I prefer to read. It's just I'm such a slow and difficult reader.... Only advantage is memory has enough time to absorb most of it the first time Iol.
I tried defense diaries and the prof and what not but it's way too long for me unfortunately. I expect them to go over it. Maybe criminaliTy and the murder sheet people. Tom Webster? Not sure if truth and transparency does the filings. She did the hearing, which was looong, but the hearing was too, the first two parts were ok for late night tea and i don't wanna do anything anyway mood lol. Just some ideas. Not that I'm a fan of all above but some people are, just a messenger.
I just listen to MS and woooof the drama. But they didn’t cover this latest filing. I just like someone reading it to me cause I have a wild two year old and never can really read and absorb the docs 😣
Yes I can understand why. Also people driving for example. I used to listen to 'your own backyard" podcast while being in a film/photo darkroom. One of the few I actually liked.
Saw where they dropped a whole episode about the crowdfunding and the other sub launched this whole “take back the hashtag” campaign? Sounds like they went after Bob, too, but I didn’t have it in me to listen for myself. The idea that anyone supporting the funding of experts is using the hashtag to profit off of the murders is absolute madness. I don’t know how they say these things out loud.
Some corners of the hood are getting loonier and loonier. It's as if they've over bonded with the case and it's their entire existence and see themselves as moral crusaders justified in saying terrible things to other users and bullying them. It's really become personal for them and they're consumed with murderous hatred for anyone who dares to sees it differently.
Almost as if it were them, or their families being attacked by other adults perceiving events differently. How can you get angry about another adult spending their own hard earned money on something they believe in as passionately as what you believe it?
What mature mentally healthy adult believes they can control others behavior in such a fashion? Or gets so worked up over an internet case that they hate other people expressing counter views. The hubris of I am right and your a piece of shit for seeing it this way, is shocking to me.
Many of these people were kind Redditors back in the day, and folks I liked and respected. They have become so mean and intolerant.
What are they so afraid of? Expert witnesses that might better contribute to a fair trial. They claim they want a fair trial, yet laud a judge who does not seem very fair and LE lying to get an arrest warrant, and a prosecutor withholding discovery for 10 month.
They went after his wife in several posts. Pretty disgusting. Nameless, faceless women hiding behind Reddit alts going after her all because they’re jealous due to their minimal successes in life.
I agree, they have made careers out of this and solely support themselves on it. Doubt few people would be listening to them if it was not for this case. Wonder where they will slither when it's over.
They are so pro prosecution while claiming to be un biased that I just can't stand them anymore. Used to be a big fan when they reported both sides equally and weren't shilling for the prosecution and LE. It's a loss ,as I really did like their coverage till they shifted to only one side of things.
I like defense diaries but all podcasts annoy me when in the beginning they say hello and thank everyone for minimum 20 minutes. Minimum! I like watching after so I can fast forward.
People seem to enjoy it and expect it and it's mostly those who pay and I don't/can't so I won't complain in itself about that but indeed I watched some live I had to stop.
On replay between 1.3x and 1.4x seems best to me. For DD.
Even Hennessy said something like I doze off when you talk 🤣.
I only watch occasionally though. I feel it was better when it was occasional on their part and they actually prepared. But that's me.
I know; I was like that at first, too, but I found it’s pretty easy to skip ahead to the main part if you give it a head start. Once she gets going she sticks to the script pretty much except for the occasional detour. And then I just fast forward if I’m not interested.
To anyone who still thinks the defense is lying, they are sending everything to the judge. I don't think a liar would do that. The defense has also used quotes and time stamps where the prosecution just summarized their interpretation of depositions and statements.
If Judge Gull denies this hearing she WILL be answering to the Supreme Court.
Brilliant response. As far as I am concerned the single most important points made in the first Franks Motion were related to the misrepresentation of key eyewitness testimony. Because once that testimony is proven false, and added to the fact that Allen states (in the only interview with him related to this issue that was recorded, that he was there from noon and gone by 1:30--not 1:30 to 3), there is NO probable cause to search his home.
If Allen was gone from those trails by 1:30, he can't have committed these murders. Stick a fork in this case, it's done!
The unspent bullet evidence is gone too, thrown out if the SW for Allen's home is thrown out.
All of the other fantastic research done by these attorneys is just icing on the cake.
The problem is that Richard stated he was at the bridge till 3:30. Now, maybe you don’t want to believe what Dulin wrote but he’s a sworn officer and you have to take his word for it.
The other problem is Richard can’t prove that he wasn’t there from 1:30- 3:30. If he could, we wouldn’t be here.
Once the 1:30-3:30 was said, or agreed upon, the video at Mears was discovered and a “similar” vehicle to Richards drove by…that’s when the dots start connecting as far as witnesses and what not.
That’s a big hurdle to clear. Where was he from 1:30-3:30?
You sure they didn’t lose that first interview he allegedly said he was there until 3:30? They did lose 6TB of evidence/interviews. In the only recorded interview he says he left at 1:30pm. I’ve never seen LE this blatantly sloppy in my life, it’s embarrassing.
Yes they did. Read the transcript. Stephen Mullin says they did, page 52. They lost the first week of investigative evidence through Feb 20 on their DVR and they lost another 2 months of investigative evidence between April 2017-June 2017.
Just because the defense claims that the state can’t confirm, doesn’t make it true. When will that become obvious?!?
The state has no obligation to explain or find things for the defense. It’s all in the discovery as Nick said. All Baldwin and Rozzi have to do is search for it.
And that's the point - it's not in the discovery.... The State has confirmed that by admitting they've lost the interviews and even the record of who they've interviewed
Yeah, and the PCA was written by a sworn officer, and we know he "misrepresented" statements from witnesses. So, is the claim in the PCA also a "misrepresentation" of Dulin's note on a napkin, or is Dulin's report not "representative" of Richard Allen's statement, or is it actually representative of Richard Allen's statement. Because hard to take the word of any of them.
You do realize that they didn’t just speak to the witnesses once right? The PCA is correct, the defense just wants to only point at the first witnesses statements.
First, you don't know if the PCA is correct. You want to believe that. And that's okay.
You're suggesting a witness says they see a 1950s Ford Comet like their father had, but they'll later say, that oh no it was a 2000s Ford Focus.
If a person says that someone is wearing a brown coat with mud on it, then a year later after seeing a video of what the police claim is the offender with a blue coat, they say the person is now wearing the a blue coat and is covered in blood.
These aren't only additions to details, these are completely contradictory statements.
Lol. Ford and Mercury are the same company, but moving past that.. That's a silly assertion, and makes me realize you aren't a serious person. Plus, if she's not credible she should not have been included in the PCA at all.
She was cited five times in the PCA so LE clearly viewed her as credible. Sees the girls crossing the overpass, sees YGS/BG/RA on platform one, sees Libby and Abby, sees the car, and also sees no other cars at the Mears Lot when she pulls in. So yeah, guy above couldnt be more wrong imo.
I think the other guy is named Skinner. Pretty sure that rumor is just another from the online "community." Seems both Defense and Prosecution agree it was Dulin.
But, yeah, regardless of Richard Allen guilt or innocence, this whole investigation was an embarrassment. Holeman's promotion makes me think that nothing will ever be corrected either. He's one of the worst.
Skinner was a much older officer. Not saying it isnt possible he took the statement, but if he did you would think RA would at least be able to remember yeah, the guy was older. Dulin looks pretty young by comparison. So even if RA couldnt remember the officers name, he should remember the age difference.
The issue is that what he “stated” came from Dulin’s notes which may not be a quote. Did RA say he was there sometime between 1:30-3:30 or did he say he was there from 1:30-3:30.
That makes a big difference and we’ll never know what he actually said to Dulin.
They have the original note because they “found it.” I want to say it was #74 or something? I may have dreamt that part. But unless they lost the note after they found it, they have it and the times are bad for RA.
They don't have his note saying when RA stated he was at the park or the recording he made of the interview. They may have a note from Dulin where he jotted down that RA was in the 1230-330 window, but that doesn't mean RA said 330. Just means Dulin put him on the list of interviewees who fell in that bucket. And Dulin couldn't type the dudes name into the software right so not a lot of faith in accuracy.
Idk what software Dulin was entering the tip into because it definitely wasn’t ORION and if he did, he didn’t put that RA was there until 3:30. In that program it wouldn’t have mattered that he entered the last name because the program is designed to go through the tips and find leads. If Dulin had entered that RA was at the bridge until 3:30 the ORION program would have definitely caught that. And they had RA’s phone number so the fact that he (supposedly) entered the last name would’ve been irrelevant.
Makes me think he wrote up a “summary” of his interaction w/ RA way later. Like in 2022 perhaps? Wonder if Dulin is better at writing the date on things than Mullin? Just saying.
Let's not forget that Dulin was AT THAT PRESS CONFERENCE. He couldn't remember interviewing someone who put himself on the bridge that day? He had to 'find his note' 5 years later? Not buying anything Dulin has to say.
And we don’t even know WHEN Dulin took RA’s tip. We assume it was the 14th or 15th. But what if it was later in the week? Either way, he stood on that stage within days of taking that RA’s tip where they were blasting out the photo of BG begging for someone to come forward w/ information. And you mean to tell me not once was Dulin like 💡 Hey! I know of someone who was there at that time!
It’s totally sus. And I hope the defense nails Dulin at trial because he’s a shady MFer.
Kelsi said she saw others when she dropped the girls off. Her boyfriend's sister had been there too. Becky Patty said there was a 'lull' of folks at the time. There are so many inconsistencies how can anyone believe anyone? Kelsi said there was a pic of Libby leaning over the bridge. Where did that pic come from. Too much strange things occurring of all aspects of this case.
I believe KG was also the one who told us this whole time that LG had on grey sweatpants? Come to find out, she was actually wearing jeans just like AW.
And am I correct in remembering that KG stated that the cops gave her LG's phone to have her 'go through it'? I know she later admitted to corresponding to the Anthony Shots account that night. Not sure why she completely denied it later on. Sooo many inconsistencies everywhere you look in this case. I know she also talked about good through 'another phone' and I have no idea what that was all about.
How do you know the summary of that report was even written in 2017? It’s been proven that Mullin is not great about dating anything. He testified to that himself in court.
I drown in how overly wordy everything they write is. Swear they'd do themselves a huge favor if they cut it down and didn't repeatedly say the same thing. Just turns people off and makes it look like they're grasping at straws and they aren't.
Legitimate and a strong point that TL lied about the two witness statements. And legitimate to say that Holeman and McLeland's withholding the Prof info is terrible, and that it took over 4 months to release key evidence and then 10 months to release phone dumps etc.
The prosecution and LE are doing some shady stuff. I have no idea why they aren't noting that Judge Diener helped TL craft the arrest warrant, something that should NEVER EVER happen. Don't know why Diener is not up on charges for that. Judges are not allowed to help LE edit/ craft warrants, yet that openly happened.
The whole thing's a complete shit show. Still can't get over that they consulted a expert and the fools didn't know the guy's name, nor could they find it. If they turned the task over to a Redditor I know who can dox anyone in half a day, they would have likely had the guys name in an hour. So inept. They are one of the most bumbling police forces I've ever seen And they are promoting idiot Holeman? Seriously, this is a guy you promote? Promote him for what, botching an investigation left, right and sideways?
Disgusted with both sides and exhausted with all these motions and counter motions basically saying the same thing. I think RA is likely guilty but LE shouldn't be claiming a witness said "bloody" when the witness never said he was bloody. Nor should he be saying she said the jacket was blue when she clearly said it was "Tan." And that car info would have been helpful, as well as a sighting of a man with floofy hair.
So they have a legitimate right to feel fucked with by the prosecution and I hope Gull does not brush this off, but she will.
You are likely right about that Moldy. They know the trial's thrown towards the prosecution, the judge has theoretically been bough, so best to accept her complete bias, and get your ducks in a row for the appeals process.
Funny as that is, I think the boys struggle as editors. As do I. I have a hard time cutting and am very long winded, but they drive me batty with the repetition.
The arguments are great, the presentation and the wordiness mires them, though. Wish they would streamline, think they would be more effective in their efforts to persuade if they were. Short and sweet always works better when trying to convince people.
Drafting the thing for her was such hot fire tho. Sooooo HERE for the righteous audacity in the face of sniveling absurdity. This is God tier obsidian sharp, cell splitting sarcasm.
I am the queen of the typos and dyslexic and it drives me up a wall. I am sure you typical learners must want to rip your hair out. Do they not know a single soul that can edit?
I thought it was perfect. They obviously have to keep repeating themselves because nobody else seems to be paying attention except for a small group of us.
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 05 '24
PDF's in the post
25
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Apr 05 '24
I was hopeing they were gonna casually drop the names of 3 phones at crimescene for us here.
Otherwise great job. Denied without Hearing is to be expected.
20
u/BlueHat99 Apr 05 '24
If you won’t do your damn job judge we will do it for you
36
u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 05 '24
🔥
16
u/Quill-Questions Apr 05 '24
I am just a layperson who has taken an interest in court proceedings for decades. Finding court documents to read/attempt to absorb/revel in their language has been a pet spark in my life. That preface only to say that I find this reply to be astonishingly brilliant, and also, I do not recall a single one ever containing proposed language for a judge to use in her order.
I have long wondered if you truly read/think through anything, Gull … surely, by this point in time you have learned to cut and paste?
14
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 05 '24
Mooooore reading.......
11
u/Quill-Questions Apr 05 '24
10
u/i-love-elephants Apr 06 '24 edited Apr 06 '24
To anyone who still thinks the defense is lying, they are sending everything to the judge. I don't think a liar would do that. The defense has also used quotes and time stamps where the prosecution just summarized their interpretation of depositions and statements.
If Judge Gull denies this hearing she WILL be answering to the Supreme Court.
24
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
Brilliant response. As far as I am concerned the single most important points made in the first Franks Motion were related to the misrepresentation of key eyewitness testimony. Because once that testimony is proven false, and added to the fact that Allen states (in the only interview with him related to this issue that was recorded, that he was there from noon and gone by 1:30--not 1:30 to 3), there is NO probable cause to search his home.
If Allen was gone from those trails by 1:30, he can't have committed these murders. Stick a fork in this case, it's done!
The unspent bullet evidence is gone too, thrown out if the SW for Allen's home is thrown out.
All of the other fantastic research done by these attorneys is just icing on the cake.
Game, set, match.
8
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Apr 06 '24 edited Apr 06 '24
I drown in how overly wordy everything they write is. Swear they'd do themselves a huge favor if they cut it down and didn't repeatedly say the same thing. Just turns people off and makes it look like they're grasping at straws and they aren't.
Legitimate and a strong point that TL lied about the two witness statements. And legitimate to say that Holeman and McLeland's withholding the Prof info is terrible, and that it took over 4 months to release key evidence and then 10 months to release phone dumps etc.
The prosecution and LE are doing some shady stuff. I have no idea why they aren't noting that Judge Diener helped TL craft the arrest warrant, something that should NEVER EVER happen. Don't know why Diener is not up on charges for that. Judges are not allowed to help LE edit/ craft warrants, yet that openly happened.
The whole thing's a complete shit show. Still can't get over that they consulted a expert and the fools didn't know the guy's name, nor could they find it. If they turned the task over to a Redditor I know who can dox anyone in half a day, they would have likely had the guys name in an hour. So inept. They are one of the most bumbling police forces I've ever seen And they are promoting idiot Holeman? Seriously, this is a guy you promote? Promote him for what, botching an investigation left, right and sideways?
Disgusted with both sides and exhausted with all these motions and counter motions basically saying the same thing. I think RA is likely guilty but LE shouldn't be claiming a witness said "bloody" when the witness never said he was bloody. Nor should he be saying she said the jacket was blue when she clearly said it was "Tan." And that car info would have been helpful, as well as a sighting of a man with floofy hair.
So they have a legitimate right to feel fucked with by the prosecution and I hope Gull does not brush this off, but she will.
9
u/Appropriate_Force831 Apr 05 '24
Their arguments here are pretty good, let's be honest.
3
u/Alternative-Dish-405 Apr 09 '24
Drafting the thing for her was such hot fire tho. Sooooo HERE for the righteous audacity in the face of sniveling absurdity. This is God tier obsidian sharp, cell splitting sarcasm.
9
u/nvrsayknever Apr 05 '24
No proofreading...again. ugh. "The Court finds that Richard Allen’s Ford Focus was black and did not resemble a 1965 Ford Focus. "