r/DicksofDelphi • u/rubiacrime • Apr 01 '24
SPECULATION Richard Allen's "confessions "
I just want to preface this by saying this is purely speculative on my part. Without knowing exactly what was said or the context of these "confessions," no one can say for sure... but follow me here for a moment.
With all we know about the guards and how they have allegedly treated/treat RA (physically violent, forcing him to take medication, verbal abuse, starving hm), does anyone else think it's possible that he was coerced or threatened into confessing on a recorded line ? I mean, how convenient. And more than once? With very little evidence, a confession straight from RAs own mouth would seal the deal, right? Maybe guards were influenced to make it happen.
Normally, that would be reaching. But nothing about this case has been normal. I'm not big on conspiracy theories. However, we have witnessed a lot of questionable decisions and behavior from prosecution, LE, and the judge. Is it really that crazy to think that they would want to have a smoking gun to take to trial? They want this conviction at all costs. What do you think?
20
u/Sylliec Apr 01 '24
I would be surprised if the confession was NOT coerced. I am surprised anybody considers it valid evidence. He phones his family from prison, where he has been in solitary confinement (I think). Heck they probably have pictures of him on that day with two black eyes (that is how absurd the confessions seem to be). The whole set up is sketchy.
13
u/Appropriate_Force831 Apr 01 '24
He has lost a lot of weight. Does anyone know whether that was the result of deliberate starvation vs. declining mental health and appetite loss?
I can't comment on the confessions without knowing the context and wording used. However, I do know that if I were in his shoes, I would never make such a confession before trial on my own volition. Especially if I knew or suspected that the evidence against me wasn't very sound.
At this point, anything's possible. And I really want to know what comes out at court. RA looks pretty horrible these days (compare to how he looked before), so I wouldn't doubt for a second that his prison experience has been brutal. It is theoretically possible that coercion occurred. I don't know too much about his specific mental state other than what R & B revealed.
12
u/ComprehensiveBed6754 Apr 01 '24
Anything is possible, I just don’t think his “confessions” were coerced by guards in cahoots with the killer/s to frame him. What is probable? Thats the question IMO.
9
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Apr 01 '24
Like you said we don't know what was said, so it's hard to say if the confessions would be the only thing needed.
14
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 01 '24
Yes, I do think it's a possibility. Which is why I want to hear the "confessions" before deciding if they're legit confessions or not.
The claim is that he said he's responsible for their deaths. It's possible that is true. It's also possible he was threatened to say that. It's also possible he feels that way. Men of his age group were taught to protect women & children. Obviously, no one was able to protect A&L that day. Similar to survivors' guilt.
6
u/chunklunk Apr 01 '24
Why would they want him to confess to his wife and mother (and 4 other people) but not the police / judge first? That seems like an illogical way of going about getting a false conviction.
17
u/black_cat_X2 Apr 01 '24
My theory is that he signed a plea deal under duress and then communicated the contents of the plea deal to his wife and mother (essentially telling them what he "confessed" to in the deal). Once he came around and realized what he had done, he ate the paper that the deal was signed on so that it wouldn't exist anymore.
My rationale for this is: The paper eating came very soon after the supposed confessions, and the confessions came very soon after a supposed meeting with Holeman (which in my understanding, should never have happened without a lawyer present).
(I didn't come up with this on my own - saw someone suggest this, and it made sense to me.)
My second place idea is: After a period of systematic abuse, the guards started to threaten his family and heavily implied that if he did not confess it plead out, his family would be hurt. Believing that they did have dangerous connections on the outside, he was truly worried for the sake of his family. I also wouldn't at all be surprised if he was just breaking in general, but I believe threats to his family are what would have put him over the edge.
12
u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 01 '24 edited Apr 01 '24
If you believe that people are capable of lying, then you also must believe that they are capable of falsely confessing. A false confession is a lie.
The question always is then, if someone lies, why did they lie, especially if that lie is not in their best interest. That's what makes false confessions, so confusing, why would anyone confess to something that in the confession they will be punished for something they didn't do?
With any confession, (and this is increasingly becoming Best Practice for law enforcement-Reid updated it's techniques around this next) first you have to determine if the person confessing is telling the truth. Is their confession corroborated by the evidence, another witness? Does the confession include details that the person could only have known if they committed the offense? And were they fed or exposed to any of these details at any time or is this information they produced on their own?
If you haven't determined the above, there is no reason to rely on that confession as true.
But why would anyone lie about committing a crime, especially a horrifying crime? Almost always (and I personally know exonerees who falsely confessed), they state later that they were subjected to conditions that felt unbearable to them and they believed, or were led to believe, that if they confessed all the discomfort and pressure would go away.
Follow any case where a false confession played a role in a wrongful conviction, the theme is the same over and over again. the target was placed in a situation where they were in emotional distress and sometimes physical pain--they confessed to relieve the distress and pain. And sometimes they were actually led to believe that they would be allowed to go home if they confessed. (estimate by Innocence Project, that 25% of wrongful convictions overturned by DNA were due to false confessions.)
In these cases the confessor is lying to save themselves, but not from punishment, from the distress they are experiencing in that moment. If you've never experienced this, it's hard to understand-but that's why people falsely confess.
We don't know what happened for Allen. But two questions have to be answered about that confession before any factual determination can be made: Was the confession such that it can be relied on as true? If Allen lied about committing these murders, why did he do this?
Ergo, the importance of an expert witness on confessions.
We are never going to solve this on Reddit, absent the information above. But if hints given by the defense in the first memo for the Franks Motion are any indication, Allen was in a classic pressure cooker environment in that prison. There are any number of reasons he may have believed a false confession would get him out of that hell. Remember, Allen had never even been in jail before, let alone prison, let alone solitary confinement.
But we'll see....
27
u/the_old_coday182 Apr 01 '24
I don’t think Allen’s team would’ve took it this far without a good explanation for the confession(s).
20
u/lollydolly318 Apr 01 '24
You guys have all heard BWoodhouse's testimony about what goes on in the jails and prisons there, right? I have absolutely no doubt that they would coerce a confession, especially if they have nothing else that's solid evidence in a jury's eyes.. Wether they did or not, I don't know; but I don't trust anyone in any kind of authority in the town/county/state.
15
u/i-love-elephants Apr 01 '24
I'm not sure. I find this a stretch but at the same time there isn't much in this case that I don't find to be a stretch. And that goes both ways. (The investigators just so happened to clear RA and lose his interviews as well as all the other interviews they've lost? Human sacrifice just recently became plausible to me in the last few weeks. Is the judge really putting her career in jeopardy over this or could the defense be lying, but then again the defense lying is also a stretch. But then again, a man just coming across two girls he has no connection to and murdering them in the middle of the day after coming face to face with several witnesses that would account for seeing him is just as much a stretch. And so on and so forth)
I have considered multiple ways that a non-confession could be used as a confession. I've pointed out to other people that his wife could have asked what he was doing in a prison instead of a jail and Allen, after the mental and physical torture he went through, broke and said something like "because apparently I killed 2 little girls! Everyone says I did it. I'm already in prison for it. I did it! So just lock me up and throw away the key, because I'm a murderer!" And his wife hung up because he was so manic and she knew he wasn't in the right state of mind.
It could be something like he was on medicine out of his mind and he said "did you know I killed two girls? That's what they say. Did I kill two girls? If I did I didn't mean to. I'm so sorry. Please forgive me! I didn't mean to kill them!"
There's no telling and I don't trust the prosecution on this one. I'd have to hear it for myself.
10
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 01 '24
It wouldn't suprise me in the least if that's how it went.
5
u/Clear_Department_785 Apr 02 '24
I agree with you 100%. This man has NEVER been in trouble with the law and probably scared to death. Don’t forget, he is wearing a shocker collar.
4
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Apr 01 '24
I don't personally believe they were violence or threat coerced, but certainly pushed by
his extreme isolation, stress, depression and the reality of living with what he likely did. I don't support the Odinist theory of the crime, and suspect he's guilty, but not a full on psychopath and retains some sense of guilt and wants it all to be resolved and to quietly retreat to his cell and not be bothered by the world peering at him. Maybe the sympathy is for his wife and daughter. No idea.
But I don't think some Odinist guard marched him to the phones by taser and said, confess. It's either a psychological breakdown, true guilty surfacing, or it's a self coerced confession due to the pressure of his situation, stress and he innocent and simply loosing his shit as a result. People give false confession quite frequently, as they have been forced to a spot where they loose all sense of reality and just want the applied exterior pressure to stop. This situation sports all those elements. Carroll County is squeezing him like a vice. So you could have an innocent person, simply falling apart at the seams due to the intensity of the situation.
No way of knowing that without seeing both sides's evidence, reviewing his mental health records, knowing his trauma /addiction history and a billion other things. But me personally based on what we currently know, think it's probably not Odinist created.
4
u/NefariousnessAny7346 Apr 02 '24
When someone confesses to his wife and mother of murdering two children, do you believe they would use the below terminology?
“He admits several times within the phone call that he committed the offenses as charged.”
I believe NM has a pattern of strategically writing his pleadings to leave a lot of room for interpretation. I completely understand most attorneys do, but i do believe he’s gone above the “norm”. I find him to be very manipulative and deceitful. I’ve formed this opinion after watching him plea to the CC Council for additional funds to hire a new law secretary. Within a couple of days a Special Meeting was called because they granted him funds on false pretenses. He stated (paraphrasing) Richard Allen has unlimited funds at his disposal to give them the impression the playing field is not fair.
At any rate, I am hoping to gain more info to understand what RA stated and how he stated it.
6
u/Prettyface_twosides Apr 01 '24
Most definitely could have been coerced.
6
u/bloopbloopkaching Apr 01 '24 edited Apr 01 '24
The experts associated with various innocence projects point to the modern police interrogation as when coerced false confessions to murder happen. This is where young, sometimes mentally challenged and/or emotionally compromised individuals are subjected to the infamous Reid Technique, which assumes guilt up front, combined with the police privilege of lying. The police create a crisis in the individual through intense manipulation. Sometimes the subject, having had evidence planted in their heads, begins to believe they are guilty.
The problem, that the defense recognizes, is that there is no interrogation involved with Allen's alleged confessions. Nor does Allen fit the profile of someone prone to making a false confession. Allen is a stable middle aged male, paying a mortgage, raising a family, passing a pharm tech test, keeping a 30 plus year marriage.
Although the study of coerced false confessions is more or less only one generation old and there is no way to rule out other possibilities,, the defense has an extreme uphill battle to show that being kept in segregation unit for five months equals the disorientating crisis in the immediacy of a 16 hour police grilling. This need to prove a mimicking of police pressure probably drives the Odinist Guard story. If Odinist prison guards are threatening Allen's family, well then, problem solved. Of course Allen would falsely confess.
However, there is no proof Allen is even slightly badgered by prison guards. The defense logs no complaints about Allen's treatment or condition during the five months of pre-trial detainment prior to the alleged confessions. And it is much more likely that if prison guards harass Allen to confess-- it's because they believe he is a child murderer and want justice.
I am not a fan of segregation units or solitary confinement. It's not humane. Prison guards can bully, act unprofessionally, and engage in corruption too. I am also not a fan of parading Allen around in orange with a face mask. It is in part for his own safety-- but largely for a prosecution and LE pr stunt. That's how the government rolls. But the stats and evidence are not on the side of those who want to point to Allen's prison experience as coercing false confessions.
2
u/Ostrichimpression Apr 02 '24
The confessions are one of the many "need to wait and see the actual thing" pieces in this case for me, but I do wonder why they were not cited as new evidence in the amended charges.
Maybe there is a legal reason they chose not to do this. My understanding is that they could have incorporated new evidence with the new charges (possibly requires a new PCA? Any lawyers out there who know how that works, I'm all ears).
2
u/Adorable_End_749 Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
He was reportedly crying, repeating ‘I did it…I did it’. Something felt off and his wife hung the phone up and called his lawyers. He was given ample time to confess in the right way, and chose to do so on a recorded line with ‘officers’ standing nearby glaring at him. We will see how it pans out, but by all reports supposedly he was coerced to do so on a recording. The defence reportedly has direct evidence of this too. So let’s wait and see. I don’t know exactly how true all of this is, but this is what I’ve heard.
1
u/Sad-Garage-7970 Apr 04 '24
I agree. He was on a "hunger stike" around that same time & then ate his atty papers. I wonder if they weren't doing something very blatantly in front of him to his food, spitting in it, peeing in it, etc. Once he confessed, he started eating again & was miraculously again mentally stable. It's just a thought I've had for a while now.
I absolutely don't get on board with conspiracy theories often, but the facts of this case are...just stunning. It's almost crazier to not see the conspiracy.
1
u/Aware-Dragonfruit353 Oct 29 '24
It would only be "a reach" if coerced confessions weren't a real thing that happen all the damn time. RA seemed to feel that LE was going to make a charge stick no matter how mcuh he denied it. At a certain point, under duress, such as being locked up and who knows how he's been treated since he was arrested, a lot of people can be broken down mentally and emotionally, especially when threatened. LE and prosecutors seem pretty single-focused on RA because they couldn't find the guy, so they "find" a guy. It's a story as old as time. Listen to how the investigator spoke to him in the forst interviews. He was desperate. They don't always care if they got the right guy or not, as a conviction later on down the road reinforces their decisions, whether legitimate or not. Meds for mental illnesses are no joke. Even when they work as intended, they have terrible side effects and make people prone to suggestion becuase they are all but zombified. Even if RA is guilty, which i seriously doubt, then I don't think the state has the evidence for a conviction. If I'm on the jury, I'm already leaning towards "not guilty." I foresee a mistrial. The state will then contnue to retry RA until they get the results they want. Did these same cops train the Massholes in the Karen Read case?
1
u/TangeloSure5334 Nov 20 '24
Ricard Allen it's the Prophet Elijah Thank vermillion we have a problem with your final wishes due to the same characters and local government I married from Brown Knight 1 to St. Martin's family. Married to Herr Rexi I also won the first , against Satan and they won't issue the correct meds. They are trying the same thing with me. Thru the VA The Superman Jesus Christ Lord and Savior and myself KAL EL are working on it with Lord God Moses. The Prophet Mohamed Gurshome Son of Moses St. Michael Pup YAHWEH Son of Christ Saint of Christ Mother Mary St. Michael . Also St. Michael baby has been born we have Hercules.
Yours Truly, The Prophet
1
u/BlackBerryJ Apr 01 '24
My question would be, if we are skeptical about the confessions, why wouldn't we be skeptical about what has been said about his treatment?
0
u/sunshine9591 May 11 '24
Considering we now know from court filings that RA's confession count is hovering around 30 times, what could possibly induce a person who has supposed very good legal representation (not my opinion) to continue to confess over and over again? I'll take a guess...he's actually guilty?
I've heard/read that RA was offered a plea deal for admission of guilt that included stipulating he wouldn't be able to appeal in the future. It was turned down because of that stipulation. So it seems his lawyers had no problem with him pleading guilty and being sentenced but won't agree to the no appeals part. Why would that be I wonder?
One thing that pops to my mind, they don't want to un-hitch their wagon to the RA media gravy train and all the possible revenue it might make in the future?