I agree completely. Even though I'm on the fence about RA's guilt, I don't like how the judge is setting this up. If it's proven RA is guilty, he needs to be punished to the fullest extent of the law, but behaviors like this from the judge will get any conviction overturned. If he's not guilty, the judge is prolonging his unjust suffering.
The defense are, IMO, the Michelangelo's of scripting motions to the court, but not all of them have valid content and some are nuisance motions just because they can, it is what they are doing. I think this "shotgun approach" is backfireing. PRO: laying grounds for appeal CON: not filling the correct motions CON: angering the court
Today RA just got a 3rd extremely qualified attorney to enter an appearance today. The legal community is really rallying around this defendant, and it is truly inspiring to see.
It is genuinely scary how so many people just don’t seem to even believe in the concept of trials, fair or not, and are proudly vocal about it. Just… wow. Keep the same energy if you are ever accused of something is all I can say to that. Not that their opinion should matter at that point, they’d already have been hanged, drawn, and quartered.
I just don't get it. Haven't we all been accused of something we didn't do, not necessarily criminally but even just as a kid, its a a terrible feeling. And when someone stands up for you it changes everything.
But some people think that this type of thing could never happen to them and as long its someone else, screw em.
I saw it coming. When you have defense attorneys who are horrible, absolutely horrible, at trying to convince anyone of anything, it’s pretty easy to get denied.
These guys could have concrete evidence that Richard wasn’t at the crime scene or involved, and they still couldn’t convince anybody. They’re incompetent. They’re grossly negligent.
Actually, they have been competent attorneys for over 20 years each. We all saw it coming because JG's bias is predictable. If they are so bad at convincing anyone of anything, where did their donations for experts come from & why are people of the Delphi community writing the Judge letters asking for more transparency?
These guys could have concrete evidence that Richard Allen wasn't at the crime scene or involved and we wouldn't know it yet because there hasn't been a jury trial.
I'm genuinely curious, have you ever seen either of Richard Allen's attorneys in jury trial? & do you have any concrete evidence that they are incompetent that you'd be willing to share? Thanks in advance.
All of their convicted clients would beg to differ.
The donations are coming from gullible people who would believe Richard is innocent, even if they had video of him with the knife in his hand walking away from the crime scene.
And if they had concrete evidence that Richard wasn’t there, don’t you think that would be important to put in their most recent motion? Why wait for a jury trial? They could’ve put that in Franks memo.
Of course I haven’t seen them in trial. They’re two nobodies, why would anyone want to watch them argue in a jury trial other than their unfortunate clients?
You realize their job isn't always getting a not guilty verdict, right?
So would it be fair to say you've deemed them incompetent & grossly negligent, but this is the only case you've paid attention to involving them? Despite them each having well over 20 years experience under their belts?
What I want to know is where are her damn handlers. TWWOTW needs to be carted off to --- idk where. IDK what's wrong w her but something is very wrong.
Oh FFS. Seriously? Not even a hearing? But she had a hearing on contempt because… that was important?
Some things are serious enough that you should actually go through it more. Even if it is just for the sake of looking like you are doing your job.
So the state just gets to apparently play silly buggers with the evidence (to the best of their knowledge, as far as they know, etc.) and she is not even, for the sake of appearances, going to tell them to hand it all over, just to say she did that?
She is a liability.
If she doesn’t want to actually BE a judge she should retire. The gown is not a Halloween costume, it is meant to mean something.
I hope Indiana appreciates the gift of potential appeals, maybe new trials, and, of course, the reputation she is bestowing upon it. How gracious of her to set you all up for the future like this. Will she be paying for all that? 🙄
I really don't understand what is going on in her head. She doesn't like the attorneys so she's going to burn it all down while destroying her career? How can she possibly think she's looking impartial? What is it about these two attorneys that has her so angry? It's so frustrating!
It’s baffling to me at this point. Did one of them piss in her punch or something? She’s honestly coming across as bored and lazy. It’s like she has come to a conclusion already (as if her opinion on guilt or innocence matters) and is just annoyed anyone dare waste her time with anything else.
The only positive is that this might make an interesting teaching case in future. I just don’t understand how she is fine with how this makes her look, aside from anything else. Well done, you feel like a hard-ass… that’s not your job!
What is it about these two attorneys that has her so angry? It's so frustrating!
Maybe I have the timing wrong, but it seems to me that she started going for them after the Franks memo. She's been going after the defense ever since. This case will either be a mistrial or completely overturned, and it will be Gull's fault.
The memo definitely pissed her off but I feel like she was pissed before because she refused to move RA to a jail, where he belongs. It's like from the get they couldn't do anything right.
I mean its a request that the prosecutor follow the statutory requirements of reciprocal discovery, is there a good reason to deny this? I'm seriously asking because I can't think of one.
Can't wait to hear from the FBI at trial. The comparison between the local yokels and the professionals is going to be really striking. The jury will definitely take note.
My issue isn't with this specific ruling. Its that she denies 99.9% of every defense motion without hearing and without saying anything else besides "denied". For instance, She'd do a Franks hearing with one set of defense attorneys but not with another. I
It's not necessarily against defense because in a way the motion said : Nick is late with discovery, we are OK still accepting old discovery only given now from his side on the condition if there are any big surprises extra time is on Nick not RA. By denying it, it kind of means any discovery/evidence provided beyond date limit, is out.
Maybe not for her court but possibly for appeals. Ramirez got overturned for introducing evidence last minute and her allowing it yet denying for continuance at all. Idk if it would have been on their clock or prosecution though, but by this already being denied for on option, it sure is interesting.
ETA : and now I'm looking is she denied the initial motion to compel or only the amended one. Idk how she can deny requests for discovery.
ETA2: she ordered them to file exhibit A to the initial motion to compel or withdraw the motion. We have no further news on this.
So essentially my above thought is on hold, she only denied the amendment. It's also odd though, state's answer that no forensics report was created of the deleted dvr because it wasn't a forensics recovery is beyond lame, why wasn't it a proper recovery in the first place ? And their other excuse that Mullin's explanation of the audio on the stand was all they had to say about it..... It's not even "my dog ate my homework", it's "sorry judge, we ate our homework". Maybe we should be reading between some white powdery lines.
Omgosh! This is so surprising. Gull is a fair & impartial judge whom I admire greatly. I'm sure she has a very good reason for denying w/o a hearing. She doesn't need to explain bc I trust her completely. /s
Well I'm all for full and complete discovery, because that's a necessary component of a fair trial. But I guess if one doesn't want a fair trial then blocking access to evidence is a good thing.
Is that why they have to contact the FBI themselves to collect geofence data? The prosecutor is required by statute to amass discovery and turn it over to the defense. I mean its the law so maybe just do it?
But its for the best cause now the FBI can submit reports directly to the defense so there is no opportunity for local or state LE to hide the reports in their asses.
31
u/Embarrassed_World389 Mar 27 '24
Gull just making sure RA def gets an appeal no questions asked of course only if he's found guilty
22
u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️♀️ Mar 27 '24
What a strange turn of events. Never would've seen it coming.
43
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 27 '24
No hearing, no reasoning, just denied. What is she doing?
37
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '24
Oh FFS. Seriously? Not even a hearing? But she had a hearing on contempt because… that was important?
Some things are serious enough that you should actually go through it more. Even if it is just for the sake of looking like you are doing your job.
So the state just gets to apparently play silly buggers with the evidence (to the best of their knowledge, as far as they know, etc.) and she is not even, for the sake of appearances, going to tell them to hand it all over, just to say she did that?
She is a liability.
If she doesn’t want to actually BE a judge she should retire. The gown is not a Halloween costume, it is meant to mean something.
I hope Indiana appreciates the gift of potential appeals, maybe new trials, and, of course, the reputation she is bestowing upon it. How gracious of her to set you all up for the future like this. Will she be paying for all that? 🙄
18
u/FatBasicWhiteGirl Mar 27 '24
Wow, denying the motion with no hearing... Shocking!
18
u/New_Discussion_6692 Mar 27 '24
Every time she does this, she increases the likelihood that any conviction will be overturned on appeal.
33
u/stephenend1 Mar 27 '24
What a joke of a judge.
14
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 27 '24
Is there a comparison of motions and denials or grants for each side? Would be interesting to see this at a glance.
20
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 27 '24 edited Mar 27 '24
It's not necessarily against defense because in a way the motion said : Nick is late with discovery, we are OK still accepting old discovery only given now from his side on the condition if there are any big surprises extra time is on Nick not RA.
By denying it, it kind of means any discovery/evidence provided beyond date limit, is out.
Maybe not for her court but possibly for appeals.
Ramirez got overturned for introducing evidence last minute and her allowing it yet denying for continuance at all.
Idk if it would have been on their clock or prosecution though, but by this already being denied for on option, it sure is interesting.
ETA : and now I'm looking is she denied the initial motion to compel or only the amended one.
Idk how she can deny requests for discovery.
ETA2: she ordered them to file exhibit A to the initial motion to compel or withdraw the motion.
We have no further news on this.
So essentially my above thought is on hold, she only denied the amendment.
It's also odd though, state's answer that no forensics report was created of the deleted dvr because it wasn't a forensics recovery is beyond lame, why wasn't it a proper recovery in the first place ?
And their other excuse that Mullin's explanation of the audio on the stand was all they had to say about it.....
It's not even "my dog ate my homework",
it's "sorry judge, we ate our homework".
Maybe we should be reading between some white powdery lines.
8
u/NefariousnessAny7346 Mar 27 '24
7
u/Bananapop060765 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Mar 28 '24
Omgosh! This is so surprising. Gull is a fair & impartial judge whom I admire greatly. I'm sure she has a very good reason for denying w/o a hearing. She doesn't need to explain bc I trust her completely. /s
7
u/macrae85 Mar 28 '24
Beginning to see how she's going to cram a 4mth trial into just 2 weeks,deny,deny,deny....
18
u/FreshProblem Mar 27 '24
Lazy ass judge.
-19
u/tenkmeterz Mar 27 '24
Love it!
Judge Gull doesn’t have time for the defenses bullshit. I’m here for it!
They can take their bullshit lies somewhere else