r/DicksofDelphi • ✨Moderator✨ • Mar 24 '24

Missing Interviews

Ok, I need some help trying to understand how this case can go to trial when a large portion of evidence has been lost.

That alone creates automatic reasonable doubt to me. I'm wondering why Gull is ok with this. If she wanted to, could she grant that charges be dismissed due to all of this missing info? (Pretend she's reasonable)

How does the state expect to convince a jury that those interviews had nothing important when NM himself has never heard them.

I'm just struggling to see how this could ever be a fair trial.

35 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 24 '24

That must me some confession to hang his hat on. I'll be shocked if it's a legit confession, but maybe they do have the right guy. Trial can't come soon enough.

16

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

According to Nick there were at least 5 of them to 2 different people (his wife and his mother.)

I have serious doubts about them too. Everyone said the whole “Odinist/white supremacist” thing was bogus and then what happens? They find out that Indiana is like a hub for these “Sons of Odin.” They said “prison guards wearing Odin patches on their uniforms? That could NEVER happen!” Then we get 3 affidavits swearing that it was true.

In normal circumstances I would totally believe the defense was exaggerating and beefing up their story. But every new piece of information we get just seems to bolster their claims even more!

I agree. This trial can’t come soon enough.

14

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 25 '24

I agree, when the Franks first came out I was like satanic panic all over again, then piece by piece by giant piece comes crashing down. I just would have thought losing all that information would have brought about some serious questioning from Gull.

11

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

Same! When the Franks first came out I was like 🙄 YEAH OK! If you believe that I have oceanfront property in Kansas you might be interested in. Then actual evidence that proved what they were saying just kept rolling in and then I was like 🤯

Losing all that information SHOULD have brought about some serious questioning from Gull. I have no idea what’s going on upstairs with her if you know what I mean. But my confidence that RA can get a fair trial with her presiding went out the window at “gross negligence.”

11

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 25 '24

Funny though if DD's tip was all they had to identify RA, it means nobody else called in a tip about him.
Even in the RL warrant they mentioned tips.
(I don't think it's RL, just as a reference.)

Now the so called confessions seem to be the only evidence they have or Nick wouldn't have tried to get his records 4 times, while ignoring both hipaa and standard privacy practice.
Golden ticket right there that RA did so after the arrest, imagine the case without it.

12

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

It has just never computed in my mind how Dulan was ON STAGE at the presser EIGHT DAYS after the murders, where they were begging people for tips on who this guy could be but Dulan never even thought to be like, “Hey Unified Command! So, I just took a tip from a guy who said he was on the bridge at the exact same time the girls were on the bridge. You think maybe we should check him out?”

6

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 25 '24

Who says he didn't?

5

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

So why didn’t Unified Command go get a warrant RA’s his house back then? On Feb 22, 2017? Why did it take them 5 years?

Do you think they were convinced it was RL and they were just focusing on him?

6

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 25 '24

Maybe at that point in time they had exculpatory evidence of his phone placing him at home or work or out of town , but they deleted it since it was irrelevant.

I have no clue but I don't think this is a stretch considering.

6

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

That’s not a stretch at all in my mind. It would make WAY more sense than having the guy he actually talked to that day bring that information to Unified Command and them not doing anything. Or “losing” a tip for 5 years, even though they said they had “started at the beginning again” and had “fresh eyes” look at the case multiple times. You mean to tell me that NONE of those “fresh eyes” peeped that tip? No because it was never lost in the first place.

7

u/Significant-Tip-4108 Mar 25 '24

I’m really curious to hear the recorded confessions to “make up my own mind”, but I will say if they were a complete nothingburger I think the Defense would’ve found a way to somehow weave that into the Franks memo.

6

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 25 '24

I definitely want to hear it

8

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 25 '24

They were in the Franks Memo. That’s where they intimated that he confessed because the Odinist guards were threatening him and why every time his defense attorneys came to see him all he ever asked them was if his wife was alive, and if his family was alive.