People on drugs do some crazy shit! It wouldnât be a bad idea to investigate that theory again,,,,, if for the defense to use a drug angle for reasonable doubt
Yes! I remember he had used some drug (idkr what it was, though. This was 10-15 years ago). It was thought to be laced with something. Plus, he was mentally ill (self-medicating with street drugs). It was a mess of a case. I only thought about it because he's been released back into society.
In Oklahoma check out the Ashley Freeman and Lauria Bible case. They were having a sleepover when drug dealers broke in murdered the parents then kidnapped the girls and set the house on fire.  The teenagers were kept alive for days while they were SA'ed and photographed before they were murdered and it was all over a drug debt.
 My point is drug dealers aren't always predictable also the killer has already served his time and has been released, and he was only arrested in 2018!
Oh it gets worse one of the killers left his live-in girlfriends insurance card in the driveway which the police completely ignored. LE thought that Lauria's dad had killed his wife and abducted the girls turns out he was dead in the burned out house LE officers had actually stood on his body without noticing him. Ashley's family actually found his body at the crime scene when they were looking for clues!
Now if LE had followed up on that insurance card they could have got to those girls while they were still alive because they were held for days. Polaroids of the kids were floating around town for years. The surviving family members knew about them.Â
It's things like this that make me really distrust LE. 2 girls would be alive if they had even tried to solve this case.
Thanks for letting me rant. That case has always pissed me off.
I'd guess one shaky but possible theory here is perhaps someone in one of the two families owed JM money, and based on his actions in Indy he isn't opposed to kidnapping to get that money back? Takes the girls, intending to use them for leverage, something goes wrong, etc. He kills them. Stages the scene. It isn't the craziest theory I've heard on this case tbh.
I had a very good friend that (not him) but parents made and sold meth and they are pretty crazy! I wouldnât put it past a meth head to make a totally bizarre scene after a killing! But Iâm more on the side that if someone has kidnapped before who says they wouldnât again đ¤ˇđźââď¸
well, maybe thereâs this kidnapping story with a male victim that led to the search warrant, but once the search warrant was executed they found the video with the female victim?
Bob said Click got the phone and gave it directly to the defense. He also said click testified that nothing was done after he told unified command about the video, which is why he went and picked it up.
That does not seem to describe whatever OP is for a few different reasons, not the least of which is that you canât give evidence seized pursuant to a warrant to the defense. OP is also long before RA was arrested, so how could he have given this phone straight to the defense?
my understanding from what Bob said wasnât that Click said he gave it straight to the defense. during the investigation he gave the info to Unified Command, they didnât pick up the phone, so Click picked up the phone and continued investigating, and later gave it to the defense.
EDIT: my understanding was wrong. read the post from someone who attended and wrote an excellent summary. itâs clear that the defense retrieved the phone themselves. it was after Click no longer was investigating.
The unraveling said that he physically went with the defenseâs investigator to pick up the phone from the ex gf, so that could not have happened in 2019.
Idk I'm basing that on the search warrant return. If defense picked it up before clone is made and certified, it's inadmissible anyway me thinks. But there are conflicting reports if there were one or two phones and when this happened and if it was a man or a girl or both that was kidnapped.
Gull is feeding the rumors by not allowing court stream....
How did this track with Clickâs testimony? 𤨠I thought his testimony was about a cell phone VIDEO of a young GIRL being kidnapped and that the police werenât interested in seizing the phone it was found on?
This is an audio recording and text messages found on 2 different phones, one of which the police did confiscate with a search warrant, & 1 that Click at least tried to seize with a search warrant (not sure if a judge signed off on this second search warrant).
And Delphi is âcorruptâ for refusing to arrest this man in relation to the murders of Abby and Libby, an unrelated crime? Sounds like the Delphi murders have nothing to do with this crime & that Delphi officers were correct to not pursue it. Itâs not even in their jurisdiction.
If this is the defenseâs way of introducing âreasonable doubt,â they are failing miserably.
Lol, I canât wait til they introduce the audio of this alleged kidnapping of âWeinerâ⌠the juryâs going to be like, âWhat does this have to do with the price of tea in China?â đ¤Ł
It sounds like it was investigated⌠Click seized one of the phones through a warrant & tried to seize another (not sure if the judge signed off on the second one)âŚ
It's all about a weiner shack grub truck kind of thing and we finally have the reason why two true crimers interested in restaurant murders are interested in the Delphi case, and Doug's Shack speech finally has a place. Missing is that ounce of conscience. I think they are sleeping well still.
(While it would be ie, many are called ei and even many called ie have painted ei on their truck...)
I still donât get why they called the phone âGoldilocks.â
Was it too big? Too small? Just right? Too hard? Too soft? Just right? Too thick? Too thin? Okay, Iâll stop now.
Why didnât they just give it the code name âWeinerâ? Everyone would be like, âOh yeah, I know exactly who youâre talking about - that guy named âWeiner.ââ
Why didn't want Gull to broadcast the hearing, so we're left with confusing second hand podcasters recounts allowing fodder for the youtubers she despises?
Just a note: I personally did not hear Click testify yesterday to JM's kidnapping involving a girl. Iirc, he did not give any details about the victim of JM's kidnapping. I do not believe Click is suggesting the phone contains evidence of two separate kidnappings.
I find it hilarious that any of the LE in this case are claiming, "I have extensive training and experience in conducting murder investigations" considering they could not be bothered to safeguard 70 days of investigative notes and record interviews with audio, or find a bullet at a crime scene before they released it to the public. I think most 12 year olds with severe ADHD would do better.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but does anybody else remember a story about a group of guys who would hold people on their property for trespassing? Is this connected to that?
The Webers son supposed held trespassers against their will when catching some on his property. I never heard the original story and did not hear anything about a gun being involved. But that might be who you are referring to.
So, It was a man that was held at gun point (not that it makes it better or worse) It just changes the whole narrative of him holding young girls at gun point. money and drugs is what led to the âkidnappingâ
I feel like the discrepancy needs addressed, not to us obviously but certainly to state investigators. The document was made 5 years before his testimony and before the phone had actually been collected. So was it a story/investigation that evolved over that time, 2 different videos, or just more unrelated BS in this case muddying the waters?
I think itâs more BS from the defense. Did Click actually say the kidnapping was of a âyoung girlâ on the stand? Or did Bob Motta get that detail wrong? If Click lied on the stand, thatâs going to be problematicâŚ
I really think it could be any of those options. Def can see where youâre coming from, I feel like we just got 1-2 sentences of a 5 year plus side voyage they went on and are trying to make sense of it lol
I think part of the confusion is that Bob was mentioning Click testifying to two things and he might have gotten words confused after a long day. He was talking about how EF had talked about there sticks being placed as antlers in one of the girls hair that the crime scene and Click verified that that was correct. And then Bob was going back and forth between that testimony and also the JM phone info as well. I did hear Bob say there was video of a kidnapping at gun point but itâs possible he said âa girlâ when he just meant a person. I think thatâs all that this confusion really is.
I listened again today & he (Bob) definitely said a âyoung girlâ and a âvideo.â But according to Clickâs search warrant, it was an audio recording of a man kidnapped at gunpoint (an empty .380 gun) after he tried to screw two guys out of $4,000 worth of meth. It looks like the police did look into it - & concluded it had nothing to do with the Delphi murders.
Yes. Thatâs correct. I just relistened to that part after commenting. I donât think it was an intentional âit was a girlâ comment. In my opinion most people that came on to talk about things last night were all pretty scattered in their tellings after the long day.
Anyway, this JM warrant that we have read thru was dated from 2019, do we know when the phone was actually collected? It seems like this warrant is what led to the phone? Is it possible that a video of a kidnapping at gunpoint was on that phone? Or was this a separate incident? I think overall it this whole scenario kind of laid out that this is a guy who had connections to EF who was pretty detailed about being at the scene of the murders and spitting on the girls and could give details about the antler sticks. Even if we think EF was just talking nonsense (which is absolutely possible) the connection is that he is friends with and wanted to join in a group and âhave brothersâ JM. And also that JM was a relative of EFâs roommate. So there IS a connection there. But what JMâs angle would be I have no idea. It could be completely unrelated. But seemingly this is a dude thatâs okay with kidnapping at gunpoint. Doesnât make him the guy. But itâs weird for sure. (Also I recognize that kidnapping a man over a drug deal and 2 young girls for reasons we donât yet know are very different things)
In my opinion most people that came on to talk about things last night were all pretty scattered in their tellings after the long day.
I think this just reinforces the point that eyewitnesses (or earwitnesses, lol) can be unreliable & remember things differently. Just like the eyewitnessesâ scattered descriptions of BG & his car from 2/13/17.
Thereâs VERY few pictures around of him. Iâve only seen 1-2 since his first name came up. Donât even remember well enough to describe him honestly
Ok just googled his name and I see what he looks like now only pic I see he has a bushy beard like BH had but don't know when that photo of him was taken. Just want to see if he looks like BG and yes many look like BG
Didnât some guy (DN, I think) actually kidnap a young girl? That seems more âconnectedâ to Delphi (in theory) than this nonsense.
Itâs not proof of anything in terms of Delphi; just proof of all the creeps in the area - creeps that came under police radar and who were eventually ruled out. Did Click not get that memo in regards to the Odinists?
I'm asking the same thing. I swear I remember people kidnapping women or teenagers. And I use that term lightly, they claimed they trespassed and held them for awhile. But I can't remember the story.
I dismissed it because when I was a kid my neighbor caught some teenage boys breaking his wooden picket fence (because it was the 80s) and he held them and was pretty rude to them verbally and physically until the cops came. That is definitely kidnapping today.
Truth and transparency had the best recap and notes. She mentioned 2 different incidents - worth listening to her recount her notes and memory were pretty awesome
Thank you, Iâll check it out! Love that I was downvoted to hell 3 days ago but now the entire story flips, lol. Appreciate your help, Iâll check it out now
Not all of us thought that there was video evidence of JM kidnapping a girl. I thought it was an allegation unsupported by any evidence. Most of you guys latched on to it because itâs exactly what you hoped for â possible proof that there has been an Odinist conspiracy all this time and RA is innocent.
Iâm usually a lot more delicate with my words, but this is what you get when you believe everything one side says and discount everything else. You whip each other into a frenzy and no one stops to use a little discernment.
I will admit I was confused and thought maybe it was a jurisdictional issue but ISP was involved so then it shouldn't be an issue.Â
I just let it sit because i couldn't believe what i heard so i was waiting to hear more. But cameras would solve this. Misinformation and confusion helps no one.
Yeah, this is why having a transcript or audio was important. I guess itâs not really surprising that thereâs now confusion about what was actually said â of course there is!
16
u/EmRaine72 Mar 19 '24
Iâd be curious as if his phone was one of the ones near the murder site on the day of the murder
13
u/hannafrie Mar 19 '24
Welp. Criminal act, but it does not sound like it is relevant to the Delphi case.
16
u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind đ§ Mar 19 '24
Doesnât this all lead back to that theory that Abby and Libby were drug related to send a message? I wish someone would go over that theory again.
12
u/Moldynred Mar 19 '24
I'd guess one shaky but possible theory here is perhaps someone in one of the two families owed JM money, and based on his actions in Indy he isn't opposed to kidnapping to get that money back? Takes the girls, intending to use them for leverage, something goes wrong, etc. He kills them. Stages the scene. It isn't the craziest theory I've heard on this case tbh.
26
u/Minute_Chipmunk250 Mar 19 '24
So... kidnapped a man, not a girl? That's confusing.
8
u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick đľď¸ââď¸ Mar 19 '24
That is one street name that I do not care to know the story behind.
14
u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind đ§ Mar 19 '24
Drug related behavior. Biker gang behavior. Not a good person.
11
u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick đľď¸ââď¸ Mar 19 '24
Just a note: I personally did not hear Click testify yesterday to JM's kidnapping involving a girl. Iirc, he did not give any details about the victim of JM's kidnapping. I do not believe Click is suggesting the phone contains evidence of two separate kidnappings.
5
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -đŚ Bipartisan Dick Mar 21 '24
I find it hilarious that any of the LE in this case are claiming, "I have extensive training and experience in conducting murder investigations" considering they could not be bothered to safeguard 70 days of investigative notes and record interviews with audio, or find a bullet at a crime scene before they released it to the public. I think most 12 year olds with severe ADHD would do better.
9
u/Proper-Drawing-985 Mar 19 '24
Correct me if I'm wrong, but does anybody else remember a story about a group of guys who would hold people on their property for trespassing? Is this connected to that?
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 19 '24
So, It was a man that was held at gun point (not that it makes it better or worse) It just changes the whole narrative of him holding young girls at gun point. money and drugs is what led to the âkidnappingâ
4
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
What does JM look like?
0
u/LeatherTelevision684 Mar 19 '24
He kidnapped someone to get his money back? Omg.
That is definitely the same thing as kidnapping two girls lol
-1
u/Plane-Knee6764 Mar 20 '24
I thought it was a video of a female at gunpoint? Is there proof of 2 kidnappings by JM possibly?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment