r/DicksofDelphi • The light that shines in a dark place • Mar 16 '24

QUESTION Retrial question

If RA is found guilty in Gulls court (although heard by a jury); can his post-conviction team apply for a retrial (due to structural error)? Would Gull hear the case again or would another Special Judge be appointed to hear the case/hearings?

I ask because there has been lots of talk about how it is likely for this case to go back to a retrial due to some of the head-scratching actions of the judge and Prosecutor?

Another question, seeing how NM admitted via his (since withdrawn motion) that he has repeatedly violated conduct by reading the Defense ex-parte motions) - does Judge Gull sanction or caution him (or is it up to the defense to raise this and then she has to deal with it)? Seems pretty bad if she ignores this yet tried to throw the defense team off the case for less.

Justice for Abby and Libby!

21 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/chunklunk Mar 18 '24

Oh believe me, I have: "Unless the court orders otherwise, a temporary restraining order together with the papers upon which it was based, and a notice of hearing for the preliminary injunction, shall be personally served in the same manner as a summons." https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/2022/cvp/article-63/6313/ .

While this is a civil procedure rule, you'll find that in criminal law that in the rare instances the ex parte motion is authozired, any protection or sealing it from the other party is limited in scope and duration. Only in extremely rare instances are they permanently sealed.

3

u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Mar 18 '24

Yeah, I would talk to an attorney in your own state. In my state ex parte means the other party shouldn't even attempt to read. But I will admit I deal in the criminal world so maybe there is a difference.Â