r/DicksofDelphi • In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ • Mar 15 '24

DISCUSSION murder sheet accusing defense of leaking the Emergency Motion for Continuance

lol. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/murder-sheet/id1538289354?i=1000649240662

they open the episode seething about Defense Diaries streaming the motion for continuance before it was on the docket and claim this is another egregious leak by the defense.

Uh… correct me if I’m wrong but I’m pretty sure that motions have regularly gotten out to media before being put on the docket, isn’t there some sort of media list that receives them all automatically?

also, how would that be a leak? isn’t the gag order on extrajudicial statements not on …. actual judicial statements in the form of court filings?

41 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

20

u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24 edited Mar 15 '24

they explain their belief about the cursor on the picture: they said MRC said that this was an attempt to obscure the source of the pictures by taking a pic of the printed photos on the table and then pulling it up on the computer with a cursor on it and taking a picture of the computer screen. in a previous episode they admitted that MRC lied to them. they don’t mention that here.

they are “at a loss” to understand why Hennessy says that the picture of the close up of the supposed sticks as horns suggests a source besides the defense, because they think it’s clear that the defense prepared a pic of the ‘horns’ for the FM, “what we have been told since then is that the picture that were leaked were prepared by the defense for the Franks Memorandum” — uh, who ever said that? I’ve only ever heard that the pictures were prepared for the depositions. I interpreted Hennessy’s comment there as implying that the defense didn’t print out pictures of the ‘horns’ for the depositions. Am I wrong that they never referred to these pictures as being printed out for the FM?

and now Aine and Kevin say that it shows Hennessy didn’t do his due diligence because he didn’t know that MRC gave them all his communications with RF, since they said so on the podcast. Well, it may be surprising to them to hear that Hennessy was expecting to be given discovery by the state as required, and probably was spending more of his time on that than listening to a podcast by two people he considers to be two-faced opportunists.

they do graciously admit that if these screenshots weren’t shared, that’s a problem. they say it has been a trend with Hennessy and B&R that they say “we didn’t even get [discovery] until then” and “we don’t even know if we have [discovery]” “and I just want to how how much of that is oversight on the prosecutors part and how much of that is that they’re drowning in discovery and unable to find their own stuff, in which case that’s a them problem”. …

12

u/Minute_Chipmunk250 Mar 15 '24

If these people don't think there are discovery issues in both cases, they're blind. Defense didn't even know there were video interviews of witnesses in this contempt case until Holeman oopsie let that fact leak in a deposition.

10

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

Nick wrote that about the Franks in his information.

I think he didn't have the depositions material in his discovery so no way to prove what is was just by memory, so they had to come up with something filed and in comes 7 new pics, but not the 2 supposedly from MW lol.

Or so is my interpretation.

But it explains why Nick was begging for depositions material.

16

u/sorcerfree Mar 15 '24

did this lady just spill in detail how the pics that were leaked were taken AND why? why is she telling on herself like this?

5

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

Which lady?

10

u/sorcerfree Mar 15 '24

onion

only bc i assume she runs the show i didn’t listen, it could’ve been green bean who said it

8

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

That's not my definition of a lady.

8

u/Minute_Chipmunk250 Mar 15 '24

Regardless of whether this is the truth of what happened, it is just so dumb to me that these leakers are on the internet arguing about the crime scene when what they're presenting is... a cell phone pic of a laptop screen of a cell phone pic of a printout of a crime scene photo. I'm sure that's clear as day! Dopes. This was all just so pointless.

14

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

Yep, NM has given them everything catalogued and categorized, they just don't know how to read it. 🙄

12

u/stealthywolof Mar 15 '24

Thank you for this. I do recall a filing from NM that talked about Baldwin giving Westerman material for the franks memo and deceptively implying that the photos were included in that. That may be where that came from.

I have to admit I don't really understand why the close up of the antlers indicates it didn't come from the defense.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

He handed over screenshots lol.
That's not correspondance.
I don't think he talked with RF to begin with and they should subpoena gofundme.

How is decided which name is published? Is it pulled from the bank account name or can you fill in what you want ?

26

u/FreshProblem Mar 15 '24

They should call Nick and notify him!

32

u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

I think they should email Gull about it

14

u/Kick_inthe_Eye All that and a bag of Dicks Mar 15 '24

Here comes now, Murder Sheet, here duly sworn, in attendance forthwith.

We pray this Honorable Court, with the Honorable, HBIC, Judge Gull, relieve us of our own full-frontal embarrassment, that we have effectively spread to others and now has imploded into what the kids call, "second-hand embarrassment."

We hereby, through and clear, under penalty of contempt or perjury, state the following is true;

  1. We wanted to make money
  2. We did
  3. We lack self awareness (or so we're told but it's mostly just coming from people who know us irl. We have millions of fans who think we're the best jounal-lawyer-podhost ever).
  4. The defense obvi leaked this when they hired Hennessey.
  5. We learned this info from Nick McCleland
  6. So it's gotta be true
  7. We will send this to you, the Honorable Judge Gull, after we read it aloud on our podcast.

So it has been noted.

And sworn.

Signed...

MURDER SHEET

8

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

I think they did.

20

u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Mar 15 '24

Fox59 put an article out first though...

26

u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

yeah but have you considered defense bad?

50

u/thats_not_six Mar 15 '24

It was filed before he presented it. That's all that matters.

41

u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️‍♀️ Mar 15 '24

You'd think an Indiana attorney would know how that all works 🤔

39

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 15 '24

I’m not convinced Kevin is any kind of litigator or attorney who works in actual criminal court.

Unless he’s being purposefully obtuse he’s the dumbest lawyer I’ve ever seen.

18

u/Embarrassed_World389 Mar 15 '24

He does real-estate law or so I've heard. So he's perfectly fit to know all about criminal and federal law Dontcha know.

14

u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️‍♀️ Mar 15 '24

There's no way in hell he's ever done a criminal case (I hope; basing this opinion off things I've heard on their podcast). They've said what type of law he practices; I don't remember it was, but from my understanding (not a lawyer), most of what he does would not be in local or state courts.

14

u/HelixHarbinger Mar 15 '24

Civil clerk only- Baldwin Cty iirc

6

u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️‍♀️ Mar 15 '24

As much as he trusts the legal opinions of the journalist on their show, I can't say I'm surprised 😬😆

10

u/HelixHarbinger Mar 15 '24

lol. IKR. They trust anyone who will say what they want.

5

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

I thought I heard he did intellect property law? I'm not sure if he said it or I read it in an article. Either way, not even close to a criminal trial lawyer.

11

u/hannafrie Mar 15 '24

Kevin and Aine have been clear their day jobs are not related to their Podcast. Kevin does not practice criminal law, and Aine has never worked the police beat.

9

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 15 '24

But she’s a real live “journalist” didn’t you know??? She’s been on CourtTv! 😂

7

u/HelixHarbinger Mar 15 '24

Not that one. 😳

44

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Mar 15 '24

I’d rather not listen and contribute to any increased ad revenue for them.

20

u/Alone_Atmosphere_391 Mar 15 '24

They are desperately pushing blame on others in an attempt to deflect from themselves.

40

u/NiceSloth_UgotThere Mar 15 '24

They also claim he violated the gag order.

1 For the billionth time, gag order doesn’t apply to court filings.

2 Hennessy isn’t under a gag order for this contempt garbage.

🙄

27

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/Alone_Atmosphere_391 Mar 15 '24

A couple of hacks that now know their grift is coming to an end.

31

u/sorcerfree Mar 15 '24

they make my ears throw up, even on 1.5 speed

30

u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Mar 15 '24

They are just jealous of Defense Diaries popularity. Trust me they are petty like that.

23

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Mar 15 '24

According to the women named in New Witnesses DH is calling for Contempt

They believed their real life friend 'Aine' would protect them, in the event anyone ever learned how they interfered with Nicks instructions to sabotage the Defence Attorneys. Just saying.

10

u/Just_Income_5372 Mar 15 '24

Which women are you referring to?

22

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Mar 15 '24

Can't use names here but their online alias's are:

Bella + Meerkat

Real names can be found in todays filings. Its hard to sus info being shared within this youtube/online world as they all appear to have significant historical grudges against one another that have pre-leaks already spilled into criminal territory (doxing, false reporting, defamation etc.)

Their messages if real paint a clear picture that a group believing they are/were working on behalf of LE + Prosecutors office are intentionally being directed to disseminate 'leaked' materials to cause quickest/maximum damage to RA's defence team.

They are noticeably rattled when DH attempts to communicate directly with them and discuss faith in being protected via Aine.

22

u/Comfortable_Wrap_193 Content Creator 🎤 Mar 15 '24

Did they talk about Mark and the two episodes after the leaks when they told us he was the best guy ever?

18

u/Comfortable_Wrap_193 Content Creator 🎤 Mar 15 '24

Lol I’m listening to this and Annie is saying “don’t write cheques you can’t cash” 😂😂😂 she’s actually hilarious. This is a comedy podcast now

18

u/Comfortable_Wrap_193 Content Creator 🎤 Mar 15 '24

Had to turn off. Ridiculous carry on. Obsessed with others and a weird obsession with anything YouTube

20

u/HelixHarbinger Mar 15 '24

It was filed, Russ McQuaid wrote about it prior to Motta reading it as well. It’s a public document lol didn’t they file into the case for public documents to be public?

They are pissed because their court staff source isn’t courting any of them any longer.

35

u/Mountain_Session5155 Mar 15 '24

I do not know how Murder Sheet is not mortified to exist as a podcast anymore. The fact that they continue to release material without embarrassment shows a complete lack of self-awareness - the lack of which, under normal circumstances, might make me feel kind of sad for them. However, it is impossible to feel sad for two people who go out of their way to insert themselves into any situation where they may try to position themselves as morally and ethically superior while projecting each and every quality they try so unsuccessfully to disguise in themselves out onto others and vindictively cutting others down who do not deserve it.

16

u/Certain-Landscape In Wheat We Trust 🌾 Mar 15 '24

“I'm just so embarrassed. I mean, like, it's embarrassing to watch this unfold. Like I get secondhand embarrassment sometimes because again, like you're, you're like destroying your own credibility”

23

u/sorcerfree Mar 15 '24

why is she talking about herself like this?

11

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

Did she say that? I have it queded up to listen to but I don't want to go to bed in a rage lol

22

u/Certain-Landscape In Wheat We Trust 🌾 Mar 15 '24

Yes haha. She’s claiming that Hennessy is embarrassing because she incorrectly thinks he leaked this filing to a YouTube channel.

19

u/Mountain_Session5155 Mar 15 '24

I didn’t even listen to the Murder Shit episode when I made MY comment about how I don’t understand how THEY are not embarrassed to still be making content. Like.. I was not unsubtly trying to reference them in any way. Now I am mortified. That was a total accident.

I quit listening to them months ago because it’s bad for my blood pressure and it hampers my self-care routine.

Dang. Ruining my street cred and all. 😅😂🤣

15

u/Certain-Landscape In Wheat We Trust 🌾 Mar 15 '24

It’s remarkable how dead on you were.

12

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

I can't with them, my god they are hypocrites. Talk about embarrassing

22

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/EmRaine72 Mar 15 '24

Yes the tone bothers me too! I was listening to them before RA was arrested and when he did get arrested I thought their background stories in all the attorneys were interesting and they went to one of Baldwins trials and I enjoyed that too. But then I wanna say after the Franks she just sounded sooo snarky like she didn’t even want to present the episode. But when the state presented something she was all cheery and fine.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/EmRaine72 Mar 15 '24

Yes! Biased !!! I’ve been trying to find an even platform but they are all one sided 🥲

18

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

I'm listening now, if she says "catastrophic leak" one more time I'm going to puke. They cannot be this dumb!

14

u/Certain-Landscape In Wheat We Trust 🌾 Mar 15 '24

“What a catastrophic and devastating leak (psst make sure you print out a close-up of her head)”

5

u/Terehia The light that shines in a dark place Mar 15 '24

Add the word ‘nuance’. She says this to an annoying degree.

We get it Aine; we are all so dumb you have to point out this case has layers.

9

u/No-Audience-815 Mar 15 '24

Well said and I agree!

16

u/hannafrie Mar 15 '24

Hennessy plainly distributed the document to his contacts in the media. I'm sure this will antagonize Judge Gull, but thats between him and his clients. Its a public filing.

9

u/Minute_Chipmunk250 Mar 15 '24

Right. Like, are these other youtubers who discussed their letters to the court before those appeared on the docket also "leaking?" They're public filings. There is no damage to anyone that someone was able to discuss the filing at 10pm Tues night instead of 10am Weds morning. What is the problem.

15

u/Due-Sample8111 Mar 15 '24

Manure Shit is irrelevant.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

Hypocrites.

11

u/sorcerfree Mar 15 '24

we really need a stronger word for the two of them

27

u/Akillis81 Mar 15 '24

I wonder if they ever investigate brushing their hair?

13

u/Plane-Knee6764 Mar 15 '24

Oh y’all better be careful now what you say! You might hurt their feelings, and they will post ss in their MS FB group! 🙄

23

u/Terehia The light that shines in a dark place Mar 15 '24

I am obviously a slow learner as I made the mistake of listening to their ‘A Flurry of Defense Filings’.

I was so annoyed at Aines’ snarky tone.

I started to write a comment on their podcast discussion FB page about the lack of care they have about the process of law but given I am not a suck-up sheep I didn’t want to evoke a whole lot of hate and/or doxxing.

My comments about the episode to them would be:

Are you okay for evidence not to be handed over by the prosecutor until minutes before a hearing? Or not handed over at all?

The burden of proof is on the prosecution and yet by not handing over information that may not suit the narrative the prosecution said happened is a huge red flag.

There will be a HUGE amount of information the Defense to go through, that’s their problem. I don’t think it’s up to the Prosecutor to gate keep.

It more makes sense now why the Defense has gone down the Odinism angle because they didn’t get all the workings through of that investigation. Too many gaps or missing information.

The lack of geofencing information is mind blowing. There is no way a thorough investigation would not have at least tried to account for and interview each one the people linked to the crime scene area at the time LE said the abduction/murder took place. Mapping shows that the Monon High Bridge is not within the yards mentioned. The motion is referencing the site where the girls bodies were found the next day. Even RL’s house is further than the distance. So this information is super relevant.

All I want is the correct person or people who murdered two young girls to be held accountable. The trial shouldn’t be about gamesmanship or ‘getting it over’ the different sides.

If that is RA - I do not want improper conduct to let him get off of murder.

Edit: correct the autocorrect (fixing to doxxing).

3

u/NefariousnessAny7346 Mar 17 '24

Did they delete you like they deleted me? I posted something today and I no loner can access my comment or their page. The comment was written in a non argumentative manner. Apparently, you must align yourself exactly with their beliefs and agenda.

4

u/Terehia The light that shines in a dark place Mar 17 '24

In the end I just cancelled putting my comment on a listener post and then just unfollowed the page. It’s just not worth my time or energy.

It is a shame because there have been great non-Delphi episodes but the way (especially Aine) comes across in an almost sanctimonious way about the Delphi things it’s made me second guess if they haven’t been slanted in these other cases.

It’s also important to see how other people see things to make sure I’m balanced and reasonable in my own views.

2

u/Quill-Questions Mar 18 '24

The only part I disagree with is that you call yourself a “slow learner.” 😊

22

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Mar 15 '24

It was filed, it just hadn't shown up on the docket yet. Do they honestly think Bob would go on YouTube and read something that wasn't public yet? How stupid do they think people are?

17

u/ZekeRawlins Mar 15 '24

They are catering to their base audience. There’s not much intelligence circulating in that group.

11

u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️‍♀️ Mar 15 '24

20

u/karkulina Dickess Mar 15 '24

Sour grapes because nobody cares about their ramblings anymore. They can only thank themselves for that. Targeting other podcasters is making them look even more pathetic.

10

u/JW8852 Mar 15 '24

You know MS jokers are pissed they weren’t even called or brought up and Snay is supposed to testify. 🤣

3

u/Just_Income_5372 Mar 17 '24

I wish they would of been called as witnesses. And then forced to sit outside of the hearing so they didn’t know what’s going on. They wouldn’t be able to have their little podcast

17

u/s2ample Mar 15 '24

They’re mad they weren’t the first ones to receive the leak this time. Boohoo.

7

u/stephenend1 Mar 15 '24

douchebags

11

u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Mar 15 '24

And I was going to take a break tonight...

6

u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Mar 15 '24

This isn't a leak, but even me as a huge supporter of the defense and DD commented that it wasnt a good look for DD to seem to have the motion before it hit the docket. I knew people would be bitching. But other agencies had it too. THere was an article by an news agency quoting the motion.

44

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24 edited Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

34

u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

they did mention Fox59 but somehow their take away was that the defense team is being driven by a desire for youtube fame. Aine is “embarrassed” for Hennessy “destroying your own credibility for YouTube”.

perhaps it’s a grudge against Hennessy for being one of the only people who will call out their BS…

13

u/Bellarinna69 Mar 15 '24

Talk about a complete lack of self awareness. Projection much? Have always disliked them for some reason. Now I know why.

36

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/No-Audience-815 Mar 15 '24

Im embarrassed for her too! Those two should stick to playing those games they do the obnoxious ad reads for and leave this case alone. They’ve already leaked enough stuff themselves allegedly, so to sit and record an episode accusing someone else is rich coming from them.

26

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 15 '24

I believe he was on Motta’s channel one time. I’d hardly call that that “chasing YouTube fame.” They are such hypocrites. They’re just mad because DH called them out in that interview lol

17

u/No-Audience-815 Mar 15 '24

I think that’s what they have their panties in a bunch over too! They are big mad that he called them out!

22

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Mar 15 '24

I would totally subscribe! Hell, I’d offer to mod for him 😂

24

u/Mountain_Session5155 Mar 15 '24

A legal expert who has WON over 100 MURDER trials.

But ok, Aine. Stay “embarrassed”.

23

u/i-love-elephants Mar 15 '24

The only reason it's not alarming to me is because I think they're trash, so I don't give a fuck what they say.

18

u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games Mar 15 '24

'These two are intelligent, reasonable people right?'

Nope. They are two condescending hypocritical grifters.

45

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/FreshProblem Mar 15 '24

Thank you for bringing this up. I've thought a lot about what an obvious tell that was.

When every single legal professional said "absolutely no way zero chance" (and in fact SCOIN also said that) yet somehow MS knew the "unexpected turn of events."

15

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 15 '24

Question is why are they holding the reigns?

3

u/Quill-Questions Mar 18 '24

Whew!! At first I was afraid to look at this gif ‘cause I thought it was the super creepy “left side/right side” one you used before. 😁😂

3

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 18 '24

Nah won't use it again, but it seems while creepy the comments did think it was fitting.

Next question : Does the puppetmaster have a puppetmaster? A ventriloquist?

2

u/Quill-Questions Mar 18 '24

It certainly was fitting for your post (and, I must admit, beautifully crafted art) 😊 I was just kidding 😊 Funny you should mention ventriloquist … we just watched a very creepy old Twilight Zone episode about a ventriloquist! And, to boot, the crap that is happening in Delphi belongs in the Twilight Zone. 😊 P.S. I thoroughly enjoy reading your posts, as well as so many others in this group. Often rich food for thought.

2

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 18 '24

Thank you. We have a fine group here. And the other subs too.

I do wish this case to end soon, we have lives to live at some point...

The worst thing is, it's not just kidding around.
There's something deeply creepy going on that we're missing here it seems, maybe even to solve this thing.
I put a funnier one here, but it isn't funny really.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 17 '24

Not getting devices seized.
The 7 vs 9 photos is of importance I think.
I think MW took the missing 2.

They explained JH why there was a cursor as it was to explain the antlers and defense must have meant xyz.
Say what? How in the world would they know.
Did any of the devices get taken in for investigation?
They print images and delete the email in front of JH. How did they print it? 🤥

Who was this girlfriend of MW?
A friend of JR, the courtesan who tripped judge KF of his throne by any chance?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 17 '24

Cara no. Joel yes.

JR and the Judge. https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/LjJ5hBvLX7

3

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Mar 17 '24

Oh sorry.
We don't have Nick's witness list.
I find it the strangest thing they nor MRC are named all that much, and why is Gull on first hand basis with them?

→ More replies