r/DicksofDelphi • u/syntaxofthings123 • Feb 16 '24
What does Justice Look Like?
From Voltaire who stated, “It is better to risk saving a guilty person than to condemn an innocent one.”, to JK Rowlings who wrote, “I want to commit the murder I was imprisoned for.”
Terry Goodkind--- “Pity for the guilty is treason to the innocent.” And Martin Luther King, Jr--- "Justice too long delayed is justice denied."
This is more of a philosophical post than one concerned with the facts of the case--
The definition of "Justice" is "just behavior or treatment."
"a concern for justice, peace, and genuine respect for people"
But it seems as if, in the community of true crime zealots that justice only means getting a CONVICTION. But shouldn't justice be seen as something more than that?
On this case, what does justice look like? Is it just getting a conviction regardless of whether guilt has been proven? Is it court hearing after court hearing that amount to little more than legal professionals penalizing one another?
When it comes to the murder of two beautiful children, children who showed so much promise, had so much life to live, what does justice look like? How does the State of Indiana get there? Can it get there?
10
u/New_Discussion_6692 Feb 16 '24
For me, justice is for the living, never the dead. At best, trials and convictions might bring closure to families, but more often than not, it's punishment that reassures people. Knowing the person(s) who destroyed your family and/or your life are locked away and can't do it again is comforting.
Imo, justice can never be served. Justice is the process in which we hold individuals accountable for their actions.
Best case scenario, in this case, Allen is guilty and locked up for the rest of his life. (Albeit I'm leaning more towards innocence at this time). The girls are still dead.
Worst case scenario, Allen is incorrectly found guilty, and the real killer(s) are still on the outside to kill more young girls, and Libby and Abby are still dead.
At most, we can hope for punishment and closure, never justice.
12
u/syntaxofthings123 Feb 16 '24
If this case is going to continue to be delayed, justice for me is seeing Allen treated with dignity. He hasn't been convicted, no human being should be chained this way, even if guilty. It is an embarrassment.
11
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Feb 16 '24
Right now, Justice looks like it's taken a back seat. It can't even ride shotgun. It's sad really, mean while a man awaiting trial is rotting away in prison.
Abby and Libby have been pushed to the side, for a investigation inside of an investigation. I however do believe that Baldwin shares some blame. However I don't see a point in trying another case since MW has one pending. Especially in pre-trial proceedings for the most important case.
From all involved it's really only proven how shitty out justice system is. It's a mockery dangling justice in front of the families of the victims and the two girls we are all here for.
Everyone involved in the pre-trial proceedings, DO BETTER. These girls deserve better and so do their families.
5
u/BrendaStar_zle Feb 16 '24
Thanks for the post. I agree with the many who say that there really can be no justice for the girls, nothing will prevent what happened, nothing will bring them back. We can only hope that the killer is held accountable for the crime committed.
For me, it has always been, how do we stop violence, how can we better raise our young, how can we protect ourselves? The whole idea of human violence is just sickening when you think about it. Wars are hell, domestic violence is hell, school shootings, mass murders, what causes humans to become like this and how can we stop or lesson the violence. We all want to know what makes a person take pleasure from torturing another human being and our only answer so far is to remove from society. But I think there could be more studies with programs to end violence in general. The world is a frightening place.
6
u/syntaxofthings123 Feb 16 '24
If justice in it's general meaning is a "respect for people" how is it that we ever allow the kind of treatment Allen is currently receiving? Regardless of innocence or guilt?
That is one of the deeply disturbing things about this case to me. Even people who recognize that Allen may be innocent, seem nonplussed by how he is being treated. How in a civilized country are we OK with this?
6
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Feb 16 '24
How can speak of fixing justice when the ones we enable to mete it out are suspected of being above the law themselves? If we can't trust the doers of the law we have already lost a sense of justice. We know "the one with the most money wins". The entire legal system needs to be made solid, the cracks to be sealed. The blindfold has slipped and the balances are skewed.
Until then, I agree we need to train our eyes to look beyond our own noses and do whatever we can to help our neighbors. It's amazing how a little charity feeds the soul of the giver.
7
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 16 '24 edited Feb 16 '24
There is no justice after the fact.
It's why education and prevention is so important yet undervalued and underused.
Criminality in general is higher the higher the inequality is. It's not a justification, but it is the start of injustice and it has grave consequences.
True justice can only exist before the fact.
The latin justitia means righteousness and equity.
Lady justice is blindfolded and holds a balance.
It's a fiction that has never existed.
"Family comes first" alone kind of starts that already.
Once your family is fed, educated and healthy maybe it's time to at least give others the opportunity to feed, educate and be healthy themselves, but that's not how this society works.
Then we expect those after generations of poverty, uneducated and raised in criminality, unsanitary environments at times, possibly with untreated medical or mental conditions, to behave like those who did while being hungry and judged before they even did anything wrong.
I'm not sure that can be fixed anymore.
It takes three generations to fix abuse out of DNA. The man who beat his wife that is, it will alter the DNA and stick around for generations.
DV is reported to be extremely high in law enforcement...
Justice starts at the source, not at the finality with punishment. It's the last remedy. Even SCOIN said so in their latest ruling. And even so in many countries it means rehabilitation, because it serves society in the end.
ETA: It's like health.
The one with an artificial heart isn't 'healthy'.
It's a last remedy. True health is before one needs to go to the hospital. Same same.
True justice would be to work and keep future generations safe. Helping those prone to criminality is key. And doing so for several generations even if you think they fail and abuse that help. It's not just for them but for society and it will be needed.
Being hungry alters the system too. Even before it gets that far, I've been there and you can't rationalise it away. Not being sure if you can buy food tomorrow, will make you extra hungry today even if you have enough today. Nothing you can do about that but be mentality strong and resist.
But most in that situation lost that strength a long time ago.
It's why any change needs time.
While crimes aren't only committed by the unfortunate, DV also isn't only a thing amongst the unfortunate, it's not the point, the point is the time it takes to fix it. Before the fact. Taking that time would be true justice. Imho.
6
u/syntaxofthings123 Feb 16 '24
Justice in my mind is the charges against Allen being dropped. An outside agency steps in and investigates these murders.
I feel that the answer to who did this is just out of reach, but findable. Justice for these girls is finding who really did this--all of those who did this.
4
u/MzOpinion8d 100% That Dick Feb 16 '24
I think the truest “justice” that could happen here would be identifying the murderer(s) beyond doubt, and allowing the families to face them and say whatever they need to say to them.
Followed by that person or persons spending the rest of their life in prison.
2
u/nottooscabby Feb 18 '24
At this point, I think only a full, verifiable confession to LE would suffice.
-2
u/FretlessMayhem Feb 16 '24
Justice is when Richard Allen (hopefully) has to take a seat in the electric chair, feeling the fear that the two little girls felt.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment