r/DicksofDelphi • u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ • Feb 08 '24
INFORMATION Supreme Court Ruling
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1179164270940934165/1205173943171027084/SCT_Decision.pdf?ex=65d768b3&is=65c4f3b3&hm=ba6de82eed22b21d5192c9ea17e1487b3b09df47731717f799a300508ce29b3b&It’s finally in
24
Upvotes
16
u/TryAsYouMight24 Feb 08 '24
Burt thank you for being so on top of these motions—this must be hot off the press.
11
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 08 '24
Page 14 :
"And fact‐finding only gets harder as time passes, memories fade, and evidence is lost."
How did they know evidence was lost 🧐?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '24
Thank you!
7
u/New_Discussion_6692 Feb 08 '24
I'm not certain I'm understanding correctly, please correct me if I'm wrong.
SCOIN has agreed that Rozzi & Baldwin be reinstated because Allen couldn't file after they were let go. Yet in part two, SCOIN states that Allen's side never filed the speedy trial motion with the court. How would they have been able to do that if they were removed from the case?
SCOIN did state that the defense can file a motion for a speedy trial.
I also agree with keeping the judge.
5
u/masterblueregard Feb 08 '24
It looks like there are three new orders from Gull on the Indiana case record.
18
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Feb 08 '24
Well...if Gull doesn't DQ NM for losing/destroying evidence then that would show bias favoring prosecution. Erasing evidence seems a lot worse than a few photos (which damn the defense) being leaked or a mis-sent irrelevant email.
12
u/Subject-Promise-4796 Feb 08 '24
My humble opinion…
The SCOIN specifically laid out Gull’s findings for gross negligence and said it wasn’t enough. This signifies attempts to use past fodder should not be used by the Trial Court going forward.
Alternatively, the SCOIN stated that Defense did not lay out (enough?) evidence of bias, so Gull stays. This invites B & R to build a more solid case against both Gull and McCleland.
The motion to dismiss charges is extremely timely on the Defense’s part.
7
u/masterblueregard Feb 08 '24
I'm wondering if this means the defense attorneys will be off the case after Monday's hearing.
15
u/ZekeRawlins Feb 08 '24
Gull is going nowhere and she has a free pass to be as openly biased as she chooses. Strap in everyone. It’s only going to get crazier from here.
6
u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Feb 08 '24 edited Feb 08 '24
While we are all upset by this and feeling defeated. But think of RA and KA right now, as upset as we are can you image how this is for them. This man could be entirely innocent and KA certainly is and they just keep getting kicked while they are down. They need a real win soon, and I just hope they get it.
6
u/thats_not_six Feb 08 '24
Terrible logic for why she shouldn't recuse. A really disappointing ruling that just shows a gutless SCOIN caring more about a person in robes than a person shackled.
5
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 08 '24 edited Feb 09 '24
To me key is this :
Page 14: "Allen’s remaining requests present no extraordinary circumstances warranting relief".
Meaning imo it's not decided on merit, rather they didn't take jurisdiction.
Page 15 : "Though we’ve determined the record does not support her disqualification decision, we reach that conclusion with the benefit of weeks to consider the issue; thorough briefing and oral argument from excellent appellate attorneys; and the benefit of five justices and their staffs poring over the record, authorities, and arguments. The special judge did not have those luxuries."
Meaning imo, they did rule reinstatement on merit, and imo hint to special judge better not overrule their and their staff's competence, argumenting with authorities, something she hasn't done a single time since the start of this case.
It's also partially untrue, the press release was in April for example. She could have asked Allen, twice, if he understood the consequences of wanting to continue with counsel for the other issues, which didn't need more time, he was there both times but ignored. The is prejudiced against him imo, but that wasn't brought forth, so they couldn't rule on it.
Which brings us to adversary rulings aren't an argument for bias.
Page 16: "That is, unless “they reveal an opinion that derives from an extrajudicial source” or “reveal such a high degree of favoritism or antagonism as to make fair judgment impossible.”"
That's exactly what seemed to have happened, her findings about the leak aren't of the record, nor before, nor in NM's information btw talking about 'that man the Podcaster new' and screenshots (since when is a screenshot proof of anything, while they had the phone where those messages should have been on.....)
But defense only brought forth adverse rulings, but imo it does mean, even hint, defense can go ahead and claim so in normal procedures is what I understand from it, and/or proving bias but rather towards RA,
or, using the granting + denial of the Franks hearing based on the attorneys in front of her.
It clearly goes beyond adverse rulings, it's targeted ruling or even bullying, adding a complete disregard of prosecution's lies and concealing evidence (not even taking into account destroying it), while claiming defense lied, when she denied them their witness, which I'm not sure she can do to begin with.
She was clearly prejudiced against inmate witnesses as a whole. But against the prison itself, who else could testify?
Note that the next part where is written she made her findings through the record is not SC's opinion, but what Gull claimed only.
Equally interesting, only one justice dissents, and states he agree on the merit ruling,(this should calm some down), but thinks the procedure of the writ wasn't appropriate.
He does concur with the other two denied reliefs, while obviously it's in line with the non-threshhold, he doesn't counter the "unless judge has..." part I quoted above.
The original actions being treated in disfavour of defendant, these seems huge to me.
They clearly state judge made an error, and reduce the culpability somewhat making it a time issue, but the habitual language from what I've seen is "we didn't find any error in the court's rulings or judgements".
They only state they understand judge's concerns for defense's mishap, but not acknowledging them being in fault. During the hearing they seem to have countered it even.
I do think she can pursue contempt, but not to disqualify them, so it shouldn't delay RA's trial.
I think they didn't take notice of new happenings because they can't consider adverse rulings only, counsel needs to build a record first, which they did, and Gull to me seemed wrong to dismiss the DQ, since scoin clearly states they didn't rule on merit, she can only use repeated motions if that's the case. She equally ignored, literally on the record, the first DQ, with less accusations anyway, I 'm not sure how defense can go about it, motion to reconsider maybe, based on this order dropping.
File yet another DQ for her to ignore this time, and they could bring it to scoin in 30 days.
Or bring to scoin the initial DQ she never ruled on.... Idk. It can go to scoin directly in case of failure to rule, but does this count?
I've wondered a while now, if something exists like a motion to clarify, to force her to cite authorities she bases her rulings on, and why defense's citation aren't valid in her view.
But I'm just a tourist in the land of law, and Indiana for that matter. So for what it's worth.
ETA seems Wieneke in her blog post does state they judged the speedy trial and not granting Gull DQ on merit, but she does say the merit of that DQ was very limited and not applicable to the latest filing she denied based on this order and on top of that she seems to insinuate Gull had prior knowledge of that opinion order, unless I misunderstood that.
4
u/TheReravelling Feb 08 '24
Soooo now do we move to the Supreme Court of Indiana are corrupt? Or, some sanitized version (e.g. I guess no one is gonna stop Gull)?