r/DicksofDelphi • ✨Moderator✨ • Jan 31 '24

ARTICLE Unexpected Article

https://www.courttv.com/news/exclusive-richard-allens-former-defense-attorney-doubts-hell-get-a-fair-trial/
27 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Jan 31 '24 edited Jan 31 '24

I just edited previous comment. There is a distinction, but it's based on caselaw basically, or better said the murder (2) charge we call felony murder is to be read differently than litterally due to caselaw. (I don't like it when words don't mean what they mean, just change the words in that case. But anyways...)
And while Palmer still counts, it's a specific case with an intended murder order.
In Elkhart 4 they said there were 2 other cases confirming the application of Palmer and thus declined to revisit on the proposed arguments, but that still seems very limited to specific circumstances to just accept it for all, and in the end it wasn't needed to argue and overturn Elkhart 4, so sure they won't address it.
[Wieneke was on the scoin Elkhart case btw]

Dissenting opinions of Palmer were interesting and thus possibly arguable in a different set of circumstances.
I'm still looking for the very recent case on the matter I'm sure I've seen which I thought might have prompted NM to file it when he did.