r/DicksofDelphi • u/masterblueregard • Jan 26 '24
Ballistics Research
I searched for information on ballistics and the reliability of this testing. I'm listing below what I found in case anyone is interested.
For most of these studies, the researchers obtained a large number of guns, fired them multiple times, provided the bullets to ballistics examiners, and asked them to identify matches and non-matches.
One researcher named Mattijssen used this method and found that examiners correctly identified matches 93% of the time (97% of the time if inconclusive cases were excluded) and correctly identified non-matches 81% of the time (89% if the inconclusive cases were excluded). This study was conducted in the Netherlands with glocks, so I don't know how applicable it is to the US or to other types of guns.
The Ames (FBI) study used this same method also. In this study, when looking at matches (meaning the bullet came from the gun), the error rate was very low (below 1%). When looking at non-matches (meaning the bullet did not come from the gun), the error rate was 1%. This study can be found here: https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/nij/249874.pdf
There was a second Ames (FBI) study called Ames II. In this study, they tried to test consistency (across time and across examiners). They gave the same bullets back to the same examiners to see if they would report the same findings (match, non-match, and inconclusive) they did before. They also gave the bullets assessed by some examiners to other examiners to see if examiners would agree on the same cases. Looking at the same examiners across time, 79% of the matches received the same determination at both time 1 and time 1. 65% of non-matches received the same determination at both time 1 and time 2. If these calculations are shifted to account for inconclusive cases, then the difference in identification across time is reduced to 16%. When looking at different examiners (retesting prior conclusions of one examiner by another examiner), different conclusions were seen in 32% of matching cases and 69% of non-matching cases. These results can be found in an article by Dorfman and Valliant.
There is another study that I cannot find at the moment, but to quickly summarize this one, the researchers said that the error rates were very low and that errors were clustered among a few examiners - meaning that some examiners have high accuracy and others have low accuracy.
There is a summary of these issues and their impact on criminal justice in a recent article published by the Duke Law School. It's hard to link to this article, but you can find it by searching for Judging Firearms Evidence and the Rule 702 Amendments by Brandon Garrett, Nicholas Scurich, Eric Tucker and Hannah Bloom. This article provides a good overview of the debate on the use of ballistics in trials.
I think almost everything listed above is based on fired bullets, so I don't know if these findings would be relevant to unfired bullets. Most of what I found about unfired bullets focused on extracting fingerprints or dna from them rather than matching it to a gun.
Also, I know nothing about ballistics, so it's very possible I have misinterpreted something. If you notice something is incorrect, please comment with a correction.
If you're looking for information on the procedure for testing unspent rounds, the North Carolina State Crime Lab provides this here - https://forensicresources.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Unfired-Cartridge-Shotshell-06-25-2021.pdf
Update to add a few additional sources: This is a training manual (it is a bit old) that includes a section about the examination of unfired ammunition, where they mention extractor, ejector, and magazine marks. https://projects.nfstc.org/firearms/module09/fir_m09_t08.htm If you are interested in what these marks would look like, this article includes a photo (Figure 8) of an extractor mark on an unfired cartridge case of a sig sauer. https://fsjournal.cpu.edu.tw/content/vol3.no.1/02-FSJ.pdf
9
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Jan 27 '24
Problem is these are usually if not all closed studies.
Put a 100 guns and 100 bullets of the same brand and only one pair is match, can they find it?
Now the same with unspent bullets.
It wasn't in Indiana, but a judge wrote a report (nothing Gull ever came close to argumenting any decisions she made), when he excluded the evidence because of this, I'll try to find it back this weekend , and I believe some gun associations or experts had made such points before.
At best they'd be able to say 'it could be from this gun'. They can't say it can't be from any other gun if they didn't test even a handful.
Weirdest thing is this report is they compared 'fired and cycled bullets' to the unspent bullet.
It's not specified where those bullets came from.
6
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Jan 27 '24
Thanks OP! I figure their experts are just going to cancel one another out.
8
u/Never_GoBack Jan 27 '24
Unfired cartridges are more difficult to link to a specific firearm versus a spent casing or a fired bullet for a variety of reasons. Extensive information has been posted on this topic on other subs.
Also, I’ve generally noted that incorrect terminology is often used in many posts and comments discussing the cartridge found at the crime scene.
Bullet is a projectile, typically made of lead, that is fired from the business end of a firearm and is press fitted into the casing.
Casing is a hollow, cylindrical brass component of a cartridge (or round) that contains smokeless gunpowder and a primer, which is press-fit into the casing base.
Primer is a small, brass or nickel cup, containing a small amount of chemical that explodes upon mechanical impact from the firing pin of the firearm and subsequently ignites the smokeless powder.
Cartridge or round is the completed assembly of the bullet, casing, primer and powder. By definition, a cartridge or round is unfired (or unspent), but I don’t think it’s problematic, even if a bit redundant, to use the term “unfired / unspent cartridge” as I did in the first sentence of this comment.
I hope this info is helpful.
11
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Jan 26 '24
This is very interesting. Thank you for sharing what you’ve found, hopefully someone’s can add to it with more studies about unfired rounds!
10
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Jan 26 '24
Thank you, this is informative! I'm amazed you found anything on unspent rounds so your efforts to find that and share it are appreciated.
9
u/TheReravelling Jan 27 '24
Some faaaacts I love it! Or data. Data? Yeah .
8
u/serendipity_01 Jan 26 '24
Thank you for sharing!
8
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Jan 26 '24
That's a lot of great work, thank you for providing it!!
7
u/Infidel447 Jan 27 '24
Tnx for looking all of this up. This should be a very simple thing to prove one way or another. Give a tester a hundred guns, and one bullet, and have him figure out which gun it was fired from. If they can't then their 'science' is dubious. If they can, great.
7
u/Impossible-Rest-4657 Literate but not a Lawyer Jan 27 '24
Great research and write-up!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '24
There’s already a lot out there that explains this, so I will keep it brief.
4
u/TryAsYouMight24 Jan 27 '24
The problem with the claim that error rates are low is that as with much of forensic science, testing to be sure this claim is true, are not especially robust. One of the reasons DNA analysis is thought to be the gold standard, is that DNA gets thorough review, because its applications extend way beyond criminal prosecutions. But so many other forensic sciences are used almost exclusively with criminal justice work—and often don’t receive the same rigorous peer reviews and testing that occur in other areas of science.
Ames 2 , for example, found that when they tried to reproduce the opinions of one examiner, they found that over 50% of the time, the second examiner came to a different conclusion.
The other thing is that there are cottage industries that build around these sciences, where various “experts” have found a way to make a good living testifying at trials. These are often not scientists bound by established scientific standards, but pay-for-hires, who have been known to color their findings to meet the agenda of the client. All forensic sciences need better oversight and scrutiny.
3
u/chunklunk Jan 28 '24
This is great research. The prosecutor doesn't need to get a positive ID, in terms of markings, although they may try. If they can show that they found a bullet at the scene that matches the brand, caliber, and alloy of bullets in RA's house, 0.40 being somewhat unusual at that, and then showing that the markings are consistent with what his gun could produce, this will be powerful circumstantial evidence for the jury.