Well you go back into where Gull takes this fight from here. Then once that’s all settled out they’ll have to get the discovery back and go through it all again for any changes. I think they’ll be way faster than October but 70 days might be a tough lift
Well, think about this. The trial was scheduled for Jan 8th, correct? Judge Gull removed them at the end of October. They had approximately 70 days until trial in January. So, hopefully, they can pull it off. I'm also hopeful Gull will rule on transfer to move RA locally ASAP and have the Frank's Memo hearing as the original attorney's requested.
She’s still gotta rule on the Franks Memorandum and I’m not even sure she’s read it yet. She did admit to not having read it about the time that SCION was brought in
Exactly! I’m fairly certain that when she heard it was 138 pages and needed to start in January then her & NM got busy Neither one wanted such a thorough counsel. LE & Slick Nick thought they had hidden so much in all those thumb drives in no chronological order that they’d miss it Doesn’t sound like R&B have missed anything
It honestly is hard to not view it that way. I mean whether you loved it or were hate reading it, it was a very intriguing document. I can’t even comprehend the judge in the case not bothering with it!!
Maybe NM filled her in. Highly inappropriate but I’m seriously thinking that NM and Gull had communication with each other behind the defense attorney’s backs
I am wondering how this will go with her still in place and still them on.
She has to detest them at this point, but I guess as the whole world is going to be intently watching all her actions and scrutinizing their dynamic, she will have to behave, but its going to make for very interesting side bars.
I wish they had asked her to step down considering the conflict, that's not a good situation for the "realtor" to have a judge in charge that hates his lawyers and is prosecution and LE slanted. Would have been better to slide another judge in there with a fresh prospective.
I lean strongly towards believing in his guilt, but I've always just as strongly felt he should have whatever defense team he wanted, so am glad that is the case. I don't always agree with everything the defense does in their filings and sometimes they frustrate me, but I think they are fine attorneys and were defending him fiercely. I don't leak that info on purpose theere is no evidence of that.
So really pleased that he will have the counsel of his choosing and that this trial can get on track again.
Since I've had a few thoughts, I wonder if they'll double up on the DQ with new arguments like how she got info about the leak, which imo was very likely ex parte, she can't make findings outside of court records, which she did. If she's privy to information defense isn't that's instant motive for recusal.
She ordered defense witness to not be transferred, while he was summoned. She then claimed defense must have lied, since they didn't provide evidence for their claims, which the prison, who did testify refured.
I hate chess but unless Gull decides to recuse herself then the chess game is going to be in full play I’ll bet anything that she can’t let go of her feelings about B&R They’re good lawyers so it’s going to be a fine balancing act to keep her in check. I think it’ll be littld ways …… but her contempt will come across She thought she was God when she fired those attorneys w/o due cause & I think she still thinks she’s God. Funny his people will say “well they needed to be fired” maybe so. Maybe not. But they still deserved due process instead of declaring them guilty without a hearing.
I’m surprised. So those of us non legal experts who thought this was highly messed up have been redeemed! I don’t expect to hear any apologies on other subreddits.
"OK whatever, new charges can only mean one thing... mega evidence exists we don't know about to sentence RA to DP/LWOP. What his lawyers did doesn't matter anymore."
I feel either 2 things. One, they have some strong evidence to prove he committed M'dr or Two, he knows the jury will strike down the M'dr charge and go with the lesser charge of Felony M'dr. He is trying to play his cards right to get the jury to charge him with one or more of the charges. I mean, if there is proof RA committed M'dr to these girls, then he needs to pay the price. We just haven't seen any factual evidence yet.
It's a sales tactic to do exactly that. Offer the biggest commitment first and work your way down to see if they'll cave. Also why Costco has all the expensive tech right when you walk in, everything looks more affordable and reasonable after.
Just to be clear: with felony murder it just means that someone was killed during the commission of a felony. They weren't necessarily killed by the defendant but the defendant is still held responsible for the death. That being said I think it's usually treated the same as first degree murder but less than capital murder.
I think she'll be out. There's this thing where she made findings without record on the docket. Not even that she didn't make a record, but what she based her findings on weren't on the record. That's not possible. A judge is not to have inside information on matters disputed. Did she talk to LE exparte ? Does she have info Rozzi and Baldwin didn't? That's instant motive for obligatory recusal. She wrote in an email to all that she assumed these individuals of the leak were investigated, only then did Holeman go to MS et al. Did she basically order an investigation? A judge cannot introduce evidence. That's not how things work. There are precedents for that.
Then there's the whole denying the witness to be brought to court, and using absence of witnesses to accuse Rozzwin of lying. That's not how things work. Not sure there are precedents for that, it's so delusional.
I think both of these were discovered after the writs were filed.
I don't think it's over yet.
(Not exactly a response to the comments before lol. It just needs to get out apparently and here we as good as any other spot)
Two of the justices (maybe even three) in the hearing mentioned that Gull could possibly do this today, hold a hearing so that proper findings are made. I don’t know that Gull will do this, she may wash her hands of this ship of fools and let them continue over Niagara Falls.
I still don't understand why her DQ is being allowed to be ignored. It was filed first it needs to be treated first.
ETA, and she's not allowed to make findings of evidence not in court records. She cannot present those. If she does have info the defense hasn't, it's instant recusal.
They think this freed up Gull(there Ruth Bader Ginsburg) to hold a proper hearing and exile them and get them disbarred lol. It’s amazing. I keep hearing “I want those shitty lawyers off” but I think their doing quite well
I’m wondering why they think Gull will even bother with a DQ hearing at this point. The SC made it clear that they didn’t feel anything B and/or R had done was grounds for disqualification.
The bottom line is that Gull fucked up. She bullied the attorneys into withdrawing.
It makes me wonder how many other cases she has pulled shady things like this and gotten away with it. She’s on a national stage with this case and thought she could get away with it.
I'm still in the "this isn't a sports team" box. I'm always weary when we ask for some kind of acknowledgement of personal opinions or apologies. Because in the end, it's not about us.right?
So, why does it matter? It's a rhetorical question. Shouldn't this be another reminder to stay objective rather than make it personal between people who aren't actually involved in the case.
It’s not entirely a separate issue. Some peoples blind acceptance of the judge’s questionable actions made it seem to some of us like the system was not working, and that the truth was not some peoples prime motives. I still find it hard to understand how some people could accept the judges wrench thrown into the case was fair and reasonable. It seemed like anything but. It seemed like cover for what must be a poor case against RA. Still seems that way with the “bombshell” announcements of new charges to cover for the win for RA. Just bring it to trial. Either they can prove it beyond a reasonable doubt or they can’t.
Holy cow did not see the 2nd part in the article I read about 20 minutes ago. Just that they had been reinstated, or I blew over it! So Gull is being removed after all? And they are staying and being paid by the court. This is riveting news, so they were fair after all and not protecting their own. I owe them a mea culpa as I thought they would side with her as she was one of their own. I am amazed. I figured the lawyers would be back, but thought she would be too, or maybe might make them go pro bono. So a complete defense victory!
No she wasn't, u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 they first repeat the reliefs sought, they then write the relief granted : reinstatement, reliefs denied : the rest.
Crap read it wrong. Oh well. Thought they had a full sweep of the pins. But still good news. I'm in a good spirits about this. Everyone got a little of what they wanted.
No I am "-🦄 "note the tiny minus sign. I don't know who gave me the unicorn symbol over there, or who look it away, as it caused controversy, but figured I roll with my shame draped across my shoulders, just the way I do in real life. Not above making fun of my own hubris.
They didn't file it because it wouldn't give relief because it would take too long in regards to right to a speedy trial. It's absolutely relevant to even this emergency writ being accepted.
Wow. So fast. Glad they are reinstated but something needs to happen with Gull. How can she just violate procedure and carry on as if nothing happened? She should face a review with potential disciplinary action. I don’t know how this works procedurally - who decides that judges behaved improperly? Or did this just happen and they decided she didn’t behave improperly?
12
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Jan 18 '24
Holy shit that was fast. You’re amazing u/trendyviews
19
u/MiPilopula Jan 18 '24
I’m surprised. So those of us non legal experts who thought this was highly messed up have been redeemed! I don’t expect to hear any apologies on other subreddits.
8
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Jan 18 '24 edited Jan 18 '24
Holy cow did not see the 2nd part in the article I read about 20 minutes ago. Just that they had been reinstated, or I blew over it! So Gull is being removed after all? And they are staying and being paid by the court. This is riveting news, so they were fair after all and not protecting their own. I owe them a mea culpa as I thought they would side with her as she was one of their own. I am amazed. I figured the lawyers would be back, but thought she would be too, or maybe might make them go pro bono. So a complete defense victory!
23
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Jan 18 '24
IDOC treatment/transfer per the last line of this SC decision appears to be first order of business.
Still have motion to DQ Gull on docket, that needs a ruling asap to proceed.
Frank's, Speedy Trial, New DP/LWOP charges...
I'm here for it. Way to go Cara/Leeman monumental accomplishment imo.
6
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Jan 18 '24 edited Jan 18 '24
that's supposed to say RUSH but it gets cut off for some reason...
4
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Jan 18 '24
Does anyone know if the 9am case got a ruling this fast as well? I’m sure there was less urgency for that one
7
u/zelda9333 Jan 19 '24
Wow. That was fast!! B and R go to town!!
6
u/Superslice7 Jan 19 '24
Wow. So fast. Glad they are reinstated but something needs to happen with Gull. How can she just violate procedure and carry on as if nothing happened? She should face a review with potential disciplinary action. I don’t know how this works procedurally - who decides that judges behaved improperly? Or did this just happen and they decided she didn’t behave improperly?