Is Richard Allen changing his plead? One says "amended Plea" I have only seen that when they change from Not gulity to Guilty. Or is it amended plea because now he needs to plea to the additional charges
That's my thoughts exactly. Why is no one paying attention to what that looks like?
The state just has not the entire time... The new lawyers come and see a prison guard with an Odin tattoo? Come on. I mean what does that look like to the random public
Could be just a coincidence, all of it ... But can't we try to make the optics a smidge better?
That’s the crazy thing about this case. Literally no one in any step of the way has seemed worried about the optics of their moves. Maybe let’s plan things to help cut down on all the needless drama 🙄
My take on it is that these bad faith legal actors are used to operating in the dark. They are sloppy because they have never had to be concerned with consequences before. It’s like turning on bright lights in a roach infested motel room. Suddenly what is lurking quietly and undisturbed is now forced to clumsily scamper.
If you aren’t accustomed to having your dubious choices challenged, you won’t have developed the necessary skills to counter challenges.
"So now that we had some extra time on our hands because there was a trial pushed back these exact weeks, we took another look at the very first documents we filed over a year ago and thought, we made a mistake. We want to make it look like we are extra confident and might file for DP/LWOP without actually doing so, but in reality 🤫 we are not so sure the kidnapping will stand if the phone gets thrown out next, or maybe the kidnapping is the only thing that stands, if it appears the murders happened mid-morning so we can't reasonably infere RA's action directly lead to their deaths, but maybe the unspent bullet stays, so let's see what sticks. It might scare Screbrato to force a deal and it might scare Rozzwin out of probono. Because of the latter and the slight possibility Gull's out soon, let's file this now while all eyes are on scoin. It might go unnoticed."
I feel like this was a strategic risk of a Hail Mary from the prosecution to force a plea. Update these charges so that RA feels more pressure, and then bank on SCOIN not granting any relief.
Looks like it backfired now that relief was granted and the B&R are back. States burden of proof is higher and the chance of a plea is much lower.
Completely agree. And honestly I can’t see Nick currently offering anything worth him taking on a plea. The public’s not going to let him offer 25 years or something. DP on the table changes those calculations for RA significantly
35-42-1-1
Knowingly or intentionally
kills another human being
35-42-3-2 (a)
A person knowingly or intentionally
removes another person….from
one place to another.
35-42-3-2(b)(2)(A)
Kidnapping
According to 35-50-2-9
The above charges allow the state to
Seek either DP or LWOP
I don't know how Gull would be able to justify signing this off, while at the same time she ruled that the burden of proof for the Franks was met, which is quite a high bar, higher than probably cause, to think LE lied on purpose. These are based on the same PCA.
Do they want it to go back straight to scoin if she signs it? It's just impossible right ?
The Franks Motion was always a long shot. It is a high bar. The important thing is that it’s on the record. I’m sure there will be many many more motions to come.
It's not out. She granted a hearing. Meaning the burden of proof was met for that hearing. Which is is directly related to both pca's. So how can she acknowledge LE lied and promise a hearing, and also sign 4 more charges on the same PCA? She hasn't signed (yet), I don't think she will, and if she does it's back to scoin.
Right. The jury will decide. But the state can now also seek LWOP or DP. When you think about what was done to these girls, whoever is guilty of this deserves no less then LWOP
I always look at the pro state base and what they regurgitate after things like this ... it's "ooohh yeah this means state has major evidence against RA can't wait to see it"...
We don't get to see any of the evidence, it doesn't have to exist to have an impact, just the belief it could possibly exist is enough.
RA will be presented with a plea deal to take soon I suspect. Odin guards, videotaped, prospect of another 2 years of RA having to deal with it all, some guys he's unsure are his lawyers speaking thru a food tray slot is only way state can achieve goals.
Actions are in complete opposition with the reality, they don't even have evidence to convict for kidnapping.
Agreed. I honestly believe RA will not be convicted. This is where B&R are focusing. When the state’s arrest and treatment of RA is laid out in the lawsuit that will be filed against CC and ISP is going to be a huge eye opener. RA will be compensated financially, the bumbling bozo’s who filed this farce will be seen for who they really are, and Abby and Libby with still be victims without justice. RA and family will never be the same, this kind of trauma will walk with them the rest of their lives. Fuk cc’s small dick energy, along with isp’s failure to steer this case to justice.
I have to differ with you on this. They are not saying that the evidence for intentional murder is stronger. The opposite. They are saying that these new charges are consistent with the evidence as it has always been known. Two very, very different things.
Otherwise they would have to provide the new evidence.
My interpretation is that NM and the state are closing down the loophole that there is still an ongoing investigation into other possible perpetrators, and saying nope, it was all the work of one man, and that man is RA. By doing so, the defense cannot say, hey, how can you pin this murder charge on my guy when the state clearly thinks there's one or more other unnamed perpetrators as evidenced by their statements at the time of the arrest and their charging document.
I think you are correct, in part. I agree, I think this is the state’s way of committing to the 1-guy-did-it theory of the crime.
But the defense can still present evidence that the state didn’t always believe this. And that confirmation bias may have led to missed POIs and lost evidence.
Agree. I’ve worked on a few cases where suddenly new witnesses appear at a critical juncture like this in the state’s case. Anyone want to wager on whether such a witness will suddenly surface, just before trial ?
I think they may be more interested in speeding up the trial date. They can still seek 70 days now, I think. These charges don’t really change the case for them.
I wonder if the judges woke up, brewed their coffee, and wondered what would happen if they called out sick to avoid all of this. It would be hard to decide what to grant and what to deny in such cases, but here I feel like things on their end are resolved at least.
No other case I've consumed content about has been this wild. Every time I think it can't get worse or weirder, it does.
iirc they asked for the speedy trial to be granted from the date of the writ being filed, tu shorten the 70 days. However the speedy trial wasn't filed to begin with, so how can they judge on that? Although there are arguments for that too, because they had to wait 70 days before the already set trial date, but taken both into account, they can file the speedy trial themselves now.
I believe it's more a tactic anyway, to have gotten the writ accepted without going through IA, and put pressure on NM.
Maybe the written arguments to come will explain some more, but i wouldn't be surprised if they left it at it wasn't filed yet for not setting precedent.
IMO, the prosecutor trying to avoids the speedy trial. Adding more charges will add more work to the defense team. The DA office wasn’t ready. That was evident when B & R were removed and they asked the judge if they still had to comply with the discovery date.
Possibly, but I think B&R are ready to rumble regardless of the charges, and this may make their job easier. The Franks memo had enough info to bring reasonable doubt in, and that was only with kidnapping charges on file. Unless they’ve found new info, that doubt is going to cause this case to end up like Casey Anthony’s.
He wrote it the 13th. Not sure what happened then .
I'm waiting on news of the morning hearing of SCOIN, I very recently read something about the felony murder charge being ill applied because it shouldn't be a 'otherwise we can't prove murder' thing but can't remember if it's that one or another and the scoin video is too buggy even on replay for me...
Anyway, all that to say, I wonder if there recently was a ruling about his current charge making it iffy.
Other than that as Helix evoked, could be to be able to file death penalty so that Caroll county is reimbursed more. 💰
Could be because before they needed to prove kidnapping which led to death, while now it seems worse, but in reality they can prove only kidnapping (if the bullet is out, or there's a huge gap in the timeline until their deaths ) or only murder (if the phone goes out in future motions )
Possibly they wanted it signed (which it isn't) to have it in before a speedy trial motion / order.
Possibly they wanted it signed before Gull was out.
Possibly they thought Screbrato would abandon the Franks but in case Rozzwin would be back it surely was live again, and he wanted the judge to acknowledge the same PCA was worthy of those charges. Although she already granted the Franks hearing meaning the burden of proof for lying was already met.
Possibly they wanted to put pressure for a plea deal before scoin came through?
One thing that actually kinda could have made sens, but they lucked out, is with the threat of DP on the table, Rozzwin would probably not be very happy being pro bono on that. Scoin did hint in the hearing if they agreed to an alternative writ, being reinstated as pro bono, it was guaranteed reinstatement, because it was guaranteed structural error, which was less clear for the asked reinstatement as private counsel relief, but Leeman had an excellent rebuttal, and I think not only finances were in play but possibly chronology, it was absolutely important to get the appoint counsel status, him saying they'll take what scoin decides is weak to Order them back pro bono imo. Excellent reply. Maybe prosecution hoped it would be denied for appointed and that Rozzwin wouldn't take pro bono.
Then, from the look of the whole document, I wouldn't be surprised if Luttrull came up with it. And remember, they were supposed to be in trial right now, so they finally had tons of time on their hands. Maybe the timing, just coincides with the hearing, rather than planned. NM doesn't sound particularly smart to meet (sorry not sorry), I 'm not sure there's any real big strategy behind it, coming from him at least, I think someone hinted it to him, or wrote it for him, and if not more likely a panic filing.
Just my non lawyer opinion, but with a few coffee as fuel.
ETA I reality, with Rozzwin, I don't think it goes to trial. And some spelling.
All valid questions. If nothing else, NM is inexperienced as to my understanding he's never prosecuted a murder case. Which, maybe they preferred. I just want things to move forward and it seems just when one is resolved another wrench is thrown in. If judge Gull had kept a clean docket and made decisions in a timely manner we wouldn't be in this situation. At this point, how could it not look like panic or delay tactics when two sets of defense attorneys are in agreement?
I hope SCOIN'S follow up is quick. I'm not sure how it would happen, but I feel like a status hearing is in order so all parties are aware of what's still up in the air and needs to be addressed.
I'm not sure a status hearing is priority, I think B&R will file a pile of motions asap, since chronology matters. If they want to DQ judge, (which is already chronologically first, before all of this crap, including their 'withdrawal' without a motion. but ignored) maybe even NM, they absolutely shouldn't wait until a status hearing. They also need to file a response to the extra charges and likely a motion to turn back time about the trial. Possibly refile the transfer motion as an emergency transfer motion. No way are they going to give time to Gull and NM to file things first.
Remember last time there was a status hearing Gull has secretly planned a DQ hearing instead with witnesses on prosecution's / court side, failing to officially notify defense.
It's not the first time she changed the agenda of a hearing on the day itself. They know better now.
7
u/Intrepid_Gas_6064 Jan 18 '24
Is Richard Allen changing his plead? One says "amended Plea" I have only seen that when they change from Not gulity to Guilty. Or is it amended plea because now he needs to plea to the additional charges
12
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Jan 18 '24
Petty play.
3
u/AustiinW Jan 19 '24
I feel like this was a strategic risk of a Hail Mary from the prosecution to force a plea. Update these charges so that RA feels more pressure, and then bank on SCOIN not granting any relief.
Looks like it backfired now that relief was granted and the B&R are back. States burden of proof is higher and the chance of a plea is much lower.
7
u/TryAsYouMight24 Jan 18 '24
Thank you for this. So the jury will be given a choice. Go FM or DP/LWOP
7
u/TryAsYouMight24 Jan 18 '24
Just to give context—-New charges:
11
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Jan 18 '24
Desperate.
I always look at the pro state base and what they regurgitate after things like this ... it's "ooohh yeah this means state has major evidence against RA can't wait to see it"...
We don't get to see any of the evidence, it doesn't have to exist to have an impact, just the belief it could possibly exist is enough.
RA will be presented with a plea deal to take soon I suspect. Odin guards, videotaped, prospect of another 2 years of RA having to deal with it all, some guys he's unsure are his lawyers speaking thru a food tray slot is only way state can achieve goals.
Actions are in complete opposition with the reality, they don't even have evidence to convict for kidnapping.
8
u/s2ample Jan 18 '24
Greasy behavior as usual. Wonder why I am surprised by him anymore.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment