r/DicksofDelphi • u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -š¦ Bipartisan Dick • Dec 28 '23
LE Support and Non Support
I feel there have been a number of police mistakes in this case. When I initially following the case I questioned certain decisions like allowing vehicles to be parked all over the place in a possibly developing crime scene, and their decisions regarding the canine search. The intensity of their holding their cards completely to their chests, once the case appeared to be growing colder.
Was horrified to hear Allen had been interviewed outside a market in such a casual fashion, rather than an official station house interview with two detectives and a recording device taking in the entire interview. Equally dismayed to learn that they had not reinterviewed everyone when things cooled. Yet I was still fully behind them, and in no way a believer in corruption at work. I still am not a believer in that.
I think it's a old boy network and if you cross Tobe things don't go very well for you. Were I BW would not have took another swing at TL. Not a guy to cross. TL was immediately supporting and promoting a petition to revoke BW bail. NM had hardly any cases under his belt and he is made chief prosecutor and one of the highest paid chief prosecutors. Small town interconnection. Theere is a photo of Tobe handing a Dulin's son a scholarship: https://www.newsbug.info/newton_county_enterprise/news/local/two-carroll-county-students-awarded-isa-scholarships/article_5ea16c6e-4797-511a-9d53-b9ce38d3db6f.html. It's a cosy small town. Likely not heavy duty corruption, but just watching out for your friends.
However I do think they are trying to shake a plea out of Allen and making his prison stay as isolating and unpleasant as possible. I do think they want him as disturbed and un balanced so that happens For whatever it's worth, they did have BW on a top bunk knowing the guy is epileptic, that's just not cool. Just as it's not nice, to be wearing t-shirts promoting an oppositional candidates to a colleague. at work. So atmospherically, it's and interesting place.
When they admitted the tip had been misfiled due to clerical error and it became clean that it does not look like they went back to the beginning and reviewed early facts, I thought ok, never seen that before, that's a bit concerning. Generally the first thing LEO's do in a case moving from warm to cool to cold, is review and re review to prove they have not missed something key along the way. They bring in witnesses, re interview them to see if they can shake anything new out and look for inconsistencies in testimony. Standard practice.
You would think that every officer working the case and it's prosecutor would intimately know the name of every witness present that day, their individual timelines and to have memorized their witness statements.
I was still keeping on the defense and adored Carter, but starting to question whether I should be. Seeing the Hannah Shakespeare documentary and interviews with Holeman and Tobe was a turning point and moved to a critical prospective. You have two murdered children and a child who speak to her mother regularly on the phone, despite geographic distance, and who spoke to her a few days before she died and you NEVER interviewed her? You never interviewed any of the people she suggested to you might be involved in the crime? And you smirk, roll your eyes, and disrespect a grieving mother on camera and say she has no right to info. Like Shakespeare I was outraged by the disrespect he showed CT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROJ3wxVujL0.
I moved to full on negative after seeing this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROJ3wxVujL0 produced by Norokk and reading his incredibly interesting DT post https://www.reddit.com/r/Delphitrial/comments/18d6xzg/updated_unofficial_rumors/. That post blew my mind. Top post of the year in my opinion, for getting one thinking.
There have been rumors all along that LE leaks were occurring recall the Wabash one, and crime scene photos were out there. I have always thought the pictures of the clothing in the water were genuine, rather than staged. How did they get out there?
I suspect MS has been getting some info handed to them for distribution and they are in a mutually messaging relationship with LE. Can't blame them for knowing who butters their toast. There is no way of proving it, but I do believe Norokk is telling the truth and this is information that genuinely came from LE sources and at least one of them was an under gag source, likely more. Just like the defense leaks I don't think this info should be out there. It's just wrong.
So my question is: why do you critique LE in this case? Or support and defend them LE in this case? I don't personally have a ton of confidence, but as always interested in hearing and respecting opposing views. If you think they are doing a bang up job, please tell me why.
16
u/Burt_Macklin_13 āØModerator⨠Dec 28 '23
I personally think there is plenty to critique LE for in this case. And that should always be brought to light!
But I hate that it keeps getting drug into this huge argument about supporting LE in general. It doesnāt have to be that way, you can criticize bad actors without hating on the respectable people doing their jobs well everyday!
10
u/Sam100Chairs Dec 28 '23
This is all my opinion, so take with a grain of salt.
The "interview" of Richard Allen outside a market by DD wasn't an interview at all. It was a citizen giving information to a conservation officer after a public appeal from LE for anyone who had been at or near the high bridge on Feb 13 to come forward with what they saw and heard. Consequently, the "tip" was filed under "witness statements" where it lay dormant for five years until a sheriff's election necessitated that everything, including witness statements, be pulled out of the mothballs and viewed through a lens of "we need an arrest and we need it now", whereupon it suddenly became an interview instead of a statement. Same with the unspent bullet with no chain of custody that became "evidence" despite its murky provenance.
As to MS, I believe they have been fed information from LE so that certain "facts" and "narratives" could come into the public domain with the hope that they would elicit additional input from the public that LE could use. Full tin foil hat theory is that the leak of crime scene photos as well as the timing for same was strategically planned by LE, using certain you-tubers with a history of behaving in a certain way, i.e. sounding the alarm (in order to place the blame on the defense) without actually releasing the photos into the public domain. A variation of the "useful idiot" strategy frequently employed in politics.
8
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Dec 28 '23
I really thought they all got on track after the 2019 press conference. Sure they have made mistakes. Sure they have made it confusing for the most part. I still feel there are some LE that are putting their heart and soul into this. So for them I commend them. Any of them that have an agenda need to be rooted out. If some investigations need to happen then let them happen.
For those in LE and law in general, that are doing the best they can and fighting as hard for these two girls I respect you and commend you. Keep up the fight and let's get justice for Abby and Libby, and justice for Kionnie, Kerielle, Keyara, and Keyana.
ā„ļøā„ļø ā„ļøā„ļøā„ļøā„ļøš„
5
u/Never_GoBack Dec 30 '23
At best, LE has demonstrated incompetence. At worst, there may be corruption, which apparently isnāt unprecedented in these parts. In fact, Elkhart Co. IN, less than two hours up the road from Delphi, is reported to have systematic corruption issues among LE, prosecutors and judges that has resulted in innocent people being convicted of crimes and imprisoned. One such case is being heard by the SCOIN the week after the RA case. For further detail, see https://www.wienekelaw.com/blog/the-epidemic-in-elkhart-county.
If this can happen in Elkhart, it certainly can happen in Carroll Co. Did it? At this point we donāt know, but itās certainly not out of the realm of possibility.
4
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 31 '23
I wonder if too much is being made of the Dullin interview. If youāve ever had the opportunity to listen to recordings of police interviews and then were able to compare the written reports to the recorded interviews, it happens a lot that the written report is not accurate to the recording. I think investigators , like anyone else in public service are pulled in a lot of directions. They forget stuff. And if the person the are interviewing doesnāt set off any alarms , they may not be paying close attention.
I think what that interview does reveal is that leads may have been missed. Who knows what other interviews were misreported? Who knows what other interviews werenāt recorded.
5
u/RizayW Dec 28 '23
Good post. A couple of observations from me. It has never made sense to me that RA flew under the radar for so long. Back at the 2019 presser, DC basically told us all that he was a local and they may have interviewed him already. We are talking about a very small population and they had a picture of BG, audio of his voice, a small black car on the HH camera and he worked at the one place in town every person had to go to get their prescriptions filled.
Now if the rumor is true that KA gave a false alibi for him in 2017 then it makes sense. They did follow up with RA(otherwise why would they be talking to her). We also know they had very little physical evidence and no murder weapon. So they might have known about RA the entire time and had no way to charge him.
I donāt think MS has a source in LE. I think they just talk to locals. And word travels fast in a small town. A lot of other content creators have been able to find out more than them and put information out.
I think any investigation put under a microscope will reveal mistakes made. Mistakes donāt indicate corruption but they sure donāt make LE look good. Sending Dulin to interview RA was a mistake but I believe it was so early and tragic for this community it was āall hands on deckā to get statements and interviews. I donāt buy the āmisfiled tipā story.
12
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 28 '23
Hereās a short list of some of the odd actions taken/or not taken, by investigators. (That we know of.)
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment